화사도 그렇고 문별도 그렇고 안부르면 아예 입을 안움직이네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ존나 간지

@user-cx2yi2ft6u

3 жыл бұрын

자신이 안 부르고 있다는걸 보여주는 양심👍👍👍

춤 너무 격해서 립싱크일 줄 알았는데 놀람 4분동안 저렇게 춤추면서 노래할 수가 있구나.,.

This is the best one. So accurate. Most MR removed don't remove the recorded singing they only remove the music which make them sound so stable (even for the artist that lip sync 90% of the song) We can hear moonbyul skip some parts to breath, and also her breathing.. This ladies and gents a proof that she sang live. We don't need any tho, because we know mamamoo don't lipsync but still.

since she perfom as solo, she need not to sing some parts to take a breath, especially with such hard choreo she did so good! 💜

@arctic_corner

4 жыл бұрын

Alla agreed !! 🖤

This one is an accurate mr removed. Im proud of my girlie learning how to lipsync some parts to take a breath but never forget singing live as much as she can. am i the only one proud she isn't that noticeable while lipsyncing 😂

@jjescorpiso21

4 жыл бұрын

I thought she was lipsyncing the whole time lolol

I don’t blame her for not singing some parts. she’s not used to singing so much at once in general, especially on her own, plus all that choreo while singing is hard for most

@Deliriummary

4 жыл бұрын

Most soloist do that to maintain a good performance, Hyuna and Sunmi do too!

@25beee

4 жыл бұрын

Hwasa did that at twit too, she intentionally not singing at some parts

@chikanime1257

4 жыл бұрын

Actually, all the soloist do that, even boa and chungha do it, because its hard to sing like 3 minutes straight, so they usually lipsync in the hardest parts of the choreo or when there are backup vocals (for groups, its usually the vocals that everyone sing at the same time)

@amaliaazizah5621

4 жыл бұрын

Hwasa herself, with twit does the same thing as byul too. But she sings more, while byul choreo is more complex.

@adriana4084

3 жыл бұрын

ya not like twice, they lipsynce most of the time but not because of taking their breath but sometimes they just don’t sing but only a few line they sing

AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO'S PROUD BECAUSE MOONBYUL SKIPPED SOME LINES JUST TO LIPSYNC?! OMG I LOVE YOUUU

@maize1604

4 жыл бұрын

LIEYK THEY REALLY IMPROVED IN LIPSYNC-ING

@nolongerasimp2041

4 жыл бұрын

I don't get your comment...

@maize1604

4 жыл бұрын

I mean she really improved in lipsync-ing since HIP era, aren't you proud of heeeer?

@myownstory1416

4 жыл бұрын

@@nolongerasimp2041 mamamoo in general sucked at lipsyncing, if they did it you would see it from a mile away... so the fact moonbyul looks like she is singing everything is an improvement on that part?

@nolongerasimp2041

4 жыл бұрын

@@myownstory1416 okaaaay...I just thought it was weird that people praised her for being good at lipsyncing But I got it now😂

평소에 하도 라이브만 하다가 춤이 더 격해져서 라이브 안하는 파트가 늘어 어색하겠다 립싱크 못하기로 소문난 마마무인데ㅋㅋ 하지만 하는 파트는 너무 잘해서 놀라움🤭

미친 이 사람이 진짜 랩퍼라고요? 지금 당장 다른그룹 메인으로 가라해도 완전 잘할 사람인데ㄷㄷㄷ 진짜 대단하다

나머지 세멤버의 노래실력이 워낙 넘사벽이고 별이 파트가 랩이라 팬 아닌사람들은 별이실력이 보통정도인줄 아는데 사실 별이도 미친실력임. 보컬로 들어와서 김도훈에 의해 랩하게 된건데도 랩메이킹은 물론 발성, 딕션 뛰어나고 안정적으로 라이브 소화가능. 다른 그룹보면 메보가 많이 불러야 30초 정도 부르던데 별이는 30초를 생라이브로 랩함. 마마무는 진짜 미친실력 네명이 모인 그룹인거.

