Every Indian is rediscovering that we are Transforming to Bharatiya .....

@Unfollowthem

3 жыл бұрын

Its great but One real point is missing... That is A, Without a we are moving to B... I mean 'A' is Samskruta here... Because everything written in it....

@SR-mv2mf

2 жыл бұрын

Jai Bharath

So much money splurged on some "iconic" lit fests where the focus is always either bashing India or bashing Hindu civilization. And, here we have a lit fest with minimum resources but exceptionally brilliant minds actually making us think, dig deeper into our own civilizational treasure of knowledge so that one day we can hope to see the emergence of an India that represents its own values! I am just delighted listening to these guys.

@goodearth5584

5 жыл бұрын

I totally agree with Praveen

@usc4405

4 жыл бұрын

Couldn't agree more. 🙏🏻👍🏻

@frankjackal

Жыл бұрын

We need to do more than just support with likes.. we should educate ourselves and the next gen (our kids) so that can they build and take this fwd.

After a long time a discussion about India with Indians..

@saurabhgrover6737

6 жыл бұрын

Unfortunaltely in English, Including yours n mine comment.

@praveenrai6965

5 жыл бұрын

Succinct and brilliantly put!

@Uttam_Kumar_Jana

2 жыл бұрын

@@saurabhgrover6737 Its a lovely & useful language ,lets embrace it and appreciate it and spread to it all parts of Earth to unite Humanity in ways.

Very fruitful discussion... Rather than wothless Jaipur fest like events we should have these kind of events more often....

@jyotivyas9286

6 жыл бұрын

plank god ekdum Satya!! 🔥🔥🔥🤝🤝🤝🍃🍃🍃🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳Jai Bharat Mata va Jai Sanatan Dharm kee...!! To keep quite and nicer... Yes Being Bhartiya .. is Absolutely Needed ... Rather than being a hub ofAngrez. . BeingBhartiya. 🤝🤝🤝🔥🔥🔥🍃🍃🍃🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🌫️🌊🌫️🌊🌫️🌊💕💕💕🔥🔥🔥...!!🐦

@lakshmiram7977

4 жыл бұрын

Keep giving information and educate people what they should do to take India forward adn how to influence government go ahead with the good policy for India

@Unfollowthem

3 жыл бұрын

What is Jaipur fest..

The 19th century Bengali Renessaince by Tagore, Rammohana Roy, Vidyasagar, Subas Chandra Bose, Vivekananda contributed heavily to modern India. I see these three Bengali have same capabilities.

@jatinderbhan

6 жыл бұрын

Don't forget Chetanya Mahabrabhu, Lahiri Mahashaya, Sri Aurobindo, Ramakrishna Paramhamsa, Paramhamsa Yogananda, to name some of the spiritual luminaries. An Indic renaissance cannot be complete without a strong spiritual framework. Unfortunately, the Bengali culture got hijacked by Marxism with disastrous consequences not only for Bengalis, but for the whole of India.

@rrrajlive

5 жыл бұрын

Amb Dar No, he (Rammohan Ray) learned 11 languages so that he could understand how the world and India works. To win you need to learn your opponent/objectives. British learned Sanskrit. They have better knowledge about Vedic culture (it's different they misuse) then we do. Now, we know how the world politics works. Now, we can proceed to face those issues.

Bibek Debroy !! Bow down to ur knowledge, articulation & sharp messaging, Sir.

@DipakBose-bq1vv

4 жыл бұрын

He has presided over the gross economic failure of this BJP government. Modiji must sack him.

Oh I so wish I could come to this festival. The concept of India and Bharat is so well elucidated

@soumendraphukan2679

5 жыл бұрын

Jamal Uddin same

Exceptional discourse...we hv gr8 history, civilization, culture & spirituality, economics..slowly getting drained out with a very specific agenda to an extend of state sponsored, sanskrit language is strategically removed, pythagoras becomes more relevant than vedic maths, aryabhata has no place, whereas Galileo become father of observational astronomy, hardly find any hypothesis, text of aryabhatta in this so called modern education system. India was not just economic, it's strong foundation was weakened and today also with persistent and consistent efforts by certain vested interest to demean indian civilization and spirituality... infact we are breeding a generation that doesn't hv any belief system, cultural bankruptcy, cursing own roots, follow west or middleast sabysachi mukherjee becomes sebastian mukherjee, sitaram becomes Stephen/Salim or shahjan, mohandas palanyswamy becomes Mohammed Ali palani...intellectuals say what is in the name...but fundamentally every aspect, thought prcoess start with the name... Such discourse is an eye opener for confused generations looking to be either left/right..

