Capt. Eric 'Winkle' Brown: the first Mosquito carrier deck landing

Ғылым және технология

The People's Mosquito is a UK registered charity dedicated to getting a DH.98 Mosquito flying once again in the UK www.peoplesmosquito.org.uk/ca...
In March 1944 the De Havilland Mosquito undertook carrier deck landing trials on HMS Indefatigable in the Irish Sea, giving the then Lieut. Brown the chance to make the first deck landing of a British heavy twin-engine aircraft. In this video the Patron of The People's Mosquito talks about the aircraft and the challenges he faced when presented with the task of landing it on deck.

Пікірлер: 401

  • @watsisbuttndo829
    @watsisbuttndo8294 жыл бұрын

    " The arrestor hook broke and i had to make a decision, i went full power and the torque drove me off the side of the ship where my wheels may have touched the water" . Bet the old bugger clanks when he walks. Nowdays people loose their mind when somebody calls them stupid on twitter.

  • @dirkdiggler3552

    @dirkdiggler3552

    4 ай бұрын

    8😮98888008999988888778887778😮😮😮😮😮😮

  • @dirkdiggler3552

    @dirkdiggler3552

    4 ай бұрын

    888888

  • @moxey25
    @moxey254 жыл бұрын

    Met him fixed his toilet then stayed for tea really nice bloke

  • @rbtsimpson1966
    @rbtsimpson19668 жыл бұрын

    Capt Eric 'Winkle' Brown truly is one of the finest examples of the Greatest Generation. What an honour to watch this video.

  • @lordbadman9264
    @lordbadman92644 жыл бұрын

    The number of aircraft this man flew will never be surpassed.His logbook is a film that must be made

  • @mogsyman
    @mogsyman4 жыл бұрын

    I never managed to chat to Eric but saw him at close quarters at Shoreham some years ago on the terribly sad day of the Hunter air crash. He was lucid and very chatty and it was a joy to actually see in the flesh what can only be described as an absolute legend. RIP Eric, what a truly magnificent man you were.

  • @soulpaua2097
    @soulpaua20974 жыл бұрын

    That Mosquito footage is from out in New Zealand. We've rebuilt several now. Don't worry Capt. Brown we got ya back!

  • @banjopete

    @banjopete

    4 жыл бұрын

    Jesse Sorensen ,Kiwi ingenuity!

  • @goojedooje660

    @goojedooje660

    3 жыл бұрын

    Blenham South Island nz

  • @user-kp4ts4mc8l

    @user-kp4ts4mc8l

    7 ай бұрын

    Well done you lot😊

  • @nervo6321
    @nervo63214 жыл бұрын

    This man should be held in the highest esteem......

  • @NVRAMboi

    @NVRAMboi

    6 күн бұрын

    I believe he is. On *both* sides of the pond.

  • @cheesenoodles8316
    @cheesenoodles8316 Жыл бұрын

    Eric Winkle Brown is a legend. I did get to see a Mosquito up close with a flying demonstration recently. It was as beautiful as I imagined, maybe a bit more.

  • @sblack48
    @sblack486 жыл бұрын

    I was told that even in his 90s he could still tell you the characteristics of every plane he flew. All 400+ of them. A national treasure.

  • @flybobbie1449

    @flybobbie1449

    6 жыл бұрын

    We have an old boy at my flying school, he's 93 and remembers his time in the RAF. He remembers Morse code, the marks of radio fitted to his aircraft and all sorts. Tells all about going on the Queen Mary to Canada, his training and tales etc. I think sometimes we get scared of old age and memory loss, but many keep their marbles.

  • @EdMcF1

    @EdMcF1

    6 жыл бұрын

    I have the immense privilege of attending a talk of his when he was 95, he spoke for 90 minutes on his feet, the only point at which he was looking for a word was for an RAF term about pilot rotation (which he quickly remembered), given he was FAA in the war, it wasn't even 'his' jargon. It was the most astonishing evening, his anecdotes whether horrifyingly sobering and humorous.

  • @ElSmusso

    @ElSmusso

    5 жыл бұрын

    EdMcF1 I envy you, but thanks for sharing the story :)

  • @jgrif9256

    @jgrif9256

    4 жыл бұрын

    Read his books. Great reading.😀

  • @gravyboat2370

    @gravyboat2370

    4 жыл бұрын

    And they gave knighthoods to bankers and not this legend !!!

