BJP's Muslim outreach, Shias, Pasmandas & clergy's falling clout-- Shekhar Gupta with Sanya Dhingra

#CutTheClutter #muslimpolitics #NarendraModi
With barely weeks to go for the Lok Sabha polls, BJP's Muslim outreach is focused more on welfare politics and catering to the Pasmandas, who RSS believes are converted Hindus. In Episode 1408 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta in conversation with Sanya Dhingra, discusses the reasons behind BJP's Muslim outreach, its focus on the Pasmanda Muslims, how both BJP and Congress made use of the Shia-Sunni divide and what it means for the Muslims in India.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Sanya Dhingra's article here: theprint.in/politics/origins-...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our KZread Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

Пікірлер: 1 000

  • @ThePrintIndia
    @ThePrintIndia3 ай бұрын

    Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

  • @wisdomhighschool9975

    @wisdomhighschool9975

    3 ай бұрын

    You got time last year if 4.4% growth rate for Just one quarter, But you are doing irrelevant episodes when Quarterly Growth was A Phenomenal 8.4%, 3 New Large Semiconductor Plants in Gujarat and Assam with $ 15 Billion Dollars in Investments, Sandeshkhali etc

  • @wisdomhighschool9975

    @wisdomhighschool9975

    3 ай бұрын

    You got time last year if 4.4% growth rate for Just one quarter, But you are doing irrelevant episodes when Quarterly Growth was A Phenomenal 8.4%, 3 New Large Semiconductor Plants in Gujarat and Assam with $ 15 Billion Dollars in Investments, Sandeshkhali etc

  • @wisdomhighschool9975

    @wisdomhighschool9975

    3 ай бұрын

    You got time last year if 4.4% growth rate for Just one quarter, But you are doing irrelevant episodes when Quarterly Growth was A Phenomenal 8.4%, 3 New Large Semiconductor Plants in Gujarat and Assam with $ 15 Billion Dollars in Investments, Sandeshkhali etc

  • @wisdomhighschool9975

    @wisdomhighschool9975

    3 ай бұрын

    You got time last year if 4.4% growth rate for Just one quarter, But you are doing irrelevant episodes when Quarterly Growth was A Phenomenal 8.4%, 3 New Large Semiconductor Plants in Gujarat and Assam with $ 15 Billion Dollars in Investments, Sandeshkhali etc

  • @anilkumar-xq4iz

    @anilkumar-xq4iz

    3 ай бұрын

    Dear Mr shekhar, in these kind of videos when you look at the camera to address us, it feels Sanya is neglected .....maybe the camera cus close up on you or you can just talk and listen to Sanya full episode...it's fine..for audience my sense. Meanwhile, always love to hear you and The Prints content. This one too.

  • @mountolympus1098
    @mountolympus10983 ай бұрын

    Muslims don't vote for muslim parties? Wrong wherever muslims are majority they vote for MUSLIM PARTIES. Example - Hyderabad, Secunderabad,Malegaon,Kishanganj - AIMIM. Malappuram - Muslim league. Assam - Ajmal. Kashmir - 3 families. Yes there are few seats in west UP, Mewat and middle Bengal where muslims don't vote for muslim parties - reason they don't have option there yet.

  • @Civic_cons7394

    @Civic_cons7394

    3 ай бұрын

    According to this man, owaisi ki ghar wapsi hogai.🤣🤣🤣 Lie for appeasement looks like this. People don't have options in UP,Bihar so they don't choose them but when they have they stick with partitioning thought holding parties.

  • @drsharma8644

    @drsharma8644

    3 ай бұрын

    They also votrd for pakistan

  • @kshitijmawal5098

    @kshitijmawal5098

    3 ай бұрын

    That few seats will also vote for chuslim leader only once they cross the demography of 50%

  • @vishalsontakke1651

    @vishalsontakke1651

    3 ай бұрын

    This started happening when BJP started polarization for majority votes

  • @Samasaya_Samadhaan

    @Samasaya_Samadhaan

    3 ай бұрын

    Bhai logo, what ever you are explaining he know it more then you. No need to correct him. Try to understand why he did this show? Very simple, he want to convey to Muslims plz vote BJP!! Because BJP want to capture some muslims vote...

  • @ravishingravi
    @ravishingravi3 ай бұрын

    Consolidation of Hindu votes = Communal. Consolidation of Muslim votes = Secular. Modi = Communal for SG. Owaisi = Secular / Friend for SG

  • @saif9765

    @saif9765

    3 ай бұрын

    Why Hindus consolidate behind bjp ?

  • @ChakraVart1

    @ChakraVart1

    3 ай бұрын

    @@saif9765because the congress abandoned them

  • @HeavenRacer422

    @HeavenRacer422

    3 ай бұрын

    ​​@@saif9765because congress and like parties are is|amist party. Indian secularism is is|amism.

  • @SrinivasRao-vd4ki

    @SrinivasRao-vd4ki

    3 ай бұрын

    ​​@@saif9765why muslims consolidating behind Congress nowadays ? Should Hindus not consolidate? .

  • @Artrader_em8ko

    @Artrader_em8ko

    3 ай бұрын

    @@mohibquadri4053Hindus vote for all parties. Congress can’t win any state with only Muslim or minority votes. There are many hindus voting for them n hence they manage to win some. Infact, more percentage of hindus vote for congress than the percentage of Muslims voting for BJP. Infact, Muslims world wide are a huge vote bank for left wing parties worldwide- democrats in US, Labou in UK n even in EU. The idea that hindua only vote for religious reasons is exaggerated as congress incompetence and corruption and obsession towards socialist policies are one of the main reasons to vote for BJP. Many Hindus also vote differently in state n central elections. How can we be communal in centre n secular in state? If the state congress or local parties have done better development then we are happy to vote for them. Congress needs to reflect on itself n its incompetence rather than blame their election failures on hindus alone.

  • @smitaj2209
    @smitaj22093 ай бұрын

    As a Brahmin, I object to the loose term ‘brahmanavad’ used for Ashraf Muslims. It’s demeaning both communities who will not relate to being identified with each other . And for this reason I will hold taking up a subscription

  • @HadddHarami

    @HadddHarami

    3 ай бұрын

    True that. Channels like The Print do not leave any opportunity to demean Hinduism at any point. Even when he is referring here to the casteism and discrimination among the muslim community he uses the term "Brahmanvaad" & not "Ashraaf-waad". Hindus have to understand how they subconsciously leave hints to create a divide among Hindus by trying to highlight the Varna based division among us. I am an OBC and have many Brahmin friends I never faced any discrimination. I hangout with them 24×7 and they are my friends for life.

  • @rahulhoysal7607

    @rahulhoysal7607

    3 ай бұрын

    True. These channels are the ones that create these fancy term. How long do these bigots want to keep bullying the brahmins. Nonsense of an episode.

  • @sarthakjoshi9824

    @sarthakjoshi9824

    3 ай бұрын

    Wallet strike

  • @hpatel788

    @hpatel788

    2 ай бұрын

    Saiyad vad

  • @Siddharth_Rao
    @Siddharth_Rao3 ай бұрын

    Shekhar is so hollow when he says thet Muslims trusted Hindu leaders, when these leaders so openly pandered to the whims of their vote bank. These 'Hindu' leaders were not only influenced by this vote bank on domestic issues (eg: Shah Bano, WAKF act) but also in our country's external affairs (How many PMs dared to visit Israel?)

