They should’ve gone through who they missed and got the reactions

It will never not shock me how little Jack knows about baseball

@sl796

6 ай бұрын

Jack doesn't know anything about anything lol

Ty Cobb seems to be a player that people often forget when talking about the all-time great players.

@silver_ipad_games

23 күн бұрын

Ty Cobb is my guy

I'm so triggered by Jeter being higher than Pujols, Koufax, George Brett, Joe Morgan, etc

@jjoworld

6 ай бұрын

5 world series does that for you

@ShedTech8

6 ай бұрын

I agree, except Jeter is better than Koufax

Trevor Plouffe not being ranked is a ROBBERY

@al3xaguirr3

6 ай бұрын

He came in at 101 unfortunately

@hendog5396

6 ай бұрын

Anti Twins bias 😤

@yetigonecrazy

6 ай бұрын

106 career HRs doesn't even get you on this list?? Lame!

@alexkaplan1136

5 ай бұрын

He’s definitely a top 100 name-sounds-like-fart player.

Verlander being lower than Scherzer is nuts

@whowastheoneguy4719

6 ай бұрын

But but... he has 2 different colored eyes!!

@johnny8052

6 ай бұрын

i think they should be closer but saying scherzer is better not nuts

New challenge idea: name every baseball player

@nobeardthepirate9172

6 ай бұрын

Jack glasscock

@dylankrejci9965

6 ай бұрын

Frank “Pop” Dillon Only reason I know this guy is because he (sort of) shares my name, Dylan. And he was born in the same town as me. And he went to the same college as me. Just, like a hundred years apart

@NinersFanMan

6 ай бұрын

Sales Lucas has entered the chat

@dennischen5367

6 ай бұрын

Kevin Padlo

@fantasybum438

6 ай бұрын

Van Lingle Mungo

I was SCREAMING Yogi the whole video. Lol

@soylentgreen7074

6 ай бұрын

Same

@johnwray393

6 ай бұрын

Nolen Ryan for me.

@paulfusco7525

6 ай бұрын

Hammering hank Aaron for me

@aureumursa1833

6 ай бұрын

Willie McCovey for me.

@alexw3985

6 ай бұрын

@@johnwray393Nolan Ryan was one of the first names they said

King Albert at 30 is nuts. Especially behind Trout and Jeter; and Jeter is my all time favorite player. Who made this list?

@sethbachman1518

6 ай бұрын

I am a die hard cubs fan and when i saw bert at 30 i almost shit. easily a top 15 player all time. dominated the game for 20 years

@zachkennett6480

6 ай бұрын

Griffey just outside the top ten, Trout there too, Jeter on the list at all, I think ChatGPT made this list

@geezushasrisen

6 ай бұрын

@@zachkennett6480Jeets should be on there for sure, but he shouldn’t be higher than guys like Albert, Jackie and- IS THAT ICHIRO??? Yeah, no. This whole list is terrible.

@Karmy.

6 ай бұрын

Jeter is mad overrated

Jake's face during the pause after MIckey Mantle is probably a top JM Baseball moment

Pujols at 30 is OUTRAGEOUS

@thechocolatefactory

6 ай бұрын

29th all-time according to BWAR

@cartierhendrix

6 ай бұрын

It’s espn, they literally know nothing lol

@SoroushHashemloo

6 ай бұрын

​@@thechocolatefactory14th among players post-integration.

@Sam_Baseball

6 ай бұрын

@@thechocolatefactorybro using bwar to justify pujols being at 30 💀💀

@misterjakemczilla

6 ай бұрын

@@Sam_Baseball🤣🤣🤣

this list showed that ESPN should stay out of baseball

@dennismonk9559

6 ай бұрын

yeah.. i knew that after the first guess.

@danday9697

6 ай бұрын

For real. Having a guy with less than 400 hrs and less than 2k hits 15 places higher than a guy with 700 hrs and 3300 hits is laughable

@theweeklydosage

6 ай бұрын

Haven’t even watched the video yet and this is the only comment I needed to read to know how it was gonna go.

I was thinking Cobb, Tris Speaker, Cy Young and Jimmie Foxx from the old days. Trout could fall to the 80s or 90s if injuries and rapid decline hit him like many of his contemporaries. Jeter is not a top 50 player, sorry.

