I will never forgive the writers for building their romance up only to kill melendez off like that. it’s so unnecessary and Claire deserved some happiness

@asiyah7714

3 жыл бұрын

Completely agree!

@mirnagisselle

3 жыл бұрын

I AGREEE

@RoyalMasterpiece

3 жыл бұрын

I stopped watching because of it.

@maryammaryam9883

3 жыл бұрын

@@RoyalMasterpiece me too

@fhjuhjj8943

3 жыл бұрын

They should bring Dr.kalu back

Nothing will ever be the same without Dr. Melendez

@simplyemilia479

3 жыл бұрын

i agree completely. i still haven’t recovered from his death.

@Michelle020892

3 жыл бұрын

As sad as it is, that’s probably the point. Some things, in not everything, will change.

@alebakwenare8781

3 жыл бұрын

I just watched season 3 and I am not okay 😭😭😭how did you guys overcome?

@dallyaa4336

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@thejourneyofjessicaherbert

2 жыл бұрын

Right!!!!!!!!

The good doctor will never be the same without Melendez’s smile 😭

Honestly I would’ve been fine with anyone else dying except for DR. NEIL MELANDEZ. He held the whole plot together more than anyone else in the entire story. From the 1st episode I’m so used to listening to ppl say his name a 100 times

@33MOO33

Ай бұрын

I only want Claire and Melendez to live so they can have their happily ever after…honestly though I’m happy with the heartwarming last moment with Melendez in this scene..

No one asked for this closure. We wanted Melendez alive, not a figment of Claire’s imagination.

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

His death was completely unnecessary and complete bullshit I think keeping Lea just so they can see her with Shaun in my opinion was completely an utter bullshit! Honestly I could care less about their relationship I would much rather have Dr. Melendez. I love Shaun and everything but I would much rather have Dr. Melendez then have Lea be with Shaun no offense. And no offense to David Shore & Daniel Dae Kim I think their amazing producers but killing Dr. Melendez off was the stupidest thing they ever did.

@sharondolanstyles6079

3 жыл бұрын

I know right! If this was a show like Vampire diaries, I could say that he will definitely come back, but at this point, they really did kill him, and it's hard to accept. Their ratings have also gone down significantly, pretty sure it has to do with this cut.

@janeojeogwu7123

3 жыл бұрын

I hear you Loud and clear Sis! This is some bullsh*t!

@shabnammullick3183

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly!😭

@a-rue-nima

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 agreed. I love Shaun and Lea but Melendez and Claire's is the perfect love story ❤️ It was meant to be. Maybe they killed off Melendez to make it more accurate, like there isn't as much romance that happen in a hospital between colleagues. Like they'd shown in Grey's Anatomy, attendings falling in love with residents 😕 But they could have transferred Melendez or Claire. Idk. Whatever happened is really sad :(

I will never get over the fact that they killed off melendez just for pure shock value... it did nothing but take away from the story... and the only person that it affected was claire..

@marionlapierre6088

3 жыл бұрын

That is why I have deciced to stop watching the show.

@kanenas5159

3 жыл бұрын

@@marionlapierre6088 same here, unfortunately

@positivevybes247

3 жыл бұрын

@@marionlapierre6088 thought it was just me. The show to me right now is completely unwatchable.... I can't stand the fact that they killed a main character for "shock value".. Like what??.. For absolutely no reason. Plus Melendez was one of my favorite characters in the show...

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@positivevybes247 He was one of my favorites too! And honestly Nick was the reason I even started watching The Good Doctor in the first place. I know everybody is like it's just a show it's time to get over it well I'm not over it yet and I don't think I will be for quite a while. And I think them killing Dr. Melendez off was completely unnecessary and complete bullshit!

@meghna9922

3 жыл бұрын

And Claire has only experienced trauma all her life. Melandez had his heart broken twice and both of them were finally perfectly ready just like us audience and they decide to just snatch away Melandire

Can you let Claire be happy for once? She lost her best friend, her mom and the one person she could share her grief with is now gone too. All of this in 2 years? Killing Dr. Melendez just for shock value in such a vague manner was totally unnecessary and so disrespectful to both character and the actor who plays it.

