BJP’s ‘parivaarvaad’ paradox, and the dynasties holding its fort | Mandate 2024, Ep 2
#loksabhaelection2024 #mandate2024 #guna
In the second part of this series, Sreenivasan Jain explores whether - and why - dynastic politics is here to stay, with the Scindia bastion of Guna as a case in point.
In one election after another, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has wooed large chunks of the Indian electorate with the idea that the dynastic rule of his “corrupt” political rivals has come to an end under his government.
But the new BJP under him isn’t without dynasties. From leaders such as Jitin Prasad, Anurag Thakur, Piyush Goyal, Bansuri Swaraj and Rita Bahuguna Joshi, to erstwhile royal Jyotiraditya Scindia - who helped the party topple the Kamal Nath government and bring the BJP back to power in Madhya Pradesh.
Scindia, meanwhile, is again in the fray from Guna, where Sreenivasan Jain met his son Mahanaaryaman, a fourth generation Scindia, in the interior villages of the Madhya Pradesh constituency. He went from one village to another, asking for votes, possibly preparing for his entry into the world of politics.
But Scindia Junior denies allegations of ‘parivaarvaad’, saying that him being part of Scindia’s campaign is not a political debut. “This is me supporting my father.” He insists that his only inheritance has been a devotion to public service, and all that he is focussing on is his company. “When sons join businesses, that’s not dynastic politics.”
The BJP, meanwhile, offers a convoluted defence.
Asked about BJP allies from political dynasties, including Ajith Pawar and Jayant Chaudhary, a BJP leader says, “Raja Ram, to defeat Ravana, do you know whose help he took? I will not give you a bigger example than this. To destroy Ravana we need Vibhishan. The goal is what is important.”
Asked about the party’s decision to field leaders like Jyotiraditya Scindia, another insists that “this is not about family”. “Dynasty is when you are launched. Maharaja Scindia does a lot of hard work. He goes to affected people, people who are suffering, he goes to their house.”
But in the remote parts of Guna, development is skewed and locals say the Maharaja last visited them when he was part of the Congress. Even then, faith in the dynasty seems to be unwavering.
A local who points to issues such as uninterrupted power supply and joblessness says he will still vote for the BJP leader. “See we believe in him, that he will find solutions to our problems.”
On the campaign trail, it seems evident that dynasty may help overcome some discontent of the kind that’s seen in Guna. And parivaarvaad across party lines is here to stay for long.
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscript...
Power NL and TNM's coverage of the 2024 general elections: www.newslaundry.com/2024-elec...
Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app
Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61...
Follow and engage with us on social media:
Facebook: / newslaundry
Twitter: / newslaundry
Instagram: / newslaundry
Пікірлер: 547
Subscribe to Newslaundry: www.newslaundry.com/subscription?ref=social Power NL and TNM's coverage of the 2024 general elections: www.newslaundry.com/2024-electionfund?ref=nl-social Download the all-new Newslaundry app: www.newslaundry.com/download-app Join us on WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va61PEo0QeacOqU9vr2k
@mrsarkar6933
21 күн бұрын
Rahul Gandhi ji has a clear vision for youth employment. Save the constitution vote for Congress
@shreea3131
21 күн бұрын
rinivasan again got presumption and pretext wrong on Dynastic politics....BJP and Modi is NOT against political families or family dynastic politics but they are against when political party leadership positions are taken up by dynastic politics like DMK/Congress/RJD....etc
@zzzzzzzzzzyy
21 күн бұрын
@@shreea3131 why don't you watch sudarshan news and the rest of Godi PRESTITUTES..they report as per ur requirement....don't come n vomit on sane platforms
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
@@zzzzzzzzzzyy What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@zzzzzzzzzzyy
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 his report is 10000% accurate...why don't you make a report and counter him... narendra and his gibberish barf doesn't count...he has ZERO credibility even among his voters..first time in Indian history the PM post has been reduced to a Anti national RSS pracharak Post.##ABKI BAAR PHEKU FROM PMO TO TIHAR
Using the term Maharaj Scindia in this age of Democracy is a shame in itself. Hes just equal to every Indian citizen.
@cofeewithkrun-hz6ix
20 күн бұрын
Public itself is responsible for their misery and poor status of our country, we fell down to the feet of these power centers giving them more of it to the point where they control everything. See old people touching his feet and he doesn't mind it at all and then giving gyan.
@tarun1255
20 күн бұрын
Is he forcing other to say him maharaj ??
@cofeewithkrun-hz6ix
20 күн бұрын
@@tarun1255 Yes there are news where he asked his party workers to do so.
@abc_cba
20 күн бұрын
@@tarun1255 he is found in many instances in the same video refering his father as Maharaj instead of asking people not to use that Second being - freedom struggle khoon meh hain, I mean if someone is a killer, his children will be the same or that if someone is an autorickshaw driver his kids would to the same? Clearly wrong.
