Cold steel compared to united cutlery Combat Commander Quick look.
Автокөліктер мен көлік құралдары
A quick side by side of the two items.
I liked the look of the Commander but the loose handle was a real deal killer. check it out • United Cutlery Combat ...
I sent the Combat Commander Gladiator Sword back.
Пікірлер: 313
I've been backpackin and bushwackin with that very cold steel Gladius for 3 yrs now. All the black finish has come off but she's still rippin and roarin. Good purchase especially for the 45 bucks I spent on it
@schlinge-fling
3 жыл бұрын
So it’s just like a silver sword now? I think that’s badass. I have one but it’s not faded yet.
@keviiinramaaaage7650
3 жыл бұрын
@@schlinge-fling ya it's just silver and has a nice bit of patina to it now too
@sunsetsleeper
3 жыл бұрын
The left i like better but the right is good for stabbing...
@frankcastle4715
3 жыл бұрын
Bought mine for $30
@Sip_Dhit
3 жыл бұрын
Well the one on the left is made to be a tool the one on the right is made to be a weapon
The U.C. has the wasp blade beautiful shape with the pommel. Great but the cold steel is a superior tool in my opinion
@larryterry7874
3 жыл бұрын
@@mrt4413 what ?
@MrSalsa1995
3 жыл бұрын
@@larryterry7874 look at this guy back talking Mr T. I sure pity the fool
@Sip_Dhit
3 жыл бұрын
I mean one is basically a modern representation of the Roman Gladius which was a combat only weapon always to be used in tandem with a tower sheild often with others along with you, the handle forces a hammer grip resulting in stabs being upwards instead of forwards, additionally its bot a slashing weapon clear by the blade shape, where the hilt on the left one doesnt force your hand has a much better grip for swinging and that swept point adds some weight into the blade that the other doesnt, long story short they're not comparable as one is made as a tool and the other is made as a weapon
@dannyn6558
3 жыл бұрын
@@Sip_Dhit The Romans mostly do stabbing attack with their Gladius swords, since the swords have a short range. Their main is a throwing spear called; a Pilum(pronounced Pila) and the Gladius is the close range secondary. they also carry a lightweight tower shield for defense.
@ninjesus4079
3 жыл бұрын
@@Sip_Dhit which one is the weapon?
Good to see the Roman Gladius industry is still thriving after all these years
@jnotlog7040
Жыл бұрын
Just like their roads 😄
@REBELSCL
Жыл бұрын
@@jnotlog7040 And there shitters…..
@wizrom3046
9 ай бұрын
the Romans made them for a thousand years and barely changed the design.... its the perfect urban weapon for close quarters
So at least their both Carbon BUT the United is a hollow grind meaning it will cut easier, but more likely to break off the tip or roll an edge. Cold steel wins in this case IMO
@rajgill7576
3 жыл бұрын
If you're actually going to use this more than 30min you'll be putting your own grind and sharpen on this eventually. The factory sharpen means next to nothing bro
@EvanJones-jn7nu
3 жыл бұрын
United Cutlery takes the W imo because it’s never broken and imo shouldn’t be used for anything too heavy duty.
CS torture tests always beat competition...they freaking stand on those hilts and blades
I'd rather take the *thud* vs the coin drop lol
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
Then cold steel is the one you want
@maz1702
3 жыл бұрын
Same
@franklinwill22
11 ай бұрын
Great observation 👍🏾
The united cutlery sounded like a toy compared to cold steel
If it came down to it, the Cold Steel would be my choice.
Thanks for the comparison video that doesn't label which one is which 👌
@hazsneax
Жыл бұрын
If you were about twenty IQ you could understand which is which, easily. Cold steel is the one with the ball on the pommel. United cutlery is the one with the window breaker spike on the pommel.
@cornixdemetrius7883
11 ай бұрын
@@hazsneaxIf the creator had 20 IQ he would refer to them in order in his title, instead of making someone go to two separate websites to find out which is which.