I can’t bring myself to watch this show again especially with Melendez being killed off

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

same

@alegarcia2012

3 жыл бұрын

I refuse to watch it...

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

@@alegarcia2012 I'm glad to read that

@lisailes1711

3 жыл бұрын

Ya I haven’t watched one episode of the new season after what they did. If they somehow bring him back then I’ll watch again.

@debbie9271

3 жыл бұрын

Me too

I can't watch this show without seeing Melendez being the ultimate boss

Once again I ask, did Melendez really have to die

@whosaprettykitty5076

3 жыл бұрын

Nope

@toscawilkinson5528

3 жыл бұрын

They were unnecessary

@RoyalMasterpiece

3 жыл бұрын

It is the stupidest death in TV History, IMO.

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@RoyalMasterpiece I completely agree with you! I feel like the only reason honestly they're even bringing Dr. Melendez back in my personal opinion is because so many fans last year was so pissed off that they had killed his character off so they're bringing him back as a ghost/hallucination for Claire! so they could keep their ratings going and at the same time keep the viewers happy because excuse my french knew they fucked up by killing Dr. Melendez off. Cuz you know damn well that the only reason half the viewers are even tuning into this season is to see if Dr. Melendez is going to make an appearance and David Shore knows this & is using it.

@ryhemswiftie2121

3 жыл бұрын

I think it was for them to make shaun the main surgeon &the good doctor in the serie

Closure, are you kidding??? Guy dies right after finally telling her he loves her and we’re talking about closure with a ghost, hallucination or whatever. Claire and Melendez were perfect for each other and they deserved to be happy, and so did we after watching the relationship been teased for three years.. I understand wanting the show to be realistic and whatever, but a character loosing her mother and the man she loves in the same year seems a bit over dramatic

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

It wasn't even closure I think having Neil come back as a ghost/hallucination for Claire is cruel, I mean how much more do they need to put poor Clare through. I understand she needs to grieve or whatever but come on having her hallucinate about Neil is a bit extreme. I understand wanting the show to be realistic but having Nick come back as a ghost/hallucination seems a bit overly dramatic in my opinion. I ❤️ Neil to death and I'm happy as can be to see him again but they could have found other ways to bring him back into the show other than having Claire hallucinate. Having him come back in flashbacks is one thing but having Claire hallucinate about him being there is another. And I still feel like the only reason they even brought Nick back honestly is because so many fans were pissed off last year about them killing his character off that they decided to bring him back as a ghost/hallucination to keep their ratings going and at the same time still keep their viewers happy! Because you know damn well that half the viewers that are tuning in this season are only tuning in so they can see if Dr. Melendez is going to make an appearance this season because do you honestly think they give two shits about Lea and Shaun's relationship? NO. They want to see Dr. Melendez.

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 but they are unable to understand that we don't want this ghost shit, we want him to be alive and I really hope rating will continue to drop even more

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@sole449 well maybe the ratings dropping will make them realize that killing Dr. Melendez off was a HUGE mistake and that they need to bring Nicholas back.

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 yes, but ALIVE

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@sole449 Well of course alive! They just can't bring Dr. Melendez back which sucks they would have to bring him in as another character. I mean for all we know Dr. Melendez does have a twin brother I mean they never really went into his family. all we really know about Dr. Melendez is that he was taking care of his sister that was disabled.

DR. MELENDEZZZZ!!!! MISS HIM SO MUCH

@vgg31

3 жыл бұрын

And this is not making me (or anyone else who misses him as much as me) feel any better 😭😭😭

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@vgg31 no it doesn't make me feel any better I'm happy to see him but at the same time it also makes me want to cry.