@sabiebright4554

6 ай бұрын

Listen, there are 33 players in the history of baseball to hit 3000 baseballs in play, and Jeter is one of them. Even with poor defensive metrics, he had a 115 ops +, the same as greats like Robin Yount. Jeter might be a little high because of all the hits he accumulated, but there is a real argument that he is a top 50 player all time.

@stephenwalk2186

6 ай бұрын

@@sabiebright4554 jeter is high because its espn and they have a massive boner for red sox and yankees

@ItsGamingFancy

6 ай бұрын

​@@sabiebright4554for me is just weird some of the players they put behind him.

@AidanCulverREAL

6 ай бұрын

⁠@@sabiebright4554Yes, he’s borderline top 50 and they put him like 30 places too high. That’s why the complaints are valid.

@alexisborden3191

6 ай бұрын

I knew this was gonna full of boomer rankings like Jackie Robinson being high 30s, and Babe 1, but I'm kinda surprised they didn't put Nolan Ryan in the top 20, they were correct, he's not a top 40 player, but I'd have figured they'd be peak muh one hundred and eight miles per hour was definitely real totally calibrated equipment for sure wasn't juiced gun.

How did all the Yankees guys not think of guessing Reggie Jackson?

@Supersloth58

6 ай бұрын

Or YOGI!!!

@spaghettisauce445

6 ай бұрын

yankee fans are usually dummys

how did nobody say Ty Cobb ?????

W/out Lucas, they're fucked. None of these guys know much of anything about baseball before the mid-'80s, if it even goes that far back. It'd also be good, if you gave a microphone to the person telling you whether you were correct or not.

The fact that Dan probably can't name a single person that was on the 2023 pirates A's or Royals is so funny

I was yelling Ty Cobb and Rogers Hornsby for the last 10 minutes of this video.

ty cobb!!!!!!!!

It’s very frustrating that the host is not mic’ed. I’ve rewinded 12+ times this video just to hear her say a player’s number on the list

They need to do this sort of thing again...but with the entire staff vs. Lucas. I'll still take Lucas.

Jeter being 28 and like 20 spots above Ripken is absurd

Can you name the 100 most recent players to be elected into the Hall of Fame? Would be a really fun idea.

This might be JM baseballs best vid ever

I understand it’s the bit but having everyone clap after every answer is audio torture

I felt Ernie Banks was an easy get.

@voncornhole

6 ай бұрын

Before Jack said "steroid era" looking for a Cubs player, that's where I thought he was going. Surprised no one went with Banks right after that

there are 342 players in the Hall of Fame. Bernie Williams is not one of them.

Jeter at 28?!?! Come on.

Jack Chesbro is in my baseball lexicon now because of the yanks episode and his name has made a couple of appearances

Appreciate so much that they used Vlad and Thome’s Orioles photos lol

Tony Gwynn at 44 is why people don't trust baseball analysts

I had some super old names ready to go. Grover Cleveland Alexander and old Hoss Radbourn. Also surprised no one Said Yogi Berra.

@jacobmccain8082

6 ай бұрын

I was thinking Yogi Berra would go when Mantle and Joe D went. I'm guessing he was probably #4.

@ejflor1313

6 ай бұрын

Yogi lmao

@MrandMrsBullock

6 ай бұрын

I was thinking the same. Really surprised! And what about Reggie Jackson? Crazy to forget him when there are some Yankee fans up there

@soylentgreen7074

6 ай бұрын

@@ejflor1313 10 rings

@johnwray393

6 ай бұрын

I kept yelling Nolan Ryan!!

i was screaming Tom Seaver the whole tme

i'm sorry but how did ya'll not get Ty Cobb lol love your vids.

It’s funny to me how Jimmy immediately runs to his phone while he pouts.

Can someone explain why Mariano Rivera, Jackie Robinson, Albert Pujols, and Pete Rose aren't above Jeter?

@Nick-xu7ns

6 ай бұрын

People love the Jetes, man. His persona amplifies how people remember his play.

@alexisborden3191

6 ай бұрын

All the same old memes about Jeter every Yanks fan screeches all the time is why ESPN thinks all those players are worse than Jeter.

@ItsGamingFancy

6 ай бұрын

@@alexisborden3191 dude I'm a Yankees fan. But nah lol. He was good but not top 30. Maybe not top 50

@alexisborden3191

6 ай бұрын

@@ItsGamingFancy Then you've definitely heard them and know exactly what they'd say if you asked them. I agree with you he's not a top 30 player.

