Chance of Taiwan, China Reunification is ‘Nil’ - What Happens Next?

Ойын-сауық

'International Relations Consists of Keeping Myths Alive'
There's no solution to the situations in Taiwan and Gaza, says former Singapore diplomat Bilahari Kausikan.
by Hope Kahn, National Press Foundation
Most international issues have no solutions, but they can be managed, says Bilahari Kausikan, the former Permanent Secretary for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Singapore.
“That’s good news for diplomats and journalists because it means we’ll never be out of a job,” he told NPF International Trade Journalism Fellows.
Taiwan and Gaza fall into this category of management as the best-case scenario, Kausikan said.
The prospect of Taiwan joining China is “nil,” Kausikan said.
“Why would the Taiwanese want to voluntarily reunify? There’s no support for the two extremes of unilateral independence or reunification. Most people want the status quo to remain and I think the status quo can be maintained.”
But while Kausikan criticized China’s leader Xi Jinping as “mediocre at governance,” he does not anticipate war.
“Whatever you may think of the Chinese leadership, they’re not gamblers, and they’re not going to roll the dice with the most important thing to them which is the continuation of party rule. … If there is a risk, it’s going to be conflict by accident, by miscalculation - not war by design.”
There are two scenarios where the Chinese must fight, he said. “The first is a very low probability, high impact scenario, which is if Taiwan revives its nuclear weapon ambitions … the higher probability scenario is if Taiwanese domestic politics takes some strange turn.”
Kausikan says that a lot of international relations and diplomacy consists of keeping myths credibly alive so people don’t take drastic actions - which is true in both Taiwan and Gaza, he said, “which gives you something to write about.”
Gaza has been “ill managed for quite a long time,” Kausikan said.
While a two-state solution is favored by many nations, “I have not seen anybody come up with a viable pathway to a two-state solution,” Kausikan said, predicting that the conflict will remain subregional and not spread. After “mistakes” in Iraq and Afghanistan, the U.S. is “offshore balancing” with Gaza, Kausikan said.
“You have these demonstrations about Gaza at the universities, but the demonstrations over the Vietnam War were far worse. Why? Because Americans were dying.”
Speaker: Bilahari Kausikan, Former Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Singapore
Transcript, summary and resources: nationalpress.org/topic/bilah...
This fellowship is part of an ongoing program of journalism training and awards for trade coverage sponsored by the Hinrich Foundation.
This video was produced within the Evelyn Y. Davis studios. NPF is solely responsible for the content.

Пікірлер: 392

  • @Liboch
    @Liboch3 күн бұрын

    This guy once suggested that Cambodia and Laos be expelled from ASEAN for being too close to China. He is a nut case. Even the US wouldn't suggest this. 😂

  • @GeoScorpion

    @GeoScorpion

    Күн бұрын

    Yeah, we would. We're very annoyed at how close Australia and Canada are to China and Cambodia and Laos are just suburbs of China in comparison. That said, I admit that they see China as a sometimes protector against a sometimes-aggressive Vietnam.

  • @michaeltse321

    @michaeltse321

    15 сағат бұрын

    Singapore is a joke. They have has the same party since 1959 - lol - their elietes are just as corrupt as the US and western countries - lol

  • @kongking5048
    @kongking50482 күн бұрын

    he has no ideas what he was talking about.

  • @lowpecklim855
    @lowpecklim8552 күн бұрын

    Cynical n low class diplomat or exdiplomat from spore..surprising😢😂

  • @rbc812

    @rbc812

    Күн бұрын

    Nope. He is so wise, smarter than Lee Kuan Yew. XJP is a shit brain.

  • @xmen2130
    @xmen21303 күн бұрын

    He is not fit to lick the shoes of his ex bosses George and Kishore.

  • @rbc812

    @rbc812

    Күн бұрын

    George and Kishore are communists.

  • @barryng1

    @barryng1

    Күн бұрын

    Kishore and George are shameless CCP arse kissers.

  • @exoticGlobalTravels

    @exoticGlobalTravels

    12 сағат бұрын

    Kishore was only Ambassador rank. He is a Permanent Secretary. Higher rank than Kishore.

  • @ssss8162
    @ssss81623 күн бұрын

    Kausikan is an embarrassment and not worth my time. I'm just here for the comments

  • @chriswong9158

    @chriswong9158

    2 күн бұрын

    Only did 8:00 min., now signing off !!!

  • @user-ed9so2rb4k

    @user-ed9so2rb4k

    Күн бұрын

    He is trying very, very hard to reproduce the image of his predecessor Prof. Kishore in the Foreign Ministry. Any success???

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI

    @Fr.VeniceLAI

    Күн бұрын

    ..myself glued and even downloaded and saved the entire episode to watch again and again to this man's genius and out-spoken insights ... so, so very rare these days, where most if not even Presidents and Prime Ministers dare spoke so openly such comments ... that Paramount Leader Xi Jinping (soon likely to be named Chairman Xi) as a mediocre performer !!.

  • @rbc812

    @rbc812

    Күн бұрын

    Disagree with your communist view. He is so brilliant. XJP and Putin have brain made from shit.

  • @petervote7914

    @petervote7914

    Күн бұрын

    He is ultra hardcore anti China, anti chinese. Very odd this kind of sinophobe can be Singapore diplomat. I see him as human garbage.

  • @gc23336
    @gc233362 күн бұрын

    Management of 1.4 billion in housing, infrastructure, food, heathcare, education, jobs - mediocre? Arrogant.

  • @rbc812

    @rbc812

    Күн бұрын

    The truth is the Chinese are escaping. That is mediocre.

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    Күн бұрын

    Even Xi Jinping's daughter has moved to USA. She has been in USA since 2010.

