The implication of Birdo and Yoshi’s relationship falling apart is vile slander. They are deeply in love, Yoshi has been pooping out eggs and throwing them since Yoshi’s island. HE HAS BEEN DOING IT SINCE MARIO WAS A BABY! Way before ever meeting Birdo. She is not pressuring him to do this, it is a shared hobby that they both do, and enjoy. Overall, this sentiment of Yoshi and Birdo drifting apart is built upon weak evidence and lies.

@fructiferous

Жыл бұрын

🙏🙌

@pugstick

Жыл бұрын

First of all those are enemy being put in to eggs and second he probably has war PTSD from that event so it works I think

@smt64productions40

Жыл бұрын

That’s actually a different Yoshi, if the Yoshi is to be believe to be one of the 7 Star Children and is the Baby Green Yoshi that hatched at the end of Island DS

@IndustrialParrot2816

Жыл бұрын

Reminds me they are T4T and you can't convince me otherwise

@edgelux3381

Жыл бұрын

she literally has her engagement ring on, im so excited for their wedding

One thing you forgot to mention is that in the Paper Mario series, Birdo is portrayed as a pop star and actress who is loved the world over and has a very large number of adoring fans.

@bookshelfhoney

Жыл бұрын

Good for her ❤

@Arcsin27

7 ай бұрын

queen shit

I love how this entire theory is debunked by the simple suggestion that it's an engagement ring, not a wedding ring. Only one partner wears the engagement ring, and it's usually more showy with a big diamond like the one Birdo wears 😅

@KeyanCarlile

Жыл бұрын

Ratio

@Princess-Daisy

Жыл бұрын

W

@mantisnt1335

Жыл бұрын

@@KeyanCarlile lmao failed ratio

@Hello86257

Жыл бұрын

@@KeyanCarlile failed ratio

@mantisnt1335

Жыл бұрын

@@KeyanCarlile You think hearting my comment will free you from the guilt of the failed ratio? You are sorely mistaken. “Oh haha,” you think “Look I’ll support this comment so it looks like I’m a funny guy.” But that does not change the fact that you failed the ratio. It is an inarguably reality and a permanent blemish that cannot be erased, irony and satire will not free you from blame.

Peach may be a princess, but Birdo is a queen.

@zed54

Жыл бұрын

No need to pit queens against each other

@YouHaveUno

Жыл бұрын

@@zed54 There is only 1 queen.

@oreganoed8913

Жыл бұрын

All hail Birdo.

@king_poyo64

Жыл бұрын

And she slayyyyyyyyyys

@cesar6447

Жыл бұрын

Birdetta*

"She doesn't have sex, she's a dinosaur." kinda sat with me...

@eldin_volcano

Жыл бұрын

Same here, Birdo

@shardgunner4815

Жыл бұрын

Who’s gonna tell Keyan dinosaurs had sex 😬

You’re not the only Birdo stan. She’s an icon. She’s a legend, and she IS the moment.

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

You're right

This video is an adhd kids paradise….. the amount of tangents you went on is actually incredible it all ties back to birdo thank you for this insightful inflow of knowledge

If Birdo has a million fans, Keyan is one of them. If Birdo has ten fans, Keyan is one of them. If Birdo has no fans, that means Keyan is no more on the earth. If the World is against Birdo, Keyan is against the World. Keyan loves Birdo till his last breath.

@prageruwu69

Жыл бұрын

same

@cosmicspacething3474

Жыл бұрын

Vernias:

i dont think there’s a single fanfic out there that has been written better than the heartbreaking birdo yoshi saga you just wrote

@KeyanCarlile

Жыл бұрын

It isn’t a fanfic, it is 100% real and canon

@vortex_all9055

Жыл бұрын

duh of course its canon

@Goomba1309

Жыл бұрын

Still a better love story than Twilight

8:09 maybe Mario isn’t human, maybe Mario is a Mario?

@EternityKingdomsHeadHoncho

Жыл бұрын

That’s actually canon

@vortex_all9055

Жыл бұрын

mario is a homo nintendonus he is not a homosapian

@EternityKingdomsHeadHoncho

Жыл бұрын

@@vortex_all9055 True, BUT Mario Odyssey made it clear the people of New Donk City weren't human.

back in 2009 when poorly drawn vore art was everywhere on youtube i saw her eat mario and luigi and i was so scared of her eating me that i was crying and screaming and i have been a birdo fearer for my whole life

@robotx9285

Жыл бұрын

God I didn't need to remember those abominations.

got absolutely humiliated at the reiteration that everyone knows birdo and yoshi are a thing, because as a kid my younger brother and i thought they were siblings so we played as them sometimes if we were teaming up as a symbol of sibling strength.