This whole situation... kinda turns me off. I just don’t feel like the whole Melendez dying plot was necessary and I understand there are people like, “gEt oVeR iT”, but I really like this show. I’m allowed to be upset if I feel as if a stupid decision was made, and killing Melendez? That was a really dumb decision. Melendez and Claire had a story worth expanding, hell Melendez without Claire had an interesting story. We only saw his sister once and we don’t really know much about his parents. I understand the writers want this to be realistic and it is. Death is very prominent in this show- I mean, we got it with Claire’s mom and Shaun’s dad. The Good Doctor is still too new for those main character deaths, in my opinion. It’s not a show about the supernatural, or gang violence, or zombies, etc. This season just feels really weird (and I’m not talking about the Covid stuff). Melendez didn’t get a proper goodbye and I know covid has affected a lot, but his death feels so meaningless

@patmebg3794

3 жыл бұрын

Isn't all death the same way?

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

Hey I know exactly how you feel I'm still very upset and pissed off to my core that they chose to kill Dr. Melendez off and people are like get over it, it's just a show yes I understand that but I'm like you I'm allowed to be upset. And I thought picking Lea over Dr. Melendez was bullshit to begin with still pisses me off especially since she wasn't even a main character. I mean for god sakes she was MIA half the time on the show! and I think it's bullshit that the only reason they even picked Lea over Dr. Melendez was because they wanted to see her with Shaun which let's be honest I think it was a bullshit reason to begin with. I mean I'm extremely happy to see Dr. Melendez, I mean he was the only exciting part of the first two episodes for me but it wasn't the same as actually having him there. And honestly I know this sounds stupid but watching these episodes makes me want to cry because I miss Dr. Melendez. And I think it's bullshit that they're having Nick appear as a ghost when they could have just kept him to begin with. And FYI before someone corrects me Nick stated in several interviews that it wasn't his choice to leave and David Shore also stated that his leaving was for creative decisions.

@sarafawaz3939

3 жыл бұрын

Till now iam saying whyyy they killed him off !! What a stupid call

@sarafawaz3939

3 жыл бұрын

I can't agree more with you

@whosaprettykitty5076

3 жыл бұрын

@@patmebg3794 yes, but this is a tv show- tv show deaths are written

It kind of feels like he was brought back to appease fans of this storyline. For me, it just reinforces how stupid they were to have gotten rid of him in the first place.

@meghna9922

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly Exactly Exactly!!!

@teedoug5433

2 жыл бұрын

I just binged the show I'm stopping at season 3. It's over for me. Maybe they thought they were grey's anatom, killing off a main character like that. Absolutely stupid move

@mishxalhey7319

14 күн бұрын

Same here binged the entire show and just stopped as soon as he died. It’s nothing for me now. He was such an iconic character 😭

Since day one... Melendez & Clair relationship is all I voted for. Wish they could have a beautiful relationship ❤️😭.

@robertaquaye2483

2 жыл бұрын

i did also, could not wait for it.

I hope they fired the guy who forwarded the idea of killing Melendez for making the worst decision ever and losing so many viewers single handedly 😒✌🏻️👏

Am sitting here just wishing we'd seen something as simple as Melendez hugging Claire. I mean I will never know what that is like!

@janeojeogwu7123

3 жыл бұрын

💔💔...they played us big time..

@rayrachelle2145

3 жыл бұрын

@@janeojeogwu7123 From the very first encounter, just.......why?

I'm not watching this show again, like ever. For me The Good Doctor is only of 3 seasons.

@anonymouslyme1115

3 жыл бұрын

Ikr, I don't give a hell about what happens on the further seasons

@sandavijithminirathnayake7033

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly .

@najieguerra7486

3 жыл бұрын

Same

@shanzehmalik3170

3 жыл бұрын

relate

@azlenematamin2776

3 жыл бұрын

Same

I think season 4 really should be the last season, there's no point carrying this thing any forward. To me Murphy was not the only character whose storyline required attention and detail. Claire and Melendez had a very different relationship from other things i have seen on tv. Both characters individually too were extremely layered. Melendez wasn't the usual cynical, reckless, playboy, detached doctor and Claire wasn't the usual female resident who was always a damsel in distress and required her attending's validation. Both extremely intelligent and dignified characters, and I would have really looked forward to seeing one of the very few uncomplicated, non toxic, enriching tv romances. it was a foolish decision to kill him off like this.