  • @jnordne2
    @jnordne23 жыл бұрын

    As an airplane nerd who majored in Aerospace Engineering, I could talk to this man for hours and hours.

  • @bodieofci5418
    @bodieofci54183 жыл бұрын

    Amazing man. I have his book and a signed picture from him. His life story makes a James Bond film look boring. RIP Sir.

  • @bertram987
    @bertram9874 жыл бұрын

    He is one of the greatest Britons! What an absolutely amazing Man!

  • @roboaten6931
    @roboaten69314 жыл бұрын

    His book is a revelation - his approach was to practise everything mentally beforehand. Years ahead of his time and he reckons the reason he survived.

  • @vambo67
    @vambo673 жыл бұрын

    The memory on this guy was amazing, you can truly say he lived life to the fullest! Maximum respect!

  • @gordonstuart5800
    @gordonstuart58004 жыл бұрын

    The greatest pilot ever flew more airplanes than any pilot ever, a great Scotsman yeh.

  • @stevemull2002
    @stevemull2002 Жыл бұрын

    I had the pleasure of meeting Eric, twice, and listening to his talk for a couple of hours, WOW, is an understatement, what this man did, was truly a lifetime of a 1000 men, but crammed into a handful of years, ive never understood why he wasnt made a Sir, when any muppet in parliment, only has to fart, and they are made one !!

  • @raymondgill9796
    @raymondgill97967 жыл бұрын

    It is humbling to hear this man talk. What a great generation.

  • @Twirlyhead
    @Twirlyhead6 жыл бұрын

    The Barracuda story (easiest to deck land, RAF pranged all five) - priceless.

  • @davidmaccormack7067

    @davidmaccormack7067

    4 жыл бұрын

    I crash landed a hang glider from a flat spin,not bad for my 2nd flight and no one told me how to,l thot l was fukt,tore the arse outa ma Jean's ouch 'Anlandugen sie gehen veg von ist gute Landun ' ok l limped away...straight to the pub Pepperdog181@gmail.com

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    3 күн бұрын

    Yes indeed he actually taught Jeffrey Quill how to land on a carrier and yet Eric Brown gets no mention in Morgan and Shacklady Spitfire the History

  • @tedfrederiksen4989
    @tedfrederiksen49895 жыл бұрын

    Eric Brown has to be the greatest Naval Aviator of all time & all navies, my personal opinion.

  • @belchnasty

    @belchnasty

    4 жыл бұрын

    Greatest aviator period.

  • @MrDaiseymay

    @MrDaiseymay

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@belchnasty correct

  • @sblack48

    @sblack48

    3 жыл бұрын

    He is the equal of any other test pilot from any service or nation but the fact that so much of his work involved ship board landings makes him unique. Landing on a boat us dangerous enough in a proven airplane but being the first to do it in airplanes never intended for it is a whole other level. Then evaluating all the german military airplanes including rockets and jets. It's hard to fathom the depth of his experience.

  • @james5353
    @james5353 Жыл бұрын

    What an incredible life that man had - a true legend of British aviation

  • @MACLAD6666
    @MACLAD66664 жыл бұрын

    Another scotsman that proved we got fvcking balls sir. Salute to that man, what he showed to aviation would take 4 lifetimes to learn by anyone else.

  • @burningb2439
    @burningb24393 жыл бұрын

    Anything with Eric Brown you sit , watch an listen ..

  • @robinmcphail34
    @robinmcphail343 жыл бұрын

    Absolute legend, got his biography and " Wings of the Luftwaffe ". If he couldn't fly it, no one could.

  • @postwar46
    @postwar464 жыл бұрын

    What a professional ! He Quietly worked out how the expectation could be achieved. I believe he was 95 years old at the time of this interview.

  • @antiussentiment
    @antiussentiment4 жыл бұрын

    "I had a boffin assigned to me".. ~ smiles ~

  • @mattharte7334
    @mattharte73345 жыл бұрын

    This talented pilot had an incredible life and it's a brilliant interview about deck landing a Mosquito on a ship, it was incredible, must have taken nerves of steel, I can recommend his autobiography too.