  • @MrHumanforlife

    @MrHumanforlife

    3 ай бұрын

    It's called politics retard. That is the literal definition.

  • @pardeeptandon

    @pardeeptandon

    3 ай бұрын

    The Shah Bano case was a rare mistake made by the Congress.

  • @kshitijmawal5098

    @kshitijmawal5098

    3 ай бұрын

    Exactly , propoganda and manipulation from start to end. Golden rule and Universal Law to identity leftist. The person will always and always without exception try and will whitewash, downplay, rationalise, defend, and normalise EXTREME RAD!CAL ISL#M!STS.

  • @vedanshbharadwaj2576

    @vedanshbharadwaj2576

    3 ай бұрын

    @@pardeeptandon Is 1984 riots was also a rare mistake?

  • @mohibquadri4053

    @mohibquadri4053

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@vedanshbharadwaj2576 Manusmriti is a mistake which golwalkar and hedgewar gave to UC traitors who used it politically to mislead people since so many years.

  • @rohitrai6187
    @rohitrai61873 ай бұрын

    It is unfortunate that Shekhar totally ignores the sword conversions and jizya conversions and other forms of violent or coerced conversions

  • @ravishingravi

    @ravishingravi

    3 ай бұрын

    Its not unfortunate. Its deliberate.

  • @Vivek-tm6tp

    @Vivek-tm6tp

    3 ай бұрын

    👍✨ Excellent point ! ​@@ravishingravi

  • @SrinivasRao-vd4ki

    @SrinivasRao-vd4ki

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@ravishingraviyes. He is a cunning fox. He speaks sweetly like Prannoy James Roy erstwhile chief of NDTV

  • @pardeeptandon

    @pardeeptandon

    3 ай бұрын

    Jizya did not apply to Brahmins, Sadhus, Jain and Buddhist monks as they were considered men of religion.

  • @yellareddy

    @yellareddy

    3 ай бұрын

    That is false propaganda. @@pardeeptandon

  • @rupamverma1092
    @rupamverma10923 ай бұрын

    The angle of Forced Conversion of Hindus was conveniently ignored. This, in my opinion, makes the largest population of pasmandas.

  • @tellsparck

    @tellsparck

    3 ай бұрын

    Many (perhaps most) of them left voluntarily to escape the caste system. Why are you ignoring that?

  • @harshitsingh1600

    @harshitsingh1600

    3 ай бұрын

    Then why cry on Ghar wapsi when we are correcting those mistakes !!

  • @PS-to6gr

    @PS-to6gr

    3 ай бұрын

    @@tellsparck can u show us proof ? Above all we are reforming our society unlike others

  • @lovekanaujia345

    @lovekanaujia345

    3 ай бұрын

    Exactly, Checkar Gupta is Islamic slave who would never talk about reality of Islam.

  • @crimsoncrysolite5056

    @crimsoncrysolite5056

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@tellsparckWe can make sure Muslims convert back to Hinduism or Jainism to escape Misogyny and shia sunni conflict

  • @pranovgoutam
    @pranovgoutam3 ай бұрын

    Yet another propaganda episode by SG and I must say he does the job with finesse. There are three things he's trying to achieve with this.... 1. Create a rift between Hindu population by refering Ramvilas Paswan that Upper Caste didn't allowed lower cast to enter shrines hence they chose to become Pasmanda Muslims. 2. Creating a confusion among hardcore Hindutva voters that gradually Congress-isation of BJP is taking place with their outreach to pasmanda muslims. So that they should start looking for other options of BJP. 3. Giving the glimpse to Pasmanda's that they must stay united and vote in bunch. And refrain from voting Asad Owaisi and go for mainstream opposition which gives them the best chance to keep BJP away from power.

  • @rajp6339

    @rajp6339

    3 ай бұрын

    perfect breakup on SG's fake narrative.

  • @AA13494

    @AA13494

    3 ай бұрын

    No2 is correct. hez outreach is worrying. muslim empowerment is going to harm hindus in the long run dnt expect them to be grateful. on the contrary it is causing more conversion of hindus to muslim to avail all the benefits they openly say hum free me schemes bhi lenge, par vote nahi denge.

  • @ashwanisrivastava8948

    @ashwanisrivastava8948

    3 ай бұрын

    What a hollow and random discussion with little relevance to the topic mentioned

  • @MrDragoo1

    @MrDragoo1

    3 ай бұрын

    But what Paswan said is true...upper caste hindus didn't allow hindus from SC/ST inside temples..

  • @AA13494

    @AA13494

    3 ай бұрын

    @@MrDragoo1 to kya convert ho jaoge?? Woh bhi bina padhe bina jane ki quran me likha kya hai. Sex slavery, pedophilia, hate towards kaafirs, etc is worst than temple entry being denied if at all that is true

  • @mady5647
    @mady56473 ай бұрын

    This choice of voting Hindu-candidates did not extend to regions of Kashmir, Hyderabad.... It was about choosing an appeaser who can win and not development.

  • @anuragdas9400

    @anuragdas9400

    3 ай бұрын

    and the sky is blue

  • @FreddieMurphy746

    @FreddieMurphy746

    3 ай бұрын

    Hyderabad is not muslim majority. Actually, the Hindus don't vote in bulk in Hyderabad whereas Muslims vote completely one sided. Check the demographics...

  • @saif9765

    @saif9765

    3 ай бұрын

    Please explain, what is appeasement ? Jobs employment education scholarship reservation......if employment means this, then I think all parties have appeased hindus only......

  • @rka-truthalwayswins5127

    @rka-truthalwayswins5127

    3 ай бұрын

    What's the point of giving voting rights to a community that doesn't believe in democracy and votes as brainwashed zombie sheep??!!

  • @rakeshksahu

    @rakeshksahu

    3 ай бұрын

    @@saif9765 Are muslims excluded from this(Jobs employment education scholarship reservation).?

  • @Siddharth_Rao
    @Siddharth_Rao3 ай бұрын

    The two hosts agree that the only reason for lower caste Hindus to convert was, the hate they received by fellow Hindus but somehow conveniently fail say a word on forced conversions, anti Hindu pogroms (eg: Razakars), destruction/desecration of thousands of Devalayas. On an unrelated point, what is disinformation?

  • @AsifAhmed-bf5hg

    @AsifAhmed-bf5hg

    3 ай бұрын

    Nahi bolenge toh Paisa kon dega

  • @anshuraj4277

    @anshuraj4277

    3 ай бұрын

    Most conversion was voluntary

  • @Goofyderclown

    @Goofyderclown

    2 ай бұрын

    Yes, and unicorns are real too. Right? 😜 ​@@anshuraj4277

  • @sankalp6872
    @sankalp68723 ай бұрын

    Asma Begum would have been a good fit for this discussion. Her views would have carried more weight. BJP is a farsighted party. Islam needs reforms. Even Saudi Arabia is now embracing modernity. Islam cannot escape modernity and the BJP knows this. Diminishing casteism is already helping the BJP consolidate the Hindu vote. Rahul Gandhi's caste card and Adani card politics has no relevance to Modern India. Incompetence of Rahul Gandhi is a THREAT to Indian DEMOCRACY.

