Im not a NY fan by any means. But Joe Girardi has every right to be pissed off here.

@RS-tz2zn

8 жыл бұрын

+john Magill This is karma for when A-Rod shouted "I got it" while running the bases against the Blue Jays

@johnmagill3072

8 жыл бұрын

You know its a fucked up call when a Rangers fan and A Sox fans sides with NY.

@MonthManAugust

8 жыл бұрын

+Ryan Shaffer For an event that happened in 2009, if not earlier, why would karma hit in the one season A-rod COULDN'T play in. (He was suspended for the entirety of 2014, AKA when this video took place.)

@RS-tz2zn

8 жыл бұрын

Themerc2006 It was double karma, being suspended for cheating all those years, and then having this happen when you appeal due to all the rest of what Rodriguez has done...

@MonthManAugust

8 жыл бұрын

mathew davis good for you

That's a dirty and dangerous play. It's clear he was targeting the 3B, and had no intention of tagging the base.

@tristanpotts3300

3 жыл бұрын

Agreed, I am not a Yanks fan and I agree with you, that should have been an ejection of the baserunner.

I remember this play. He wasn't even close to being able to touch the bag. No gray area in sight. It's a text-book example of interference. It was so flagrant, I don't understand how it went unnoticed.

@dangerouswheelco433

8 жыл бұрын

I was there that game I was furious. Though Kelly Johnson was hated

@shadowheart52

8 жыл бұрын

Couldn't think of a good name so i guess this is it I just learned recently that's the ruling on taking out a fielder, that the runner has to be able to touch the bag. It's clear he wouldn't have been able to. This should be a reviewable call. Why is this less of an umpire judgment than a call at 1st base, or a homerun? I don't get that.

@dangerouswheelco433

8 жыл бұрын

shadowheart52 the ruling was bases loaded nobody out

@ALLDaySKiiLLs

8 жыл бұрын

shadowheart52 he still could of reached the bag

@mgarzabell720

8 жыл бұрын

Couldn't think of a good name so i guess this is it The problem is that almost every runner in this kind of play does this and it's so rarely called.

If I were Girardi, I'd ask the umpire to lay down where the guy slid and ask him if he can reach the bag from there. Case closed.

@Gradius6

3 жыл бұрын

That's exactly what Girardi did at 2:45.

I'm an Orioles fan, but how the duck was interference not called there? I... there's literally no good reason why interference wouldn't be called. Pearce was 4 feet outside the base and pointed his legs into the fielder's ankle. Also, he didn't even attempt to reach out to third. I feel like that kind of move is suspend-able.

@lm_Cray

7 жыл бұрын

Patrick Hogan agreed man. I enjoy watching heads up physical play but that was 100% interference.

@g00gleminus96

6 жыл бұрын

Yes, stupid call. It's a clear out a third and the interference at third prevented the defence at third from making what was otherwise a very doable double play.

@aaronaguilar9172

6 жыл бұрын

HOW THE DUCK CANT U FCKING SPELL FUCK RIGHT

@critter2

6 жыл бұрын

cause the umpire are not used to the new rule and second he could of judge the runner was able to reach the base if this was runner for yankees they be plotting the effort

@michelleadouglas5111

6 жыл бұрын

Me to should of been an interference for that

they need to change the replay rules that should've been a replay review.

@xplayman

8 жыл бұрын

Exactly as Michael Kaye said. Every call is an umpire judgment call. It's silly. Pearce is going to hurt somebody playing like that.

@jedimaster833

8 жыл бұрын

There wasn't a need to review the runner clearly went out of his way and went out the baseline

@danewalker9281

8 жыл бұрын

+Dan Grissom Jr but because the umpires are oblivious and complete imbusals, they could've reviewed it (if it was allowed) to correct their mistake

Ugh, get the stinkin' call right. That was clearly interference. Should be runner on 2nd with 2 outs after the play, if they had called it right.

@tyvulpintaur2732

9 жыл бұрын

Samuel Marinov Even if it was interference, the throw was way too high to first.

