CHEAP v/s EXPENSIVE Pastel Pencils - Not what I thought...

I'm testing the cheap(er) Carbothello pastel pencils with the expensive Caran D'Ache pastel pencils.
So are the expensive Caran D'Ache pastel pencils really worth it? I was suprised by both brands in this review!
Reference photo credit to Julie Marsh
unsplash.com/photos/a-black-a...
Stabilo Carbothello Pencils I used:
Titanium White 100
Ivory 105
Grey White 110
Lamp Black 760
Cold Grey I 720
Paynes Grey 770
Caran D'Ache Pastel Pencils I used:
Greyish Black 008
Light Grey 003
Silver Grey 002
Black 009
Chinese White 901
Bismuth Whit 811
Clairefontaine Pastelmat Paper in Dark Grey
Full pet portrait course is coming soon!
Full length online art classes:
emilyrosefineart.gumroad.com/...
Sign up for the pet portrait masterclass release:
emilyrosefineart.co.uk/
Favorite brand of pastel pencil? Faber Castell
Favourite paper for pastels? Clairefontaine pastelmat
How to transfer an outline:
• Accurate Outlines from...
How to draw curly fur:
• How to draw curly dog ...
How to draw fur:
• How to draw fur | BEGI...
How to draw a dogs nose:
• METHOD for drawing dog...

Пікірлер: 30

  • @bridgetspaeth9751
    @bridgetspaeth97515 ай бұрын

    Just wanted to say that's a Boston terrier not a French bulldog(frenchie). Nice video and review tho! I want to start working with the pastel charcoal pencils and your videos are really helpful.

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Thanks Bridget! Call myself a pet portrait artist 🫣

  • @CayGjertson
    @CayGjertson4 ай бұрын

    Thank you for your review! I have been working in watercolor but have been thinking about pastels and didn’t know what to invest in. As I have learned with watercolors, there is a huge difference in brands and it has taken me a while to learn which colors I prefer in which brands. I love hearing “permission” to spend less and still get a quality I can learn to use.

  • @davidmolloy126
    @davidmolloy1263 ай бұрын

    Thanks very much Emily Rose, I love your honesty .xxx

  • @bobmorey3952
    @bobmorey39525 ай бұрын

    Great video! Wish you could’ve had the 750 for a true comparison since their true black, as another previously mentioned. Softer than CD and FC and similar darkness to FC, but CD is slightly darker of the three IMO. Love the 770 for shadows and undertones (feel it gives a little more vibrancy/depth vs FC 181, although 181 is a little darker. The 760 is too greenish for my liking, although that sometimes has use)! The 770 & FC’s 175 dark sepia are my most used pencils. Keep up the great work! I’d love to see another similar video!

  • @annetteatkins7164
    @annetteatkins71645 ай бұрын

    I adore the CarbOthello pastel pencils. I have the Faber Castels and the Derwent, but the CarbOthello’s buttery texture is my favorite. 750 is the blackest black in the set. I think the 760 pencil is more of a indigo.

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Amazing, thank you so much for the information Annette! I shall have to get that black and try it out myself 😊

  • @catrionaparker7485
    @catrionaparker74855 ай бұрын

    Thank you ,very helpful review.

  • @miss-asketches5284
    @miss-asketches52845 ай бұрын

    Helpful review, thanks! 👍

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Thank you!

  • @danasmith5761
    @danasmith57613 ай бұрын

    This helped me a lot, thank you. How do sharpen the pencils, can you use a pencil sharpener?

  • @elliegreen872
    @elliegreen8722 ай бұрын

    Very useful, thank you.

  • @sheri2554
    @sheri25545 ай бұрын

    I have the full set of Faber Castell and 48 Stabilo Carbothello. What CD pencils would you recommend to supplement with the Caran Dache?

  • @PianoSightReading
    @PianoSightReading5 ай бұрын

    Thank you so much for this comparison, Emily. I have Derwent pastel pencils and wonder how they compare to these other brands. What are your thoughts on the Derwent pastel pencils? Have you tried them?

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Hi, I’m not the biggest fan of Derwent overall, but they have a few great colours. I find them too chalky and ‘dusty’ so the details fade away as I work. However, for a few colours I would certainly use them 😊

  • @PianoSightReading

    @PianoSightReading

    5 ай бұрын

    @@emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820 I see. That's good to know. I might add a few carbothello pastel pencils to my collection and see which ones I prefer. Thanks!

  • @CreativeTeamGMA7
    @CreativeTeamGMA75 ай бұрын

    This is good review, i am now learning to use paspen i prefer always FC when it comes to details and its hard but yes for colors and blending its Carbo i heard if you got a carandasche pastel broken you can do a replacement..

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Yes I think I’d agree! FC are the most similar to a regular pencil so I think that’s why I like them for details. The carbothello set do offer a lot for their price 😊

  • @CreativeTeamGMA7

    @CreativeTeamGMA7

    5 ай бұрын

    Used the reference and how u did this , and i was surprised did a decent work, ty

  • @anderssolaas6954
    @anderssolaas69545 ай бұрын

    Helpfull! And nice drawings:)

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Glad it was useful!

  • @Norunormii
    @Norunormii5 ай бұрын

    Thanks! Your a great help ❤️

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Thanks so much!

  • @fuzzydragons
    @fuzzydragons5 ай бұрын

    i would love a full set of Caran D'Ache pastel pencils,m the f ew I have our never used lol (afraid to waste them lol)

  • @rosetorres8912
    @rosetorres89125 ай бұрын

    Hi Emily I was interested in signing up for the pet portrait masterclass; I wanted to know if this class would also include the full-length online courses you already have. Also, I noticed the price is listed in pounds; how much will that be in US dollars? Thank you

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Hi Rose, so the new pet portrait masterclass will be its own stand alone course. It’s still being made, but will include full length portrait drawings, special technique classes and advice for setting up as a pet portrait artist. When it’s ready to be released, they’ll be a lot more information about the details 😊 In terms of pounds to dollars, I’m not sure. I believe the exchange rate will be set by the payment system, so PayPal or your bank. 😊

  • @marjoleinschut8296
    @marjoleinschut82965 ай бұрын

    Lamp black is not black, you are right. In the 19th century they used a kind of oil for their lamps which had a color between darkblue/black and dark grey. So this is why they call it lampblack and not black! Caran dáche I find the blackest black of all ranges and the azurite white is great for whiskers, the whitest white :) you did an excellent review, thank you!

  • @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    @emilyrosewildlifeart-paste9820

    5 ай бұрын

    Thanks so much for this! I shall have to get their neutral black and try it out. Totally agree that the Caran dache black is fab, it’s just so velvety dark 😊

  • @euartes2794
    @euartes27943 ай бұрын

    😀👍👍

  • @mute_ed984
    @mute_ed9845 ай бұрын

    The first one is also justified depending on the situation. If Doggie watching TV or something