強烈要求新專輯收錄埋呢個版本，有冇人贊成呀呀呀?

@alas0820

3 жыл бұрын

一定要呀唔該！

@chengchang1233

3 жыл бұрын

讚成, 覺得好聽過mv版好多

@wongbrian1581

3 жыл бұрын

同意x10000

@careerwalker2742

3 жыл бұрын

@@chengchang1233 各有各感覺，都一樣正!

@jasonl7008

3 жыл бұрын

真係正過MV，好鐘意個arrangement

4月15日爺爺出交通意外既晚上 的士上播住呢首歌 路上一直喊住唔想接受將會面對既事 結果十日後 爺爺都係離開左我地 疫情之下 連進入病房見爺爺最後一面既機會都無 只可以成班屋企人係病房門口 攬住部電話zoom住同爺爺道別 走廊上既喊聲 電話屏幕上既眼淚 屋企人為爺爺最後一次唱既詩歌 呢一幕幕都如此可怕… 原來 面對生死有時呢四隻字 係可以咁無力咁懦弱… 唔知可以點面對去接受呢一切既事 但多謝呢首歌係最迷惘既時候一直陪住我 呢份詞，呢份曲，同你地既歌聲， 成為左留下來的人既止痛藥。 爺，希望你係天家可以繼續你既歷險， 約定你，那日再見，好嗎?

@user-de4sf6cw4l

3 жыл бұрын

gayau

@simpher222

3 жыл бұрын

加油

@raytsui6294

3 жыл бұрын

add oil !

@maggiel6903

3 жыл бұрын

睇到你啲字個心好痛。共勉之

@henryhin7849

3 жыл бұрын

RIP

點解四子把聲咁唔同 夾埋又可以咁好聽㗎🥺🥺🥺

@jennywoo3583

3 жыл бұрын

真係好好聽！令人感到很舒服！

@jennywoo3583

3 жыл бұрын

真係好好聽！令人感到很舒服！

2024 每次聽都好感觸 香港人 你好嗎？

@user-ec3zi4hs6y

17 күн бұрын

take a good care of yourself...add oil

香港人如何不愛CAllStar💛

我是新歌迷， 用三個月聽番佢地十年嘅歌， 才驚覺(點解啊😭)佢地原來好多正歌， 絶對係實力+偶像派 ~留意的轉折點是有次在youtube 看到ViuTv的片，是他們農曆年上去唱大約半小時果集，好聽到不得了!之後就逐首歌揾，逐個樣認，逐把聲認，好似穿梭時空咁🥰 ~CF聲音好有磁性，感情拿揑超正 ~On聲音好有感染力，暖暖的魅力 ~Jase超穩定，滑音好聽，騷味正 ~King高音一流，音色唱功勁 總之4個精英合體冇得輸❤❤❤

@wymanberg

3 жыл бұрын

想當年，我都係咁入坑😌

@7flower953

3 жыл бұрын

呢10首超正(排名不分先後)~不得不聽 遲了欣賞他們， 他們的歌有極強感染力💜 1.薄情歌 2.生於斯 3.再不再見 4.我們的胡士托 5.差詞 6.音樂殖民地 7.家書 8.逾越生死 9.時日如飛 10.天梯