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    Күн бұрын

    ​@@rbc812most of CCP elites families are in USA, UK, Australia...😂😂😂

  • @jmjt3709

    @jmjt3709

    Күн бұрын

    At the same time, the top Chinese scientists and engineers educated and working in the US are heading back to China.

  • @thebarehandsdoctor2769
    @thebarehandsdoctor27692 күн бұрын

    Who is this guy? full of bullshit,

  • @lagrangewei
    @lagrangewei2 күн бұрын

    I am Singaporean and I support Chinese reunification. people might be in denial but it is inevitable. it might take 1 year, 10 year or a 100 year. however the chinese identity in Taiwan will not disappear. the native will not allow the creation of a "Taiwanese" identity that threaten their own heritage, they saw what allow to America native when the American identity was born...

  • @user-ed9so2rb4k

    @user-ed9so2rb4k

    Күн бұрын

    How long can US support Taiwan, which is located thousands of km away while China can actually "visit" Taiwan on every Sunday morning!

  • @barryng1

    @barryng1

    Күн бұрын

    You are not Singaporean, you are a CCP wumao shill and little pink propagandist

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI

    @Fr.VeniceLAI

    18 сағат бұрын

    Are you aware..likely after Taiwan ROC unification to PRChina if successfully acquired, without much damage or consequence .. . Singapore / & South--East-Asia may be next in the Chinese Communist Party radar/target sight. If you're a Singaporean ... you can download this CCP's song, "Ode to the Motherland" via KZread, you should be prepared ... the current CCP doctrine is expansion of its domains ... to take control of all countries in the South-China-Sea, after taiwan ROC.

  • @HYH2023

    @HYH2023

    15 сағат бұрын

    How about Singapore "reunified" with China? Quite a lot of Chinese think it is part of China. Why not make it de jure?

  • @octavioferrer1676

    @octavioferrer1676

    14 сағат бұрын

    @@user-ed9so2rb4k It is not only America but also many other countries around the world with similar democratic ideologies ,many in the Indo-Pacific region, that will support the Taiwanese people fight for independence from CCP rule.

  • @Jin-oq2qu
    @Jin-oq2qu3 күн бұрын

    Its better to listen to George Yeo's views. Kausikuan in Chinese means sheet stirrer.

  • @williamkwah1
    @williamkwah12 күн бұрын

    He is not a good speaker. I switch off after the first few minutes.

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    8 сағат бұрын

    @@williamkwah1 you would listen attentively if he was a CCP shill like Kishore 🤣

  • @kongking5048
    @kongking50482 күн бұрын

    What a clown 😢

  • @chriswong9158

    @chriswong9158

    2 күн бұрын

    A clown that can lead to what US/NATO offer to Europe today.... Peace in ASEAN was not following the West.

  • @rbc812

    @rbc812

    Күн бұрын

    Hi communist.

  • @petervote7914

    @petervote7914

    Күн бұрын

    He looks like a clown also.

  • @GeoScorpion

    @GeoScorpion

    Күн бұрын

    Yeah, you are: You post the same three words everywhere that shows China in a poor light. 🤡

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    8 сағат бұрын

    @@GeoScorpion he wants 50 cents

  • @user-my7wn6ps1y
    @user-my7wn6ps1y5 күн бұрын

    Another u.s. spokesman

  • @360du

    @360du

    2 күн бұрын

    And you are a 🇨🇳 spokesman?

  • @huanghermann5207

    @huanghermann5207

    2 күн бұрын

    @@360du Yes, so what?

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    Күн бұрын

    At least he is not a CCP'S spokesman.

  • @coshyno

    @coshyno

    10 сағат бұрын

    @@ggc7318 CPC*

  • @ssss8162
    @ssss81625 күн бұрын

    Kausikan is a clown. He has been making excuses for the US for years.

  • @360du

    @360du

    2 күн бұрын

    And you are a CCP apologist?

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong91582 күн бұрын

    Henry Kissinger Quote: “To be an enemy of America can be dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal.”

  • @Kimmimaro86
    @Kimmimaro862 күн бұрын

    In the Cantonese language, his name is literally "Gao Si Guan", Sh*t Stirring Stick.

  • @clipwat1511

    @clipwat1511

    2 күн бұрын

    😂 nice!

  • @Utube1024
    @Utube10242 күн бұрын

    He is of indian origin (ah san) no surprise for being anti-China.

  • @charliecheng3340
    @charliecheng33403 күн бұрын

    I call kassakan a Mediocare from Singapore

  • @axnjack5
    @axnjack56 күн бұрын

    It looks like this guy is constantly drooling. Kind of annoying.

  • @PrimeChaosVC
    @PrimeChaosVC3 күн бұрын

    Wow, this woke me from the illusion that Singapore will always select exceptional and really competent people for important tasks. We need more people like him doing talks like this in public, so we know what kind of people we are dealing with for the sake of rational Singaporeans.

  • @liongjiahwong5478

    @liongjiahwong5478

    2 күн бұрын

    How competent are you. ? Are you in politics if you do not join one and push your worth.

  • @choysiongwong7187
    @choysiongwong71872 күн бұрын

    The BRI Belt and Road project is a part of CHINA PROJECT (my definition). This project is similar to that abandoned by the USA. But they try to derail the China Project. Back to topic at hand, 'China' and Taiwan may unify at another level, a great fear of the USA/other.

  • @dylanthomas12321

    @dylanthomas12321

    9 сағат бұрын

    BRI is a failure. Do the research.

  • @saehian
    @saehian2 күн бұрын

    US's lackey. 😂😂😂. He doesn't knows China loans and help which conquer or colonise countries.

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    Күн бұрын

    At least not CCP'S lap dog like Kishore.

  • @simonlow3338
    @simonlow33382 күн бұрын

    He is a rubbish

  • @rbc812

    @rbc812

    Күн бұрын

    Nope he is so smart.