@vortex_all9055

Жыл бұрын

god damn it i get moments like that some times

@504ever4

Жыл бұрын

I always thought Birdo was Yoshi's sister too. I think that was one of those word of mouth rumors that got spread among kids back in the day.

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

My mother, who is already a 57-year-old lady, had never seen them in her life but as soon as I showed them to her, she asked me: Are they brothers?

Good choice to release this after April Fools, this is peak already from the first 20 seconds.

Yoshi/Birdo, Enemies to Lovers, slow burn, forbidden romance, canon trans character, 100k words 10:47

Hear me out, what if Yoshi doesn't actually wear shoes and his feet just look like that? Alternatively, perhaps Birdo is wearing shoes and she just has a pair custom made to look like her feet? Also, regarding your theory about Birdo and Yoshi separating because Birdo attacks with eggs, I think you're forgetting about 1995's Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island. In Yoshi's Island, Yoshis used eggs as a projectile attack. One could argue that this was a trait he picked up from Birdo. However, Yoshi's Island takes place when Mario and Luigi were children, so it's extremely unlikely that Yoshi knew Birdo at this point because they've only been shown knowing eachother during times where the Mario Bros are adults. It seems that Yoshi and Birdo are both okay using eggs as projectile attacks and have both done so before even meeting. Also, I think it's likely that the eggs they attack with are unfertilized considering that they both seem to just be able to continuosly lay them without to needing any help from a partner in generating them, so they never had the potential to become children anyway. Unless you believe that Yoshis and Birdos reproduce assexually, which I doubt because Birdo's complicated history with her gender identity compared to her biological sex implies that at least her species has multiple sexes and likely reproduces sexually. And regarding your theorization about them being unhappy because Yoshi doesn't wear a wedding ring, have you considered that maybe Yoshi and Birdo aren't married yet and the ring on Birdo's finger is an engagement ring? Engagement rings traditionally have a large center diamond and wedding rings are generally a bit simpler and are more balanced. Birdo's ring matches an engagement ring more. It seems that they've just been engaged for a really long time, and my headcanon for the reason why is because every other time the Mushroom Kingdom has had a party, it devolved into a board game filled with rage as friends turn on eachother over coins and stars. Since a wedding is just a big party with two people as a focus, they fear how their friends would behave at such an event, so they've been pushing it off.

@moosesues8887

Жыл бұрын

Yoshi feet have been shown before in obscure artwork but if yoshi appears barefoot in a modern Mario game it might look similar to birdie feet

In Birdo's new phase of life as a good guy, she is in way less adventures as she used to. She can comfortably wear her wedding ring at all times because she's not in situations she truly fears she'll lose it. Yoshi, on the other hand, is constantly getting into scenarios where he could easily lose his wedding ring. After talking it out between the two of them, they both agreed it would be safer to keep his ring elsewhere for the majority of time. (Where? Idk. Not my business...) Birdo is also part of the "Barefoot is Legal" movement. Her friends don't love it, but respect her decisions & understand most footwear won't fit her anyways.

@Isthatthegrimreaper170

11 ай бұрын

Good for her honestly Shoes are annoying, imagine when you’re a dinosaur

You’ve convinced me to feel bad about calling Birdo the derivative name, “Turdo”, as a child

Every time Keyan shows that birdo kissing yoshi image, I die a little.

@KeyanCarlile

Жыл бұрын

Mayhaps your discomfort from the image stems from a deeply-instilled fear commitment

@Jawaddles

Жыл бұрын

@@KeyanCarlile No, it's definitely the feet.

@editordimentio

Жыл бұрын

I’m gunna get ptsd from those feet

@vortex_all9055

Жыл бұрын

@@Jawaddles maybe you just think that because your mind is tricking you to avoid thinking of that deeply-instilled fear of commitment

@Jawaddles

Жыл бұрын

@@vortex_all9055 ...nope. It's 100% the feet.

"Offensive Abortion" is a pairing of words that I didn't think would ever occur.