@Ashura113

3 жыл бұрын

@@7flower953 有太多了，十首不够

@Kay-kf1sr

3 жыл бұрын

偶像派🤩

@wongdada9597

3 жыл бұрын

人成熟了，歌也唱得愈來愈好

琴日爺爺係醫院走左。聽到C AllStar既呢首歌，感觸不少，於是寫左封信比爺爺，希望佢睇到！ Rest in peace, my dearest grandad:) Dear grandad, How are you? When I am writing this letter, you probably have reached a new world in heaven, starting a brand new life there. In this letter, I would like to express 3 message to you: what I appreciate from you, what you could have done better, who I am going to be in the future to serve as one of your biggest legacy. I hope you can read this in heaven, knowing your grandson who might not have a close relationship with you, always respect you and love you. You will forever be my hero, my role model, one of the greatest man I have ever seen in my life. I love you and really hope you could enjoy a blissful and abundant life up there in heaven. I believe my Lord Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit will be with you, rest in peace. It is painful to say I didn’t have a very close relationship with you when you were sitting next to me. I am naive and there is always an intangible barrier between us that somehow stopped me to be more willing to talk with you. I always think you are the most traditional Chinese man that I have ever met, speaking to you was a bit frightening to me. Yet, sometimes you did make some jokes or laughed for a bit when my brother and I were saying something stupid. The moment when I saw that smile hanging on your face, I couldn’t express how heart-warming it was deep inside my heart. I will certainly remember that smile for the rest of my life as it is the most precious piece of memory of you to me, I hope that I could see that smile again when I meet you again in heaven. Though our relationship was slightly distant, I still have immense respect of what you have done for the family and the success you had in your life. According to my light memory, you came from a poor family in the rural place in china, slowly building up your success by coming to Hong Kong. To me, you are a great businessman who have substantial demand on yourself but still upholding the important integrity of a man. I have been looking for different people to learn about throughout my life, there are many famous people I respected who start with nothing but end with everything. However, I often miss out one of the closest people who I knew was one of those, and that is you, my grandfather. I am sorry that I could only appreciate the hard-work you dedicated, the hardship you overcame when you left this world. I admire your mentality and courage to defeat poverty and live a successful life by creating this beautiful family, I will serve all these principles as one of my integral value and this is the best gift you have ever given to me. I also appreciate the dignity you have by not letting yourself to satisfy on an adverse situation, especially when someone looked down on you or being condescending. You taught me how to be a real man, who would not let anyone even yourself to look down on yourself. No matter what kind of circumstances, you wanted to be someone respectful of and think highly of, I will do the same from now on and also the rest of my life. Although you have always been a hero of mine, and I have learnt so much from you, there are still something I wish you could done better. Your dignity might have came to an extreme at some point of your life, it become an ego barrier that stopped you to receive the help and support when your body is so weak. I wish you could have understand that a person is never capable of doing everything on his own, and it is definitely not humiliating to request help from others. On the other hand, I understand that the traditional man you were lead to the reluctance of receiving help from others, I felt sorry that I didn’t do more to help you get over this barrier. Oh well this is life, rather than regretting on what I could have done better, I choose to accept it and treat it as another lesson of life. I wanted to remind anyone on the message: we are too insignificant to control things happening around us, it is wiser to ask for a helping hand from others whenever it’s desperately needed. Grandad, I might not have known the entire story behind your reluctance, but this is my view toward it. The last message I wanted you to know about is my aspiration. I consider myself as a legacy of you and it is my responsibility to live out the best version of myself, so you will be proud of me when you view my life from the heavenly kingdom. I am 19 years old and desperate to get whatever I wanted even though it might seems impossible to anybody. I believe that the courage you had have passed to me genetically, I don’t mind to start with nothing as I am courageous enough to conquer whatever obstacles coming. I also have a high standard regarding myself just like you, I fear boredom and mediocrity more than risk, I want to be hero just like you. In the past years of life, I have fulfilled the expectation of society to seek for a rather safe route of life: being a physiotherapist. I knew that I would not be truly happy on playing it safe, I believe you had a similar belief when you were at the same age. My aspiration is to become a hedge fund manger, sounds crazy right? Unlike the typical path to the finance industry, neither did I study Finance nor Economics, I was only trading with an account set up by my friends and me. However, I am confident to say that such aspiration is not a pipe dream, because of the mentality and dignity you had taught me. I knew that you will see my dedication high above, believing in me to accomplish such meaningful goal. I also learned that joy doesn’t come from abundance itself but the gracefulness of being abundant, you have been through so much in your life to understand this lesson. I am here to tell you that this lesson has deeply engraved in my mind and became the most important value of mine. I promise that I will walk my talk, and one day I will become someone as successful as you were. I love you forever, you will be missed, my beloved grandad. Love, Davis Poon 21-06-2021

@ericpun_hker

2 жыл бұрын

朋友，加油

佢哋好似變形金剛咁 單挑又得 合體又得😎

@ch-la

3 жыл бұрын

同意！真係好鬼正！

@ellielau8454

2 жыл бұрын

@@ch-la 909009000⁰00000099⁰⁰99900000000

@johnyeung4084

2 жыл бұрын

形容得好貼切

@nobits4903

2 жыл бұрын

真的鼎佢哋唔住，好聽到痺。

@felixli9128

2 жыл бұрын

4個都好L唱得。。。。。。

聽 C AllStar 唱 live比聽CD更正💚💛💙💖

四子好神奇 好似每首歌各自有個崗位 CF/Jase 初段低音位 Jase/On 唱中段build up King/CF唱激昂高潮位 King爆最高高高高音 但有時交換唱/2個唱/3缺1 都可以carry到wor