  • @rka-truthalwayswins5127

    @rka-truthalwayswins5127

    3 ай бұрын

    BS!! Congress led INDI alliance parties are Anti Hindu & Anti national crooks; NOT just incompetent!! What's the point of an opposition that works against the people & the nation??!!

  • @abhay_cs

    @abhay_cs

    3 ай бұрын

    Well put. Asama Begum is a delight to listen to.

  • @SafavidAfsharid3197

    @SafavidAfsharid3197

    3 ай бұрын

    Read about the Mu'tazila section of islam.

  • @puneetmishra4726

    @puneetmishra4726

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@SafavidAfsharid3197 what about it? It's dead for 1000 years

  • @varunkhugshal9049

    @varunkhugshal9049

    3 ай бұрын

    Izlam can not be reformed , its the word of Allah, when it says clearly you can strike your woman, that means you can, or when it says you can only have sex with either your wives or slaves, that means you can.. so you kaffir have no right to suggest reform, you'll be seen on the day when 9:29 can be applied with strength

  • @someguy2707
    @someguy27073 ай бұрын

    Brahman hate is so strong that Ashraf scale is explained on Brahman scale. Brahman hate must not die.

  • @maniaphobia4719

    @maniaphobia4719

    3 ай бұрын

    Why hate Brahmins ??? Can anyone today live a life of a Brahmin ?? Wake up at 4 AM , take bath , pray for the sake of the world , go out and beg for alms , read the scriptures, evening preach the same ; No saving for tomorrow even ; Thats what as per scriptures ; No wonder unenviable , tapsvi life and if they succumb to other pleasures it is quite natural in this totally corrupt and bad society ; Today a true Brahmin should wake up in the morning and curse the society for being toxic and nasty ; Thats the natural reaction for Brahmin hate !!!!

  • @ninjagamings4997

    @ninjagamings4997

    2 ай бұрын

    Cry chamar

  • @ajithreddy1987
    @ajithreddy19873 ай бұрын

    Shekar is losing it . We viewers/voters r now a days too smart to clearly understand ur intentions 😌

  • @samodhmadhavan

    @samodhmadhavan

    2 ай бұрын

    These articles are for understanding stuff... And apparently not for you

  • @arvind50

    @arvind50

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@samodhmadhavan He understands and therefore he knows. Do you understand?

  • @garygeorge-wi7co

    @garygeorge-wi7co

    2 ай бұрын

    SG is upset he is missing his regular bottles he used to get under the Congis. No wonder he is desperate to get pappu back.

  • @firstsparkle5378
    @firstsparkle53783 ай бұрын

    Even today, it rarely happens that a lower caste person charges its religion voluntarily,because Dalits doesn't agree with your alalysis that they have "rented identity",which can be vacated with some ups & downs... All the Prominent Dalit Politicians after Independence identified themselves as Hindus because they know that their core constituency identify themselves as Hindus.... Increase in Islamic population in India was the product of forceful conversion & Gunda tax called " Jiziya", imposed on non Muslims for doing kufr...... Islamic Invasion of India was the bloodiest chapter of human history, & i can understand why Print can't talk about it

  • @seshanm54
    @seshanm543 ай бұрын

    It is not 'RSS believes' it is a fact...the Ashraf are not all Brahmins practicing Brahminvaad as this lady says...the Ashraf are those claiming Arbi, Irani or Turkic blood.

  • @Pandit_Reviews_Everything

    @Pandit_Reviews_Everything

    3 ай бұрын

    Exactly and what is Brahamanvad. Comparing two things which are irrelevant and has no sense at all. @theprint, I would request you to use correct words in the journalism you publish. This is total rubbish

  • @puneetmishra4726

    @puneetmishra4726

    3 ай бұрын

    She said "brahmin" as an analogy so that Hindus could understand. Obviously they are not Brahmins.

  • @kicksomeup6998

    @kicksomeup6998

    2 ай бұрын

    @@puneetmishra4726 They are using it as an epithet and a moniker. The next time an RSS crowd attacks Muslims, should I call it an Islamic attack, because that is what also happens in some Muslim countries to religious minorities? People need to be held accountable for their discourse.

  • @orunabho
    @orunabho3 ай бұрын

    There is a racial angle to the Ashraf and the "others" All pale skinned Afghan and Turki lineage thinks they are racially superiors. All backward Muslims are invariably darker in complexion. They don't marry amongst themselves for racial reasons. Islam or otherwise. Note that there are dark skinned Brahmins in India - Brahmins traditionally being the priestly class acroas societies - not a race or ethnicity. For example the compiler of Veda was a Dark skinned person. As are moat important deities in India - be it Shiva or Vishnu or Krishna or Rama or Kali. So when discussing Islam and its problems, why bring in Brahmins. Looks like an easy punching bag for most colonized minds.

  • @randmht9976

    @randmht9976

    2 ай бұрын

    Shivji is not dark my friend. He is white as a camphor.

  • @nishantshrivastava9674
    @nishantshrivastava96743 ай бұрын

    Aaj hmre beloved abdol ne mohabbat ki dukan kholi h Karnataka k rameshwaram cafe me🤗🤗🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼 Perhaps people have forgotten love bites our beloved abdol used to give in mumbai local trains, hyderabad, delhi akshardham. Too much peaceful 🤗🤗🤗🤲🏼🤲🏼

  • @yj9032

    @yj9032

    3 ай бұрын

    Google murder of graham staines

  • @wrathofhade

    @wrathofhade

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@yj9032It is equivalent to what sentinelese killing of Johan Allen Chau, Missionaries deliberately go to the remotest parts of the country and try to insidiously convert the indigenous population, so times people convert and sometimes this kind of things happen. So my message is to keep the message to yourself and leave the people alone.

  • @boulevard7863

    @boulevard7863

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@yj9032google gauri dey. You'll know what happened to her at the hands of missionaries in meghalaya.

  • @FreddieMurphy746
    @FreddieMurphy7463 ай бұрын

    Ruhollah Khomeini the first supreme leader of Iran stayed in Lucknow. Fun fact: Even Tipu Sultan's proposal of marrying his daughter in Nizam of Hyderabad's family was rejected by the Nizam because Tipu's father Hyder Ali was an Ajlaf

  • @ChinmayKarlekar
    @ChinmayKarlekar3 ай бұрын

    Your video started with misleading information. If Muslims considered Gandhi and Nehru as their leaders, who fought for Pakistan and divided India on religious ground?

  • @sandeepsapkal4472

    @sandeepsapkal4472

    3 ай бұрын

    The ones who went on the other side

  • @elborrador333

    @elborrador333

    3 ай бұрын

    @@sandeepsapkal4472 The 97% of muslims who voted for pakistan went to pakistan yes?