Most engaging and informatively diverse discussions ever.... Great panel. Thanks for this great ensemble

Its always delight to listen to Bibek Debroy... What a scholar!!!!

India changed the mindset of povertarianself since Pokhran A explosion! One has to thank the late Bajpaiji! That kick started the confidence that was missing before!

Sanjeev Sir's input at last was on point. Nothing happens spontaneously , blood needs to be spend for things to happen.

If only our news and mainstream media brought these real intellectuals for Indian commoners... each one here is a highly knowledgable one man battalion

Only 3.5k views, shame on us!!!!

Bibek Debroy is God...Nothing more, Nothing less

Pondy Lit Festival discussion is quite fascinating. Such platform for alternative narrative of real India rather confusing and suppressive left view imposed on us. Govt must heavily invest and involve Hinduism culture history civilization of Bharat with correct narrative on India. We expect in the coming days more such discussion across around the world should start now.

India has a lot of soft power, sufficient & increasing economic power, deficient hard power. We need to up our game and bring in reforms and progress .

It's really amazing to watch and listen and even interpret according my understandings such talks. 🙏🏼 🙏🏼Jai Shri Ram

What a brilliant mind he has Bibek Debroy! What depth of knowledge firmly rooted in the vedas which gives us our identity. Respect!

This type of debate should happen in Election Campaigns in Bharat 😍

definitely a great discussion. I am a great fan of Debroy da...

There are two incidents in Mahabharata where Dharmaja is taught Rajaneeti: In Sabha Parvam during Rajasooya Yaga Narada taeches Yudhistira. In Shanti Parva Bheeshma teaches Raja Neeti to Yudhishtira. Then Yudhoshtira answers Yakshaprashnas in Aranya Parvam. In all three discourses you find origins of Kautilya Neeti. It was not the first time Kautilya exposed his ideas tot the world.There were already there in Mahabharata.

I just came here to listen Abhijit Iyer Mitra.

Only Mourya, Mourya and Mourya......wat abt Chalukyas, Hoysalas, Rashtakutas and Pallavas who contributed enormously with their creative administration and public welfare, we can't ignore their contributions towards culture and education in their hejomony.

@rohitjha8626

5 жыл бұрын

Damn right

@MP-ik6eh

4 жыл бұрын

Besides the Mauryas and Guptas, the Pala-Pratihara-Rashtrakuta triparties also kept the empire intact and safe from invasion.

1:28... Sanjeev is correct. We can see the NATURAL PROGRESSION & EVOLUTION of the society & even ethics along the continuum of time & evolution to keep up with the change in the social perceptions. It was the same Vishnu Bhagwan who came as the Avtars, & clearly indicated the course correction required FOR THAT PARTICULAR TIME... The "god" did not interfere in the natural progression of the society... only came when the society could no longer figure out howto deal with the chaos they had themselves created over the period of time by "pushing the envelope" in all areas. That is how I see the HINDU Dharma & culture of Bharat. In today's date, we will need to make the correction & adaptation based on what is needed for the advancement OF BHARAT TODAY, & NOT based on what the foreign invaders who trashed it for 1000 years tell us because it is in their vested interested...

Wow, I had no idea about Sri Aurobindo's upbringing.

Thank you for sharing this!

Dharma cannot be codified completely. This understanding comes from a detailed study of the Mahabhārata, which Bibek Debroy has done. He is correct.

Very nice. Let there be many more such events.

Mr. Sanyal u r just brilliant as always.