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

that was so well said!

Oh my freaking god, the way he looks and smiles at her, knowing what they felt, makes me melt as many times as i watch it, also incredibly sad. They deserved so much better i hate the writers for doing this to me

Just bring him and Claire back, make something up like Marvel be doing all the time 😭

If they really wanted the character to leave, The writers could have shown Melendez getting injured, and lose the stability in his hands, but NOOOO, let's kill him off by septic shock.

But can't forget Dr Melendez for a moment , whenever Good Doctor is mentioned...Miss him so so much. A character dearly missing...not happened many times..Salute to Nicholas for putting life in that beautiful inspiring character...Thank you @Nicholas Gonzalez

I have stopped watching this show post Melendez death. This popped in my YT recommendation, just clicked to see Melendez. I can't watch it anymore, especially, with them portraying Covid-19 stuffs, I simply can't watch it after losing my grandma 2 months ago. I can't go through those emotions again. Killing Melendez is the stupidest plot development tool I have seen in a while. It just killed the series for me. And now this Claire talking to ghost or hallucination thing to give her a "closure"? Lol that's another stupid plot point. Claire deserves better, losing her mom and then Melendez (after confessing about her feelings). Writers went pretty crazy to make it "realistic".

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

very well said

@janeojeogwu7123

3 жыл бұрын

Me too..I’m done with this show 😞which is quite sad because this show was one of the few that really got me hooked..

@shabnammullick3183

3 жыл бұрын

Same here

@samlal3618

3 жыл бұрын

@@shabnammullick3183 I hope abc cancels the show 😤😤😤

I don’t want to watch it anymore without him

I was haunted, when Dr. Melendez's death. I was crying.

The most unnecessary death of all time. Doesn't make any sense! Stupid writers.

I just dont feel like watching season 4 #missingmeledez 😔

@alebakwenare8781

3 жыл бұрын

I just tried and failed dismally 😭😭😭😭

When she looked away from him and then looked back and he was gone. 😭💔💔💔my heart is shattered

His death was unnecessary period. I feel like this closure is more for us than for Claire💔😂

I love so much this quotation : "This room is filled with stories that were cut short ; like ours. But you, you have an amazing story ahead and I can't wait to see it". I love it, but it makes me cry.

You know, I was glad to see Melendez back and all, but this only infuriated me even more. Neil and Claire deserved so much better. The only reason the writers did this whole thing with ghost!!Melendez was to cover their asses after seeing our anger about their terrible blunder killing him off. Plus his goodbye was pretty anticlimactic IMO. I tell ya, The Good Doctor is really on a downward spiral and killing off Melendez got the ball rolling.

I hate that they killed off that wonderful character! The show is history now. For me.

@RoyalMasterpiece

3 жыл бұрын

💯

@broadwaydest

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed! I refuse to watch the show I’m literally only watching this clip to see how they attempt to make up for their mistake... didn’t do well at all

@alegarcia2012

3 жыл бұрын

Same!

@Anna.78651

3 жыл бұрын

Same here

The story would have been very good if Melendez died treating covid and getting caught and died a hero fighting an unexpected and un known virus... His death would have had meaning! Unlike the original plot where they killed him just to keep story interesting!

@ocbusfan

3 жыл бұрын

If only they knew COVID was coming had they decided to kill him off that way instead, but the last season ended before the pandemic hit

@radhakrishna-fv6dt

3 жыл бұрын

@@ocbusfan yea... And they again brought him as a ghost to claire....! That's just sad! U know they shouldn't have done that... they are dishonoring charecter!