  • @bogomir67
    @bogomir677 жыл бұрын

    This gentleman would forget more about aviation in 5 minutes than most people would learn in a lifetime.

  • @MrDaiseymay

    @MrDaiseymay

    4 жыл бұрын

    He holds the unbeatable record, of having flown more aircraft types, than ANYONE ELSE---BY A MILE !

  • @MW-bi1pi

    @MW-bi1pi

    2 жыл бұрын

    If Eric Brown was that mentally sharp in his 90's, imagine what he was like in his 20's and 30's.

  • @SISU889

    @SISU889

    Жыл бұрын

    Well said , Sir.

  • @davebartos7743
    @davebartos77432 жыл бұрын

    I understand he till holds the record for most deck landings. RIP a true legend.

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    3 күн бұрын

    Yes and the most different types of aircraft flown

  • @shiangtingkung2904
    @shiangtingkung29042 жыл бұрын

    Capt. Eric “Winkle” Brown is a legend and my hero! What a great pilot!

  • @nicksullivan8075
    @nicksullivan80754 жыл бұрын

    I cant remember what i had for breakfast. What an amazing generation.

  • @31144

    @31144

    3 жыл бұрын

    Snap, his recollection is unbelievable, I literally can't remember what I did yesterday, His autobiography is a fabulous read ! !

  • @rotax636nut5
    @rotax636nut54 жыл бұрын

    This man was an actual Force Of Nature, thank you and God Rest you Eric Brown

  • @guts067
    @guts0677 жыл бұрын

    Phenomenal understated courage. Thank you Captain Winkle Brown.

  • @murraystewartj
    @murraystewartj4 жыл бұрын

    It's these small footnotes to history that are the best. So sad that so many have been lost as the greatest generation passes. Thanks for this.

  • @TheDarwiniser
    @TheDarwiniser8 жыл бұрын

    read his book, wings on my sleeve. when you see the pace and the skill this man displayed flying multiple aircraft daily, round the clock, it beggars belief. i dont have heroes, but damn this man knocked on the door when i realised just what he has done.

  • @H4CK61
    @H4CK615 жыл бұрын

    What a Man. fearless in his quest of testing planes to there limit. Many never survived but Winkle was the test pilot of test pilots.

  • @airplanes42
    @airplanes42 Жыл бұрын

    The greatest pilot from the era when pilots were actually skilled stick and rudder men.

  • @peterlethbridge7859
    @peterlethbridge78596 жыл бұрын

    Probably the most gifted pilot to have ever flown. A truly remarkable man indeed

  • @Simonsvids

    @Simonsvids

    6 жыл бұрын

    Not necessarily. He was certainly the pilot given the most opportunity to fly different kinds of aircraft. But he was more of an engineer than a pilot. He would calculate everything. Not the kind to fly without considering the risks. In combat situations you do not have that luxury.

  • @petej8556

    @petej8556

    5 жыл бұрын

    He was an operational combat pilot to start with in the War. RN fleet air arm, & has quite a number of confirmed kill's. It was because of his outstanding abilities as a Pilot that his superiors advised for him to transfer to testing aircraft.

  • @mothman411

    @mothman411

    4 жыл бұрын

    Of course Simon, do thrill us with your personal tales of air combat...........

  • @kevinstraus1478

    @kevinstraus1478

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@mothman411 don't know about Simon but there I was in a F4 over Hanoi doing Mach 3 guarding SR71s from Mig 15s. Can't say more as it is classified

  • @rjk69

    @rjk69

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@Simonsvids You do not survive as a test pilot if you are not a gifted flyer. A new aircraft has to be flown by instinct and feel, he had both and survived to tell the tale.

  • @jamesgivens4446
    @jamesgivens44465 жыл бұрын

    Captain Brown should have his own posthumous channel! Anyone who has been a PIC IS IN ABSOLUTE AWE OF THIS MAN,

  • @thatguyfromcetialphaV
    @thatguyfromcetialphaV2 жыл бұрын

    His autobiography Wings On My Sleeve is a fantastic read. RIP Sir.