  • @KoHo-xy2mp

    @KoHo-xy2mp

    Күн бұрын

    He is so smart even then xi

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    8 сағат бұрын

    @simonlow3338 just because he is not on the side of CCP ?

  • @steventan385
    @steventan3852 күн бұрын

    This guy is a maverick He thinks he is the smartest guy in town. No way near Kishore.

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    Күн бұрын

    Kishore is a 🐍

  • @philipwong895
    @philipwong8956 күн бұрын

    The US is continuing with its strategy to keep Asia poor and divided. This policy was articulated in the top-secret U.S. Foreign Policy written 76 years ago. February 24, 1948, Declassified U.S. Foreign Policy: Furthermore, we have about 50% of the world’s wealth but only 6.3% of its population. This disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia. In this situation, we cannot fail to be the object of envy and resentment. Our real task in the coming period is to devise a pattern of relationships which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security. ... that Japan and the Philippines will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system and that if we can contrive to retain effective control over these areas there can be no serious threat to our security from the East within our time. Taiwan was added to the Pacific security system after Chiang's army retreated to the island of Taiwan in 1949. South Korea was added after the Korean War in 1953. The attempt with Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia was abandoned in 1975. The 1989 attempt in China failed. The 2019-2020 attempt in Hong Kong also failed. Anywhere in the world, if there is a border dispute, it is usually the result of a line drawn by an Englishman; if it is an internal dispute, it is usually the US fueling it. Difference in implementation of divide and conquer strategy. The 'Arsenal of Democracy' produces 40 percent of the world's weapons. It is a very profitable business model in which other countries buy these weapons to fight each other. The key is maximizing profits without shedding US blood by inducing conflicts between and within countries outside the USA. One client is eager to spend AUD 368 billion to buy a few high-quality used nuclear-powered submarines. This business model's critical components are NATO, QUAD, ANZUS, Five Eyes, AUKUS, and MCC (Mutual Cross-Service Agreement). The US makes the rules, and the US and their friends do not have to follow them. Since WWII, the United States has started 201 wars, overthrew 36 foreign leaders, killed or attempted to kill 50, dropped bombs in 30 countries, and interfered in 86 foreign elections. To make the world safe for democracy, the US has caused the deaths of tens of millions of people in its conflicts in Korea, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, and Syria. The CIA was involved in covert operations that resulted in mass killings of communists in over 22 countries, 500,000 to 2,000,000 Indonesian civilians disappeared in 1965-1966.

  • @tthotty8679

    @tthotty8679

    2 күн бұрын

    If that’s facts then you need a channel

  • @grannylil8036

    @grannylil8036

    2 күн бұрын

    👏🏻

  • @vivienneL1011

    @vivienneL1011

    2 күн бұрын

    Why you guy has so much knowledge, well informed...?

  • @choonhockong8215
    @choonhockong82153 күн бұрын

    I suggest Bilahari Kausikhan watch the video: Lee Kuan Yew on China, Taiwan and relations with the USA and the rest of the world. The founding father of Singapore independence from the colonial master, I saluted him as a visionary leader who helped Singapore economy growth and social security, etc. Don't be a mouthpiece for the Western powers. 😂

  • @darthvader4209

    @darthvader4209

    3 күн бұрын

    What makes you think Bilahari hasn’t watched nor learned from LKY? Perhaps you shouldn’t be a mouthpiece for the CCP either 😂

  • @Jin-oq2qu

    @Jin-oq2qu

    3 күн бұрын

    Bilahari kausikan has been discredited in Singapore.

  • @stvnzhu2387

    @stvnzhu2387

    3 күн бұрын

    @@darthvader4209 how much u r paid by CIA ?

  • @ssss8162

    @ssss8162

    3 күн бұрын

    @@darthvader4209 How has anyone here been a mouthpiece of CCP? Kindly elaborate

  • @darthvader4209

    @darthvader4209

    3 күн бұрын

    @@stvnzhu2387 I wished the CIA pays me. I’ve heard they pay well; much better than 50 cents 😂

  • @user-ne8yi1io4h
    @user-ne8yi1io4h5 күн бұрын

    Laughing gas Bila in the same league as Kamala 😂 keep on laughing.