@geoballer21

9 жыл бұрын

^^^ And why do you think the throw was way too high at first? Maybe bc someone slide way out of the way to slide into the guys legs?..

@tyvulpintaur2732

9 жыл бұрын

George Ever try to make a throw while running? Chances are your throw will be off the mark as well.

@tyvulpintaur2732

9 жыл бұрын

dbo20 He had already released the ball before the runner slid into him.

@RS-tz2zn

9 жыл бұрын

***** Not true...if you go to 0:38 or 3:36 of the video you can clearly see their feet touching and the 3b still with the ball in his hands...

you too smart for them Joe

That's interference. Call should have been made.

worst out of base slide ever. what the hell happened to baseball?

@Pepe-gy8dk

8 жыл бұрын

He did it on purpose idiot

@melbias5046

8 жыл бұрын

Pepe your knowledge of baseball overwhelms me. i always thought the player was the bag,. thank you for your insight.

@mattsiphone2804

8 жыл бұрын

+mel bias 💀💀💀

@melbias5046

8 жыл бұрын

Raavn 💀💀💀

@frankcastle9691

7 жыл бұрын

mel bias corrupted by steroids and money?

Sometimes I feel like these umps just make the rules up as they go. Runner at 3rd should be called out instantly.

@LukeMitbo

8 жыл бұрын

1st*

@MAMP

8 жыл бұрын

Yes thank you :)

@critter2

6 жыл бұрын

in fact if there no rule cover in rule book we do

@davelinicus

6 жыл бұрын

lilbromarky1 the runner at third was out, it’s the runner to first that should be out

3:11 "the vain in his neck is starting to pop out now, here we go" hahaha. Never herd a reverence like that from a commentator before.

@chrizles

8 жыл бұрын

+Greysen Gagné he said his neck is starting to bulge lmao

@trey2325

4 жыл бұрын

Right howd he butcher the quote that bad 😂

Unbelievable, complete BS, this is exactly why... brawls happen like last Sunday, this was ridiculous

@XcelGamingXcellent

8 жыл бұрын

If you think this slide was bad you haven't seen anything. My grandfather told me back in his day this would have been a sissy girl takeout slide

@kellengonda1863

7 жыл бұрын

+XcelGaming gtfo

Die hard Redsox fan here......and I think the Yanks were hosed. If you can't reach the bag then you're interfering.

@johnboggs1164

8 жыл бұрын

this is one reason why they changed the slide rule after two players, including tejada almost had career ending injuries due to dirty slides. there are hard slides and there are dirty slides. this one was right up there with utley. i say if they break a rule like that and the player gets injured, they should end their season right there. zero tolerance.

@airplanegod

6 жыл бұрын

The Orioles are worse than The Yankees at this point. They play dirty, aren't any good, and pick fights with almost every team they play.

*actual conversation between umps "So who do we want to argue?" "Well, Joe is already out here…" "True, and Showalter full head of steam is never good" "So we going for Joe?" *all agreeing "yea" *makes call "safe!"

The way Pearce walked off the field after the fact kind of tells you everything you need to know about his intentions.

Greg Gibson the home plate umpire would have motioned to both players

Dude if his cleat sticks in the ground his career could of been over! I'm not a yankee fan btw.

If the runner goes outside the baseline he should be out anyway, seeing how had he stayed in it, he would've been out to begin with.

@jumperguy9867

8 жыл бұрын

Just a little bit of information for you. The baseline is the line between bases. The four baselines make a perfect 90' x 90' square. Runners are allowed to go outside the baselines all the time. I think what YOU mean is that runners are generally not allowed to go outside the base PATH - which is defined as the direct route between a runner and the next base. With that said, the base path/base line argument is irrelevant here. The runner clearly interfered with the throw and he did it deliberately. He was already out, so that out stands. The umpire screwed up here. This was very clearly interference. Thee are FOUR umpires in major league games. It is inexplicable how the 3rd base umpire could have POSSIBLY missed this. He has ONE job!! And he wasn't doing it.

@defiantone8556

8 жыл бұрын

I'll recheck my MLB Rule Book on that one.