  • @manjulashanmugasundaram706

    @manjulashanmugasundaram706

    3 ай бұрын

    Jinnah and his ally Hindu Mahasabha

  • @jaydev7155

    @jaydev7155

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@manjulashanmugasundaram706ok Jinha and Hindu mahasabha alliance But why fucking Nehru created only Islamic Pakistan but not Hindu rastra?

  • @PanakaluPoonakam

    @PanakaluPoonakam

    3 ай бұрын

    @@elborrador333That's correct. Elections in 1946 most of them voted for partition. But they decided to stay back.

  • @therandomthings6933
    @therandomthings69333 ай бұрын

    Shekar chooses smart words for his favorites. When congress party /RJD takes(buys) other party MLAs its defecting, when BJP does its poaching/operation lotus…woh 😅

  • @Ninjashank

    @Ninjashank

    3 ай бұрын

    That Padma bushan should count to something , no ? 😂😂😂

  • @pendsenarendra
    @pendsenarendra3 ай бұрын

    This interview spreads false information about muslim politics. In fact muslims vote for someone who is likely to defeat hindu party.

  • @kshitijmawal5098

    @kshitijmawal5098

    3 ай бұрын

    Yes, 👍

  • @ashishb
    @ashishb3 ай бұрын

    Consolidation of Hindu votes = Communal. Consolidation of Muslim votes = Secular

  • @harmandeepsingh7662

    @harmandeepsingh7662

    3 ай бұрын

    Its the way you do it

  • @raxeev

    @raxeev

    3 ай бұрын

    The interpretation of so called intellectuals like SG

  • @FreddieMurphy746
    @FreddieMurphy7463 ай бұрын

    And call Ashrafs as Syeds not Bhramanwad. Syeds are considered superior in Pakistan as well. Even during Turkic & Mughal rule the clergy were of Arabic or Turkic origin

  • @gustakh1050
    @gustakh10503 ай бұрын

    Muslims did not choose Hindu as their leader. They ensured that in grab of secularism their interest is protected there by becoming left's and secularist vote bank or catchment areas. 😂😂

  • @mady5647
    @mady56473 ай бұрын

    Madam said violence within community caused lower-castes' conversion. Does same apply to upper-castes of Kashmir, Punjab, Sindh converting to Islam? Read about Kashmir's 7th Sultan known as Butshikan (idols-breaker). Why natives of Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan i.e Parsis, Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains took refuge in India? And what is the % of non-Muslims now in these countries?

  • @HeavenRacer422
    @HeavenRacer4223 ай бұрын

    In 1946 elections when Azad(an is|amist) was leader of congress. Mus|ims voted for more is|amist Jinnah just to get Pakistan. While hindus voted for congress under is|amist's leadership in the name of secularism. 96% mus|ims voted for is|amist parties. Even after partition they allowed them to live them in India. What we get in return? That's enough

  • @maniaphobia4719

    @maniaphobia4719

    3 ай бұрын

    U r right ; Hindus in India are magnanimous and allowed India to remain secular even after one third land is seperated and given as per their wishes ; Thats more than enough ; If any complaints here , they are free to go

  • @chanakyabharat756
    @chanakyabharat7563 ай бұрын

    Shekar acting naive on why Indian Muslims dont vote for fellow Muslim leaders, its because they know they will not win anyhow and naive journalistscan show that to split Hindu votes.

  • @Hanamantaray
    @Hanamantaray3 ай бұрын

    BJP did more welfare to Muslims in every centrally sponsored scheme with 100% ground delivery ,even Muslims accept this hard truth,but they will vote whichever party is best fitted to defeat BJP in each seat. Eg.Muslims will vote for UBT shivsena/NCP/CONG to defeat BJP. Other than BJP owaisi worked for welfare of Muslim but Muslim votes owaisi not BJP. Regional parties and Congress took Muslim votes as granted 15% vote bank.

  • @govindss27

    @govindss27

    3 ай бұрын

    There is something more fundamental that BJP doesn’t offer, that is dignity to Muslims. That’s why they would vote for anyone else but BJP

  • @Doomsday_-ct5kj

    @Doomsday_-ct5kj

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@govindss27 why give Dignity to a single community and make them feel special. We are all special. No need for appeasement . I think people who wanted to feel special went to Pakistan and Bangladesh

  • @govindss27

    @govindss27

    3 ай бұрын

    @@Doomsday_-ct5kj giving dignity does not mean treating someone specially, rather it means not treating someone with unrestrained contempt

  • @Doomsday_-ct5kj

    @Doomsday_-ct5kj

    3 ай бұрын

    @@govindss27 I don't think given the history and the kinds of beliefs this particular community holds is enough to not look at them with 'unrestrained contempt'.

  • @hj2711

    @hj2711

    3 ай бұрын

    @@govindss27that’s what congress wants you to believe.

  • @mountolympus1098
    @mountolympus10983 ай бұрын

    Shia card will work but pasmanda can't. Why? Pasmanda are like obc of Muslims. You might think they are little backward in comparison etc but they are core of their respective religion.

  • @ppatel75

    @ppatel75

    3 ай бұрын

    Exactly, Muslims needs to divide in terms of their sects instead of Pasmanda and ashraf.

  • @bittertruth8374
    @bittertruth83743 ай бұрын

    When was Kashmiris muslims trusted Hindu leaders?

  • @subodhjain6440
    @subodhjain64403 ай бұрын

    Pasmanda needs to re-converted and welcomed back to Hindu fold. BJP needs to be careful as outreach to Muslim should be taken in context in bringing them to Hindu fold. If this is an appeasement it going to fail miserably and damages Hindu vote. Remember how well in fatwa for shahi imam for Bajpai in 2004 turned out to be.

  • @pamtam1

    @pamtam1

    2 ай бұрын

    😂😂🤣🤣

  • @pamtam1

    @pamtam1

    2 ай бұрын

    Why not reconvert theDalits/OBCs/SC/ST/Shudras etc to Brahmins as a ghar wapsi and welcome them to the Brahmin, upper caste fold??😂😂

  • @pamtam1

    @pamtam1

    2 ай бұрын

    Will you reconvert the Pasmanda Muslims to Dalit/OBCs/SC/ST castes??😂

  • @abhishekdesai965
    @abhishekdesai9653 ай бұрын

    There was a chance that shias might have voted to the bjp. Historically bjp has gotten 9-11% muslim votes that's close enough to 15% of 15%. But outreach towards pasmandas will not work and in long run may backfire towards its Hindu vote bank. That's because even though being pasmanda, they choose to identify as sunni and feel entitled then to bdentify oneself as pasmanda and feel discriminated. That's because the fatwa system to outcast any dissident voice against the maulvi driven Muslim society. Maulvis have got a lot to say in daily affairs of their religion and being predominantly patriarchal society, women of the community prefer to go by t opinion of their men's opinion largely. Also stand of bjp on issue of caa, ucc population control bill, Kashi vishwanath and mathura Krishna mandir. The Muslim community is never ever going to vote for bjp. No matter the access given to them to govt resources by the bjp government . This will eventually lead up to sophisticated and soft hindutva votes away.

  • @nikhilrodye8226

    @nikhilrodye8226

    3 ай бұрын

    You can’t move forward as a nation if BJP doesn’t engage the 15% of population.