@naanallamuthu5038
19 күн бұрын
They wanted to bring back King rule, that's how they are trying to prepare the country.
Vote for India. Save India from dictatorship. Save democracy, Save Constitution.
@aksman8563
21 күн бұрын
😂
@r00t_augusta36
21 күн бұрын
1975 emergengy
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@r00t_augusta36 now you are doing same😆🤣
@r00t_augusta36
21 күн бұрын
@@vsansanv29101_sd I think you have pappu fever should contact your dhruv rahtee doctor
@AbhiBaba12402
21 күн бұрын
😂vote on local candidates not on hinduism khatremai hai or savidhan khatre Mai hai vote for local candidates
This report is now a tight slap of all those who blame Congress for "Dynasty Politics".
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@housednb2212
21 күн бұрын
Of the 77 years of independent India Gandhi family has directly ruled 39 years and indirectly 50 years,Rahul baba comes and talks about generational wealth and Elite taking control
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@housednb2212 as if bjp pappus earn there wealth by honest means🤣🤣🤣
@PrahaladKundapura
21 күн бұрын
Welcome to Karnataka out of 28 seats 8 seats given to family members of the Congress party 😂😂
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@PrahaladKundapura when your party has given to more than 15 familly dynasty in karnataka you cry about congress 🤣🤣🤣
No shouting, no abuse, moderate tone and speed , crystal clear message. Just came across this channel. Continue doing good work .
@cheriankuruvilla3722
16 күн бұрын
Compare Srinivasan Jain with the barking dog Arnab Cowswamy. What a big contrast ?
The best way to expose a fool is to let him speak freely....Well done Srini. Kudos!!!
@morvaridfernandez3105
18 күн бұрын
💯 you got it absolutely right!!
Seeing Sreenivas Jain with boots on the ground , momentarily I thought that I was watching NDTV of our old times.
@ramap4542
17 күн бұрын
True
@pavankumarduvvuri2629
16 күн бұрын
All those who had were peddling their vested agenda and still believe in that they can with their never say die effection towards their masters who think can bring back their lost bouquet of comforts, just ran away with their bags and bedding packed and the people who stood back knows the truth and they stayed away from all the nefarious agendas of the PRONOY and his few soldiers, and had no hesitation or guilt to stay back....🙂
@pavankumarduvvuri2629
16 күн бұрын
Karma will catch you, how far you run, no matter how superior spoken english you have or how big journo you have been in the past.....🤝
@CadetRaaj
16 күн бұрын
@@pavankumarduvvuri2629 Wholly wrong. NDTV is now new Godmodania on the horizon .
@CadetRaaj
16 күн бұрын
@@pavankumarduvvuri2629 He had good Karma, therefore, he is bouncing back.
Loved it. The scindia kid tried his best to deflect but couldn't. Hope people vote these "royals" out
Thanks Srinivas for such a brilliant piece of ground reporting, thoroughly exposed BJPee's hypocrisy 👏Thanks Srinivas for such a brilliant piece of ground reporting, thoroughly exposed BJPee's hypocrisy 👏
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@D.ThirumalaikumarKumar
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666are you have hearing problem? Even people with hearing proplem will understand modi's parivaar politics speeches.
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
@@D.ThirumalaikumarKumar And what about his speech in parliament where he mentioned what he meant by dynastic politics, dumbhead
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 dumbhead first remove dynasty politics from your party🤣🤣🤣
@nealjeffers12
21 күн бұрын
That sounds more like a political party problem than an Indian Citizen problem !@@ErikBerg666
Very sad state of affairs. Ignorance & hypnotism at heights 😥
Best thing about Jain saheb is that he expose them right infront of them..keep up the good work guys
Hypocrisy of fascist communal Bjp is completely exposed.
Its so good to see Shrinivasan back to press world. ❤
It’s tough being a journalist, But it’s Gut-wrenching being an honest journalist.
I just feel contented after watching such a brilliant report. I used to find such reporting only with the foreign media, but I am now happy and proud to have you guys , especially Sreenivas
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 chamelion party and chamelion supports flock together🤣🤣🤣
@PrahaladKundapura
21 күн бұрын
Chuslim
@vMorse001
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 it is not biased he have also talked about the Congress and other opposition party “Dynastic Politics”,Go and watch the video once more 😂
@Subhash_1987
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 Hello, *IT Cell* employee, *copy-pasting* the same thing in every comment. 😂😂
Royalty ended in 1947
@yourconscience27
21 күн бұрын
That's why BJP wants to take this country 200 years back.
"my startup my startup my startup........."