@jumperguy9867

8 жыл бұрын

defiantone MLB Rule 7.08 Any runner is out when- (a) (1) He runs more than three feet away from his base path to avoid being tagged unless his action is to avoid interference with a fielder fielding a batted ball. A runner’s base path is established when the tag attempt occurs and is a straight line from the runner to the base he is attempting to reach safely (b) He intentionally interferes with a thrown ball; or hinders a fielder attempting to make a play on a batted ball; Rule 7.08(b) Comment: A runner who is adjudged to have hindered a fielder who is attempting to make a play on a batted ball is out whether it was intentional or not. If the umpire declares the hindrance intentional, the following penalty shall apply: With less than two out, the umpire shall declare both the runner and batter out. With two out, the umpire shall declare the batter out.

@defiantone8556

8 жыл бұрын

Yea, I have the rule book, I just don't have the time right at this moment to dig it out. lol

@jumperguy9867

8 жыл бұрын

defiantone I had it in pdf form...

The out runner is interference and the BR is also out.

@prsguitars42

9 жыл бұрын

MS Jeon BINGO!! (FCCABU member)

@LanzaNation

6 жыл бұрын

That’s how it should be

*So basically after the umpires got together and still got the call wrong, they dismissed Girardi's argument, and also apparently told Showalter some version of, "Look... we got it wrong, but don't push your luck. Jones only advances to 3rd." I state this because if the umpires stood by their bad call fully, Jones should've been awarded home based on the throw going into the stands, according to the rule. So they got it wrong, and instead of fully correcting the situation OR continuing on the same wrong tangent, they just made up their own rule on the spot. Classic.*

Definitely out of baseline. Umpires said never mind the evidence, we are always right.

#SaveDodgerFilms

@grandpas_brownies8710

9 жыл бұрын

Agree I dont know if it was The Dodgers stadium owner Or whatever Told him he is banned from filming not fair thought this was a free country

@PicoRiveraCalifornia

9 жыл бұрын

William Calabretto Dodger legal team said no. They're just scared that people will not go to the games and see his vids. Dodgers Legal team are pu$$ie$.

@luigifratto926

9 жыл бұрын

Even though it's a free country it says u can't retransmit it

@audis4299

9 жыл бұрын

William Calabretto Yeah but to be fair it is the Dodgers' property.

@grantgilcrease7522

9 жыл бұрын

Ryan Coffey i liked dodger films but it does say no transmission or distribution without the express written consent of the mlb

Joe Girardi has every right to be pissed off. That was a super illegal slide. How can that be counted as a run?

If I were Girardi , I would move the base bag to the position where pearce just slipped to.

I hate it when players do that I'm like "play the game fair"

@nolanj6744

9 жыл бұрын

Yes I hate the Yankees but that was interference GO BOSTON RED SOX!!!!!!!!!!!!

@giraffelord3056

9 жыл бұрын

+Nolan J oh good I was confused with the Los Angeles Red Sox

@renardmigrant

9 жыл бұрын

Greg Csak it's not really a dirty play, just the umpires called it wrong. He was maybe 3 feet away from being able to touch the bag, if it's 10 feet then that's dirty.

@exarkunrocks

8 жыл бұрын

Martin Gardner if you're any distance at all away from being able to touch the bag, with your toes up, and no attempt is being made at reaching for the bag you're sliding way far away from, then it definitely is a dirty play. Not only is it interference, that kind of a move could have cost Johnson a long trip to the DL and Pearce a long suspension. Or should have, at any rate.

@renardmigrant

8 жыл бұрын

exarkunrocks I think he just got a little further from the bag than he intended to. You don't have to attempt to touch the bag, it's not in the rules. 7.09 (d) says "Comment: If the batter or a runner continues to advance after he has been put out, he shall not by that act alone be considered as confusing, hindering or impeding the fielders." Barring any evidence to the contrary, he didn't intend to go out of the base path, he just ended up there.

Interference by a retired runner ... The next closest runner to home is out. That should be the ruling.