Im pretty sure rather than her deadname being catherine in japanese, the jp version isnt deadnaming her and she just prefers a nickname

@gracekim25

Жыл бұрын

Yeah I’m sure Birdo is a nickname 😅

There is this morbid hilarity in the fact that out of all of the modern iterations of Birdo, the BRITISH game manual decides to misgender her.

@invertebrado

Жыл бұрын

You saying that the bri'ish are transphobic?!?!?

@hopefullywholesome1955

Жыл бұрын

Well, we all know what lives in England

@jazzycat8917

Жыл бұрын

Terf Island strikes again

@tsunamiscientist568

Жыл бұрын

J.K Rowling wrote the British game manual, if you didn’t know.

@alolannassie

Жыл бұрын

british people don't be transphobic challenge (impossible)

Not being able to afford clothing is the most relatable trans thing Birdo has done. What an icon

@RokkTheRock

8 ай бұрын

on god

@prageruwu69

7 ай бұрын

real

@C0lumbidae

7 ай бұрын

literally shes so iconic honestly

The whole “it was all just a dream” thingy in Mario 2 implies that Birdo may have never been bad, and that Mario has known her for a while.

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

you're right

When i was a kid I loved birdo so much I went to look up pictures of her on google images. I found some um... very detailed art that is still burned into my brain to this day.

@dedion-boutonondemand

Жыл бұрын

Just did that 2 weeks ago while looking for images for future projects. Let’s just say I search “Birdo official render” now 😅

@goingunder2548

3 ай бұрын

I remember first unlocking her in mario kart wii and having never seen her before, took to Google to find out wtf she even was. My poor 10 year old self's innocence was stolen that day.

Birdo says “Birdo” when selected in Mario Kart Double Dash. So I’m sure that is her preferred name

I used to be a Birdo hater, but now I am converted. What an absolute Queen.

On the shoe thing: the bow It could be made from natural materials but it could just as easily mean she can afford things like rings and shoes (maybe she purchased her eyeliner?), and it just happens to be a lifestyle choice

Thank you SO much for this wonderful video, Yoshi and Birdo are my favorite Mario characters and it makes me so happy to see Birdo get the respect she so rightly deserves! The fanbase still gets so negative towards her despite how overwhelmingly positively she's portrayed in recent games, and it's always nice to see that funny dino enjoyers still exist :') I'd like to talk way too long about my own interpretation of Yoshi and Birdo's marriage, because if I don't do it in the comments section of this very specific video, then honestly, what other opportunity would I even HAVE. Yoshi, throughout the years, has been consistently represented by happiness and satisfaction. Yoshi LIVES to be happy, joy is the most important thing to him. Yoshis as a species are peaceful, fun-loving, sometimes lazy, but always willing to help others, friends and strangers alike, just to make everyone happy. Birdo is similar in this regard, yet in VERY different ways. In games where their relationship is less defined (or nonexistent), Birdo is shown to be quite the hopeless romantic. She's always chasing after love, hoping to find the one who's right for her, believing strongly in true love. It's clear how much passion she has for love and romance, and how she believes love is her own key to happiness. With all this taken into account, I've come to my own conclusion on Yoshi and Birdo's relationship. I like to think they ARE genuinely happy together, but express their happiness in very different ways. Birdo wears her ring as a reminder to herself just how happy she is, having finally found the perfect partner. Their relationship means everything to her, and carrying a representation of her own true love with her at all times is just how she most comfortably expresses how happy she is and how far she has come. Yoshi, on the other hand, doesn't need that reminder. He expresses his own happiness through action, choosing to be there for Birdo and having fun with her. Board games, kart racing, any sport he can think of, he wants to experience it all with her, along with his closest friends, because enjoying life is what Yoshi is all about. Again, this is all my own interpretation, and it's very possible (and likely) no one at nintendo ever put a single bit of thought into this, but I don't care! I like to believe they're happy, because it feels good to think about! If anyone is still reading this, thank you for listening to my insane ramblings about dinosaur marriage, and I leave you with one final note.... Birdo from the original Mario Tennis for N64 is the BEST Birdo design and I will carry this opinion until the day I die. She is adorable. please bring her back. And Yoshi's best design is from Mario Party 1-3 okay bye

@skarloey1214

Жыл бұрын

This is the best novel I've read all year

@blairesydog

Жыл бұрын

@@skarloey1214 thank you for supporting my extreme fixation on two fictional dinosaurs ❤️

@mariogariazzo2024

Жыл бұрын

That was very cute, thank you

@AnotherCoyote

Жыл бұрын

Wait, I didn't know the fanbase had any legit hate for Birdo. I've only seen positive or goofy takes on Birdo... Does the fanbase posting on your favorite social media platform say mean things about her?