For Modi, the chair is dear, not the people. Modi can go to any extent for the chair.
@ravimsr8872
21 күн бұрын
Modi is a shameless leader. He is a liability to BJP.
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@jeniljebajosin5967
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 Tat is what ever fits his narrative he will accept.. how low u can stoop ?? then how come he take support of parties which are run entirely by families ?
@dnbcatalina6192
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 Hmm BJP IT cell Bot detected here.
@tarun1255
20 күн бұрын
@@jeniljebajosin5967When we are going to see congress,SP,RJD lead by a non family member, please enlighten us you librandu, I can guarantee Modi is a no no for 2029, can you say same for PAPPU
From startup to IPL chairman, nepotism is everywhere.
Rahul Gandhi ji has a clear vision for youth employment. Save the constitution vote for Congress
@AniketRoyBengali
21 күн бұрын
😂😂😂
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@AniketRoyBengali2 crore jobs promised converted to 2 crore it cell jobs🤣🤣
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
😂😂 Chamchas living in thier own fool's paradise. What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@mrsarkar6933
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 , unpadh modi ki unpadh chamcha 🤣 jindegi bhar berojgar rahena hai, phir bhi modi modi kahena hai 🤣. Burden of India..
@vsansanv29101_sd
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 bjp leader on family dynasty in bjp in karnataka Bengaluru: Senior BJP MLA Basanagouda Patil Yatnal on Friday said the party should not become a part of one family, in an apparent reference to the appointment of B Y Vijayendra, son of veteran leader B S Yediyurappa, to the post of Karnataka state unit president.🤣🤣
Vasu sir dropping bombs on a daily basis! His experience in reporting and journalism is apparent in each of the videos!
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@r00t_augusta36
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 they have pappu fever and their doctor is dhruv rahtee and left party so they tell what they are told by their so call liberal father they don't see lalu in Bihar in Rajasthan Ashok Gahlot and his son in Himachal same when syndhia in Congress Dynasty good but he told us how Ghandhi family Dynasty work and left Congress then pappu lovers had heart attack..
@ErikBerg666
20 күн бұрын
@@r00t_augusta36 True, chamchas are like zoombie, programmed to doom.
@vsansanv29101_sd
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 faku fever talking about family dynasty what a irony 😆😆
@zubinjain8675
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 So basically shift goalposts when convinient or confronted with reality.
Srinivasan, you are such a wonderful jornalist, love for your work,😇
Watching Sreenivasan Jain is a refreshing experience. I enjoy his series and his approach to reporting.
Srinivasan Jain, proud of ur brilliant work👍 keep it up God bless u, Elated to see u in News laundry. 🙌
Powerful and unbiased journalism coverage Mr Sreenivasan, i love watching your news coverage. Please keep up the good work.
Srinivasan jain❤❤
It's good to see you again Srinivas fighting the good fight with your journalism. ❤ more power to you!
What an insight...true reporting great work sir and newslaundry...am glad that people like you are fighting on behalf of all the true indians
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@zubinjain8675
20 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 And stop spamming.
Thank you newslaundary and S Jain for having guts to report from the ground and unearthed the facts. Save democracy 👍👍
The Local support for Scindia is very minimal...
Sreenivisan Jain, welcome back! 🙏😁
Real Journalism.And Real picture of Scindia....... Pls get some blessings from poor people.Heroooo..become zeerooo.ji
That was a great ans "woh hamara parivar hai"😂😂 hypocrisy ki bhi Seema hoti hai😂😂
This Jr Sindhia is definitely coming full time into politics . It’s on his face, in his words…. Dynast
And the worse is the latest Scindia talking about service to the community - the only service is to their bank accounts
Good journalism. We need journalist like Shreenivasan
If BJP does everything is right but not for others.what is happening to the janata not able to understand the facts.
Your majesty, your grace !!
It is great to see real and dignified journalism. It is nostalgic to see Sreenivasan Jain. Ground reporting in all its glory.
The royal chipmunk definitely needs a haircut😅😅😅
@vivekmandvi2199
21 күн бұрын
Din Bhai AC mein rehte hy toh garami ka anubhav bhi Bhai hota hoga
the video shows the "Rehtoric and Reality" of indian politics
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
@abinn88
21 күн бұрын
@@ErikBerg666 the meaning of dynastic politics cannot be on his terms when you are accepting all the corrupt politicians and dynasts and making them mps without giving oppurtunity to your karyakartas who give blood and sweat to the party
They way he ask questions.. yar love you sir god bless you ❤ Inda need people like you.. the real patrakarita
Amazing work from Srinivas.
