Since this track is different than the last one and there are some parts that sound live, like a possible vocal crack (?) in the end and lines ending too fast, I'll consider it for now!! If someone disagrees, tell me in the comments! ❤ If you're new to this channel, don't forget to like, subscribe, share this video with your friends and turn on the notification bell so you don't miss any MR Removed, like BABYMONSTER's, that I post! Thank you so much for watching!!

@szxmxn

7 ай бұрын

i noticed it sounds more live but probably yg edited their vocals to sound more clear than in usual music shows since they have always bad audio systems

@Human-eg7yf

7 ай бұрын

For this one I belive they Sang mostly than before , well I need to comeback from them in 2024

@Hhugaa

6 ай бұрын

Y’all need to go watch her behind the scenes because they still sound like the studio ver

Rora’s vocal’ so stable and smooth😮

if you see their last evaluation and cover I'm sure you won't be surprised by their vocals and rap 😂❤

@meeejoooy

7 ай бұрын

💯

@jisooyalove4842

7 ай бұрын

EXACTLYYY

Rora's voice is insane 😮

I will never get tired hearing Rora's voice❤

Baemon dont need mr removed to prove how good they are. All members have natural talents and all of them slayed live performance.

Asa crystal clear fast rap. Slayed Queen 🔥

It is live. You can hear their breaths

Nmixx and baby monster are prob the only groups who are stable and doesn't sound different from the studio ver

@user-vn2fz9xo4u

3 ай бұрын

Maybe itzy same

RORA will be one of the best vocalists

I believe this is live. Some lines were missed for the sake of the choreo and some notes were flat-ish (which is totally fine and normal since they were dancing the heck out) They really did good on this live performance

@frierenboomerelf

3 ай бұрын

Exactly, it's pretty obvious. I dont even know why some say it pre recorded.

MIC IS ON!!!!!😊

I don't understand why the comments underestimate their ability to sing live 😂

@simplyizza8

7 ай бұрын

because they are used to idols who lipsync

@ot7lio

7 ай бұрын

@@simplyizza8 Real :/

@sse_jen2067

7 ай бұрын

They're so use to lipsync to the point it making them def when hear real ones😭

@arsenic6111

7 ай бұрын

like literally just watch their evaluation vids they sang live all the time

@meteuteu

7 ай бұрын

We can count on Big 3 idols for singing live... SM YG JYP idol can sing live!

So far Rora & Asa most stable for singing live... Also Chiquita a little bit..

지금 부르는건 라이브인지 아닌지 확실히 모르겠지만 yg는 방송데뷔 무대는 항상 라이브였다 베몬도 방송데뷔때는 라이브를할거라고 생각해요 그것도 꽤 잘할거에요 베몬의 다른 선배그룹들이 그랬듯이 베몬 힘내고 응원할게요

They did very well, let's support and love them always♥️♥️🔥

Great job BABYMONSTER! Yguys clearly talented for this ❤🎉

if it is live they sound so good

this is a live vocal, it's immediately clear that it was recorded

ITS LIVE 😭☝🏻

Asa is a Mons7er 🥰🥰🥰

Did you watch the behind the scene?? It's Live vocal. They keep practicing before the shoot.

i think it is live, you guys should check out their behind the scene video.

I don't why im here when i know they really can sing

Rora and Haram ❤

Ofc they're singing live, they're Babymonster! Very talented babiesss! 💕 Ramiii🧡 Rora🧡 Pharita🧡 Ruka🧡 Asa🧡 Chiquita🧡

I've watched the BTS of their live performance video, the school ver. They perform live , they even did a rehearsal. I'll wait for the BTS of this one ❤️

Rora has the best voice❤

IF ANYONE STILL DOUBTING CAUSE BAEMON’S LIVE VOCALS SOUND TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE, YOU GUYS NEED TO CHECK THEIR SURVIVAL SHOW FOR SURE. THE STANDARD IS HIGH, BAEMON’S MAKING THE STANDARD EVEN HIGHER. THIS IS WHY WE STAN TALENTS 🥰😘🫶

live YG chưa bao giờ làm netizen thất vọng

I can’t imagine, how is it hard to rap and do intensive choreography?

@paroparogeeeee

3 ай бұрын

YG training is one def survival of the tough... Easy peasy for them hsha

Sebelumnya denger dlu suara nya jg ngosngosan bbrrti ini live bukan pre record kocak deh

Sheesh~ so stable

@Llllllllllllll106

3 ай бұрын

Откуда вы знали 3 месяца назад что шииш скоро выпустят???

@shirmabasil5076

3 ай бұрын

@@Llllllllllllll106 hahaha yeahh OMG😱😂

Idk if it is live or not, but I can hear their heavy breathing and Pharita seems out of tune than the other one they released.

Ahyeon pls do this with your angel voice ❤️‍🩹😔

They ateee

@frierenboomerelf

3 ай бұрын

And left no crumbs

OFC LIVE

رورا واوووو❤❤

Rooooraaaa best omg

Gila stabil banget ini mah

Rora🔥🗿

Ruka💀🔥

hello can you do babymonster first stage performance at inkigayo for sheesh please?