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

well, he shouldn't have died at all

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

The whole story with Dr. Melendez being killed off was bullshit! And I'm just about ready to give up on The Good Doctor I am not impressed with this season at all. I'm probably just going to buy the first three seasons of the good doctor that actually have Dr. Melendez in it. I already have the first season I just need to buy the second and third.

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 very well said!!

They both were so perfect like made for each other🥺

I miss him sooo much, my heart aches to a point where i can't watch this anymore , i just need more time to accept it 😔

They killed Melendez off to save Lea 😒😡. Why start a love story for him to die??? I was so amped up to see where their story would've taken them.

man, if you call THAT closure....

I really hope Melendez live again... If it like doppelganger Melendez, I really don't care as long Melendez exist again...

@amywalker7515

3 жыл бұрын

Perhaps they can write in an identical twin who appears out of nowhere.

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@amywalker7515 or they can have Nick come in and play a different character I mean they did that with Shaun's brother! I mean it will be weird seeing Nick play another character besides Dr. Melendez but at least he would be back on the show. I mean I think taking him off the show in the first place was bullshit.

@evemounguet5752

3 жыл бұрын

Same

@evemounguet5752

3 жыл бұрын

@@amywalker7515 if they do that it would be amazing I would be sooo HAPPY I don't even care if it isn't Melendez

@ryantoh9475

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 as you can see from dr melendez(nick gonzalez) official instagram account,he wrote a super long paragraph saying goodbye😭I believe he won't be returning anymore,and that breaks me into pieces

Words can't describe how disappointed I am with TGD. Killing Neil was the biggest mistake ever, I just can't bring myself to watch the new season. After 3 years of character development, 3 years of deepening his relationship with Claire, he dies from a curable disease, with no one - except Claire around him, while the whole medical staff was outside Petringa's room when she was dying. And now, when he's dead, no one, no one mentions him, like he never existed, which makes me even angrier. There are so many superfluous, annoying and boring characters that producers could have got rid of, but they had to kill one of the most beloved characters, who was about to have an amazing story with Claire, but their story was "cut short". My heart broke once again, when I heard these lines. With Melendaire, season 4 could have been the best of all. Instead of this, writers want Shea to be at the centre of attention, but honestly, I'm fed up with their storyline, it's so meaningless, the only thing Shaun cares about is sex, as he did in season 3. Claire and Neil didn't even share a hug or a kiss, but their feelings and emotions were so real, their love was so pure, that's what makes them unique. I'm definitely done with the show and I'm not the only one, there are plenty of people who decided not to watch it anymore. I'm sure Shore knows that, so he's trying to keep the audience by bringing Neil back as a ghost... but neither Nick nor Neil deserves that.

@DutchmanCalypso

3 жыл бұрын

Every single word of this is taken right out of my mouth! Thank you

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

@@DutchmanCalypso I'm glad to read that!

@west8480

3 жыл бұрын

Agree 100%. Very disrespectful to Nick, after all the hard word he's done for the show, he didn't deserved this. Shame.

@amywalker7515

3 жыл бұрын

Get a life. It's pure fiction.

@DutchmanCalypso

3 жыл бұрын

@@amywalker7515 You assume we don't have a life, just because we like a TV show and discuss what's happening there? Sad.

Feels empty watching the show without Melendez.

Missing melendez so badly 😭

@jasminjohn7308

2 жыл бұрын

❤️🥲🥲

The scenes in which dr. Melendez appears bring us dubious feelings, of joy to see him and of much sadness for his death. 🤔💔😔

the good doctor writers... you did this for what??????

@RoyalMasterpiece

3 жыл бұрын

Creative reasons 🙄

@omotayoayolola

3 жыл бұрын

Likeeeeeeee for whatttt????