춤 과격한데도 노래 불르려는 거 보면 진짜 너무 존경스럽다 ㅜ

마마무 메인 래퍼 실력 미친 ㄷㄷ 춤 격한데 라이브 안정적인거 대박이다 진짜

후렴부분은 진짜 음원이랑 똑같다

근데 이 정도면 잘하는게 안무도 좀 격하고 파트를 혼자 다 해야하니까 숨차는건 기본이고 힘들텐데 이 정도면 잘하지

Moonbyul did skip lines but the lines which she sang were stable and clear. Moonbyul can control the volume of all lines she sang without shouting or straining. She may be breathy at times but really rare rather than being breathy for half or more than half of the song like many other idols.

마마무에서 포지션이 래퍼라는 사실이 놀라움 진심 원래 보컬로 들어왔다는게 납득이 됨

노래부분은 다 안정적이네

이번 컨셉 문별이 하고싶은 컨셉 다 넣었다는데

힘들겠다.. 춤이 격해서 쉬는 구간이 없어서 더 힘들겠다..

춤이 빡세서 노래하기 힘들것같은데 그와중에 너무 귀여우셔ㅠㅠㅠ햄찌ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

She did well, knowing the fact that she's a rapper who usually has her own part in a group, and now singing a whole 3 minutes song alone + dancing. After watching the dance log on mamamoo channel where she sank down after dancing without singing, I understand now. And I understand how many idols decided to lipsync most of the time, bcs it's hella tiring singing and dancing at the same time. Applause for them all 👏👏👏👏👏

진심 춤도 노래도 쉬는 구간 없고 빡세서 엄청 숨 차고 힘들텐데 진심 자랑스러울 정도로 잘한다 ㅠㅠ

생각해보니까 저 춤에 저 마이크면 겁나 잘한거였어 장하다 문별이..

메인래퍼가 이런 춤에 이런 보컬이라니ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 멋있어 문별이ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

This MR removed is more accurate than the other ones, because the other ones used the first performance, which was pre-recorded. But her following performances, like this, it’s quite obvious she has some singing done.

별언니 항상 춤 끝나고 힘들어 하는데 진짜 노래까지 열심히 불러줘서 너무 고맙고 멋있어요ㅠㅠ

엠알있을때는 과격한몬스터확실히 메인랩퍼같은느낌이고 엠알빼면 부드러운 문스타보컬느낌 진짜 말로필요없다 완전 잘해요ㅠㅠ❤❤❤❤❤

어떻게 매인 래퍼가 이렇게 안정적이게 부를수 있엉❤❤❤❤ 역시 별이 짱❤

0:00 ~ 0:05 반주 0:31 ~ 0:41 다른 파트에 비해서 조용하고 부드럽게? 섬세하게? 불러야 하는 부분 > 춤 빡세서 숨 차는데도 호흡조절해서 죠용하고 섬세하게 부르고있음 0:58 ~ 1:02 여기서 "달달 무슨 달 다 집어삼킬 몬스터" 이 부분은 기계음같은 부분 > 일단 별이언니 목소리도 아니고 그렇다고 기계음을 낼 수 있는거도 아니고 1:17 ~ 1:23 반주 1:35 ~ 1:45 다른 파트에 비해서 조용하고 부드럽게? 섬세하게? 불러야 하는 부분 > 춤 빡세서 숨 차는데도 호흡조절해서 죠용하고 섬세하게 부르고있음 2:02 ~ 2:06 "달달 무슨달"이거도 기계음? 효과음? 같은거라서 (사람이 낼 수 없는 소리) 부르고 싶어도 부를 수가 없는 부분 2:15 ~ 2:31 까지는 원래 가사없고 뒤에 "달달 무슨달"이거도 기계음? 효과음? 같은거라서 (사람이 낼 수 없는 소리) 부르고 싶어도 부를 수가 없는 부분 > 이 부분동안 댄브함 2:48 "달 달 무슨 달 다 집어 삼킬 몬스터" 여기도 마찬가지로 기계음같은 부분 2:57 ~ ending 가사가 원래 "별이 되어 널 비출게" 밖에 없음 *결론 : 음방 밑에 가사뜨는 거에서 90프로 이상은 다 부르고있다.*

무무로써 매번 곡 나올때마다 자랑스러워 죽겠음 모두가 우리 애들 알아줬으면 하고 ❤️❤️

정장입은 햄찌가 춤춘다 목소리 좋다 귀엽다

@user-yn3qc3ou6i

3 жыл бұрын

뺙이🐥

라이브용 댄스로 설렁설렁 출수도 있는데...그냥 아예 춤추고 노래 부르네요 이분은 ㅇ대단쓰

ㄹㅇ 잘하긴 한다..