  • @insiderich7372

    @insiderich7372

    3 ай бұрын

    Brother, 15% of 15% is 2.25% of total...so how is that equating to "thus BJP gettjng 9-11%"?

  • @PanakaluPoonakam

    @PanakaluPoonakam

    3 ай бұрын

    Also there is a sizable number of Muslim women vote for BJP. They want equal inheritance rights like non mulims have, legislation against practices like Halala etc.

  • @sitarampradhan8488

    @sitarampradhan8488

    3 ай бұрын

    Only handful no of siha muslims vote BJP. Sunnis never vote BJP. Period

  • @pamtam1

    @pamtam1

    2 ай бұрын

    @@PanakaluPoonakamApparently the non Muslim women wants the same legal rights as the Muslim women of right to home, right to be cared for monetarily, right to food, clothing and general living conditions of at least the same class as they had been living before under the parent/father. And this right is undeniable until death immaterial of her (the Muslim women’s) own wealth and the amount of money that the woman earns. By the way the Muslim women have legal rights to own their own wealth and property rights as well as to their incomes even if the Muslim women earn multiple times higher than their husband or father or sons earn.

  • @wisdomhighschool9975
    @wisdomhighschool99753 ай бұрын

    You got time last year if 4.4% growth rate for Just one quarter, But you are doing irrelevant episodes when Quarterly Growth was A Phenomenal 8.4%, 3 New Large Semiconductor Plants in Gujarat and Assam with $ 15 Billion Dollars in Investments, Sandeshkhali etc

  • @pardeeptandon

    @pardeeptandon

    3 ай бұрын

    During the ten-year tenure of Manmohan Singh, our GDP increased by 2.73 times and GDP per capita by 2.5 times. In contrast, Modani achieved only a 1.67-fold growth in both aspects. It is important not to be swayed by selectively presented growth figures that the BJP has highlighted before the elections. In 2004, net FDI inflow was 0.7% of our GDP. By 2014, it had risen to 1.7% of our GDP, but under Modani's leadership, it has declined to 1.47% despite the global shift towards the China Plus One policy. What about over 200 Churches burnt in Manipur and Christian women paraded naked?

  • @hj2711

    @hj2711

    3 ай бұрын

    ⁠​⁠​⁠@@pardeeptandonwrong upa 1 was good but upa 2 was disaster, inflation was more then 10%, even on Covid years it wasn’t more then 8%. In 2013 India was considered fragile 5 economy due to mismanagement, in 2007 they passed the stupidest law on banking sector which increased the npa through the roof. If you removed covid years modi growth rate was similar to upa but with lower inflation. So after 10 years India is not fragile economy that was the case of upa 2. That’s what happens when you don’t know economics. Speaking of Manipur you never talked about Hindus that were killed. Why are you discriminating against Hindu? Manipur happened due to Myanmar kukki community opposed supreme court orders. Learn about the conflict first.

  • @wisdomhighschool9975

    @wisdomhighschool9975

    3 ай бұрын

    ​​@@pardeeptandonGDP grew by 2.2 In Modi Era from $ 1.7 Trillion to $ 3.73 Trillion in 2024 asper IMF, During UPA Years, Global Growth was 5%, China's Growth was 13%,China used Global Growth to Power it's Manufacturing,Where as Corrupt UPA was only focussing on IT in South, Leaky Scam Subsidies for most of Poor, Growth was ONLY 6.7%, Whereas Global Growth during Modi Era was only 2%, China's also Reduced to 5-6%,Where As India's Growth us 6%, That means despite Global Slowdown which will impact FDI ans Trade, India's Growth has been Phenomenal, What about 100s of Temples destroyed in Manipur, Inflation during UPA was 9%,During Modi was ONLY 5%, Despite all the Challenges, India's STARTUPs have exploded from 500 to 1.1 LAKH+ in 2024, Unicorns from 5 to 115+, Billionaires from 80 to 200+, Poverty came down from 29% to 11%, Stock Markets boomed from 1 Trillion in 2014 to $ 4 Trillion in 2023

  • @wisdomhighschool9975

    @wisdomhighschool9975

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@@pardeeptandonGDP grew by 2.2 In Modi Era from $ 1.7 Trillion to $ 3.73 Trillion in 2024 asper IMF, During UPA Years, Global Growth was 5%, China's Growth was 13%,China used Global Growth to Power it's Manufacturing,Where as Corrupt UPA was only focussing on IT in South, Leaky Scam Subsidies for most of Poor, Growth was ONLY 6.7%, Whereas Global Growth during Modi Era was only 2%, China's also Reduced to 5-6%,Where As India's Growth us 6%, That means despite Global Slowdown which will impact FDI ans Trade, India's Growth has been Phenomenal, What about 100s of Temples destroyed in Manipur, Inflation during UPA was 9%,During Modi was ONLY 5%, Despite all the Challenges, India's STARTUPs have exploded from 500 to 1.1 LAKH+ in 2024, Unicorns from 5 to 115+, Billionaires from 80 to 200+, Poverty came down from 29% to 11%, Stock Markets boomed from 1 Trillion in 2014 to $ 4 Trillion in 2023

  • @rakadus
    @rakadus3 ай бұрын

    8:15 The spin here is more than Ashwin's off spin!

  • @samirang21
    @samirang213 ай бұрын

    It's important to recognize that Sekhar Gupta, originally a Left Liberal, is now striving to adopt a more centrist stance, possibly for personal reasons or to appeal to a broader audience for his channel. While having a political leaning is natural, transparent acknowledgment of biases can enhance understanding. But it does not happen that way and right-leaning parties like the BJP are often labeled as "Opportunists" for their actions, while left-leaning parties may not face the same scrutiny with “leveraging the situation”. This observation underscores the presence of bias in political discourse. It is also for the reason he slammed “Emergency” time and gain but at the same time unable to purge “secularism” that was introduced by the unconstitutional govt of Indira Gandhi. He (like many Left-leaning old Congressi) takes “Indian Secularism” on its face value knowing fully well that we are far away from the original definition of Secularism. Indian constitution as it exists treats people differently based on their religion on multiple fronts, which is a complete farce in the name of secularism. It is also for the same reason that he tries hard to differentiate between "political Islam" and "Islam" repeatedly. It's challenging for him to acknowledge that religious identity plays a significant role in this cluster, including influencing their thoughts and voting preferences largely. With a leftist background, it's challenging for Sekhar (and those similar to him) to refrain from succumbing to the Majoritarian myth and seek solace in Islam, creating an illusion to reassure (themselves) that the myth is indeed correct. What Sekhar fails to acknowledge is that cluster voting solely based on "identity" poses a significant and enduring threat to any democracy, and this particular religious cluster continues to perpetuate this trend. Therefore, rather than focusing on whether the BJP receives any Muslim votes or not, he must analyze why Muslims, comprising a significant majority, prioritize identity over other considerations when casting their votes for a party.

  • @seshanm54

    @seshanm54

    3 ай бұрын

    YOU SAID IT!