Very interesting & informative discussions. Indians love to talk to a point where there is no Action. In history, the Muslim attacks & invasion did not believe in code of Conduct or Dharma they just killed , Looted & raped because they believed in motivating their soldiers & men by proving them the opportunity of procuring 77 Virgins providing they covert the Fakirs into Musalmans. This resulted in the creation of Pakistan partitioning the Land of Dharma. Lahore was the city of Lava & Kusha who were abandoned by their father Lord Rama. Abhijit referred to the rivalry of the Armed Forces in creation of the Strategic Command overiding the three Forces & heading the Support functions like the Space , Sattelite & Strike forces like the various Comando Forces. India presently is Transiting from the Combination of Shock & Awe Rapid deployment Surgical Stike force & the Regular Occupation Force. The Leaner & Meaner Army like the World Armies will come as the next step as there is a distinct Skill & Education bifurcation between the Officer’s IQ & those of the NCO's & Jawans or Sepoys as they were known in the British Imperial Army. The Intergration of the Armed forces first step was envisioned by the formation of the NDA at Kadakavasala in Pune. Nathan Sekhar Sydney, Australia.

Fascinating! Illuminating!

Interesting and delightful debate

iyer supremecy 🙏🙏

Thanx PLF for creating an alternate voice to take on Jaipur Lit Festival,an Urban Intellectuals’ Forum ....

Why just simply translate, it may minimise the essence. It's better to learn Sanskrit

@vvee4725

6 жыл бұрын

No. Languages are moats. In startups, and business it is important to use moats to keep a competitive edge, otherwise the competitor has an easier time appropriating your ideas. That's why translations are, imo, a strategic mistake. Rather make the Sanskrit ecosystem more robust, and attractive to users.

@vvee4725

5 жыл бұрын

Never have I ever seen someone so desperately rationalize their own suicide.

wonderful discussion

How in god's name did I miss this, great content, thanks

It's so enriching. It's so brilliant for mind-expansion.

Abhijit IM is an anomaly on this panel. Bibekji and Sanjivji are so much more articulate and so knowledgeable.

It was an engrossing time I enjoyed Thank you So much fun to learn more

Bharat sakthi : please read Subramania Bharati (1888-1921) works. .

Sanskrit shud be made compulsory in primary schools in india

Amazing amazing conversation

1:21:00 has been cut by youtube. Here the questioner was trying to ask when India was a superpower in midage why hallmark is not the same today?

Salute

Great 👍🏿 knowledge and clear mindset.

Good discussion.

What is this about security? Security is a relative baseless concept that is never ending because as long as you exist, you'll face danger. No matter what you do, as long as you're breathing dangers will always be there. If you sit for long, it will bring danger. If you walk for long it will also bring danger. So don't bring physical security and pour it on humanity in the name of righteousness. Because security is not a rigid ideology existantially, its flexible. Whatever security you bring up, it must be based under the understanding of nature of human beings entirely. Otherwise it will only affect people in a wrong way with an external facade of appearing correct. Education must be based under vedas, not societial norms or anything you guys make up as education. Human emotions and relative interest doesn't overthrow the nature of human existence. You can talk about love peace security protection all you want, existantial laws won't yeild to your prejudice. Its like staring at a wall, you can pain it whichever color you want or put glasses to see it differently. The attributes of the walls however does not change even a bit. It will be hard and rigid never the less. So whatever security law you provide for the well being. just drop it to the garbage and first focus on human nature and how to fix this. This is not a social thing, this is an existantial thing

Can somebody explain if Bibek's recalling the story of dog seeking justice in Ramayana have a meaning in the present? Does it apply to someone/party/etc.. ?

22 min 20 sec - 25 min should be the central Indian Govt policy....

I think Iyer was a little left out. He makes sense but somehow we are not able to see a convergence between his ideas and the points that Sanyal and Debroy make.

We lack political unity and economic creativity due to sanatan and budha doctrine. Both of these 2 broken the back of Hindu intellectual creativity for Science and technology.

Bibek...Brahmo samaj statrted quite earlier than 1857 and Hindu reform started at same time as well

SAVE TIME, For Bibek Sir switch to 1.5x

Sanjeev ji...🙏🙏

The lens of the Bhoore Sahibs is still not changed under Modi Govt. 49:10 Bharat Shakti has a single language Sanskrit, remember Gupta period.

If we Re correct Bibek Debroy... It will become "Viveka Devaraya" (Raya=Raja,... Rai, Roy, Raya, rav rao all the meaning is Raja)

The thumbnail is hilarious 😂🤣

When i saw the thumbnail of this video i thought the person sitting next to Abhijit is Irfan Habib.

How can Abhijit say that "decision making in the military is just as abysmal as it is in the civilian" service? On what basis does he call it 'abysmal'? Has he been in the military? Is it with 'abysmal' decision making that we won four wars against Pakistan or are protecting his life from insurgents from across the border?