  • @ex0duzz
    @ex0duzzКүн бұрын

    There's LKY, Kishore, George Yeo. And then there's this guy. Lol. 10 mins in and hes said absolutely nothing except he doesn't believe in Asian century. Sure. India is the one who's not going to join in the CHINESE century. Everything else he says is a waste of time. He keeps talking about what he believes in or not and China's "serious structural problems" and "demographic problems". If means absolutely nothing. Just another biased us/west apologist and China basher. Not objective at all. Nothing he said is insightful. XJP is mediocre and only good amassing power? BRI, his anti corruption drive, cracking down on unsustainable growth like Jack ma and Alibaba etc. if XJP is mediocre then every other leader is a joke. Just the things above already puts him and China heads and shoulders above every other leader and country. He says that eradication of poverty has nothing to do with XJP? You can say the same about any leader. He downplays everything that happened under XJP watch, but at the same time himself did not mention any reason for why he's mediocre. He made the claim, so onus is on him to back up or prove his claim.. why is Xi mediocre? He never says. Complete joke. He speaks in generalities only because he has nothing else. Why is belt and road bad? China was attacked and trade war waged under XJP watch. China overtook USA in everything under Xi watch. From GDP to every technology. He handled COVID better than any other country and leader. He raised China's technology and military power from nothing to world leader and peer of USA, if not above usa. He reigned in all the structural excesses and corruption that came about due to Dengs reforms. Deng and previous leaders never had to deal with USA attacking China with full court press and not just defended, but has lead China to greater heights than ever. Then we also have China's space program.. he took China to the greatest heights its ever been. He expanded BRICS and now everyone wants to join. Belt and road is still growing and doing great. He claims China is not talking about it so it's a failure? Nonsense. It's only a decade old, same as BRICS. But even in just that short time, it has changed the world and is reshaping global balance of power. USA and West have declined massively in the last 10-15 years while China has booned massively under XJP. Where is the mediocrity? J don't see it. I see it for USA and western leaders. Mediocrity is the best they can get if we are being generous and diplomatic. Otherwise if we are being frank, then they have been utter disasters. USA has forced its vassals to cripple and destroy their own economies and futures. Like Japan, SK, Taiwan, Netherlands with the chip ban. Like Germany, UK etc with Ukraine war. Japan with plaza accord. They are all currently in recession and have no future to hope for. USA and west supporting Israel and genocide in Gaza only gave up all credibility and China has been the biggest beneficiary of all these issues. That has all been under XJP watch. He will probably try to downplay it and say it was due to Deng or whatever which is just ridiculous nonsense. Saudi Arabia and Iran have joined brics after china brokered rapprochement between the two enemies. Malaysia joining brics. Usa forced Philippines to be cannon fodder and antagonize China over SCS but China called usas bluff, and now USA is nowhere to be seen when pH needs them most. USA and pH is all talk. China has biggest navy in the world, and now has like 280x the shipbuilding capacity USA does. China not only survived usas chip ban and full court press to kill China's high tech development, but is thriving. China is more united and stronger than ever. USA could not even kill Huawei, let alone china. China came from "nowhere" and in the last 3-4 years has taken over the global electric car industry, making USA have to do 100% tariffs and hand china the crown for free trade. China has full domestic capability to mass produce 5th gen engines and jets. China has caught up in all crucial core technologies and usa has no cards to play, nothing left to ban or sanction. Their whole decoupling and de risking strategy has failed due to XJP leadership. Even with covid, USA and wests full court press and trade wars and tech bans, China under XJP at its worst has still managed to keep 5%+ GDP growth and is doing better than ever. All serious "structural issues" like infrastructure over capacity and associated bubbles has been popped by XJP and the government intentionally. They didn't bail out ever grande and they banned the Alibaba IPO intentionally. this showed great foresight and courage to stop full on growth in return for more stable quality growth. All this and more happened under XJPs watch. All massive changes and growth. He turned China from a growing great power into an undisputed superpower and not just a peer competitor but into a superpower that everyone knows will overtake USA in EVERYTHING if it hasn't already. The Asian century? Nah, because India is part of Asia and because of its mediocre leadership and corrupt and inept system will not follow China's rise.. It's the Chinese century. And anyone who is friendly with China will undoubtedly rise with them. Just see Russia. Growing at 3-4%, fastest in the West. Mainly due to China. While EU and anti China forces are all suffering. China by itself is responsible for like 1/3rd of all global growth, and then rest is mainly from countries who are China's biggest trade partners. See Vietnam and SEA. Growing massively due to china. Compare with pH or Japan or SK or Taiwan. They are being sacrificed for us interests, while those who work with china are growing. Even if he doesn't want to give XJP the credit, China's rise and accomplishments cannot be denied. So it doesn't matter if he wants to give XJP credit or not. This guy is a joke and has no idea what he's talking about and downplaying all of Chinas achievements under XJP.

  • @octavioferrer1676

    @octavioferrer1676

    13 сағат бұрын

    USA and Ph all talk??? What about China threatening to invade Taiwan for the last 70 years and nothing has really happened but all just talk. They even threatened to shoot down Nancy Pelosi's plane on her way to visit Taiwan as a gesture of support, did anything really happen on her visit?? Of course nothing happened as expected. XJP just went on to display tantrums firing missiles past Taiwan and surrounding it to display its military might without actually firing a shot at its target in an attempt to save face. This is what "all talk" is.

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong91582 күн бұрын

    China PRC read: ‘Never interfere with an enemy while he’s in the process of destroying himself.’ - Napoleon Bonaparte

  • @jmjt3709

    @jmjt3709

    Күн бұрын

    以逸待劳

  • @metaphosV
    @metaphosV2 күн бұрын

    Big joker LOL

  • @GeoScorpion
    @GeoScorpionКүн бұрын

    A lot of what he says is NOT what we want to hear, but if we're honest with ourselves, he's not always wrong when we want to disagree with him.

  • @lokkaisa
    @lokkaisa2 күн бұрын

    If Xi Jingpin was a mediocre leader, I wonder, is there any leader can be rated as great or even good? There was a saying that it is a huge achievement by feeding and providing proper housing, education, medical care for 1.4B people. Xi has not only done that, but also had taken it to a much higher level.

  • @happyhappynuts

    @happyhappynuts

    Күн бұрын

    Hu Jintao did also

  • @Gman979
    @Gman9793 күн бұрын

    I normally don't pay any attention to this guy.

  • @josephkiang8222
    @josephkiang82222 күн бұрын

    Nuts

  • @user-cn5ri5he4c
    @user-cn5ri5he4c2 күн бұрын

    I just spent several weeks in Taiwan! This guy is out of touch. Has anyone ever spoken to anyone from Taiwan who says they aren't Chinese? Of course, not. The first thing they say is they are Chinese.

  • @MS-ce8nr

    @MS-ce8nr

    2 күн бұрын

    No sir, only 2.4% identify themselves as Chinese.

  • @georgiaguardian4696

    @georgiaguardian4696

    2 күн бұрын

    More than 65% Taiwanese think they are just Taiwanese and the number is still climbing. Why don’t you ask Koreans or Vietnamese to be united with China? You are a nut case..

  • @user-my6ig5dm9f

    @user-my6ig5dm9f

    2 күн бұрын

    ok, the south koreans and north koreans consider themselves Koreans too,. ur point is?

