I was there and the bass was huge!!!!!!!!!

@JaLa248

Жыл бұрын

I’m jealous! 😅

would have been cool to see John walk out with a french horn

@RisvoldTheGreat

5 жыл бұрын

Lol fuck off mate

Good Lord. John is giving the drummer this look like "keep up, sonny, I'm not waiting for you." What an absolutely amazing performance. And what always kills me is just how EASY he makes it look.

@YouzTube99

3 жыл бұрын

@Moose004 Agreed -- and the drummer is freakin' Simon Phillips! I got the sense that, unlike other musicians, he never went all out and had at least one more gear that he could shift into if anyone was able to challenge him. Townshend was occasionally able to get him to rev it up during shows but even he said that John's playing was just on a completely different level.

@JonHop1

3 жыл бұрын

welp he did play with Moon the Loon

@michaelkopacz6324

2 жыл бұрын

The drummer is excellent. What's with that cheesy guitar tone? Sounds like a toaster gone bad.

@tombednar6336

Жыл бұрын

Simon Phillips on the drums !!! One of The Best !

@thehyperspacefamilytree652

Жыл бұрын

Really? I thought it was the first time I heard John able to "relax" and count on a steady beat instead of having to keep it steady for the AMAZING, but...Keith Moon.

Absolutely amazing that's what a lead bass solo in a song sounds like effortless enjoying what he does and like Rodger says don't know how good this guy really is amazing rest in peace glad I got to see you 20 times in my life before you left this Earth rest in peace the memory lives on

THE OX RIP I LOVE THE MAN N I LOVE THE BASS GUITAR HE RIPS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1 BASS PLAYER EVER

Thunder fingers with his phallic monstrosity of a guitar. We miss you!

John is everything in this song 🖤🕷

Apart from an amazing performace from these amazing guys led by the amazing John "The Ox" Entwistle....it was just really nice to see the true emotions between John & Roger.........freinds form way back.......Nice...

I think they told him not to blow everyone away. He kept looking back at the amp volume. He was watching Roger so he knew what notes to play. He couldnt here at that decible! The great Ox!

This will blow your mind if a John Entwhistle fan - the LEAD instrument as it should be.

I saw the WHO so many times, three with Keith, and about 12 times after, and the first tour after the OX died and Dino took his place. I am a bass player and John was always one off my favorites,Dino is a good player but no one can replace John.I can see the WHO without Kieth but not without John, I can't see the Who anymore,they are not the WHO without JOHN ENTWISTLE !!!!

@caryborden397

Жыл бұрын

Had the same experience. And feel exactly the same.

@freddystone7584

2 ай бұрын

It’s Pino not Dino! Just saying

@frankperricone2065

2 ай бұрын

@@freddystone7584 Wow, I did write Dino instead of Pino, my bad.

This was Awesome! John’s absolutely amazing… I really focused on John watching the drummer…. & the looks he was giving him, towards the end, did you notice John was challenging him a bit! Like adding more drums on his Bass!!!!! FANTASTIC!

Beautiful....Rog gives John a kiss to welcome him, he's so proud John came to help him out with his band playing Daltrey Plays Townsend. Would have been nice to hear John better in this recording, but it's a treasure, nonetheless.

@luciajohnson7461

2 жыл бұрын

Bad mix in an otherwise epic peformance

@luciajohnson7461

2 жыл бұрын

Shut up phillips and make way of the real master

@JaLa248

Жыл бұрын

All 4 of these guys hard a Special Love for one another! ❤❤❤❤ Undeniable!

2 very extra special nights in NYC for Roger's 50th birthday... 16 yrs John is gone today but as always never forgotten and a true shooting star ..I was there and didn't realize he tapped Pino Palladino out... Keith did it with Kenney replacing him to it seems... Thanks for posting this...my favorite of John's unparelled never duplicate genius.. Love & miss you always... Thanks for the music John and your kindness too

I sure miss the Ox, so did the Who when they recorded the last album without him. The electricity was sadly absent! RIP John!

Bass not loud enough!

@muzicaempathica6479

3 жыл бұрын

@Vince Paladino ~ Should'a turned it up to 11‼

a great man !

Very disappointing editing. He was ripping through one of his patented bass lines and all we saw while he was doing it was the back of Roger's head. The problem is, they do this every single time, no matter which Who video you watch. We're made to watch Pete play power chords or Roger throw his mic around, while Entwistle provides the real value to the songs.

@notthatdonald1385

2 жыл бұрын

Very poor sound man too. Could hardly hear John.

@raymondchollet3199

2 жыл бұрын

One of my top 3 bands. Entwhitsel, was a great multi chord bassist.