@Y2JWannabe93

7 жыл бұрын

MrOpi6 nah interference which means he's automatically out and the batter is therefore out which would just mean runner on second which would of been Adam Jones

How did they fuck that up even after seeing the mark 5 feet away from the base

OMG! Not only did he go out of the baseline, he went straight towards the other side of 3rd, knowing full well Johnson was heading there! Pearce had no intention of touching 3rd. PLUS he was long out before he even started sliding! CLEARLY should have been interference!

Gotta love how the MLB is dealing with all these collision rules. It seems to me that the more obvious the base runners intent to collide, the less likely the umps are to call interference. The only time it’s called is when both the fielder and the runner had every right to collide. I just don’t understand what the umpires are thinking about when they make these calls. The rules aren’t badly written, they’re just terribly enforced.

The slide also nearly got a fan injured too.

As a diehard Yankees lover/fan, I see why Joe was pissed here

way to go mlb

Fuck that bank of america llama god damnit!!!!! AHHHHHHH

It's not interference, as he can touch the base with his hand. But with that being said, that rule reeds to change. You should have to slide into the bag. Watching the Pirates player break his leg this week, just shows how badly this rule needs to change.

If you look closely at the runner he pivoted towards where the third baseman was going

More importantly, did Johnson get an error on the throw? Shouldn't have.

If you’re pissed at Utleys dirty slide, you should be pissed at this one also.

At least they hot the call on keeping Jones at 3rd correct.

I want to know, was the guy who slid into that area between 3rd and home. Did he get drilled his next at bat? I figured that would be an obvious next step.

What’s the point of non reviewable calls if we have the technology to do so?

i know this is really old but you can clearly see that his last step before sliding he redirected himself into the thrower, running completely straight then all of the sudden a redirect, he was even looking at the thrower i would think if you were trying to slide and hit the base to get safe then you would be staring at the base, he was also miles away from the base having to completely layout to reach it with his hand

Yakeyas are my favrot team

You could see that the runner started sliding before the third baseman takes a shuffle foward

Joe has the right to be mad. This should be able to replay bc pulse they are already looseing

It’s amazing that they allowed the runners to move up.

CLEAR case of INTERFERENCE

Situations like that. Just step on a leg, they'll learn to play fair or get carried off

+defiantone exactly

That was a BRUTAL non call. Blatant to everyone in the stands except the umps.

Runner was out of reach of the base - and his slide was actually moving him further away from the base.

Why aren't there at least inner base lines drawn out on the field?

It's obvious interference. Their operating principle is apparently something other than getting the call correct.

This means the umps suck

@gazzygarcia878

8 жыл бұрын

Coming from 2 met fans, I 100% agree

@greysonG10

8 жыл бұрын

I've always wondered., what makes you guys a mets fan from a Yankee fan if you live in NY..? Same with Jets and Giants.. Do you just choose one at an early age or something...?

@mysocalledknife07

8 жыл бұрын

+Greysen Gagné... Becoming a Mets fan or a Yankees fan is a cruel joke and curse passed down from our parents, depending on which fans they happen to be 😂😂😂

@ruthmontesa6934

6 жыл бұрын

Greysen Gagné maybe people don't like the history the team had. Or the franchise history.

@batwayne708

5 жыл бұрын

@@greysonG10 at least some New Yorkers stick to one team unlike many others... Also Mets represent Long Island which is where I rather live than New York City if I were to move to New York.

Alex would’ve made that, even with that slide. Yes the runner was off the path but that throw was initially bad.

Look at it 👀

If you want to breakup the double play, please breakup it in any part of your area can touch the base bag. If you can't touch the base bag in any part of your area, and breakup the double play also slide to the defender, that's call "murder".

No futebol, um carrinho maldoso desses talvez resultasse em vermelho direto.

Following the Ruben Tejada incident I think this play will be reviewed a lot more

That was such a dirty Slide in my opinion No reason for that

the runner look like he impacted the throw ,but it might been a case where he was trying to get out the way when he started sliding the 3rd baseman was on the bag :44 i'm not sure how much direction control Pearce may have what Pearce could you assume what a fielder gonna do or where he is i kinda think it might be accidental what call should have been is running is out on the force and runners on 1st and 2ed.