  • @annleland6422

    @annleland6422

    2 күн бұрын

    Most recent poll showed that 78% of people in Taiwan said they are Taiwanese, 7% Chinese and 8% both.

  • @georgiaguardian4696

    @georgiaguardian4696

    2 күн бұрын

    @@user-my6ig5dm9f the CCP wants to claim that whoever think they are Chinese should give up their lands and properties to CCP

  • @kinboon3138
    @kinboon31383 күн бұрын

    65 minute: He mention USA has been offshore balance for the last 50 years (or after the Vietnam war). When did USA "take over" Afghanistan ? Around mid 90s. Whatever and whenever USA involved, they need some benefit.

  • @user-ed9so2rb4k

    @user-ed9so2rb4k

    Күн бұрын

    US got involved in Afghanistan because otherwise John Rambo could not be created in Hollywood.

  • @WWLooi-js8rl
    @WWLooi-js8rl2 күн бұрын

    Ha, another anglophile who has passed his use time in Asia but still sought after in the West. Another Gordon Chang but slightly better.

  • @MyHanck
    @MyHanck5 күн бұрын

    We live in the cusp of life changing dynamics and power play in the Asia Pacific and pan Asian affairs.

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong91582 күн бұрын

    Did Bilahari Kausikan call Lee Kuan Yew an Communist Agent for he, Lee did same for S'pore in the beginning for S'pore

  • @JCSY1
    @JCSY12 күн бұрын

    US spokesperson and yes man, nothing else.

  • @ansa336
    @ansa3362 күн бұрын

    He is a Chancer, he makes it up as he goes along

  • @chriswong9158
    @chriswong91582 күн бұрын

    11:00 How much nothing former S'pore diplomat Bilahari Kausikan know of S'pore history, the time of it's course direction.

  • @spencergan4353
    @spencergan4353Күн бұрын

    I agree with some of his on Gaza and how it should be better managed. But calling a XJP a mediocre leader over the last 10 years of his reign is factually incorrect. I’ve lived in China long enough to see positive changes to the people’s lives, this is done systematically with a consolidation of power but more importantly the right people who see the same picture as him. So if this is mediocre leadership the no leader is great.

  • @mingkao1

    @mingkao1

    Күн бұрын

    Hi, Communist mouthpiece, LOL.

  • @charliecheng3340
    @charliecheng3340Күн бұрын

    This guy does not have a freakin clue about China and Taiwan .

  • @yky621
    @yky621Күн бұрын

    We need diplomat who believes peace is possible if leaders wanted peace. When leaders don’t believe peace is possible, they need generals and commanders. But a diplomat who already don’t believe a unification is possible, he shoot his own feet. Luckily he is non Chinese of China nor Taiwan.

  • @SazalibinkamsirSazali-zu5yo
    @SazalibinkamsirSazali-zu5yo5 күн бұрын

    Thank you have nice Talking about the horse Racing.👍🤵🌊🔑🌊🗝🏇🏇

  • @jameschu512
    @jameschu512Күн бұрын

    Telling story without giving facts and figures is not qualifing the truth.

  • @petervote7914
    @petervote7914Күн бұрын

    He does live up to his reputation as anti China, anti chinese, this Bilahari Kausikan. As chinese Singaporean, I find him to be a disgrace to Singapore diplomacy.

  • @KQ0909
    @KQ09092 күн бұрын

    As a Singaporean, I can tell you that I have always felt that he is a dog. Lap dog. Period.

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI

    @Fr.VeniceLAI

    23 сағат бұрын

    ..i don't know about much ordinary Singaporeans' opinions about this man, Bilahari, but according to me, he is one of the bravest/smartest of man among Singaporeans, who openly dares challenged the Chinese Communist Party's United Front Work Dept. narratives permeated among Singaporeans and importantly properly able to assess/analyse about the state of affairs betw. Taiwan ROC/PRChina and others, also most critically pointed out that Paramount Leader Xi Jinping, is in fact, a mediocre performer leading & managing PRChina. It is no wonder, that despite Singapore Island small land size and small population of some ca. 5.0 millions, the island state is so prominently noticed and recognized in the World.

  • @davidchan9175

    @davidchan9175

    15 сағат бұрын

    Well, as a Singaporean, I'm always embarrassed by his immature views. I cannot listen to him for too long. Just here for the comments.

  • @stephentan7881
    @stephentan78812 күн бұрын

    A non-Chinese said so?! Singapore is more of academic involvement.

  • @user-ed9so2rb4k

    @user-ed9so2rb4k

    Күн бұрын

    It seems he can't get out of his Indianese in him.

  • @BrianPatrick-s6b
    @BrianPatrick-s6b2 күн бұрын

    That's it if anybody wants the view Singapore foreign and defence policy delivered in a non politically correct manner. LKY used to do that during national day rallies when he was PM...Ministry of Foreign Affairs always provide "clarifications" days after

  • @michaelmarchal4004
    @michaelmarchal40042 күн бұрын

    War by American design for both Taiwan and Ukraine.

  • @octavioferrer1676

    @octavioferrer1676

    14 сағат бұрын

    It is not just America but all other democratic nations that are defending Ukraine and Taiwan from authoritarian and despotic rule. War in Ukraine is obviously a Putin design and the threat of war against Taiwan is a design of CCP.

  • @mxl4345
    @mxl4345Күн бұрын

    After carefully listening to him, he seems to have a deep grudge against China and Chinese. In terms of strategic thinking, he is mediocre, compare to Kishore Mahbubani. I don't want to be impolite to call him a clown, but he is.

  • @ggc7318

    @ggc7318

    Күн бұрын

    To me Kishore is a CCP shill, a 🤡

  • @johnchang1226

    @johnchang1226

    9 сағат бұрын

    my guess is that he could become a permanent secretary was all because of his father.