JM Baseball and JM Football uploading at the same time? This is gonna be a good day

@dennismonk9559

6 ай бұрын

i didn't even know there was a jm football, thanks

When you look at the greatest shortstops of all time I think you can say Cal, A Rod, and Honus Wagner. A-Rod is clearly the best post-integration shortstop of all time offensively, but it's unclear when exactly he started using steroids, so that really calls his career into question. If you want to put him ahead of Jeter because of him clearly being a far superior regular season player okay, but I find it extremely difficult to put Jeter ahead of Ripken, let alone 40 spots ahead. And I think you have trouble putting A-Rod ahead of Ripken just because we will never know what Alex Rodriguez was without steroids. If you wants to discard Wagner because he's old okay, or put Jeter ahead of A-Rod because of similar access to the playoffs and largely different results, as well as the steroid issue, I understand that, but having both of them ahead of Ripken and by that much is hard to justify.

@madmanac

6 ай бұрын

Offense vs defense. Ripken is one of the best defensive shortstops of all time while Jeter is one of the worst (great arm, good instincts, horrible range and mobility). Ripken had more pop and drew more walks, Jeter had a much better contact bat. Jeter has the higher OPS+ (115 to 112) while Ripken trounces him via bWAR (95.9 to 71.3, most of that difference attributable to defense and games played). Jeter has arguably more memorable career moments because of his playoff heroics and was more in the spotlight throughout his career, but don't forget that Ripken was a 2 time MVP, a ROY, and the focus of one of the most indelible moments in baseball history. Cal's my favorite player of all time (O's fan) and while I have a begrudging respect for Jeter, who was certainly an all-timer, having 40 spots of difference is laughable. But hey, that's ESPN for ya.

@SilhouetteLifter

6 ай бұрын

ARod was taking roids since high school lol. Jose Canseco was his mentor for fuck's sake

@fantasybum438

6 ай бұрын

Derek Jeter and Robin Yount are pretty much the same player.

Me watching this, "TY COBB! TY COBB! TY FRIGGIN COBB!!!!!! AND ALSO CY YOUNG YOU MORONS!!! HE HAS A FRIGGIN AWARD NAMED AFTER HIM!!"

Do this for highest career WAR for each team

great video

"I got the list; I know shit" -Jomboy

Sammy Sosa not being on that list is crazy like i dont care if he used roids he still hit 600+ homers like ESPN be shit with that

@mikevanenglehoven6088

6 ай бұрын

Agreed they had all the players with roids on there but didn’t have sosa which is stupid

Why was I-Rod wearing a Nats cap? Inducted as a Ranger, WS win as a Marlin, had some decent years as a Tiger. I guess the Nats were technicallyhis last team, dosnt make much sense to me.

@ejflor1313

6 ай бұрын

NO ONE called him I-Rod you twit.

@mdkmgp

6 ай бұрын

They had Vlad Guerrero in an O's hat lol

@ItsGamingFancy

6 ай бұрын

Wait people call him I-Rod?

@832ANN71

6 ай бұрын

@@ItsGamingFancy Comes from when Alex Rodriguez was playing in Texas, it was A-Rod and I-Rod.

@ItsGamingFancy

6 ай бұрын

@@832ANN71 I'm Puerto Rican and grew up with that era of baseball and I've never heard that. It was always Pudge or Ivan

lol singing number one by Nelly good stuff

Make this a game where you get points based on where the player was ranked. Like Babe Ruth would get 1 point, but Nolan Ryan gets 42. It’d incentive outside the box guesses

So guessing shohei was freaking insane🤣🤣🤣

This was a lot of fun but for future versions of games like this, can you please mic up the person off camera reading off the positions.

Jimmy shaking his head at chipper is straight disrespect lol

Scherzer above Verlander blew my mind

I'm not entirely sure but did they get all the guys that have awards named after them?

Zo "I only wanna guess active players now" as if he knew more retired players.

Trout at 15 is wild

I just pulled up the full list and Josh Gibson is at 35 despite never playing in the mlb

babe ruth at #1 is a W

miggy being 59 is crazy

Bernie Williams lol

1:10 I say "Willie Mays" one second later: EDIT: Yo! I'm not kidding, 2:41 I say "Mickey Mantle?" then:

Guessing Bernie Williams with about 75 spots left is....questionable.