믿듣맘무의 메인래퍼인 문스타🌟 솔로곡인데다가 안무도 진짜 격한데,, 흔들리지 않는 라이브☆ 별이언닌 그냥 '문별이'라는 이름부터 모든게 다 완벽하잖아요ㅠㅠ 별이언니 '달이 태양을 가릴 때'로 활동하느라 고생 많으셨어요!!:-) 비록 막방까지 활동이 끝났지만, 모두 숨스밍해요~😊

보컬라인이 아니어도 문별도 마마무지..그치..

와 춤진짜격하네 진짜힘들겠다..ㅠ

She's surprisingly stable and on key even with all that hard dancing, it still shocks me to this day. Like she's usually super stable with Mamamoo but she doesn't have that many parts and their choreography's not usually that demanding (not that that takes away from the amazingness), but here she's on her own, her choreo is demanding and she does both singing and rapping so it's all the more impressive

엄청 힘드시겠다,, 진짜 곡 나올때마다 무무인게 자랑스러움 ㅠㅠ

Guys did You seen this?!!! That's Mamamoo's RAPPER and she's singing perfectly well while dancing super hard *.* Soooo proud of her

Now just imagine her doing an orchestrated version with a single mic stand

@ikhramaiman

4 жыл бұрын

shortboypinoy OMG that would be great.

@fiachdubhe401

4 жыл бұрын

I'm imagining a full symphonic metal version. ^^ That would be amazing.

bruh she did SO fucking good considering the fact that she's not used to dancing this kinda choreos along with singing 🤧🤧

안무너무격해서.노래를어떻게하겠어,했드니어흐.문별이보컬도안정적이고.춤은무대마다찢고 해외차트씹어먹는게 괜한게아니네.

진심 춤 진짜 빡센거 치고 라이브 미친거임 안빡세도 레전드고 빡세도 레전드..(하트)

다른것들 다 걍 멜로디없앤건데 이거는 입 안벌리는 부분도 안들리는거 보니 제대로 된듯... +이분 다른 영상도 보니까 찾아서 나온 mr제거중에 제일잘하심...

울언니 너무 완벽하다 진짜.. 잘생겼어 예뻐 귀여워 춤잘춰 랩잘해 노래잘해 다정해 완전 여심저격..

ㄷ ㄷ 잘하네

맘무 단체 활동에서도 잘 안하는 파격적인 춤인데ㅜㅜㅠ 춤 다 추면서 노래 부르셔 ㅜㅠㅓㅠㅠ

역시 갓마무 mr이 필요없는 수준

와..저 달태가를 추면서 저만큼이나 부르면 엄청잘하는거지 글고 약간 부르려고 노력하는게 느껴진당 .. 햄찌 사랑해💕

Skipped or not, those parts that she sang live still sounds exactly the same as background. Proven that she CAN sing, plus CAN dance.

엠알제거해도 노래잘부르는데

이렇게 잘한다고...? 이정도면 아이돌이아니라 기계아닌가

No doubt she has a beautiful voice coz when she sing it was exactly the same like the record..with that kind of choreo of course she need to catch lot of breath.but the moment she sing..its just amaze me...love u moonbyul!

아ㅜㅜ 안무 너무 어려운데...그래도 너무 잘한당💕

힝 사랑해요ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ팬들을 위해 라이브ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 진리야 ㅜㅜㅜ

ok but queen slayed. She skipped some parts but she had to take breathes. She isn’t used to being alone on stage and having to sing constantly, especially while dancing a that may be pretty hard for her. Overall I think she did really well and this is accurate! Our little moonstar is so amazing 🥺 AND DID ANYONE NOTICE, DESPITE THE PARTS SHE SKIPPED WHICH MOSTLY WERE LIKE background stuff like moonya or whatever or like or dadadaadaddadada stuff like that IT SOUNDED JUST LIKE THE ACTUAL RECORDING. YES MAMAMOO RAPPPPEEERRR RIGHT HERE JUST SLAYED AND STOLE OUR HEARTS HER NAME IS MOONBYUL THANK YOU VERY MUCH

thank god for an accurate one, idk what some of these channels are doing 😅 baby girl did so good, this level of choreo as a soloist and singing and rapping live so beautifully, as expected of mamamoo's moonbyul 💯💯💯💯

처음엔 저음이 많아서 살짝 흔들리는것도 같았는데 후렴엔 흔들리는거 거의 없고 안정적이다

@user-in6xc2jq2x

3 жыл бұрын

은광이랑 눈 마주쳤엌ㅋㅋ

@dam2075

3 жыл бұрын

목 풀린듯

래퍼입니다 여러분. 혹시 모르실까봐ㅎ 아시죠?