  • @randmht9976

    @randmht9976

    2 ай бұрын

    Very well said. But sometimes I wonder if it's just them being leftist or there is a sinister agenda in thier minds to bend the truth so crudely .

  • @ajeysangai521
    @ajeysangai5213 ай бұрын

    Brahamanwad? It betrays a complete lack of understanding of the cultural history of Islam in the sub-continent, besides a disregard for the real, specific and distinct issues of the backward classes among Muslims compared to those of the Dalits. There was a reason that Dr. Ambedkar made a distinction between the Dalit experience and racism. It also misses the intersectional criticism of Marxism that solidifies the oppressed and oppressor category (but even Marxism, refrains from identity monikers). By the way, Columbia University has an Ambedkar chair on constitutional law, a good history department, and an excellent library, before anyone thinks of disparaging the institution.

  • @firstrayofsun2905
    @firstrayofsun29053 ай бұрын

    Even Brahmins were converted to islam..untouchability was not the major issue…but the Talwar was

  • @premprasad3511
    @premprasad35112 ай бұрын

    What a false narrative by SG WHEN HE SAYS Muslims have only trusted Hindu leaders like Indira Gandhi, Lalu Yadav, etc !! What about Kashmir and mulsim majority areas in other parts ? Why didn't people who asked for Pakistan did not support Hindu leaders ? 7 decades after formation of Pakistan there are hardly any Hindus there ? Why ?

  • @HeavenRacer422
    @HeavenRacer4223 ай бұрын

    Mus|ims won't vote for BJP. Why do you think BJP wants to reach mus|ims? This is just an showoff. Like mus|ims do the showoff of ganga jamuni tehjib everywhere until they become majority

  • @SrinivasRao-vd4ki

    @SrinivasRao-vd4ki

    3 ай бұрын

    So true.

  • @sandeepakgupta
    @sandeepakgupta3 ай бұрын

    So why did upper caste hindus convert? Or why didnt rest of what we call SC ST of today didnt convert.....this guy and his entire team is full of crap

  • @samarthkulkarni5069
    @samarthkulkarni50693 ай бұрын

    They jave alredy choose Jinnha...whne it matters

  • @jamesgoveas3164
    @jamesgoveas31643 ай бұрын

    Dear SG, would like to request you to put together a episode on Christian castism. When I was getting married in 2002, it was a love marriage with a Catholic girl and my parents wanted to know the caste of my wifes parents. We were supposedly Brahmins amongst Catholics and they were insistent to know the caste of my wifes parents. I also learned that all my elder siblings were married to their partners after the caste was affirmed. Of course my marriage went through even though my wife's Dad was not from the same caste. Please do make some time🙏🏻 Thanks in advance

  • @donbon9770
    @donbon97703 ай бұрын

    Muslims are not MINORITY. They are second largest community in India. Sekhar Gupta, should not mislead Indians.

  • @chethan2311
    @chethan23113 ай бұрын

    Shekar Gupta have some shame while doing baised journelism.

  • @VenkateshmurthyVK
    @VenkateshmurthyVK3 ай бұрын

    In India Islam was spread by sword. Poor Hindus were subejeted to untold misery and forced to accept Islam. Pl. don't say wrong Hindu practices are responsible for spread of Islam.

  • @rakeshrathore1711
    @rakeshrathore17113 ай бұрын

    Aligarh muslim University was and is in fore front in views against India.

  • @user-in5vb4cr5d
    @user-in5vb4cr5d3 ай бұрын

    Irrespective of what people say, Congress has successfully castigated BJP as anti-Minority party & unfortunately they are falling prey to such politics.

  • @vilasksh
    @vilasksh3 ай бұрын

    There was a kid in the class who was well dressed, could speak fluent English, sit on the first bench and do all sundry work of the class teacher who was English speaking, high standard(so called). So used to get good marks in exams as he was favourite, so he used brag as topper / intelligent. In 2014, class teacher changed… rural man came with a whip. He examined this topper guys answer sheets and obvious truth came forefront. Suddenly kid become a general student… so difficult for him to digest. Since then he tries to prove that he is intelligent by all means. What do you think he should? Continue trying to prove that he is intelligent and it’s class teacher to be blamed OR accept that he is as general as rest of others??! This advise may help many people.

  • @AVK-gg9dd

    @AVK-gg9dd

    2 ай бұрын

    Very True, applicable for SG.

  • @orunabho
    @orunabho3 ай бұрын

    Even after 75 years since partition of this country in the name of Islam, the mainland is still obsessed with followers of Islam all the time. Sometimes it feels Indian media is the most casteist and most communal set of institutions in India. Nothing else to do, but the low hanging fruits and keep talking about it ad nauseam. So a US degree in political science or Journalism - the name cow belt obsession and intellectual focus.

  • @AA13494

    @AA13494

    3 ай бұрын

    Modi made the derogatory cow belt-- cool again. ppl are proudly owning it.

  • @hj2711

    @hj2711

    3 ай бұрын

    @@AA13494this is coming from gujarat, we want cow belt to become richest place in whole country, that’s when cow belt will become cool.

  • @AA13494

    @AA13494

    3 ай бұрын

    IT will atleast MP, UP are moving in a positive direction They have been backward bcz of high population and caste politics. bihar is a lost cause.@@hj2711

  • @user-qb6pp4cj7p

    @user-qb6pp4cj7p

    2 ай бұрын

    Exactly. Sometimes I feel India is all about muslims, non-muslims are here only to eat chana and appease muslims. 47 me bhi nonmuslims were mere spectators only. First, muslims wanted a separate nation, then they were given a choice to stay or to go. I mean what about the non-Muslims of current Pak and Bangladesh.

  • @saliljoshi6465

    @saliljoshi6465

    2 ай бұрын

    So true..well said!

  • @HeavenRacer422
    @HeavenRacer4223 ай бұрын

    Mus|ims don't vote for mus|im parties? They got more is|amist things from congress than any mus|im can give them. Like waqf board, shariya act, article 370. What they need? Congress's secularism is equal to is|amism. Both are same.

  • @Ravi-ot6xj
    @Ravi-ot6xj3 ай бұрын

    There are no division in islam as long as they are fighting 'Kafirs'. Dont forget that Muhammad ali Jinnah was a shia.

  • @user-tg9yh3xg6g
    @user-tg9yh3xg6g3 ай бұрын

    Shitaan stuff 😂😅 Well done Shekhar! I'm sure Elsworth Toohey's spirit will be glowing today. You interest me due to the sheer cunning of the scheme.

  • @Dk2-vs7hh

    @Dk2-vs7hh

    3 ай бұрын

    Shekar is reincarnation of elsworth tohey!!

  • @Amit-rb5pv
    @Amit-rb5pv3 ай бұрын

    Shekhar ji your interruptions are Very Very Irritating. Please let her Speak 🙏

  • @jagdeepsinghtuli5134
    @jagdeepsinghtuli51343 ай бұрын

    Shekhar you have your own show. why are you interrupting her . do your own show and let her do hers

  • @rakadus

    @rakadus

    3 ай бұрын

    He is worried about "Sar Tan Se Juda" that a Columbia educated girl might not be cognizant of. Just doing his job as a protective CEO.