  • @clementihammock7572
    @clementihammock75728 күн бұрын

    What will happen after UK Tory turned into Pumpkin and rolled aside? the implication and impact of UK's leadership deficit.

  • @kennySg101
    @kennySg1015 күн бұрын

    Very direct n frank reply to questions.

  • @ssss8162

    @ssss8162

    2 күн бұрын

    But at the same time it reveals his arrogance, his contempt and illogical hatred of China, his lack of tact, his narcissism and his complete lack of respect for others

  • @kennySg101

    @kennySg101

    2 күн бұрын

    @@ssss8162 In this world, speak the truth n your mind is rare especially in diplomatic circle. He is certainly a undiplomatic ex diplomat. Can be less blunt n tactful agreed. Comments on China is true u may not agree with his view. The Singapore view is rather neutral with no western ideological colour.

  • @kccmd9096
    @kccmd9096Күн бұрын

    Agree!

  • @Jin-oq2qu
    @Jin-oq2qu3 күн бұрын

    He is part of US foreign affairs, not Singapore's.

  • @darthvader4209

    @darthvader4209

    3 күн бұрын

    And George Yeo and Kishore is part of CCP foreign affairs. George is paid indirectly by Chinese companies. And Kishore was “forced” to resign from LKYSPP for “harboring” an agent of foreign influence named Huang Jing. Go read the news and get your facts right. Will make you look a little smarter 😂

  • @Jin-oq2qu

    @Jin-oq2qu

    2 күн бұрын

    @@darthvader4209 nice try. Providing fake news will not make you any smarter.

  • @ppp123asdf

    @ppp123asdf

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@@darthvader4209shameful pedaling of fake news

  • @stvnzhu2387

    @stvnzhu2387

    2 күн бұрын

    Loser create fake news to cover their weakness ! 🤣🤣🤣🤣​@@darthvader4209

  • @kooisengchng5283
    @kooisengchng52833 күн бұрын

    He is bellicose and rude. Prone to calling people names in the name of his master. He is the American answer to Kishore Mahbubhani and George Yeo. His mien reveals his true personality.

  • @360du

    @360du

    2 күн бұрын

    Hahahha

  • @redbeansg

    @redbeansg

    2 күн бұрын

    Please don't insult Kishore and George Yeo. There is no comparison.

  • @Gemini73883
    @Gemini73883Күн бұрын

    As the old communists would say, "running dog" is barking!

  • @nashsmith3043
    @nashsmith3043Күн бұрын

    A reflection of Spore’s dearth of genuine talent … a typical arrogant shrimp

  • @sherwoodang58
    @sherwoodang583 күн бұрын

    Xi is an excellent leader contrary to the speaker's assertion, guiding China's economic and technological growth amid great pressure from the west including Singapore. Example of great policy work: (1) long-term investment is supply chain via the belt and road allowing Chinese companies to achieve cost advantage and (2) allowing real estate industry to undergo massive correction to solve housing problem affordability / thus maybe solving declining birth rate. So Xi is an excellent leader taking decisive decision and implementing concrete action.

  • @darthvader4209

    @darthvader4209

    3 күн бұрын

    Gosh, my toes are laughing 😂

  • @saehian

    @saehian

    2 күн бұрын

    ​@@darthvader4209brainwashed darthvader.

  • @stupodest

    @stupodest

    23 сағат бұрын

    ….everyone is entitled to his/her view……

  • @johnchang1226
    @johnchang122614 сағат бұрын

    I always wonder why he could be a permanent secretary? the govt gave him a scholarship to study a PhD, but he failed half way.

  • @axnjack5
    @axnjack56 күн бұрын

    “It used to be that we thought China would do no wrong and US can do no right” which alternative dimension does he live in?

  • @dylanthomas12321
    @dylanthomas123218 сағат бұрын

    An excellent presentation and Q&A session with a smart audience by a very wise man who fully understands Realpolitik in dangerous times. I highly recommend you listen or view if you are dispassionate and analytical.Having read the comments it's clear that most are from an ardently pro-CCP persuasion, but highly emotional and lacking strategic or geopolitical insight. However, professionals and graduate students involved in foreign affairs will find this session well-worth the time, no matter your international political persuasion.

  • @aave865
    @aave8652 күн бұрын

    This controversial video surely will not go well with CCP propagandists 😂

  • @lagrangewei

    @lagrangewei

    2 күн бұрын

    it doesn't go well with anyone with a functioning brain to be honest...

  • @coshyno

    @coshyno

    10 сағат бұрын

    CPC* also what is your point ? Propagandists can be found in all countries.

  • @TrueJusticeisHistory
    @TrueJusticeisHistoryКүн бұрын

    vietnam is the best player because vietnam is not chinese? so if what he says is valid than what he is saying is he knows for certain 100% every single "asian" part of the world are all break off from china. He even included korea and japan so that is exactly the point he is trying to make, but also I think he should have done a better job in trying to sound like a neutral guy vs the obvious anti-china videos that are starting to pop out everywhere these days

  • @r.a.h.175
    @r.a.h.175Күн бұрын

    Imagine a mafia-like team, sitting somewhere now and enjoying themselves, routinely planning their next move. They examine every situation, their interests are spread in every nook and corner of the world, expediently stirring turmoil to create a state of disorder anywhere as suits them, planning the removal of those leaders that are obstacles to their plans, never losing sight of any situation as all must be in tune with their projection to dominate and control the world, to be completely in control of all aspects of businesses from a pin to a bomb, and woe betides those who dare cross their path. They use all the tools of the media to confuse and convince, they keep their puppets happy and that is easy for them, and these puppets will do their bidding with just one phone call, they make a mockery of morality and integrity, they set the standards for you to follow, it’s one big game and everyone else doesn’t count, the rest fight and die and they shall wine and dine and get their women. It’s a satanic world we are living in, they are enjoying their stimulating games. Meantime thousands of conferences, meetings, articles, books, commentaries, forums, demonstrations, interviews, and they wine and dine in the poshest places. Behind the scenes the final decisions were made. To do this and that, drag this fella down, get rid of this fella, and they sit somewhere and enjoy the show. And inconsequential speakers or do-gooders aplenty bursting their lungs, yelling or squeaking away here and there, addressing small or big groups, expressing their views on issues, just hot air as that doesn’t count to the mafia as their minds are already set. They don’t care how many will suffer and die. Their satanic minds are ceaselessly planning to ensure their control and domination over anything and everything. Their interests come first. The small guys merely suck in and prostitute themselves to these characters. That’s the situation and position and reality to accept.