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

You've said everything on my mind, I thought I was the only one who thought exactly all of that. I'm glad to see that someone else has my same views. P.S. I also love dinosaurs, and also if they are fictional

Birdo was my Mario Kart Wii main way before I came out as trans. She's a true icon and you have good taste 😊

Finally a Birdo fan

20:08 the simple conclusion here is that they're engaged but not yet married (and Yoshi's rich because that is a massive diamond) Edit: yeah, just got to the part where you talk about the class differences; Yoshi is rich and is almost definitely Birdo's sugar daddy

There is a level in Mario 2 where you have to use Birdos eggs to get over a huge gap so i guess thats when she became a good guy

what would be the tone/genre of like a tv series following birdo's tumultuous marriage? like a kids' sitcom to keep in line with the appeal of mario as a cute family-friendly world?

This channel has become dedicated to Disney channel history and random hyper-fixations and I'm all here for it

Finally, the right man for the job

I wish I had the guts to talk about my unpopular Nintendo faves the way Keyan Carlie talks about Birdo

As a Birdo fan... thank you for this incrdible video 😭😭😭

Birdos ring has a gemstone on it which implies it’s an engagement ring rather than a wedding band so I think they’re engaged and therefore it’s okay Yoshi isn’t wearing a ring

I am a birdo stan to DONT LEAVE ME OUT 🎀🎀🎀🎀🎀💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻💅🏻🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️🏳️‍⚧️

@billnocolis9368

3 ай бұрын

The person behind this account is a human not a dinosaur

HER NAME IS BIRDETTA

I love how this researched and informative video transforms into a ramble halfway through before ending with a fan-fiction story. The transition (no pun intended) was very smooth; great video!

BIRDO STANS RISE TOGETHER ITS OUR FCKIN TIMEEEEE

I'm glad this released on the 2nd so no one accidentally mistakes it as non-serious.

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

You're right

I would unironically love a 90 minute deep-dive analysis of the Gooper Blooper.

I'm a transgender girl and i love Birdo & the Mario franchise so much 💕🫶🏻✨

@krissssssss5401

Жыл бұрын

I'm glad you have that rep

@livliveart

9 ай бұрын

Girl same!! I got her in Lego form recently (from a blind bag), I was so happy omg. Such an icon

while that end section is pretty good it has been shown in Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island that yoshi eggs can be created very easily by swallowing objects, and that game takes place long before mario kart double dash as mario and luigi are babies in it

Mario 2 is canonically a dream so Birdo could have just been good all along

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

You're right

Dont worry - me and my high school friends are birdo stans - we all wanted to play birdo in mario cart

This is the video we all needed. Birdo stans unite.

Yoshi's been throwing eggs since Mario was a baby, what an hypocrite

This is turning out to be SUCH a good video, thank you so so much

She's my "lucky character" on my Mario Party game on my Switch ⭐️

love this video. also i love all the tangents you went on it was so fun

This is so nichely me. I love your channel, have watched your Lab Rats and everything. Birdo is my FAVE and I went to the Nintendo Store in NYC- no merch. Just a lego mystery character they sell. So sad. Thanks for your lore dives!!

This video is so chaotic. And I’m eating up every second of it. 😭💖

Love you and your content keyan ❤️ We stan Birdo now

0:10 seconds in and i see you have used the greatest mario party minigame imaginable. 10/10 video

Another banger of a video, Keyan!

Congrats on moving out dude!!! I'm actually just about to do the same for the second time so I know how liberating it is. And you are so right about how unfortunate looking all the Birdo color variations are in MK8

Such a tragic story... This documentary will have me forever in tears.

9:51 i would like to point out an redemption arc kind of did happen in Super Mario Bros 2, you see the last time we see Pink Birdo in the game is in world 4-3 in where there is a huge gap between spaces and the only way across is by letting Birdo help us throwing an egg and us the player travel in it Anyways great video! Loved it!

Dude just predicted the script to the Mario movie with that “Koopas, Goombas, whatever those things are” line.