@BHKMRRemoved

3 ай бұрын

I'm uploading it now!

@lotte765

3 ай бұрын

@@BHKMRRemoved yess thank you so much i’ve watched it and i really enjoyed your content!

Sama bgt sm rekaman masa

Haters gonna say its pre recorded cuz they're fav always do pre recorded 😂😂😆its fact sorry not sorry😂😂😂

I think it's not live since they don't have an ear monitor

이건 확실한 Mr 제거는 아닌거 같네 근데 얘네는 보컬 구멍이 하나도 없더라

I don't think it's live. And one thing that gives it aways is that those mics POP, LIKE SERIOUSLY POP AND CRACK WHEN THEY ARE ON and it was too unbothered by movement. I feel like the unstability of the 1st chorus is just a way to hide the pre recording (treasure also did this in jikjin if I'm not wrong, and Blackpink in HYLT so I wouldn't be surprised tbh)

@sepulvedavicente

7 ай бұрын

And before Teumes come at me, please ,kzread.info/dash/bejne/mK2d0byjZqTJlpM.htmlsi=9QcGEFjRgdLzSCel You really can tell, that's not live by any means, even if they tried to make it sound live, there's no way it's live

@alinflavo4811

7 ай бұрын

Buset pre records wkwk jelas" dari judul live

@azillaputri4714

7 ай бұрын

Do you think all singers do lipsing? Many singers are also good when do live, They're singers, not comedians, they can sing

@lutfikalut

7 ай бұрын

Even if it's not live, we already knew their quality

@Gabriella89-qe4tm

7 ай бұрын

​@@sepulvedavicente in the video link you provided. The audio is live from the members' voices when performing but the video is not. I mean MNET and most Mshows do take several takes, 1. they sing live, 2. they lipsync so they can do a full power for dance and 3. repeat the performance for maximum results when broadcast. If you don't believe it, you can watch the video again. at the end of the video there are no teume watching the performance but in the audio their voices can be heard very clearly

sorry, i don't think it's live🙏🏻

@Cuminhole

7 ай бұрын

huh? you can hear the air on mic

@dalgomie6011

7 ай бұрын

Something wrong with your ears 😌

@Human-eg7yf

6 ай бұрын

Its not like every idol who sound live is pre recorded

@user-ty5sr2qh7m

6 ай бұрын

Go to hospital immediately 😂 your ears have some problems

MAKAN TU LIPSYNC

The singing sounds pre recorded to me. The rapping is live thougj

STABILITY RANKING: RAMI PHARITA ASA RUKA RORA CHIQUITA

@MyPj25

7 ай бұрын

This is just your bias list lol. Rora is the most stable, even chiquita is more stable than rami

@dalgomie6011

7 ай бұрын

LOL FOR ME : RORA ASA CHIQUITA PHARITA RAMI RUKA

@anp6924

7 ай бұрын

For Me: Rora Asa Chiquita Rami Pharita Ruka

@prettysavage8230

6 ай бұрын

Rora is literally on the top for stability what are you even talking about??

루카 개못한다...

Rora đỉnh 🎉🎉🎉

pre record

@Dangerously_12

7 ай бұрын

Hdehh denger deh pas bagian akhir rap ruka, pre record ga bakal ilang lah suaranya

@toristanzuf.1370

7 ай бұрын

@@Dangerously_12 pre record + live, pre record tidak bisa di mr removed karena suaranya berbeda dari lagu aslinya, yg part ruka bengek itu iya sih live, tapi suara lainnya dominan pre record

@Dangerously_12

7 ай бұрын

@@toristanzuf.1370 pre record mah ya semuanya juga pre record atuh wkwkw gmna si masa tampil bareng yang pre record cuma beberapa member doang🤣

@Dangerously_12

7 ай бұрын

@@toristanzuf.1370 tolong cari data yang bener ya, ini namanya backingvocal, pre record do record dlu baru tampil, ANAK” yg kalo tampil backingvocal + live, dan cuma di beberapa part aj biar bisa ngatur pernapasan

@toristanzuf.1370

7 ай бұрын

@@Dangerously_12 "semua" yg lo maksud siapa? semua member baemon sih iya, tapi kalo yg lo maksud semua idol sih kata gw enggak wkwk

Pre-recorded…. This group bringing nothing to the table

@kickychomsan6005

6 ай бұрын

Have u watch the behind the scene? Go watch it and you can judge that its live

@user-ur9lf4je8o

6 ай бұрын

Sorry that you never experience live vocal fron ur fav🤧

@Tesmala

6 ай бұрын

So loud and so wrong. Watch the behind the scenes, its live.

@user-ty5sr2qh7m

6 ай бұрын

Đã nói ngu còn nói to😂

What about the voice of new jeans ehehehe always crack

@dalgomie6011

7 ай бұрын

😂

@imruba6635

7 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂😭

@prettysavage8230

6 ай бұрын

Ikr

@alvhicalandry3334

5 ай бұрын

im not gonna watch newjeans or lesserafim mr removed after this😅