  • @ronitsingh85
    @ronitsingh854 жыл бұрын

    Hats off to you sir! He is telling like it was yesterday he had done all this amazing knowledge

  • @gordonhall9871
    @gordonhall98719 ай бұрын

    what a great story teller -- I could listen to him talk about airplanes for hours

  • @buzzer1961
    @buzzer19613 жыл бұрын

    I remember my parents telling me about him flying a Spitfire up Scott St, in Galashiels, Scotland, during WW2, where he had relations.

  • @HO-bndk
    @HO-bndk5 жыл бұрын

    Neil Armstrong's hero. They even met once.

  • @helvehammer7846

    @helvehammer7846

    5 жыл бұрын

    *Well THAT about says it all ! ! !*

  • @Jabber-ig3iw

    @Jabber-ig3iw

    4 жыл бұрын

    They almost worked together on the X-15

  • @MrDaiseymay

    @MrDaiseymay

    4 жыл бұрын

    what did armstrong do?

  • @andyphillips7435

    @andyphillips7435

    4 жыл бұрын

    Philip Croft He said ‘ He was standing on the shoulders of giants’ Newton. ( probably didn’t, but should have done)

  • @diggledoggle4192

    @diggledoggle4192

    3 жыл бұрын

    @jonny j Think it's a joke pal

  • @dellawrence4323
    @dellawrence43235 жыл бұрын

    RIP Eric Winkle Brown RN, an exceptional man.

  • @obiemichaels9675
    @obiemichaels9675 Жыл бұрын

    What size fantastic memory from a man who simply told the facts and didn't try to talk himself up.

  • @4vepvik781
    @4vepvik7814 жыл бұрын

    What an extremely lucid Man Captain Eric Brown was and as sharp as ever even in His old age and what a Pilot!!.

  • @davidelliott5843
    @davidelliott58434 жыл бұрын

    Here was a man clearly in the latter stages of life yet such a powerful personality. An amazing human being.

  • @PUBHEAD1
    @PUBHEAD15 жыл бұрын

    Winkle is a legend

  • @tonyjennings1025
    @tonyjennings10253 жыл бұрын

    In the US. All airworthy. Also when crediting British aircraft he left out the Hawker Hurricane which surprised me. Pilots such as he will never be seen again incredibly skillful and courageous.

  • @johnevans7261
    @johnevans72614 жыл бұрын

    I had the privilege some years ago of a long chat with 'Winkle' at the Dunsfold Wings and Wheels show. We discussed the Sea Mosquito, and he pointed out the major restriction on operating prop-driven twin-engine aircraft at sea was the lack of asymmetric control if an engine failed. " The engines had to be far enough apart to allow the props to turn without hitting each other. That limitation disappeared when the jet engine took over - they could be placed close together." A simple explanation from the world's greatest test pilot - what a character.

  • @gregorypaulbox3035
    @gregorypaulbox30354 жыл бұрын

    An exceptional gentleman and an exceptional pilot.

  • @geoffdearth8575
    @geoffdearth85756 жыл бұрын

    The Mosquito was a brilliant airplane. Those who flew in them were brilliant airmen. I say this as a US commenter.

  • @alteredbeast67

    @alteredbeast67

    5 жыл бұрын

    Well i have to say that makes a refreshing change. Usually English ww2 iconic aircraft are dismissed by US citizens, largely due to ignorance, jealousy and lack of knowledge. Winkleman was also the man who made the first successful carrier landing of the F4U corsair. The famous curved approach. Before that the US were only operating corsairs from ground based runways, which was a shame as the corsair was a mighty fine carrier fighter. And along with the Hawker Sea Fury, was the only two piston driven fighters that scored a kill against Mig 15 jets during Korea. Interesting Brown mentions Britains best 3 aircraft of ww2 The Spitfire, Mosquito & Lancaster. I think the US also had 3 exceptional aircraft just as good as those mentioned. The P-51 D. The B - 17 & the Lockheed P - 61 "black widow" Even though the P - 61 was developed and put into operations late in the war, it was the only ww2 aircraft designed from the ground up specifically for night fighting. And very effective. Im sure some would disagree with my top 3 US aircraft and it could be argued the P - 47 or F4U were better than the Mustang. Or even the Grumman Hellcat. The Lockheed P - 38 could also be counted although it suffered from a number of serious issues throughout its combat life. Also i personally think the B - 24 liberator was a better bomber than the B - 17. So i guess its a matter of opinion.....