@jakemitchell9853
11 ай бұрын
@@cornixdemetrius7883 If you had 20 IQ, you would know that you'd only need to go to one website.
@raymondhoguelll2044
5 ай бұрын
Actual cold steel on left
I have the United cutlery one and honestly it's kind of disappointing how quickly it picked up an edge roll,
I find this funny because me and my roommate were literally comparing the two yesterday when we realized we both had one
@boomstick1584
3 жыл бұрын
That’s just a weird comment...
@2014crew
3 жыл бұрын
@@boomstick1584 it showed up in my feed the day I commented
@boomstick1584
3 жыл бұрын
@@2014crew ....just making a bad joke. I can’t tell which knife is the United Cutlery, for sure
@ninjesus4079
3 жыл бұрын
@@boomstick1584 ha haha
I've had the Cold Steel Gladius for 3 years and it is TOUGH. Great blade that can take all the abuse you desire. Sharpens up nicely as well
Saw a guy in the riots get his ass beat damn near to death while wielding the cold steel Gladius. I'd highly reccomend using it if you ever actually wield one. Works out better I'd immagine.
The cold steel Gladius machete sounded like the real deal while the combat commander sounded like a flimsy toy 🤣🤣
Have no clue what these are are why I'm here but its nice to see what I should get looking at the comments
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
Welcome to the dark side of beautiful blades
Cold Steel knives are so worth the money. I have a Kopis, and I abused the hell out of it. Still straight and easily sharpened .
The one on the left is better due to the blade design and grip...as a paramedic I look at the potential stab wound not the brand
@thepenguinfrommadagascar1994
3 жыл бұрын
A paramedic recommending the best one to stab someone with, good method to stay in buisness lol
@Tigerssnakes
3 жыл бұрын
@@thepenguinfrommadagascar1994 I also blacksmith as a hobby
@thepenguinfrommadagascar1994
3 жыл бұрын
@@Tigerssnakes strategy- make an extremely damaging blade, produce a large ammount, sell to criminals, then treat people who get stabbed by it.
Cold steel looks higher quality to me without any actual research. I can already see the blade go all the way through the handle.
@shawnctx
3 жыл бұрын
Both are full tang, I didn't like the big hole in the combat commander. Weak point.
Based on noise alone the one on the right sounds more heavy duty. And i like that in a chopper.
Bought one of each, United Cutlery really does the trick better then cold steel imo, very good balance and is more durable.
@yeanisch
3 жыл бұрын
Than
@EvanJones-jn7nu
3 жыл бұрын
@@yeanisch you right
@Ogrematic
3 жыл бұрын
BS.
@EvanJones-jn7nu
3 жыл бұрын
@@Ogrematic ?
@Ogrematic
3 жыл бұрын
@@EvanJones-jn7nu Most of the UC crap I bought broke under extended use.
The cold steel gladius will last you YEARS decades even I bought mine for 28 dollars 8 years ago and it still is beyond sharp and I’ve cut down who knows how many small trees and cut into logs and used it to pry open things and it never lost its edge and will always be my favorite blade
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
I got my srk 20 yrs ago.... my camp knife.... still razor sharp... and i ABUSE it
I like the grip more on the right but I like the blade more on the left
My United cutlery’s tip broke off when I tried to pull out of someone wood I was chopping with it. My cold steel is still okay as of today
Honestly they look like cheap, mass produced Chinese-esque renditions of a gladius, but they’re pointy pieces of carbon steel so I’m sure they work fine.
@TheRussianWookie
3 жыл бұрын
I rather have one of these over a original one
@DoggoWillink
3 жыл бұрын
@@TheRussianWookie I don’t know how to respond to that.
The compression makes it sound underwater
I dont get the point of blades like these. Ive used cold steel machetes, theyre ok but they dont hold up. My great grandpa forged mine from a chevy leaf spring, and i still use it every time i go out into the brush. Works better than any cold steel ive ever used
@seanwarren9357
3 жыл бұрын
Well, where do I buy a Grandpa?