@U.A212

3 жыл бұрын

WHAT WAS THE REASON BITCHHH??? No honestly the broke my heart

THEY COULDNT EVEN GIVE MY MAN A FUNERAL!😭

They could have killed shaun, lea, glassman and plenty of other characters and i would have still been fine with it. But not my boy melendez😭😭😭

This show helped me to find what I want in life and how to interact with people

There's no closure to what you've done... All of this was unecessary... Except making Claire suffer and grieve once again, except telling your viewers she can't be happy. I'm done with this show as much as I love Antonia Thomas. I can't stand seeing her crying all the time when she has so much potential. And I really don't care about Glassman and Debbie or Lea and Shaun who are only arguing. Melendez has not even had a decent ending. All seemed rushed and unnecessary. You destroy your show in only one episode (320). Congratulations.... Melendez and Claire were my little idiotic happiness on Monday. I will always remember them and imagine that they finally have the happy ending they deserved. Goodbye.

The saddest part of this is not that Claire and Melendez’s story were cut short but that they never had anything to begin with in the first place rather than just their feelings for each other which they didn’t acknowledge until Melendez dies

GUYS LISTEN / I THINK THEY JUST KILLED MELENDEZ TO MAKE SHAUN THE MAIN SURGEON IN THE SERIE & TO BE THE GOOD DOCTOR BCZ MELNDEZ WAS THE BEST

I miss Melendez so much

May 2021...I’m still heartbroken😔💔bring Meléndez back pleaseeeeee

This series is the epitome of an example of the word "STUPID"..I MEAN..WHY DID THEY EVEN HAVE TO KILL MELENDEZ!?

I haven’t watched the new season at all but did the show just forget about Melendez’s sister?

i have never wanted to fight a plot this much 😭why building up this relationship (which was the most beautiful one out of every couple this show has)at 1st place if he was going to die at the end before they even started 😭

@garbita.official.08

Жыл бұрын

I mean, at least start the damn thing!

When we asked for dr. Melendez back, this is not what we meant

#WeWantMelendezBACKandALIVE !

Everyone is pretty much saying the same as me WHY DID Dr. Melendez have to die???😭😭

We want Dr Neil back please.. 😭

Anyone else here that stop watching the show after this scene? 🙋 I tried to watch the first 2 episodes of the new season, i really give it a chance, but I just couldn't go on with it. The show was just... I don't know... like something was missing, nothing there made sense anymore, not for me anyway. And, after some weeks of thinking, I just realised, the missing piece, the one that made this show great in the first sesons, was this guy, the great and only Neil Melendez, the only scenes bearable to watch from season 4, were the ones in which he showed up. Miss you forever, Dr. Melendez! 😢😢

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

I stopped watching after 3x20.. and they've already lost 3.7 million viewers

@RBSR23

3 жыл бұрын

@@sole449 I'm happy to hear that, I hope they will continue to lose many more viewers. Because they deserve just that after the move they made for pure "shock value" this is the worth of that creative idea of killing the character that gave so much value to this show.

@sole449

3 жыл бұрын

@@RBSR23 I hope it gets cancelled

I'll never forgive this series for letting Dr Melendez die 😭 they need to bring him back

Why you kill him in the fist place 😡

I will never watch this show again!!!! And this isn't closure! Melendez shouldn't be dead!!!!

One reason that keeps me watching Good doctor is Dr Melendez and the whole romance building up with Claire, after season 3 I dont feel like watching it again.

So there's no decent funeral or anyone missing him except for Claire and Lim ?

Such a stupid death - writers did us dirty

Dr Melendez was an integral part of the show

Can we stop torturing Claire please???

The way he died was stupd, there was no closure and they left it hanging like they wern't sure what to do... ugh, they had a more interesting story than shaun and lea

@asiyah7714

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly!!!