  • @geoffdearth7360

    @geoffdearth7360

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@alteredbeast67 Our P51s would not have developed their full potential were it not for the Merlin engine (Packard license manufacture). Haven't the Kiwis restored at least 1 Mosquito?

  • @jamiecole2096

    @jamiecole2096

    4 жыл бұрын

    geoff dearth - yes we have.

  • @sugarnads

    @sugarnads

    4 жыл бұрын

    Geoff Dearth aeroplane mate. Aeroplane.

  • @mikebelcher8442

    @mikebelcher8442

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@geoffdearth7360 at least 3

  • @johnharb01283
    @johnharb012834 жыл бұрын

    what an amazing man thank god we had men like this, balls of steel!

  • @bobthompson3739
    @bobthompson373910 ай бұрын

    What a man, superlatives cannot cover a man of this stature, this is what a hero really looks like. My admiration is unbounded

  • @pwareham61
    @pwareham613 жыл бұрын

    A great british hero. I could listen to Eric recite the phone book.

  • @welshpete12
    @welshpete126 жыл бұрын

    A very great man , there should be a statue of him outside the Houses of Parliament .

  • @guysatchwell6990

    @guysatchwell6990

    4 жыл бұрын

    Should be a statue of him in Leith where he was born?

  • @dovidell

    @dovidell

    3 жыл бұрын

    SJW's would just spray graffiti on it , without even knowing the great man's contribution to the nation

  • @scottmitchell8273
    @scottmitchell82734 жыл бұрын

    At the going down of the sun and in the morning..we will remember them ..

  • @gordonbradley3241
    @gordonbradley32412 жыл бұрын

    What an absolutely ASTOUNDING bloke ? He's flown and tested more aircraft types than anybody ! They even got him to fly the luftwaffers Comet rocket interceptor after the war ? A " suicide ride in a hell machine " if there ever was ! This bloke is made of pure TUNGSTEN !

  • @306champion
    @306champion2 жыл бұрын

    That was history in the making. Like all these blokes I could listen to them all day.

  • @daveBit15
    @daveBit152 жыл бұрын

    Legendary pilot.

  • @cambium0
    @cambium04 жыл бұрын

    What an articulate speaker. Just off his head making all kinds of sense with every word. A bit slow but worth slowing down for. Mosquito was a great plane.

  • @geoffdearth8575
    @geoffdearth85756 жыл бұрын

    Capt. Eric Brown RIP from the USA.

  • @martentrudeau6948

    @martentrudeau6948

    4 жыл бұрын

    Geoff Dearth - Ditto!

  • @smartringworld8828
    @smartringworld88286 жыл бұрын

    14:16 "now the Barracuda is probably the easiest deck-landing aircraft you will ever find and they managed to prang all five of them, so I really wasn't to hopeful of the outcome!".....priceless! What detail, what a gent, what a legend. I bow in respect.

  • @nilsfinken
    @nilsfinken6 жыл бұрын

    What an amazing memory and unique ability to extract the most interesting details and lucid analyses. An incredible personality.

  • @hughtuck5147
    @hughtuck51474 жыл бұрын

    Hats off to Capt. Brown and others like him - brave, skilled - and articulate even in his '90s... what a hero!

  • @adoreslaurel
    @adoreslaurel6 жыл бұрын

    I think we should put to bed any comparisons between Yanks and Brits, each have their own re balls to the fire re risks to life and limb, Either side had men capable of extraordinary things when faced with a challenge.And I say that as neither a Brit or Yank.

  • @seansky2721
    @seansky27214 жыл бұрын

    I read Winkle's book. More than once. Not one wasted word. There is nothing like actually hearing the way he puts his words together. God rest you, Captain Brown. You have inspired so many more airplane drivers than you could possibly imagine. I would not wish to land a Mossie on a flat-top. Not one smaller than a US Navy CVA. You Beauty!

  • @theeaselrider4032
    @theeaselrider40326 ай бұрын

    I could spend endless hours, days even, listening to that man tell stories. If Winkle Brown thought the Mosquito was a pretty special aircraft, you don't need to ask anyone else about it. About as high a praise as you can get.