@36reapergrim
3 жыл бұрын
What didn't hold up? I have several and none have failed after gross abuse.
@bonitabromeliads
5 ай бұрын
The point of them is that we don't all have grandpas forging us swords.
@ArmyBoiSweat
5 ай бұрын
@bonitabromeliads9802 buy an old one or just a decent cheap one. My coworkers cold steel broke a few months after he got it and the home depot one i keep on the truck is still going strong.
@ArmyBoiSweat
5 ай бұрын
@36reapergrim usually handle issues and edge retention, im usually dealing with pretty gnarly palmettos and stuff and the edges just fold and chip more than most other knives i have
That’s so cool I wanna get one and chop something up
I have owned both. For some reason, this rivalry has been going on for years. And still, the cold steel is the best. Hands down. The Handle of the Commander has no weight and is completely unwieldy. Cannot absorb impact, follow through is a fight to not let the blade rotate out of hand.
I get it, you got TWO swords.
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
Well, he has 2 hands and 2 hips so.....
Simple quick look 🍻 I would definitely go for the cold steel. The UC looks more like a novelty or toy than anything else. Cheers BB
@DRIZZT627
4 жыл бұрын
The right one IS the cold steel
@gedeyogam9096
3 жыл бұрын
So thin both of them...
@TN-ci4ox
3 жыл бұрын
gede yogamahendra are both of them styled after gladiuses as in made for thrusting
@the1bock
3 жыл бұрын
I have the cold steel one for a year now. Sturdy and sharp.
@GabrielDeMfromNY
3 жыл бұрын
In my opinion the UC is much better, and I love Cold Steel products except they missed with this one
I have a Cold Steel Gladius machete and I have downed many saplings and chopped many branches to make room for us to play airsoft. Like all my other CS stuff, it performs flawlessly and I use it a lot. It lives in my trunk in case I need it. They stand behind their equipment. Long-time fan. I highly recommend it.
I've had the CS one for about 2 years, I have beaten the hell out of it, still comes back for more. Best 15 bucks I've spent.
I got a Cold Steel Kukri for Christmas and holy geez is it the bee’s knees
For anyone saying cold steel I have actually owned that gladius and I have big hands and the pommel irritates the hell outta my wrist and hand its constantly rubbing against it and after like 20 swings I usually put it away. Also this may be cause I abused it when I got it but the tip bends super fast but take that at a grain of salt I did stab a piece of pork meat and it hit bone
@jfilm7466
5 ай бұрын
The UC doesn't have that problem, can spin it around easily. But you'll be able to sand down your pommel quite without much effort, but how would it affect the balance?
Cold Steel! I prefer their tanto shape, I've got 6 different Cold Steel Tantos. Kobum all the way up to the Master Tanto!
@louiswilkins9624
3 жыл бұрын
Cool
@louiskhalifeh3827
3 жыл бұрын
Cool
@hindsight2022
3 жыл бұрын
Yes but do you have the magnum tanto XII ???
@Jwilliamstech
3 жыл бұрын
Negative! It's been on my radar for a while though, I'd prefer the San Mai over the CMP 3V. Just more traditional steel and blade layering construction.
@hindsight2022
3 жыл бұрын
@@Jwilliamstech yup i got 2 of em . i love the san mai . also have the sanmai outdoorsman EPIC blade
Is it just me or you can actually notice the quality of the blade/handle make up just by the sound
@Sip_Dhit
3 жыл бұрын
No alot of high quality weapons make that sound, recall alot of weapons have different designs even simple things like axes and knives are different? A tool axe is wider a weapon axe is thinner, a knife is the same way i feel that comparing what is a modified tool design on the left to the practically unchanged weapon design on the right doesnt make much sense
These look like two different kinds of gladiolus and idk if this conpairson is valid
@PopoXReturnz
3 жыл бұрын
They are both gladius-machetes within a similar price range, with bake-on finish and a polypropylene grip. Just how similar do they have to be before it's a valid comparison?