  • @kennethyeung7087
    @kennethyeung708718 сағат бұрын

    Should Singapore policy makers heed this 'John Bolton of Singapore'? He thinks the US 7th Fleet in Asia is the most formidable armada in the world.

  • @thedudeman8408
    @thedudeman840822 сағат бұрын

    How can it be a "re-unification" when it was NEVER part of CHICOM rule. PRC came after the ROC. It can only re-unify when it was one piece together. IF CHICOM gives up it's rule, then the ROC can unify the Mainland which it had ruled. Not the other way around.

  • @KEVINLTINWAN
    @KEVINLTINWAN10 сағат бұрын

    Counter-intuitive, a truly non-diplomatic, no-holds-barrred presentation.

  • @CruiseSen-b1b
    @CruiseSen-b1b2 күн бұрын

    He acts smart.

  • @lowpecklim855
    @lowpecklim8552 күн бұрын

    Suppose to be brief....rather long winded...

  • @petervote7914
    @petervote791422 сағат бұрын

    I feel that everytime Bilahari Kausikan opens his mouth, SAI comes out.

  • @Branch7ShuZhi
    @Branch7ShuZhiКүн бұрын

    Kausikan is the son of a Tamil and a Peranakan. Thus, a true blue Singaporean with his own unique view of the world. So just listen and form your won opinion after you hear from him with that from George YEO and Kishore Mahbubani. The historical reason why there should not be war between China and Taiwan: 本是同根生,相煎何太急. Time will resolve the geopolitical impasse: 富在深山有远亲,穷在闹市无人问. The right time is when the GDP per capital of key coastal cities in China, exceed that of Taiwan. Namely, 广州, 厦门,福州,杭州,南京,合肥,上海,苏州,青岛,天津, 北京,海口,........... 昆明,重庆 and 成都.

  • @masdemon1
    @masdemon12 күн бұрын

    Legend..

  • @liewwilliam3305
    @liewwilliam33053 сағат бұрын

    He should have a debate on this topic with Kishore, he will be put into Kishore's pocket in the first min

  • @redbeansg
    @redbeansg2 күн бұрын

    What a joker living in his own cocoon.

  • @r.a.h.175
    @r.a.h.17517 сағат бұрын

    Such strong disagreements with his views. Wow!

  • @exoticGlobalTravels
    @exoticGlobalTravels12 сағат бұрын

    Very insightful. much better than Kishore.

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI
    @Fr.VeniceLAI23 сағат бұрын

    ..i don't know about much ordinary Singaporeans' opinions about this man, Bilahari, but according to me, he is one of the bravest/smartest of man among Singaporeans, who openly dares challenged the Chinese Communist Party's United Front Work Dept. narratives permeated among Singaporeans and importantly properly able to assess/analyse about the state of affairs betw. Taiwan ROC/PRChina and others, also most critically pointed out that Paramount Leader Xi Jinping, is in fact, a mediocre performer leading & managing PRChina. It is no wonder, that despite Singapore Island small land size and small population of some ca. 5.0 millions, the island state is so prominently noticed and recognized in the World.

  • @petervote7914

    @petervote7914

    23 сағат бұрын

    He is also completely unknown in Singapore. No one in Singapore knows about this guy. Only ang mohs are interested in his anti China views. If he goes in front of majority of Singapore public and gives his anti China views, he will be laughed off the stage and dismissed as some sort of Sinophobic clown.

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI

    @Fr.VeniceLAI

    19 сағат бұрын

    @@petervote7914 Where have had you been living ?? or are you really a Singaporean born and raised in Singapore ?? or instead a "naturalized Singaporean" born in PRChina previously a Chinese National, now granted Singapore Citizenship and Singapore Passport ?? Are you still a member of the Chinese Communist Party and still pledge your allegiance to the CCP-Org ??. Taken from Wiki WHO IS HE ?? : Bilahari Kausikan was appointed as Singapore's Ambassador to Russia in 1994, with concurrent accreditation as Ambassador to Finland. Kausikan served as Singapore's Permanent Representative to the United Nations between 1995 and 1998, with concurrent accreditation as Singapore's High Commissioner to Canada and Ambassador to Mexico. In 1998, Kausikan was appointed as Deputy Secretary (Foreign Affairs) at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. He was appointed as Second Permanent Secretary in 2001, and was promoted to Permanent Secretary on 1 September 2010. He is currently serving as Chairman of the Middle East Institute at the National University of Singapore and is a Senior Fellow at the SMU School of Social Sciences.

  • @johnchang1226

    @johnchang1226

    9 сағат бұрын

    he failed his PhD studies

  • @watchman835
    @watchman835Күн бұрын

    2 Iraq wars and an Afghan war does not look like “off shore balancing” to any observant eyes.

  • @willsims6748
    @willsims67485 сағат бұрын

    How did he become perm sec?!?

  • @stupodest
    @stupodest23 сағат бұрын

    …unification, without doubt….but at what and whose cost?…..can we say the same for the PRK and ROK?….