  • @whigwood
    @whigwood4 жыл бұрын

    Whar a hero! I could listen to this man for ever. Not long before he died, he was guest on "Desert Island Discs" (BBC radio 4) and had Kirsty Young practically eating out of his hand, such was his magnetism.

  • @howardgriffiths9130

    @howardgriffiths9130

    4 жыл бұрын

    On that programme he recounted his celebration of VE Day by flying his naval spitfire THROUGH Tower Bridge !!!

  • @stewsretroreviews
    @stewsretroreviews3 жыл бұрын

    What a truly amazing man, loved reading his book, just so many stories in there.

  • @pcka12
    @pcka125 жыл бұрын

    Great to hear this grand old Gentleman talk, Captain Brown mentions the involvement of Barnes Wallace and in later years my dad (who was involved in the secret explosive developments without which Barnes Wallace’s weapons could not work) helped in ensuring that B W was awarded an honorary degree.

  • @flymoon24
    @flymoon244 жыл бұрын

    Hi, I can only write that I am extremely impressed and humbled by Captain Captain Eric Winkle Brown it should be Sir Captain Eric Winkle Brown!

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    3 күн бұрын

    I believe he turned it down

  • @lunaticfringe8066
    @lunaticfringe80663 жыл бұрын

    A great interview with one the greatest test pilots of all time.

  • @JamesLaserpimpWalsh
    @JamesLaserpimpWalsh Жыл бұрын

    Even a legend such as him made a model of the B2 spirit. Thanks Uploader.

  • @EricIrl
    @EricIrl8 жыл бұрын

    I've never heard Eric Brown tell an uninteresting story.

  • @geoffdearth7360

    @geoffdearth7360

    4 жыл бұрын

    That's because he lived history. He was history.

  • @P-CROZIER
    @P-CROZIER4 жыл бұрын

    An Amazing Humble Gentleman - great clip!! Thank you Sir for your tremendous contribution to our Freedom !!

  • @plunder1956
    @plunder1956 Жыл бұрын

    An amazing pilot, his log book had more aircraft types in it than are even possible today. Many were captured German aircraft from the gigantic to the tiny Me-193

  • @NVRAMboi
    @NVRAMboi6 күн бұрын

    What a gentleman. I like to think U.S. Navy Lieutenant James H. Flatley III was channeling the spirit of Capt. Brown while performing test landings of the 4-engined Hercules C-130 on USS Forrestal. "Hefty Huevos".

  • @dryflyman7121
    @dryflyman71213 жыл бұрын

    My next door neighbour was a former Mosquito pilot and had his original flying log of all his operations. We had not been here long when he died and I never got to talk to him about his service or see his log book, as his Son took them after he had died. Very sad.

  • @richardevppro3980
    @richardevppro39805 жыл бұрын

    All i can think of is this Man is a true Hero and those that gave the thumbs down are ignorant people who know nothing of the past!

  • @stephendiskin9939
    @stephendiskin99393 жыл бұрын

    Stephen Diskin. A first class story Sir. I was not aware of any attemt of anybody landing a Mosquito on a carrier. Well done capt well done.

  • @sblack48
    @sblack485 жыл бұрын

    "Yes I'll have a go at that" 😁 crazy bastard!

  • @BillHalliwell
    @BillHalliwell3 жыл бұрын

    G'day PM, The greatest pilot in the world flies the most beautiful military aircraft in the world... on to a carrier! You just can't beat that. Legendary. Should be a film made about it, nay, somebody should make a major motion picture about this amazing, humble man's life and career. It would have to contain a lot of CGI because there aren't many of the 487 aircraft left that are recorded in Capt. Eric Brown's Log Books. Just imagine, even if you, conservatively, estimate that he few each aircraft type only 4 times, that's well over 2,000 take offs and landings. I was so sad to learn that he'd passed on to the big hangar in the sky. He was one of those characters that you reckon will live forever... well, he will, as long as there is someone out there that recalls the daring feats and aviation adventures of Eric 'Winkle' Brown. I'm serious someone should send Spielberg or J.J. Abrams Eric's outstanding book, what a film! He risked death thousands of times so that other pilots could complete their missions and survive the war to be with their families again. A proud Scot, a funny man and a brilliant aeronautical engineer. When Neil Armstrong has you has his hero, you know you've made it. Thanks 'People's Mosquito' for this great video. Cheers, BH (ex-RAAF) P. S. I'm subscribing.