@kaying0206

3 жыл бұрын

舖排一流👍🏻多謝亞簡💛

@hiunamho5873

3 жыл бұрын

呢個都係最amazing 既地方，佢哋成日cover 人地既歌，但好少人翻唱佢哋既歌，因為佢哋既歌真係唔係咁易唱得好聽😂

可能係2021最有感觸既歌，多謝C all stars 為我們帶來一啲集體回憶，即使有天我們失去了香港，大家還是香港人

@wongdada9597

3 жыл бұрын

好有感覺......

@Kalicious79

3 жыл бұрын

唔係有天，其實已經失去咗啦😢

@yingyuanchen3441

3 жыл бұрын

香港，我永远的精神故乡😢

@silvialee1744

3 жыл бұрын

香港人唔好放棄，有一天總會煲底見

@kenlo0127

3 жыл бұрын

大家珍重，香港人加油

DJ King 果下“又如何避免” 好癲

@kaying0206

3 жыл бұрын

加埋佢堅定嘅眼神🔥🔥🔥

@7flower953

3 жыл бұрын

仲好清楚唔係「港女」

@LIKWAMLOK

3 жыл бұрын

@@7flower953 😂😂 第一次聽果陣要即刻返睇歌詞

@lovecallkaho1820

3 жыл бұрын

@@7flower953 原來唔係得我聽到 '港女' 😅

@thomaschan823

3 жыл бұрын

@@kaying0206 佢個樣好似唱得一啲壓力都冇😍😍好勁

過了2年再聽、依家覺得好感動

2024繼續聽，期望在唔同公司的你們可以再次合體

三百日後， 皇上拎咪， 幾有霸氣😎

單飛同合體都掂 香港第一歌唱組合 C allstar

多謝C AllStar，香港人，那日見

我是大陆人。香港人加油。

@cedriclai6461

2 жыл бұрын

大家都是中國人吧😊

@guoxinwang

2 жыл бұрын

@@cedriclai6461 东方之珠，我的爱人。

無論係原版定live版，都好觸動人心 每次聽，個心都會乸住乸住，試過聽聽下喊咗出嚟 首歌所帶出嘅message&情感都好沉重 但係偏偏好多香港人都面對緊差唔多嘅情況 或者，我哋真係需要一個渠道宣泄呢份情緒出嚟 多謝呢首歌嘅製作團隊&C AllStar

@tsewaiming4152

6 ай бұрын

！\

This version is even more heartbreaking...

非CAllfans 但我喪睇呢個version 多謝你地 香港人加油💛

Proud to be a 11 years C Allfans💛我會誓死追隨C AllStar，四子除咗一直陪住我成長，亦一直陪住香港人成長，走過高山低谷，絕對more than a 實力派，感謝C AllStar的歌聲，我係好自豪咁同人講：「我係聽C AllStar嘅歌大」

@JoanKSX

3 жыл бұрын

11年了？ 我相见恨太晚啊...

@halobarry

11 ай бұрын

​@@JoanKSX👩‍🦳tttyyyyujooppwwee!!.❤❤❤l

c all star你地好痴線 點解首歌可以好聽成咁 我最喜愛組合♡

阿king真係好正

king的高音真係正到!!!

@yyl1934

2 жыл бұрын

他不只高音正, 而是完全投入, 完全牽引聽歌者情感, 帶出眼淚位。

C AllStar = 品質保證

致所有留下來的人： 光復香港，時代革命 香港獨立，唯一出路 願榮光歸香港

仲好聽過錄音個version🤤🤤🤤

@wymanberg

3 жыл бұрын

真！今次arrangement 乾淨啲，佢地嘅vocal更突出更有質感！

呢個version好好好好聽。皇上一開口加埋表情，感動到喊！

啊king唱得真好

@yyl1934

2 жыл бұрын

他不只高音正, 而是完全投入, 完全牽引聽歌者情感, 帶出眼淚位。

道出港人痛苦心情, 是離開還是留下. 命運的決擇.