이영상mr제거진짜잘했다!!!!!

She did such a pretty good job regardless of her skipping some parts cuz honestly it really takes some energy to dance with that choreo while singing

singing solo with such a difficult choreo is so hard. im so proud of moonbyul🥺 shes amazing❤️

considering how hard the choreo was and the fact that she's a rapper, she did soooo well

❤️❤️❤️갓문별

dancing with that choreo, i won't be able to sing a single word. *역시* Moonbyul doesn't disappoint

honestly cant blame her, for not singing everything. she did amazing, and then remember that shes a rapper, she's singing, shes solo, and her choreo is super involved and demanding. we stan (gay) talent

Some parts especially the autotuned chorus parts are lipsynched in songs. Especially because Moonbyul is carrying a solo song with very hard choreo and she is only a vocalist in Mamamoo.

MAMAMOO RAPPER DID THAT, THE NAME IS MOONBYUL

I like that most times she didn’t sing some words she didn’t lip sync

I wonder why some people reacted to her skipping a few lines like "oh it's okay, she did great anyway" like they expected her to sing everything, I mean it's not that she skipped some lines to let you down, she skipped them to breathe, lol. Even group members often skip some stuff in order to not lose their breath from singing, so soloists definitely can't sing 100% live being all alone, it's common sense. She did a great job singing most of it though, and she sounded great indeed!

Damn she sounds exactly like the studio version like she is a real talented artist She is amazing she deserves to be crowned

most respect to this channel and moonbyul😘

마이크가 hip때쓰던거면 더잘들릴텐데 아쉽 ㅜ

@user-tb4kf3sd9p

4 жыл бұрын

아마춤이 너무격해서 그거는 덜렁거리게 그냥 귀에차논거니까 저렇게 붙이는거로한걸꺼에요

こんな激しく踊っててこんな歌えるの🥺本当にすごい🥺

I love that she’s taking care of her voice by skipping some parts but still singing quite a lot of it

U did very well, Shining star!

i love how she got more stable in the end even though thats when she's going to be more tired

she's amazing

Really proud of her💞

She did great! Her voice is clear and on key. I can see she`s more confident now than on her first performance.

♥️♥️♥️

Thanks for this MR Removed.. the real MR Removed compared others.. can you do for Moon Movie as well? THANKIU (yong's way of saying) 🤞🤗🥰😍

솔로 활동할때 혼자다 부르면 힘드니까 쉬어서 해도되~~~

Most accurate one!

Byul nesecita respirar en algunas partes por que su coreografía es demasiado genial 💕😔

It's her first time singing solo and every one knows that singing while dancing it's not easy! I think she's stable and sings well 👌🏻 I luv her voice ♥️

It's good. Eclipse has really hard choreography. Some soloists would go 100% lipsync with such choreo. Also keep in mind that performing in a group is different than solo because with other members you have time to stable your breath between the lines Stan Moonbyul

She is stable... With this tiring dance she still able to sing.. This is our moonstar!!!!

Although she skip few lines. She still stable, clear and awesome💕

while listening to this, i found myself catching my breath.. that choreo is sick!! sooo proud of moonbyul for this awesome performance!! the girl sang y'all!! much love and appreciation for our moonstar

it's not easy to sing with that kind of hardcore choreo. she did great!! i bet most bg will lipsync bcos of their choreo as well

又唱又跳，辛苦星星😘😘

still sound like mv 💃🏻

❤️❤️😊🎉🎉

STAN MOONBYUL

eonni really worked her self out so much dancing a hardcore move choreography rapping with power and sexiness singing with harmony and delicacy still not doing a lipsync what a PROFESSIONAL IDOL

This girl did so good considering this choreography is not easy by and means and she is usually a part of a group and I think people are forgetting that certain parts she isn’t singing is also because in the song her voice has been run through a filter to give it a desired effect at those parts so clearly she can’t sing like that. Also she is so powerful when she is going all out like damn that’s our Byulie

Also appreciate how accurate her pitch is!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Please vote for her on Idol Champ 🙏

Im getting out of breath by listening to Byul😂