  • @jagdeepsinghtuli5134

    @jagdeepsinghtuli5134

    3 ай бұрын

    That's an exxageration

  • @ajaykpaul
    @ajaykpaul3 ай бұрын

    Modi should start reaching out to ex-muslims moving forward.

  • @nabadutta6572
    @nabadutta65723 ай бұрын

    I feel so sorry for the young girl who went to the US to study political science and as expected like all US university returnees she is doing what is expected !

  • @seshanm54

    @seshanm54

    3 ай бұрын

    All return leftist Wokes with an outsiders view of Indian history. Am sure it will not occur to her to consult Dr. Faiyaz Ahmad Fyzie...You see, he is a Pasmanda Muslim

  • @esgokhale30
    @esgokhale303 ай бұрын

    Print hit a new law by calling Ashrafs “Brahmins” of Islam. Brahmins are not clergy in Hinduism, don’t equate Brahmins to Pope/Khalifa, read some history instead.

  • @TheSmithv2
    @TheSmithv23 ай бұрын

    It's Incredible how biased this piece is. The whole narrative is about why various sects is Muslims are 'disillusioned' with Modi. There's no emphasis on the fact that the clergy are losing credibility because the small group of clergy and ashrafs have kept the entire Indian Muslim community backwards.

  • @AseemKumar9
    @AseemKumar93 ай бұрын

    "full brahmanwad" at 9:51 : the disdain of the print towards brahmins matches that of communists

  • @FreddieMurphy746

    @FreddieMurphy746

    3 ай бұрын

    She could have used the term Syedwaad Or Ashrafwad term

  • @surjitkumar8877
    @surjitkumar88773 ай бұрын

    You forgot Mr Jinna to whom Indian Muslims choose as leader and it was chosen by Indian Muslims not Pakistani muslim

  • @nissarguru-xg1wx
    @nissarguru-xg1wx3 ай бұрын

    Pasmandas Conversion happened to Islam due to Jazziya. Already poor they cud not afford to keep paying. Conversion was to escape this regular payment.

  • @nitinsingh-vn7is
    @nitinsingh-vn7is3 ай бұрын

    Shekhar let her speak 😂

  • @saradhiroy
    @saradhiroy3 ай бұрын

    Hey Sania what about Ghazwa I Hindi Fatwa recently issued from Deoband? Dare to cover?

  • @shinchannauhara9145
    @shinchannauhara91453 ай бұрын

    it is good that Hindus are moving beyond their caste politics...till yesterday u people blame caste thing now hindus calling hindu themself (at least in politics) are problematics??? u should thanks BJP and Modi ji that now Hindus thinking beyond caste (in case of Politics)...

  • @adeshmukhb
    @adeshmukhb3 ай бұрын

    A discussion based on wrong premise is either a deliberate propaganda or, at worst, a misleading understanding of the current socio-political scene. So much for Columbia Uni return brown sepoy..!!!😃

  • @seshanm54
    @seshanm543 ай бұрын

    Women were not at the forefront of the Shaheen Baug protest..they were the advance party to the rioters who followed.

  • @Civic_cons7394
    @Civic_cons73943 ай бұрын

    Not minority. 15 percent isnt a minority. Maybe 1 or 2 percent Sikhs,christains are for sure minority.

  • @panimeda245
    @panimeda2453 ай бұрын

    Now we have oxgord uni graduate to teach the indian people. Well done, Shekharji.

  • @34kaushik
    @34kaushik2 ай бұрын

    Lets get one thing clear, the Hindus didnt convert only due to the discrimination faced. It was the fear of the damn sword of the Mughals.

  • @Aao_Baat_Krenge
    @Aao_Baat_Krenge3 ай бұрын

    muslims have to acknowledge that there are certain issues within their community which has antagonise the majority, they want a secular state but not secularism We do not see any intellectual muslims or reforming politician or icon rising from within the muslim community and asking for reforms within they have to ask a pertinent question that why over the course of years other minorities rise but their economic and political status declining Reforms reform yourself and become a intellectual and economic power till when muslim community relies on their number only which is fact that Hindus will remain a more in number Whereas I want to warn our hindu majority friends and colleagues we are relevant today as we reformed ourself leaved our unnecessary rituals and misogynist things within gave more importance to our real philosophy the philosophy of vedanta and Bhagavad geeta, ask any hindu today they have just a false pride if you counter them they cannot name even basic hindu texts and philosopher what they have are stories and folklore To be frank its not needed to write so much as with current our consumption level and environment degradation global warming this earth will not be a liveable place. When this earth will not remain a livable place what you will do with this petty fights If we really wants to fight, fight the real issues like climate change and wildlife destruction

  • @AA13494

    @AA13494

    3 ай бұрын

    muslims dnt care about wild life, environment or the climate. As per islam everything is created by allah for humanity and killing it is allah's wish and not haram. look at the way they do halal of goats, cows, chickens. they love animal cruelty. why wud they care about some wild animal. they will destroy it.

  • @seshanm54
    @seshanm543 ай бұрын

    Sanya Dhingra appears to think that all Ashrafs are converted Brahmins This is to convert the Ashraf exclusivity and oppression of converted Hindus, into a casteist thing. Actually, the majority Ashraf claim foreign descent and are actual RACIST, not casteist.

  • @sujeet1afmc
    @sujeet1afmc3 ай бұрын

    How come lower cast Valmikis are not being converted in Pakistan, they got converted in Christianity and still those cast are only supposed to do sanitary works….how come gates weren’t opened

  • @Sir_Realist
    @Sir_Realist3 ай бұрын

    It was the last census that indicated that Muslims were 15% of the population. The next census, when conducted will indicate the current percentage. The perception is that the percentage of Muslims has increased and percentage of Hindus decreased.

  • @randmht9976

    @randmht9976

    2 ай бұрын

    Muslims are atleast 25+ crores.

  • @SahilSharma-lc5wm
    @SahilSharma-lc5wm3 ай бұрын

    Congress has become All India Muslim Muslim League Congress Party.

  • @snathan3198
    @snathan31982 ай бұрын

    Indira Gandhi was so shaken up, she did namaz! No her father and husband were momins! She acted as Hindu to get votes!

  • @ajminhas6486
    @ajminhas64862 ай бұрын

    You missed a big upcoming chunk called ex-muslins. Join and listen to Adam seeker and Sahil.

  • @shantanuraghavnw
    @shantanuraghavnw3 ай бұрын

    Shekhar should have done this episode solo considering how many interruptions he made, not even letting the other person complete her words

  • @saliljoshi6465

    @saliljoshi6465

    2 ай бұрын

    Grandpa tutoring granddaughter for board exam 😂😂

  • @rutvikrs
    @rutvikrs3 ай бұрын

    That Jammel Ilyasi story is a mirror copy of a temple story. Sanjay dies because Indira forgot to acknowledge god.

  • @flipwithin
    @flipwithin3 ай бұрын

    You are mischievous to the core, when you know that Jinnah was supported by Muslims but you choose to ignore it totally and instead to choose name from Gandhi to Gandhi when showing muslim choose them

  • @WhistleMaster
    @WhistleMaster3 ай бұрын

    Abul Maududi - Read about him. He was an Aurangabad born Indian Muslim, he created the theological framework which led to the creation of Jamat-E-Islami, Islamic Brotherhood, ISIS and even Hamas! We now know about them, their books and their followers in India. We’ll not be fooled anymore!