好感動😭，天時地利人和，C AllStar嘅合體，廣東歌喺2021年重新受到大家嘅關注。以前C AllStar嘅MV甚少上到熱門，今次聽到唔少新粉絲支持狂loop，作為由ising聽到而家嘅第一代C AllFans，覺得感觸良多，不枉支持了11年，燒烤叉值得擁有更多。👍🏻

@winniewinwintang

10 ай бұрын

我係第一代c all fans😢

有無人同我一樣覺得King唱D高音位勁好J

@svenc5904

3 жыл бұрын

樣都好好J😂

@terrycheung9734

3 жыл бұрын

@@svenc5904 呢個就一直J開🙈

@TT-mn9mp

Жыл бұрын

已經cap曬好多條不同live嘅「降淚時 又如何避免」落嚟慢慢J 😂

聽完拉闊要入嚟洗耳

@lovecallkaho1820

2 жыл бұрын

我琴晚已經係咁做

@7flower953

2 жыл бұрын

揮灑自如👍 大家突然湧番入黎，好warm

@user-ng1mh6bz6f

2 жыл бұрын

KING好正～

唱得好呢首歌真係唔輕易。先要唱功了得，令人感覺安穩（我最怕一邊聽，一邊要擔心歌者走音😬😖😅），然後能唱出感情，感動聽眾，真係絕對唔容易呀！今晚入黎聽番3次，洗一洗別的版本。😅

2023身邊仍有家人朋友輪流走，希望大家可以幸福...「那日見」。多謝製作團隊，多謝C AllStar 憑歌寄意。

皇上個角色真係幫成首歌點咗睛

King呢個live version vocal鋪排得好好，比CD 版更好🤞🏻

King 😍😍😍😍😍😍

Jase solo嗰段好有磁性好感動。King solo同高音嗰段真係聽到好入心入肺。

情緒完全被歌曲歌詞牽動遊走，在現世香港下聽此歌更大感觸。。謝謝你們

我2021年啱啱就離開咗香港 ... 每次聽依首歌都心痛 唔單止因為啲朋友親戚都咁遠 香港嘅未來又唔知會變成點

@arkayzi

3 ай бұрын

會愈黎愈差，不過大家都要頂L住❤

近年少聽廣東歌，但因為某現場翻唱過來聽原唱，一聽就被感動落淚了。 今年最喜歡的歌，沒有之一。

我偏心皇上😍

我係聽完～姜、J、T、林先過黎，c all star原版live好聽好多⋯

@cedriclai6461

2 жыл бұрын

那四位後生仔,加點功夫吧

今天聽亦會流淚,祝大家生活平安(包括巳走的人✈️)

皇上太完美🥺

每日入黎聽一次....

個人覺得唱功穩定過塊鏡 冇心去踩，但我覺得c all star真心好聽 一個人唱又得，四個一齊仲得 安仔係我中學師兄 Proud of you brother

@TT-mn9mp

Жыл бұрын

根本唔係同一level⋯⋯淨係音準都成問題，而且佢哋冇人唱到king段bridge，已經聽過所謂最勁嘅Jer唱，得啖笑

@dora2633

Жыл бұрын

你拎來比簡直係侮辱緊callstar，鏡大部分根本連合格歌手都唔算

幾個月前大舅父走咗 公公又突然啱啱走埋 呢首歌真係唱到入肉 好掛住佢哋…

痴線，個個都唱得咁好，我聽咗好多次都唔夠喉，今晚又瞓唔到啦

停不了下來，聽這首歌總有一種心痛的感覺，他們四子的聲音令人感動到不得了，King唱的「又如何避免」真是動人到不能形容！

king真係屈機⋯⋯⋯

4子唱歌簡直係完美，實在太好聽了 ❤

比CD更好聽的live version。阿King高音一開口正到

@7flower953

3 жыл бұрын

King:「高音算甚麼」🎤

//即使費時一點 即使快樂不輕易 最後仍可遇見// Miss u all~~~ 無論大家將來响世界各地， 最後，仍可相見！🧡🧡🧡 #CAllStar合體 #勁正 #完美演繹 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

四個都獨當一面🤩🤩🤩

實力唱功當然唔洗講. what's more係佢地既演出、情感、表情的拿捏, 令成件事好好睇(visually), 是真正的performer.