The gladious machete by cold steel is wicked
Not appropriate for a gunfight !
@stonefox9124
3 жыл бұрын
It is for the next morning when the bullets are gone...
@dirkhans001
3 жыл бұрын
@@stonefox9124 crossbow,....
@stonefox9124
3 жыл бұрын
@@dirkhans001 obviously you've never fired a crossbow... takes forever to reload those things
@dirkhans001
3 жыл бұрын
@@stonefox9124 Ok, screw it....Jedi Light-saber
@stevevelobahn1814
3 жыл бұрын
Look up 21' rule.
United Cutlery has an accurate shaped blade compared to Cold Steel's blade.
I have the cold steel and it has gone through everything I've tried to cut only sharpening it twice in 8 years. I ended up getting almost all of their other versions of machetes because of it. Fantastic quality 👍
@xTreyray
3 жыл бұрын
What brand are you talking about? Im interested because I need a new blade.
Cold Steel 4 me but the United Cutlery is good also ,just not just as good. Cool of you to own them both.
Cool modern Roman Gladius should be issued to our troops .
Well the one on the right is clearly a Pompeii gladius. I forget the other two kinds.
@lightmetro7508
3 жыл бұрын
One type is mainz
I mean the one on the right is basically a modern representation of the Roman Gladius which was a combat only weapon always to be used in tandem with a tower sheild often with others along with you, the handle forces a hammer grip resulting in stabs being upwards instead of forwards, additionally its bot a slashing weapon clear by the blade shape, where the hilt on the left doesnt force your hand has a much better grip for swinging and that swept point adds some weight into the blade that the other doesnt, long story short they're not comparable as one is made as a tool and the other is made as a weapon
Incredible!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cold Steel's take on the gladius is way better than United Cutlery's gladius. Although the UC one has a cool design, the blade will most likely snap or become unusable after long repeated use, unlike the CS one. With tools or blades, functionality and durability comes before making it pretty. And even then, they're getting beat the hell up in the end. Don't waste your money folks 👍
I have that exact cold steel blade. Good quality for the price, fits well in the hand. I do like the other though, im gonna look into that one.
I was expecting a stress test
The big difference is the cold steel sword won't break
Is that the same one that goes for like 30 bucks?
Condor makes a bad ass wood grip
The CS finna go DEEPA
Cold steel ftw
Thanks man!
@adrianolucas7499
3 жыл бұрын
IO
I have the United Cutlery version. I love it, but I'd like to get my hands on the Cold Steel version as well.
*clears throat* *I N C R E D I B I L I S*
I haven’t found much that competes with cold steel when it comes to reliability and style. Other things just look cheap compared to cold steel.
Which is the best? i have a cold steel gladius are they pretty much the same performance wise?
@shawnctx
9 жыл бұрын
paul ballard I like cold steel its bigger in size even if others don't like the fit and finish. As a tool it seems more useful. The UC is nicer looking and feels good in the hand. but I wont own it. plus its shorter. as far as best? Its a personal opinion. you choose.
@mikelykan.9416
8 жыл бұрын
Love Gladius swords i have the cold steel one and it's pretty badass.
@namenloseheld1469
7 жыл бұрын
Wich one has the better steel?
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
Watch the stress tests that Cold Steel puts their blades through.... its impressive
yo, i have that same cold steel gladius
I SOOO want to get the CS Gladius.
I'll take cold steel any day, just for the pick on the handle.
@2ndhorseman
3 жыл бұрын
That's the United Cutlery one.
In short combat Commander has a thinner blade stock but a sharper edge out of the box and a cooler looking handle with less hot spots but overall the gladius from Cold steel is better made thicker blade stock better balance and a bigger handle but there are some hot spots especially if you have larger hands
I'll be perfect honest. Its a good bush knife. You can hack that thing half to death and it'll chop what you need it to chop. But it'd break against another sword or a shield. Not that many people are getting into random street swordfights these days...