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

Honestly there was no closure I thought the ending was extremely inappropriate and unnecessary no disrespect to David Shore or Daniel Dae Kim cuz I think they're both brilliant producers but they didn't even have the decency to give Neil a proper death! And that pissed me off. I love Neil and everything but they didn't need to bring him back as a hallucination I thought that was extremely inappropriate. Because all they're doing is torturing poor Claire. Bringing him back in flashbacks is one thing but bringing him back as a hallucination in my personal opinion was completely disrespectful and inappropriate. I would have even been happy if they would have brought Nick back as another character on the show just as long as we got to see Nick again. I just thought the whole hallucination thing was complete bullshit I'm sorry even though I was happy to see Dr. Melendez again I still thought it was bullshit! Because the whole time I'm watching the episodes I just wanted to cry and wanted Dr. Melendez back plus it just pisses me off that they picked Lea over him.

@asiyah7714

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 Yes them constantly hurting Claire is ridiculous, can she please be happy without having her heart stomped on!!! I prefer ANYONE over Lea, I can't stand her 👎so can imagine how pissed off I was when they saved her but killed Neil!!! Yes the hallucination hurt because he kept talking about him and Claire not having the chance to be together, it's like the writers wanted to rub salt on the wound! 💔 I would've definitely preferred seeing flashbacks, it would've been nice seeing a peek into the time they spent together when they weren't working💘

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@asiyah7714 Exactly! Not only that but last night's episode pissed me off too because they could have at least had Neil tell Claire before he moved on that he loved her.

@asiyah7714

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 YES!!!

It's nothing without you 😥😥 miss you

My motivation to watch this series was Melendez And his association with Claire was the most interesting Killing him sucks Whether you invent some science fiction or anything just bring him back preeety pleaassssseeeee😥😥😥

Vuelve Doctor Meléndez....

When she said "He changed me" I choked up a bit

Dr Melandez!!! 😭😭😭

I literally can't watch the show without Melendez it's like he's supposed to be there helping and giving encouraging words while being blunt at the same time. The energy is off without him

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

Feels weird watching The Good Doctor without him. The energy is off without Dr. Melendez! I'm trying my hardest to get into this season but I just can't. And I just can't stand Lea I used to be able to tolerate her but ever since she did that to Shaun & ever since the producers picked her over Dr. Melendez I really can't stand her.

@with-BANDURA

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 happy to hear that someone feels same like me! Out from respect to the show, I forced myself to watch 7 episodes, but couldn't stand it. It did not get better

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@with-BANDURA Not to add that the story lines are just getting ridiculous like having Nicholas come back as a hallucination for Claire was just complete bullshit! I mean seriously taking the love of her life and bringing him back as a hallucination was just complete and utter bullshit, I was sitting here thinking really hasn't Claire suffered enough first she loses her mother and then she loses Neil how much more are you going to put Claire through? And then they come up with this ridiculous storyline where Shaun starts having inappropriate feelings for another woman while he's with Lea it's like seriously you go through all this trouble to make those two a couple just to turn around and "Almost" have Shaun cheat on her didn't make any sense to me not to add that they have Dr. Lim get in this motorcycle accident and she doesn't have one broken bone not one she just walks into the ER with just a couple scratches and I'm thinking seriously? I just thought that was completely unrealistic because she would have had way more injuries than that.

@with-BANDURA

3 жыл бұрын

@@katie2967 oh yeah the ghost thing was ridiculous! I mean it is medical show, she having hallucinations means she has some kind of tumor (as Dr. HOUSE would say) and then those lines were complete shit. Yeah, storylines are super not natural, they all develop so fast, and they almost cut all the lines which they made through the seasons and start them over. I mean Park should have left or his family should join him here, they made it clear that he wants to have family back. Then Reznik story which became quite interesting to the end of season 3 is forgotten. And Shaun and Lea, I have no words about it, I fast-forward through it. It is super annoying. This relationship turned Shaun back in his development. Now he is sex obsessed teneger. It is sad, that good show became this. Double sad, because I didn't watch anything in very long time what would be so enjoyable. I gave 4th season a chance, but after I watched this week episode, I gave up. The writers had their time to prove worth of that "creative idea"...