I hate the Yankees but this is SOOO clear. How the umpires missed this is CRAZY!!! That's how knees and ankles are blown out. Ridiculous!!

there's a difference between a good hard slide into the bag and going out of your way

What did they rule what was the outcome

Jeez its ridiculous how many of these videos their are.

Where was the third base ump

What was the call after that third base slide bullshit?

Get off your knees umpire you’re blowing the game

That runner was so out of his way, he was called safe at home.

If you're sliding in 3rd, your feet should be first to touch. Doesn't seem like an accident when they're facing towards home plate instead of the bag.

Should have been Interference, out at 1st & 3rd.

This is an example of poor umpiring. The slide mark is plain as day and Girardi even points it out and the umpires look directly at it and they completely ignore it. You have evidence of where the baserunner was and can see that he was completely out of the basepath.

I could see this slide being done in a really close game. Not when you have a 3-0 lead

If I am correct if the ball is out of play the runners on first and second only get one base so Jones does not score he only goes to third

@alanhess9306

8 жыл бұрын

+colbylaskey james1629 No, The throw was the second play by an infielder so each runner gets two bases from the time of the throw.

He didn’t even pretend to reach for the bag.

Red sox fan here, this was such an obvious interference how can you get such a simple call wrong:(

That's insane! Clearly interference.

I was studying for fluid mechanics and am now here. The internet is wild.

What they should have done is eject the slider, and let the runners be on 1st and second, the slider interfered with the play so it shouldn't be called as a double.

Heck*

this clip always really bothers me. thats not baseball man..

So is this baseball or is this soccer??

@gamertag6614

8 жыл бұрын

+Jcameron2244 why would u ask such a dumb question.

@Jcameron-nt7jn

8 жыл бұрын

+Gamer tag you obviously don't understand my sarcasm i was referring to how the slide from Pearce looked like a slide tackle

@counterfit5

6 жыл бұрын

That's a straight red in soccer

@alexo.6557

6 жыл бұрын

Jcameron2244 good point and yeah that's a red card

At the 0.45 mark you can see Pearce throws himself to the left to take out the baseman.

I just watched 4 minutes of arguing for no resolution

yeah I'm not a Yanks fan but this is ridiculous and totally uncalled for

At first look is appears to be blatant interference, but there is one thing that could work in Pearce's favour. When Pearce starts moving to his left, Johnson has one foot on the base and the other behind it. So Pearce may have thought that Johnson was going to throw while he was on the base without making too much more movement, and moved to his left to avoid hitting Johnson, as Johnson was on the base. But this didn't work because Johnson then overran the base, and they collided anyway. Maybe that doesn't change anything, but it could.

I would have challenged the play to see if the runner ever touched third in the first place. Then the umpires would see that it was obvious interference.

The runner on third is out and the run does not score because the ball needs to be thrown by the outfielder to be able to advance 2 bases and that's obstruction

Steve Pearce I thought that was Placido Polanco

Only if replays where around at this time

@ruthmontesa6934

6 жыл бұрын

Robert L Guarnaccia are you fucking stupid. They said that they can't replay that kind of play

@robertlguarnaccia5657

6 жыл бұрын

Ruth Montesa yeah I comment during the video and then I heard Kay said it isn't reviewable

This should have been ruled a double play with one runner being at 2nd base. How they don't call this a double play I'll never know. Ironically, there are rules in place now where he would have been called out, but he should have been called out anyways because there is no way the runner can touch that base.

Ese es doble play el corredor que va atercera base se fue en cima del tercera base y no buscar la base ese es doble play

oh boy, they got it wrong there

Again, Vic on the dish.

None of this would have happened if Greg Gibson the home plate umpire was motioning to both players

And today's game that would be an automatic triple play with the new Ruben Tejada rule in place

He tried to trip him what the helck

We have come to a point where players and managers need to point a gun at referees and umpires to overturn poor calls. You give them a choice they reverse the bad call and they can go home or not and that's that

es una interferencia intencional y deliberada el bateador debe ser out por interferencia del corredor de 2B

They ended up teammates that year. Must have been weird at the clubhouse