  • @ExmuslimBengali
    @ExmuslimBengali3 ай бұрын

    RAM VILAS PASWAN WAS WRONG INDIAN MUSLIM IS NOT CONVERTED BECASUE OF CASTISM ITS VERY FEW MOST OF CONVETED FORCEFULLY , YOU CAN REFER MUGAL ARCAIVE .

  • @vidyadharkotta1346
    @vidyadharkotta13462 ай бұрын

    No forced conversions - what did Aurangazeb do was he doing social work

  • @ScribblingPages-Official
    @ScribblingPages-Official2 ай бұрын

    Respect Shekhar Gupta's insightful analysis on various political matters, but can't help but notice a recurring pattern in his approach. While his commentary often provides valuable perspectives, it's disappointing to see him consistently resort to adding communal colors to his narratives, particularly towards the end of his discussions. This tendency to sensationalize or polarize discussions detracts from the nuanced analysis he's otherwise capable of.. It would be more constructive to focus on substantive issues rather than relying on divisive rhetoric.

  • @rajendradangi2585
    @rajendradangi25853 ай бұрын

    Muslim won't vote for BJP no matter what!! I have seen Muslim ladies saying they get everything from BJP govt like DBT house and ration but in the end she said she won't vote for Modi. BJP wasting it's time over there they should rather concentrate on hindus politically of course they wud work for everybody...

  • @ayes1669
    @ayes16693 ай бұрын

    Sekhar is also secretly muslim

  • @P9Ed3ts
    @P9Ed3ts3 ай бұрын

    A slite correction dont use “gandhi family”

  • @BotswanaThabo
    @BotswanaThabo3 ай бұрын

    Saheba is not referring to Prophet Mhmd but the contemporary collaborators of his Islamic projects like Abu Bakar and Omar etc

  • @PS-to6gr
    @PS-to6gr3 ай бұрын

    Curious if sania can read farsi and Urdu language? What are her primary sources?

  • @checkfurniture
    @checkfurniture2 ай бұрын

    When Modi is not doing anything for Hindus then why does Muslims always expect a special treatment?? Sabka saath sabka vikas. Else, wait for Yogi, who gives the special treatment for needy.

  • @manjulashanmugasundaram706
    @manjulashanmugasundaram7063 ай бұрын

    When will Lok Sabha elections be announced?

  • @Abbasi_Salman
    @Abbasi_Salman3 ай бұрын

    The Muslims in lndia are by and large splintered unlike Sikhs, they can't afford to have a Central leadership as none of their leaders are sincere, selfless, competent, charismatic, futuristic and far-sighted enough to organise Muslims as an entity in order to lead them into power sharing in the governance by enabling them to become stake holders in the administration. Ironically, the Muslims are divided in the Sunnis and Shias, two major sects and are further subdivided in numerous groups, sects, castes, subcastes, and school of thoughts like Deobandi, Barelvi, Ahle Hadees and Ahl ul Qur'an.So they find refuge under the political umbrella of various regional parties, who often take them for granted and use them as a tissue paper.

  • @seshanm54
    @seshanm543 ай бұрын

    In any case, Sanathana Dharma, is evolving & reforming and hence must open its doors to Pasmanda Muslims, to revive the mother culture and even the mother religion, if they think fit, in course of time.

  • @Saurabhvats08
    @Saurabhvats083 ай бұрын

    Someone goes to an American university, goes and talks to a few so called 'eminent educationalists' and voila this person is an expert on the subject and can now parrot out as a pro on the topic under discussion. Shekhar ji people simply see through your biased journalism no matter how layered & scholarly you try to make it sound.

  • @Abcd-vd8eb
    @Abcd-vd8eb3 ай бұрын

    I have 2 objections in this analysis 1.M..... choose some Hindus as their leaders out of compulsion of demography. Where the demographic compulsion not present like Kasmir,Hydrabad,Assam or they have opportunity like 1946 elections of India they choosen m.... leaders.Even the hindu leader dominated partys which choosen by m.... filed m.... candidates in m.... mejority constituencies. 2.The usual Indian marxist ranting that ppl accepted islam bcz of hindu cast system failed to explain A.How could cast less Christian dominated Middle-Eastern Roman Empire totally converted into is...? B. How Zoroastrian dominated Persia totally converted into is.... C.How could Buddhist (which according to same Marxist castless)dominated Afghanistan,Maldives totally converted into is.... ? D.How could in areas like present day Pakistan & Bangladesh which had a mixed population of Hindu -Buddhist, Buddhist was totally eradicate & whereas a significant portion of hindus was present according to pre Independence British census? Yes the right wing claim all conversion bcz of force isn't true but is marxist claim also ture? The truth is between 2 extreme.Forced conversation,Jajiya tax, Pilgrim tax,economic cause, greed for higher position,voluntary conversion,cast,destruction of religious worshiping places all played a roll.When hindus weren't allowed to spread their religion then it's obvious others will spread their religion. If cast was sole reason then after independence we could seen the same trend among Dalits. "Leftist" have to understand convering up some uncomfortable turths just bcz today m.... are minority in India isn't certainly helping boosting the unity in India & proved to be dangerous for minority hindus in Pak & BD.Only truth & reconciliation can help boosting the unity.

  • @vedicforce5820
    @vedicforce58203 ай бұрын

    If the Moslems need Rafsanjani, a foreigner to come and assure them about India, it may be better for them to exist Bharat on their own accord., perhaps, to Iran and Saudi Arabia. Btw, all this supposed different sub confessions within Islam is of no interest to Bharat. All of these groups owe their loyalty to alien faiths and ideologies.

  • @jagadisankrishnamoorthy4285
    @jagadisankrishnamoorthy42853 ай бұрын

    You are right. Most of the people elected were Hindus. But only those Hindus or parties which have a left inclination like your channel, who being Hindu always says the first right in India belong to Muslims, and there were umpteen instances of visible muslim or minority appeasement.

  • @rhonyroyce
    @rhonyroyce3 ай бұрын

    He needs to let her complete her sentences without interruptions

  • @aaditya880
    @aaditya8803 ай бұрын

    Ye itni Angrezi me hi kyu bolta hai? Iska channel North belt me hi dekha jaata hai na ya poori duniya me ye famous hai abb ? 😂

  • @smrbhr7565

    @smrbhr7565

    3 ай бұрын

    Tujhe kya problem hai bhai

  • @tejamysore3699
    @tejamysore36993 ай бұрын

    9:50 see how casually she throws in the word 'brahminvaad'. Isn't your clear disdain for a particular caste, make you casteist too? Ah, but for these 'woke' folks, abusing one caste is perfectly acceptable. What a great find, ShekharJi! 👏 🤮

  • @knowabhimishra
    @knowabhimishra3 ай бұрын

    13:25 GORAKHPUR KI STORY KITNI BAAR SUN LIYA ❤😂😂😂

Келесі