I came here bcz of Mitra da

Also make it in hindi...

In hurry to wrap up the session, hamppering ideas and topic is happening. So ideas aren't having flourishing enough.

This is pondy litfest and Manoj das is not invited?

Entire Congress party with its continuous dynasty family lineage with massive humongous corruption and its deliberate regressive policies has entirely destroyed My Bharat Borsho until today.

100th like

45.45 min : The wise men who wrote our constitution didn't themselves have knowledge of Hindu classic laws, neeti shastra, rajyashastra. They were products of conditioning by colonial masters.

33.00 min Aurobindo...👍

Defensive army full stop

panelist them selves do not agree among themselves.

Abhijit is abrasive but true, Sanjeev is a BJP spokesperson but love Bibek

I don't think there is any enmity between the two separate but equally relevant ideas of 'India' and 'Bharat'. People who try to create an enmity between the two and take position behind one miss the point. India does not mean modern, and Bharat traditional. Again India does not mean an externalisation of our country while Bharat remains an internalised term. 'India' has come from Sindhu. And the cradle of our civilisation was on the banks of the Sindhu. The word Sindhu itself means river. And the early forefathers of our civilisation simply called the river next to which they grew, and which was fundamental to their way of life, as simply that - the river, ie Sindhu. This eventually became the name of the river. And the people who lived near the river were also sindhus. In course of trade with the persians, they started calling the people Hindu as they couldn't pronounce Sindhu. Gradually, when the Greeks came they started calling the river Indus and the place Indica (megasthenes's writings). And over time Indica became India. Therefore both India and Hindu are closely linked with our civilisational birthplace, the Sindhu river. Denigrating India is denigrating one's own civilisation. Hence, let India and Bharat both continue without feeling any urge to assign superiority of one over the other, or selecting one and discarding the other. That would be foolish and from the point of view of our civilisational heritage and culture, suicidal.

Bibek Debroy has such a pretentious accent it distracts you to fight your irritation more than anything else.

@jatinderbhan

6 жыл бұрын

It is not the accent, it is his pedogogical style that can be a bit overwhelming. However, he is a polyglot with an amazing breadth and depth of his knowledge on myriad topic. So not only do i tolerate him, I also have learnt to discipline myself to listen to him with care and reverence!

@DipakBose-bq1vv

4 жыл бұрын

He knows nothing.

India ki shakti 27/2/ 2019 owr Ladakh mai dikh gae Dunya ko....Bhai India janta ko bewaqoof banana band karo

Look at the number of views...one cheap ass skit video gets views in millions if not in billion... it shows what things our society really is receptive for.. such a shame

Sanjeev Sanyal gets all his dates wrong about Sri Aurobindo's life, gives a wrong interpretation of why Manchester was chosen and not London (The man who agreed to take the responsibility of Dr. Ghose's three sons and keep them in his house just happened to live in Manchester) and much else and everyone is clapping!! He wants to talk about Sri Aurobindo's life in Sri Aurobindo Soceity as if he knew better. Sadly, he hasn't read enough to know the details of Sri Aurobindo's inner life when he arrived in 1910 and he gives his own explanation of everything. Sanyal is clever enough to know that everyone is ignorant and they will believe anything he says.

@hasansk3346

6 жыл бұрын

Totally is inspired by running party it's one way thinking, there r another India by this four years and we lost more things than achieved...

@VikasSharma-ez5mm

6 жыл бұрын

@@hasansk3346 And what have we lost civilizationaly in last four years ...

@hasansk3346

6 жыл бұрын

@@VikasSharma-ez5mm dear Brother just flow the behind of u and imagine after that u will find what I lost in four years...

@VikasSharma-ez5mm

6 жыл бұрын

@@hasansk3346 couldn't understand... Him apni civilization bahut pehle se bhoolte aa rahe hain .. In 4 saalon me aisa kya naya kho diya....

@tamaleesen2759

6 жыл бұрын

@@hasansk3346 really, how much do you know about Sri Aurobindo that you want to support the above theory?

The little gnome finally got bail...he's not coming back to orissa in a hurry.😀

BIBEK Debroy literally put me to sleep! Speakers like these are out of favour. Folks are these extremely good at vocab but will fail getting their word across!!

Abhijit ayar is a murkha

Atal Ji was a visionary!