@SilhouetteLifter

6 ай бұрын

there are 342 players in the Hall of Fame. Bernie Williams is not one of them.

Bernie Williams lmao. Effin Yankee fans

@voncornhole

6 ай бұрын

The guy who said it is a Red Sox fan

I don’t care about steroids at all in this conversation. Barry Bonds outside of the top 3 is complete madness.

Never let ESPN cook again

How did no one say Ty Cobb?

I was wondering if anyone was going to say Lefty Grove

Alexei Ramírez robbed

They missed so many easy guys lol

these boys to watch some ken burns baseball.

Yogi, Doby, Ernie, McCovey, Vida, etc. Come on guys.

Nobody guessing Ty Cobb is insane!

I know they didn't put Gibson at 4, so having Pedro at 11 and him way lower somewhere is kind of bad. I would argue they had similar peaks but Gibson pitched way more, although that's also a product of the era. I don't know. I think you have to dock Pedro for being on that 2003 steroid list, especially since they clearly docked Bonds.

@MajorRza

6 ай бұрын

I have a feeling Ty Cobb was 4. Maybe Tris Speaker, but more likely Cobb.

@AidanCulverREAL

6 ай бұрын

2003 list is complete nonsense and wasn’t even really a steroid list. Bonds had other scandals.

@ItsGamingFancy

6 ай бұрын

@@MajorRza it's Cobb

@alexisborden3191

6 ай бұрын

Yeah but people don't dock Ortiz for being on it either.

Jeter at 28... maybe 328...

@yankees2864

6 ай бұрын

Maybe like in the 75 range yeah

@jeeckert77

6 ай бұрын

Cal has 25 more WAR than Jeter. The fact that Jeter is 40 spots higher is outrageous. ESPN doesn’t know baseball at all

Kirby Puckett not being on this list blows my mind.

Cal below jeter is insane

Ted William is way better than Hank Aaron. His career ops is 200 points higher. Using counting stats like homeruns and RBI is unfair when Williams went to war in the middle of his career

Pudge at 90 seems NUTS to me

Scherzer above verlander?

How in the fuck could they not say, Cy Young!?!? after all MLB named an award after him.

Feel like Jack and Jimmy should be able to get way farther than they did

When Jimmy got out, he started ruining it

@BKF0

6 ай бұрын

Jimmy is so easily the worst part of every single one of these types of videos he's in

Cal Ripken that low is a crime

Pujols behind Jeter is as bad as Rolling Stone putting Led Zeppelin 4 behind multiple Kanye and Taylor Swift albums.

Jimmy's needless Snakes hate is so funny to me, dude said "nobody remembers him as a Snake" just to be incendiary when the guy has four Cy Youngs and the logo on his hat in the hall of fame content engagement artist I guess because I commented and that's what he wanted.

@bv6377

6 ай бұрын

eh. according to the comments, jimmy hates every tem

How is Mike Trout above Miguel Cabrera 💀🙏🏻

Bonds at 8 is like putting Jordan 3. thats how bad it is

Dan should’ve been knocked out for Roberto Clemente Jr. Jr never made the majors let alone top 100!

I could’ve probably gotten 85 of 100 without missing

yeah, deGrom, ya know, etc., he won CY YOUNG awards. ya know…the award…named after a guy…….

Piazza over Rodriguez is a damn travesty

a lot of guys under valued on the list.

Let me guess. Is Ty Cobb #4?

Maybe Christy Matthewson?

T Y C O B B

Griffey is at 13 and Trout at 15 despite Trout already having a higher career WAR thatn the Kid at only 31 years old. People sleep on how good Trout has been.

@bv6377

6 ай бұрын

im so sorry dude

PUJOLS RANKED UNDER JETER LMFAOOOO

Jesus christ you just know it’s an ESPN list from some of these takes. Jeter over Pujols. Rose over Morgan. Ruth #1. Hilarious

Everyone is all upset about an ESPN ranking lol they don’t care about baseball. This is basically just the 100 best players in a random order.

How did nobody say ty cobb smh

No one picked Ty Cobb?

Not guessing Ty Cobb and Yogi Berra is craaaazzyyyyyyy

The documented time between Jimmy’s elimination and Jimmy grabbing his cell phone. 16 seconds! Does this man’s fingers itch when he is not holding a phone?

@jomboy_

6 ай бұрын

I pulled up the list to play along!