They both kinda fugly, >no ivory grip >no brass Me sad
You ever just want to buy a sword?.
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
Always
well someone's ready to kill Koro sensei
First thing is these are defined as machetes not swords. You can them buy at academy sporting goods or online anywhere from about 20 to 30$ they are considered to be work tools. But they would serve a purpose in the zombie apocalypse or in self defense.
@toothlessgrin04
3 жыл бұрын
Tha roman gladius are SHORT swords not machetes
Ever heard of the company called “Zombie Tools”? They use 5160 Spring steel to make their old fashioned ancient weapons. I’m talking knives, axes, swords, cleavers etc etc. just check their .com and see for yourself.
Is this what you eat your dinner with? I can respect a man who would. I personally like to use an odachi but each to their own. Roman weaponry is incredibly effective and extremely lethal when used by the right man whilst cutting up his chicken or carrots. I usually prepare my veg with a great Scottish claymore.
The one on the right is the Real Deal
Wow nice Roman style swords!
Any knife would be threatening if it were used by a master wielder
Cold Steel is hands down better and tougher but the United Cutlery version is pretty good alternative and alternative are important.
Been debating between the two for a little bit now but i think this video put to rest which of the two i should go for - the Cold Steel based off of the sound alone gives off the impression that it is far more durable than the United Cuterly. However, one thing I noticed that was absent in the comments below in discussion between the two is the CS handle, the metal runs all the way through while the UC version, it stops above the hole. I've seen photos of the UC hilt bent at that O. However, I do think that the UC looks a lot nicer but you do need to have some weight to the weapon and at 0.6g it just doesnt seem like enough for either protecting yourself or doing outdoors yard work.
@shawnctx
2 жыл бұрын
Cold steel, I have seen a similar item from Reaper smaller but looks good.
@The_Zilli
2 жыл бұрын
@@shawnctx thanks for the reply, now im torn between the cold steel gladius and the Cold Steel 97TKMS Tactical Katana Machete (was looking this morning) - similiar price points with the gladius being 10 bucks cheaper but the machete has that extra range and intimidation factor. Decisions decisions lol.
@The_Zilli
2 жыл бұрын
also the 420 steel of the Reaper would be a downgrade in quality - at least that's how im looking at it.
I have both and the cold steel is well tested. Took a 9mm no problem and like the top comment the black finish came off but its still going strong. Didn't like the handle though and made it thicker with an old belt
My cold steal came gladius literally came unsharpened and without a point. Like completely blunt
Isn't Cold steel where you just smack a piece of iron till it's flat, like not hot at all iron... I'm pretty sure that's how people kill the witches or something
I like the one on the left
Parabéns.....!!!!!
Cold Steel is some serious mall ninja shit.
Wtf...which one is which?
Jerard Butler: 👍🏻🧔
Want both 👍
Look at that xiphos
I like the one on the right.
Those are dope! Like spartan style short swords.
@Dinosaurthingything
Жыл бұрын
Roman style short sword, literally, as the gladius is a Roman weapon
@p.s.9658
Ай бұрын
Spanish celtiberian swords adopted by romans after Cannae battle. National pride.
Are you planning to have a gladiator fight?
You don't judge knives by looks alone!
Those look awesome! Always wanted to own one, but I went in a different direction. Wouldn't mind getting a couple for collection purposes.
@Mewofastora
3 жыл бұрын
If it's for collection purposes whatever, if you plan on having abusive testing fun go with a cheap option. If you want good (it's expensive) Swords of Northshire and Albion
I'm not sure how useful 5hese are but i do know what i own which is a kukri a machete and an artillery sword
Cold steel one is better but the united cutlery one looks way better
Where can I buy one of these?!
Great protest blade
@elliottshepherd6847
3 жыл бұрын
What do you mean great protest blade?
Dont really say which ones which
Roman's Gladius Sword⚔️
I like the steel one!
The edge profile in the cold steel wins it
Roman yelling intensifies
How much the sword in the right?