@jordanlucas7392

Жыл бұрын

That was in the trailers though

@periodicgaming5159

Жыл бұрын

@@jordanlucas7392 Ah! I didn’t watch most of the trailers, so I didn’t realize that.

i fucking love this channel man. never stop what you do

this is it. this is the single best thing i've ever watched high. THANK YOU. this is absolutely everything

Midway through watching this video I questioned myself... am I having a stroke? Is this real life? Btw, Birdo and Yoshi are happily married, they told me last night that all of their differences were resolved when I was having dinner with them. Lovely couple.

@Baconlovesreddead

Жыл бұрын

Yeah. Went on a dinner date with them and they seem super happy. Probably just get in fights for the media

Birdo is transfem and Yoshi is transmasc and together they are an iconic t4t couple

Thank you so much for this video 😭 i loveeeee birdo so much I'm glad there's other birdo stans out there ❤️❤️❤️

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

Me too, for a moment I thought I was the only one with this unusual taste.

This video is fukin' hilarious. You talk so serious yet your statements are SO silly, i can really feel how much fun you had making this video and i love it!

"I'm the only birdo stan on the planet anywhere" um false, jason sulli doesn't wear a birdo mouth just because he's feeling silly goofy smh

She’s just so down to earth unlike the princesses not only that she’s really cute

i think this is the most unhinged video i have ever watched, and i am so here for it

What would a Yoshi and Birdo crossbreed look like?

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

it would be epic

this is my new favorite video of yours. as a birdo lover thank you so much for the lore

I can't even lie i'm so down bad for Birdo, she is literally perfect in every aspect.

@KeyanCarlile

Жыл бұрын

So true bestie

@Baconlovesreddead

Жыл бұрын

That mouth can do some shit

I remember the day i unlocked birdo in mario kart wii, she instantly became my favorite character in it. And to this day she still is. Birdo was actually the reason i got into lego super mario, she showed up in the most recent blond box series for it.

i do have to say that most egg-laying species dont need to...procreate...in order to lay eggs. they need to in order to lay fertile eggs, but they can lay infertile eggs regardless

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

You're right

I used to drive without shoes on purpose because i had a phase in my life where i exclusively wore flipflops for years and i was terrified somehow the flipflop would get stuck on the pedals and cause me to crash

@citruspeach9971

Жыл бұрын

Andyways good video

Found this on the home screen. Did not have to go so hard for the purple Canon-faced dino, but you did and I love it

They are both the egglaying variety of their species, so they cannot create offspring together (even if their species would be genetically compatible), so those eggs are not fertillised. I suspect the other characters disdain towards birdo is just coming from transphobia, and whilst yoshi loves here, he feels judged by others and thus is afraid to show his commitment to birdo.

@AbsolXGuardian

Жыл бұрын

I was really expecting Keyan to say "is Peach transphobic?"

I had no idea who birdo was until now, now they’re my favourite Mario character, thank you

Finally, I know I'm not alone

Excellent video, but Yoshi uses his eggs as weapons all the time babe ❤ love the vibes and drama though

One of your best vids ever And I'm still waiting on the Gooper Blooper analysis

Birdo has been my favorite character since mario kart wii

Birdo is an icon

19:25 I think they are actually called Smeeches… Don’t ask me how I knew that.

big fan of your split second appearence in the swell entertainment transformers con video, i expected you there and you did not disappoint. also love the tengents

Finally another Birdo fan! My friends all give me a hard time for finding her neat. I wouldn't say she's my favorite but she's definitely up there. Great vid!

over thanksgiving weekend my brother and i pulled out the old wii controllers and played mario kart i played birdo every single time. she is the queen. best character.

Bro, you needed to talk about Birdo’s portrayal in Captain Rainbow! That was crazy!

@MDHCleon1927

Жыл бұрын

You're right

I can’t wait for him to make another 5 hour video about a Disney show those are my favorite videos

Your not killing ur channel :( I like watching stuff ur passionate about even if I’m not as into it. It’s ur energy I like

1:17 jokes on you this is the first and thus far only video I’ve watched on your channel.

Birdo is by far my favorite Mario character, and I was sad when she wasn't originally in MK8

3:03 Was that a Super Mario Movie reference, with the "Whatever those things are!"...? 😂

Congrats on having your own place!

This is the greatest video essay I've ever seen

2:45 waluigi learned the hard way it wasn't his arm

I watched the Birdo episode of the Super show like 2 years ago and it did not clock to me that those creates were supposed to be Birdo.

Mad respect for going out and finding and crediting all the artists, something the article should have done to begin with