@branton957

2 жыл бұрын

例如佢地generally既沉重, 例如安仔唱「使世界亮了點」的笑容、釗峰唱「拼了命成就幸福」皺眉和望向遠方

@cedriclai6461

2 жыл бұрын

真的,四子用唔同的感情去唱各段不同的詞,洽到好處！

差不多三百日了還在這樣懷念

後悔冇早D留意CALLSTAR

@7flower953

2 жыл бұрын

我一樣，呢半年真係勁多新fans陶醉到跌入坑

就1M啦☺️

實力派，真係好proud of 佢哋，做C Allfans 好光榮。

原來 C all star 唱 live 係咁好聽.... 宜家先知

多謝嘅arrangement，令四子重組後性格、聲音鮮明，尤其是段bridge真係好突出皇上，有種令人好期待佢開聲嘅感覺

一路聽，一路等皇上爆seed，不負眾望👍

出左兩首歌，已經知呢隻係神碟

jase嘅和音jeng lun到😢

等左皇上爆seed呢個機會好耐啦😭

@kaying0206

3 жыл бұрын

冇失望😍好有🔥🔥🔥

@terrycheung9734

3 жыл бұрын

不停loop嗰個位，好正

2024年有冇人 👇🏻

@cswcssbird

2 ай бұрын

可惜king 已經轉左去Sony

@manmanma131

2 ай бұрын

我還在

2022年1月2日第一次係叱咤頒獎禮上聽里首歌，一聽愛上👍

🥺🥺🥺重組嘅c allstar好勁！好想你哋開演唱會。

想起CAllStar另一首歌《再不再見》， 亦係CF先唱，之後Jase，再係On仔，然後皇上高音位。《再不再見》是情人離別的傷感，《留下來的人》是人生永別的傷痛，兩首都期盼再見。 兩首都係好歌🧡 都有超正live版💜

2個版本都100萬留名

記得的 留下的 同行的 想念的 希望我們不忘彼此不負人生。 謝謝 C AllStar 🤍

离开那片土地的飞机上时，一直循环着这首歌，万分感叹，多少人只为一个正常柴米油盐的生活被迫背井离乡，希望未来有一天，一切都能变好吧

On 1:35 嗰到唱得好入肉 好heartbreaking🥺 尤其係唱到 使世界亮了點 嗰到嘅笑容，見到都好心痛

不停loop，眼淚💧流不停。 但願香港人的苦難早日終結

4子把聲太正

我哋就係留下來的人，聽住這首歌想起這幾香港人和事，眼淚滴下！

太感動了 發現大家都傷得太深 希望九佰日後會好一點⋯⋯ 同曰

On仔既暖 CF既爆發 King既高音 Jase既滑音 4個加埋一齊真係痴撚線

睇完最近商台拉闊個live，除左林家謙之外三個走音甩beat，就知呢首歌既難度同四子既唱功好上乘

@TT-mn9mp

Жыл бұрын

亦都因為另外三個好唔掂⋯⋯呢首唔應該甩beat

好好聽!! 好期待有個大舞台比佢哋唱呢首歌！一定好感動

🍎...香港人珍重

最近有朋友選擇離開了世界 一直唔想接受呢個事實 唔知可以點面對去接受件事 但多謝呢首歌係最迷惘既時候一直陪住我 我知道我地將會有一日 彼此集合，好好相見

不如派埋呢個版本上台, 仲正過CD版

瘋狂咁loop 呢首歌，真係好大感觸，曲好聽、詞到肉、四子既演釋直頭勁過晒個d乜乜好聲音，聽左呢首歌而想喊既，真係真真正正既香港人

呢個 version 好正，皇上真係爆seed皇

點解可以好聽到咁，我從來唔會係youtube留言都忍唔住要留…好正呀！

係我心目中你哋永遠係最好嘅組合。 有冇人同我一樣聽到喊？

C AllStar永遠世一 狂loop都唔會聽厭🤯

Live 仲好聽過CD👍🏻

最鍾意皇上唱果幾句💜

多謝C All Star,這兩天剛走了一位朋友,我用這首歌暗自和他道別,所以這兩天一直反覆聽著,心裏淌著淚說一路好走,而希望他的"留下來的人"可以堅強地走下去

超 好 聽 冇嘢好補充

Live 有埋表情，好豐富，聽音感情澎湃，好聽過 cd, 4 位加油

日日都loop緊呢首歌 好好聽💕💕 有冇得無限㩒like👍🏻🥰

最近先識依首歌，一聽就愛上，自己成日哼，遲了悔改，只好講抵你離開～～～😂加油吖❤

一日聽一次

嗨趴深情随机切换！！4子好正！！同集合吧完全唔同feel！！！