@katie2967

3 жыл бұрын

@@with-BANDURA Not to mention that another thing that pisses me off about the show is the fact that they bring in Andrews niece and she gets way more backstory than Neil does and she's not even in the show four episodes! And Melendez was in the show three years and the only thing we find out about his life is he had a sister that was disabled that he took care of and before we can find out anymore about his life they kill his character off and that pissed me off. Another thing that is really irritating me this season and maybe I'm overreacting a little bit but nobody and I mean nobody except for Dr. Lim and Claire has even addressed it or showed any sort of emotion that Neil has passed away or even addressed it not even Shaun has even acted like he cares that Neil's passed away. The only two people that has even visited Neil's grave is Audrey and Claire. You would think at least Dr. Glassman considering how long he's known Dr. Melendez would at least show some sort of emotion or even visited his grave, I mean has anyone even told Jessica that Neil passed away? I mean I wonder.

I would rather have dr lim pass away than having Dr Melendez passing away

@zahabiapancha5652

2 жыл бұрын

Right?!!

Claire has been through so much, losing her mom and losing her love interest. Still, there are so many things (or mysteries) about life and death that we can't understand, and so many things we can't control. I hope all the doctors know that.

My heart is still broken.

He changed me and that's not gonna go away. 😭 Made me cry so much 🙄 why did they have to kill him off Claire was finally going to be happy

I won't watch this series ever. .dr malendez was my favourite.. can't accept his death

It's as if I'm claire... I feel genuine pain that his story was cut short

I am livid !! I will never get over how dirty the writers did Claire in one season with her mothers death then the man who she let help her heal like why can't black women just be fucking happy ? Like fuck the writers, they had no good reason to kill Melendez off, we deserved a love story, esp being that it was such a slow burn.. not whatever tf this is.

Yesterday only I have completed season 3. Talk about closure, how will you bring closure to the fans.

I haven’t watched this new season...because of what they did to Melendez and Claire’s character it was so heartbreaking...I don’t need closure jor..😭 but I hope I can get over it someday... I dunno 😒

Literally turned off the show, and never watched it again after Neil died. Destroyed it with his death imo.

@mishxalhey7319

14 күн бұрын

Same here. I was like I’m done I can’t believe they just did that, he was one of the best characters in the show.

Oh my God! Where is this going if I may ask 😢😭

Every time i see this scene.. Tear rolls down my eyes.. Characters are what we can relate to.. Melendez was one.. He didn't got his love.. His story could have been better..

I cried rivers after Melendez died. I loved someone who brought out the best in me. I realized very late and was afraid to let that person know in fear of rejection cz I felt that person had platonic feelings for me. Now I don't know whether I'd be able to find love again.

Grey's anatomy, Flash and now in The Good Doctor. Men, producers do like killing his characters.

Melendez!!!😭💔

Melendez falls into coma and then he wakes up again after a long while... I prefer this to seeing him in Claire’s imagination

They killed off an amazing character only to bring him back again as a hallucination realizing they went down the wrong direction with the series lmao

Melendez is dead but park just said the most real thing to his wife

@roycekhan2691

3 жыл бұрын

True...

I need Melendez and Browne more!

It's good that Netflix only provide 3 Seasons..

Melendez we cannot forget uuuuu love from Kerala India 💜

I love this series..can u put full episodes plzx

@moseskuria1234

3 жыл бұрын

It's on hulu

@yShaynex

3 жыл бұрын

There's a KZread account called Driet 2 that posted all the seasons and full episodes

@meghanansetty4854

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you

They should’ve kept him alive for the first episode or two, have him and Claire treat a COVID patient and Melendez unfortunately gets the rona and Claire has to sit there seeing the man she loves die slowly in front of her and it’ll have a story arc of Claire asking herself “Could’ve I done more? I should’ve saved him” etc

@sadafnayab5507

3 жыл бұрын

Omg

@janderson947

3 жыл бұрын

Yes BBC that would have been a great storyline

Which episode is this???where can I watch it

My heart aches so much 💔😭. I will never understand why they had to kill him off. Can't they bring him back? 💔💔😭