I loved your ground reporting so much, you left the party workers speechless by your questions. They expected that you were just another Godi media reporter but now on they'll be careful 😶😶
Great journalism...always a fan of srinivas
8:55 this shot proves the real apathy of india. princes are loved through generations even though india embraced democracy
@Trollika_Devi
20 күн бұрын
It's disgusting. Uski dada ki umr ki hai woh chacha. This is where caste and Dynasty power overlap.The kid does a poor job of acting humble.
It's not about for congress. It's to give BJP a break!!
Mind blowing sir Thankyou for your services
*Does J. Scindia not fart if he does fart so why he's considered to be a pious or a king?😂😂*
Bravo bravo Srinivasan Jain and NL
Good reporting SJ Keep it up Good perspective, with a lot of data & evidence
@ErikBerg666
21 күн бұрын
What a biased report, in which they have deliberately not presented or omitted the argument of BJP and what they mean by dynastic politics. PM Modi mentioned this himself on the floor of Parliament on 5th Feb 2024. He clearly said "Which dynastic politics do we talk about? If more than one person in a family, on their own strength and with the support of the public, makes progress in the political field, we have never called it dynastic politics. We call it dynastic politics when a party is run by a family, when the party prioritises members of a family, when family members take all the important decisions of the party"
It's in his DNA to 'help' people. Chote nawab qaafi generous hai
@SaurabhSharma_2
20 күн бұрын
His sense of *entitlement* and *hypocrisy* is mind-boggling 😅
@Trollika_Devi
20 күн бұрын
@@SaurabhSharma_2 😆 Yeah.
So happy to see Shrinivasan... Thank newslaundry
Hypocrisy on another level 😂😂
This guy too studied abroad 😎 all those with money have their kids study abroad and themseytalk about Hindu Muslims in India
Really love your work Sreenivasan! followed your videos on Al Jazeera and now here. It takes courage to ask such important questions. Hope you are taking safety precautions you never know what happens when you are questioning the public these days as everyone is too polarised. Keep yourself hydrated too. Kudos to you!
@jaikrishnaullal7776
5 күн бұрын
Yes please beware of the goons
Bahut achchhi report.
Thankyou
These guys are superb! Kudos to their good work. Shrinivasan Jain a great journalist.
Thank you sir
Sreenivas that's a brilliant ground report.We have a long way to go.
Nivasan jain is good.
Thanks Srinivas 🙏🙏
We are with you, sir.
Amazing amazing amazing ground reporting. Thankyou Sreenivasan Jain & NL. Keep going 👍
Srinivasan is awesome, always to the point
Thanks!
Good piece. Good to see you, Mr. Jain after a long time. Welcome back !
This type of journalism we want!!
Thanks
Great going sir
Gotta hand it to the young man he's brave enough to face the media unlike certain someone
A brilliant video. We need more of Sreenivasan Jain :)
Kingship returns to India 😮.
Just read the history. You will find the true values of that family. Those pompous words of that young guy surrounded by a few cheerleaders sound absolutely gibberish!
@ananddikshit4511
19 күн бұрын
"Come down to help people." "This is how we connect with 'these' people." Alag hi planet ke hain bhai ye.
To hear Sreenivasan jain here is so calming telling the reality on the ground 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Great to see Srinavasan Jain again.
Always a pleasure watching any report by Sreenivan .
It's in his DNA to not do actual work. Giving the same old example of doesn't a CEO's kid become the next CEO. That proves these people are treating politics as their business. Hypocrites.
Awesome reporting 💯
Parivaaarvad is in every party. Noone is different
Hey guys, it is only you I can tell that model code of conduct is absent in Lucknow in terms that BJP posters are everywhere still in Lucknow, from polytechnic Indiranagar to CM residence, all is saffron. Kindly check it out.
Best ground reporting in this election so far!!!
Yeh woh Scindia hen Jo Britishers se mil gaye the😂 1857
So brave of you Sreenivas.... awesome
11:20 DNA mein sirf dhoka dena hai,rani Laxmibai ko dhoka Dena wale
Srinivas, good to have you back, and is this channel one may expect to see you on? 👏👏👏
Glad to see Sreenivasan Jain on Newslaundry. I hope he does more of this type of ground reporting. Nice shirt too , if I may say so :)
Brilliant report Jain Saab
You are doing great in journalism.
Strong
Jain sir.. good analysis and, as adding more values to current reporting by News laundry team
NDTV's loss is Newslaundry's gain !!
It is in his DNA to help people the Junior prince is saying, day before yesterday his mother told hamara kaam nahi tumhari madad karna to the women of her province😅😅😅😅 what a hypocrisy is this????
there is no social service in there blood .. but the clan is well known as traitor who did not support Rani Laxmibai during the 1857 revolt. "bloody Traitor Maharaj" thats what present scindia maharaj did. left congress and join BJP.
Well done!!
Superb content
great job, S!
Great reporting.....keep it up....
❤