  • @ivandate9972
    @ivandate9972Күн бұрын

    He is the right mind for South East Asia,

  • @Fr.VeniceLAI
    @Fr.VeniceLAI2 күн бұрын

    With current situation developing within PRChina ... is there is chance we may be also witnessing the beginning of a possible December 25, 1991 happenings of the Dissolution of the U.S.S.R. occuring ??

  • @setisuafa-os9tv
    @setisuafa-os9tvКүн бұрын

    Sounds reasonable.

  • @BrianPatrick-s6b
    @BrianPatrick-s6b2 күн бұрын

    😊

  • @judejin3066
    @judejin3066Күн бұрын

    this guy is full of BS. CCP's economy is imploding due to collapse of real estate bubble that accounted for 40% of its economy. CCP itself admitted 40% of youth unemployment. banks, govts at all levels have cut salaries by 20-50% percent and have started to claw back salaries/bonuses from past years. In order to replace lost land sale proceeds, govts at all levels have resorted to levy fines and claw back 'back taxes' of the past 30 years which instantly bankrupted many businesses. It is utter depression in china and suicide rate has skyrocketed. CCP's iron-fist rule is a total failure.

  • @jmjt3709
    @jmjt3709Күн бұрын

    I'm always telling myself to be open to different opinions, so I have been trying very hard to appreciate the provocative tone he takes. Granted, he can be a non-Chinese Singaporean voice which is valuable, but he just comes across as way too cynical. When I scrolled to see how others felt about this, I'm glad to realize I'm not the only one that felt he comes across as a little "off".

  • @petervote7914

    @petervote7914

    Күн бұрын

    Not a "little" off. Completely and totally off. He is a sinophobe. Not only anti China but anti CHINESE. I have been tracking this clown for years already. He is very striking. Singapore is 80% chinese, but he is so brazen in his anti chinese, anti China views. There is nothing valuable about his views. Nothing but ignorance about China, pro Western drivel and the usual pro West propaganda. Actually his Sinophobia, anti China and pro U.S. views are very dangerous for Singapore. We already paid a price for that in 2016 when China seized SAF assets in HK when Singapore acted as U.S proxy in ASEAN. George Yeo himself already said that Singapore was burned by that incident and that it was mistake. This type of thing happened due to influence of the Sinophobes in Singapore government, people like Bilahari Kausikan. Very dangerous guy. All of them must be purged from Singapore government.

  • @stephenyang2844
    @stephenyang28442 күн бұрын

    Kausikan has some valid points, but he does not go deeper for rationales. China has momentum and reserve and will grow stronger to push US out of Asia.

  • @adamkhan7102
    @adamkhan7102Күн бұрын

    Kishore Mabubani, Where are you, now?

  • @petervote7914

    @petervote7914

    Күн бұрын

    PAP uses Kishore to cater to China, for ang moh, PAP will use this clown.

  • @yttean98
    @yttean985 күн бұрын

    The US tow this guy KB out to counter KB (Kishore)who proves what he said in books and lectures to be fairly accurate, and this guy comes along with No track record, just more talk which he is good at. So who would you believe in?

  • @GuzzarAwan

    @GuzzarAwan

    5 күн бұрын

    Lol Singaporeans r most intellgent and clever PPL. They have Diplomats/thinkers representing Both sides. KB a Chinese decent Singaporean representing Pro Western camp . KM a Indian decent Singaporean represent Chinese camp. But one thing is certain both r totally right. I habe heard them both and both make accurate predictions. I think LKY wud have said same thing as KM & KB

  • @ssss8162

    @ssss8162

    5 күн бұрын

    @@GuzzarAwan Kausikan is a clown. He has been making excuses for the US for years. Zero credibility

  • @choonhockong8215

    @choonhockong8215

    4 күн бұрын

    I watched the speeches/ talks given by respected geopolitics prof Kishore Mahabuni, my own opinion he gave well-balanced views of international geopolitics. I salute him, a true professional geopolitics analyst. Kausikhan speech seems to be anti China, especially when he mentioned that the North Koreans, Vietnamese, etc, dislike China Chinese. Maybe he has no knowledge of China history. I suggest he watch more of Dr David Qualaalou and Carl to get a better understanding of the geopolitics in this region.

  • @choonhockong8215

    @choonhockong8215

    4 күн бұрын

    ​@GuzzarAwan Younger KB needs to study more of Asian culture and history, especially China, Asean countries. I think China universities should invite him to China to give speeches on the Western powers geopolitics and to share views with the Chinese counterpart in world politics. 😂

  • @user-qd8yg1fp7i

    @user-qd8yg1fp7i

    3 күн бұрын

    This kausikan is d tip of d spear for ned infiltration into Sg. The naive Sg youths is d target. So, heads up, Sg...

  • @JIANGTG
    @JIANGTGКүн бұрын

    China will continue different ways to ensure reunification of Taiwan. China has strong determination and its overall strengths will accomplish this sacred objective...

  • @shiromaru8236
    @shiromaru82362 күн бұрын

    Why bother?

  • @Lee-vb4vh
    @Lee-vb4vh5 күн бұрын

    Wow interesting discussions. Audience had great questions. Outstanding views, opinions, and statements are full of geopolitical insights.

  • @kianglin
    @kianglin2 күн бұрын

    Bila Hari kau lahir? 2000 BC ?

  • @chongsewaun930
    @chongsewaun9302 күн бұрын

    Waste of time and energy listening to rubbish!😊

  • @yl4521
    @yl45212 күн бұрын

    2:00. 6:00. 8:50 views of USA and china are now balanced 10:00 Chinese local govt debt

  • @richardtang5561
    @richardtang5561Күн бұрын

    Is he on something?

  • @merlinf2869
    @merlinf28695 күн бұрын

    There seems to be an inclination that he has a new set of teeths

  • @adamkhan7102
    @adamkhan7102Күн бұрын

    Kishore Mabubani is really ankat balla.

Келесі