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    3 күн бұрын

    If they cannot get a British Film Director to do it Do not make the film Look what Spielberg did to the British Tank Crew in Band of Brothers Look at Destroyer with Hanks

  • @BillHalliwell

    @BillHalliwell

    3 күн бұрын

    @@jacktattis G’day Jack, you’re absolutely right. American filmmakers often have difficulty portraying the British, particularly in wartime, military films. Many years ago, before I became a military historian; I was a journalist who specialised in film and TV movie reviews and criticism for newspapers and radio. Spielberg’s handling of the British in ‘Band of Brothers’ was just ‘awkward’; brought about by a lack of sufficient research; a common mistake when Americans deal with the militaries of ‘foreign’ countries. Although, given the budget, Spielberg could have afforded more research to fill the ‘gaps’ in the British portrayals coming from American author, Stephen E. Ambrose who, of course, has all his Americans spot-on as they come from real-life US veterans. More importantly, ‘Greyhound’ (2020) had for its source a brilliant book written by British author C.S. Forester and that film definitely should have been filmed by a British or even a Canadian director. But this point shouldn’t always be a ‘dealbreaker’; any US director could have hired a British military advisor or historian with knowledge of the Royal Navy. The property, ‘Greyhound’ belonged to Sony Pictures but was ‘jettisoned’ to Apple TV due to the Covid pandemic. The resulting 90-minute version, directed by, Illinois-born, Aaron Schneider is not a bad film. It suffers, in my view, from two main glitches: the whole look of the film is, literally, dark and under lit, plus Tom Hanks’s role as the Captain of the title-destroyer, is under developed, unlike the ‘Skipper’ in the fictional book which was loosely based on real accounts of the Battle of the Atlantic. Sure, most of the major action sequences happen at night, yet even during the day, outside and inside the ship is spoilt by the lighting atmosphere one used to see in old ‘haunted house’ movies. For a change, the extensive CGI sections of the film are ‘well computed’ and convincing but, I think, we could have seen more detail. When the situation is reversed, British directors depicting American forces, especially in WW2, fare much better. Perhaps one of the best examples is 1977’s ‘A Bridge Too Far’. Directed by Brit. Richard Attenborough. Significant portions of that film portray American and Polish paratroopers, along with the British troops, very well indeed. Even though the source material comes from the Irish/American military historian Cornelius Ryan; the input of Attenborough, who lived through WW2 and the academic skills of Ryan’s historical research show all the Allied troops and officers accurately, down to the way they salute, their kit and how it is, correctly, worn plus all the other minutiae that makes for a convincing picture of a specialist subject. Thank you, Jack, for pointing out this frequent yet little discussed topic. Most audiences are far more knowledgeable than filmmakers might suppose and it’s the small, incorrect, detail that sticks out, ‘like a sore thumb’. Cheers, Bill H.

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    3 күн бұрын

    @@BillHalliwell Well Bill H there is nothing to say you have covered it very well indeed I am 81 this month and I used to cringe when an Englishman tried to portray an Australian I remember Summer of the Seventh Doll Poms playing Aussie cane cutters, it was cringe worthy , and the same with Band of Brothers the scene of the Brit tankie ignoring a German Tank in front of him Or that is what Spielberg had us believe . I do not know why but we always had Americans in movies when there had hardly been an American within three countries . Bridge on the Kwai An American Planter in Burma of all places The Philippines yes Burma NO The Great Escape the same its like putting Chips Rafferty in a Aussie movie about Pearl Harbour with Chips fighting off a flight of Japanese planes with a pistol . Greyhound it was not the lighting or the movie itself it was the concept of a new Captain an American being put in charge of RCN or R/N ships. Sticks out like a sore thumb Oh Yes MacArthur another cringe worthy movie. Patton Oh dear so over the top. But they love it. And that is where American posters on here get their information The Best American movie on the Second world War in the ETO was When Trumpets Fade about the Battle of Hurtgen Forrest Raw savage and no over the top heroics No headliners actors that some made it later. And the Other I only saw it this year Hacksaw Ridge the most accurate I have seen of the US in the Pacific Up there with the best of the Brit shows Ice Cold in Alex ,the CRUEL SEA.

  • @BillHalliwell

    @BillHalliwell

    2 күн бұрын

    @@jacktattis G’day Jack, you’ve raised a lot of good issues. I’ve got quacks’ appointments so I’ll get back ASAP. Cheers Bill H.

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    2 күн бұрын

    @@BillHalliwell Just came back. Thank God for Medicare

  • @NickRatnieks
    @NickRatnieks8 жыл бұрын

    The Mosquito was also the best photo reconnaissance aircraft of WW2.

  • @MrDaiseymay

    @MrDaiseymay

    4 жыл бұрын

    just say best----everything

  • @jacktattis

    @jacktattis

    3 күн бұрын

    No that was the Spitfire MkXI and then the MkXIX in the ETO The Mk XIX could get to 49000ft

  • @marcusgault9909
    @marcusgault99094 жыл бұрын

    A huge number of carrier landings, which was Winkle's self-effacing way of saying the MOST EVER, and in the greatest NUMBER of aircraft types to boot!

  • @TechNed
    @TechNed6 жыл бұрын

    Fascinating. The voice of first-hand experience. He's so right about bringing the dearth of planes back to flying status. I've no idea how many are left.

  • @bobsymons9642
    @bobsymons96424 жыл бұрын

    Father and his 2 brothers were Mosquito and Beaufighter Pilots Windsor Ontario group are building a Mosquito. One comment on Mosquito by father was that bullets went right thru instead of bouncing around off metal and getting you. Many lost on takeoff and landing, partially due to both engines rotating in same direction, making it harder to keep straight.

  • @davidwheatcroft2797
    @davidwheatcroft27974 жыл бұрын

    "Flying behind the curve" - ie.below stall speed but using the propellers like a helicopter.

  • @poruatokin
    @poruatokin5 жыл бұрын

    Just had a shiver run down my spine. at 12:02 he talks about Beccles airfield. It is known as Ellough and later became an industrial estate where I started working for a plastics company in the 1970's. At lunchtime, we would often explore the old control tower. Fascinating.

  • @MrDaiseymay
    @MrDaiseymay4 жыл бұрын

    What a great human being he was. Genious and Gentleman, I wish I had met him.

  • @paulgerald7682
    @paulgerald76823 жыл бұрын

    When here a Mossie , those twin Merlin's once you hear them you will never forget . Hamilton Airshow Ontario Canada .,1986 . And our Lanc and Spitfire and Hurricane .

  • @stephenhowlett6345
    @stephenhowlett63455 жыл бұрын

    Every memory still remembered. Strange how we mostly remember the good times.

  • @rustykilt
    @rustykilt3 жыл бұрын

    What an amazing man....Greatest pilot that ever flew.

  • @Ingens_Scherz
    @Ingens_Scherz Жыл бұрын

    What a wonderful, brave man.

  • @terrycarter4459
    @terrycarter44594 жыл бұрын

    A wonderful gentleman who I could listen to all day and what a great video.

  • @EndingSummerwithRalph
    @EndingSummerwithRalph8 жыл бұрын

    Amazing, I was totally enthralled at that story. Thanks!

  • @simongills2051
    @simongills20514 жыл бұрын

    This man was also possibly the last friendly face that Goering saw. In an interview alone with him at the War Trials they spoke to each other as pilots, Mr Brown being fluent in German. A few days later Goering took his own life. He also flew with Udet just before the War, when on holiday in Germany before the War. He was in Germany when War broke out and I reckon Udet used his influence to let this friendly English student to leave, even letting keep his MG sport car. What a full life this man had.

  • @stanleybuchan4610

    @stanleybuchan4610

    Жыл бұрын

    He was a Scot.

  • @ralphshepherd1770
    @ralphshepherd17704 жыл бұрын

    Great history lesson, glad this great man could share it with us. So much R&D and planning was made in preparation for the invasion of Japan. Glad that in the end it wasn't needed.

  • @ratofvengence
    @ratofvengence Жыл бұрын

    What a treasure this guy was!

  • @abbamanic
    @abbamanic6 жыл бұрын

    What a remarkable man. Very few like this man grace any generation.

Келесі