@terryanngallagher3605

2 жыл бұрын

@@raymondchollet3199 The absolute best who ever lived. When he died it took four guys to continue in his place with the 2002 tour, trying their best to emulate what he did with only a bass guitar. Sure miss him. Long live the WHO!!!😀

@golf4ubacknine768

Жыл бұрын

🥱

@luisamendes8181

8 ай бұрын

I agree. And in this case the bass line IS the song. Besides I don’t think that show was well produced and organised. The mood in the venue was probably good. As a video It’s almost waste of time for me

Bloody Entwistle was a legend!

@petebradt

3 жыл бұрын

IS a legend.

@raymondchollet3199

2 жыл бұрын

Entwhistle would have gotten along great with jaco pastorious. Another defining world class bassist.

Great performance with also Simon and Phil palmer, i love how John looks permanently Simon, almost to the end John thinking "Roger, when are you goin' singing"; at 5.36 there is a ghost shaking hand between Pino and John lol

Thunder _in_ Carnegie Hall.

I Love this performance!!!! These guys never get old..!!’❤

Great. Drummer

This Whole Concert was Fantastic!

Nice! Invited to play without any speakers

Спасибо! Очень приятно и интересно !🙂👍🙃

RIP John Entwistle 🙏

The Ox is incredible!’

i love at the end, he shakes Pino Palladino's hand

@stevedrums1675

6 жыл бұрын

Kind of an irony there.

@YouzTube99

5 жыл бұрын

@Jesse Fields: Missed that -- thanks for pointing it out. Pino's the only person in the organization taller than John's amps. Too bad some of John's aggression didn't rub off on him.

@petebradt

3 жыл бұрын

@@YouzTube99 Pino is a HORRIBLE player in the Who, they have Jon Button listed as a permanent road band member. He can play a lot of Entwistle licks, but even that pales to the real deal.

@YouzTube99

3 жыл бұрын

@@petebradt I think your qualification -- "in the Who" nails it. Pino is clearly a fine musician, IMO he just isn't a good fit for a the Who.

@donbrogan3158

3 жыл бұрын

Simon Phillips is the worse......

Why does the guitar sound like a weed whipper cutting newspapers?

@coldwar45

8 жыл бұрын

+Neil Kraft You win the internet lol

J'aime bien, à 4:23 John trouve le moyen de faire un petit signe à quelqu'un en plein solo de basse. :)

The best Who album.

The fans after John came out. "Screw the other bass player Can he just stay?"

It's more a tribute to Simon Philips... What a drummer

John is the man 👨 in this song sounds awesome

Awesome! Merci beaucoup for posting! :D

This tour was dynamite 🎸

It would have been nice if the cameraman would have given Entwistle a little more air time with his wonderful bass playing.

At 4:00 , the percussionist is just staring at John as if he ( the drummer ) was in the audience.

Música do meu coração ❤️❤️❤️❤️

John entwistle,tony levin,marcus miller,jaco pastorius, on a les meilleurs là.

I remember this gig..I got it on pay per view...$50.00

😍😍😍😍😍

❤️

Best who drummers that I’ve seen .. Simon Philips Zak Starkey Kenny Jones Scott Devour

@jeffmusgrave6467

4 жыл бұрын

There was a member of the band called Keith Moon are you brain-dead he was chaos on the drums and no one could replicate his beat

@jeffmusgrave6467

4 жыл бұрын

And they Were drummers that were much better than what you picked John Barnum Neil Peart Ginger Baker oh and by the way Keith Moon do you even know anything about rock and roll

@golf4ubacknine768

4 жыл бұрын

Sorry Jeff that I have to explain to you ... I was talking about THEWHO drummers I had the privilege to see live . It’s not what goes in a mans mouth which defiles them , it’s what comes out !

@christinecollins6648

2 жыл бұрын

What they’re saying here, I’ll interpret, is they were never blessed to see Moon live

@JaLa248

Жыл бұрын

Hey Kenny Jones was a great drummer too in his own right!!!

Came here for the bass, but it didn't arrive. There must be a better recording of this performance...

That's what lead bass looks like

Fucking hell its entwistle no H to be seen

OX!!

4:10 Poor drummer is totally overmatched by this song. Moon doesn't get a huge amount of respect but unlike Bonham or Peart, few can even start to emulate him. I'm not Bonham, heck, I'm not even a drummer, but I learned the top 10 Bonham parts and can easily play Limelight note for note. I can't even play 4 measures in a row of The Real Me.

He. Had. Some. Funky. Hair. Lol

roadies smile in the background and having a good time too....

Something was missing ... something like a bass sound

The last half way sub-optimal. Daltrey stompted on the bass finale or John went to soon. I'm thinking the former.

Crank it up, please

From 4:45 til 5:01, is that Lemmy from Motorhead lurking behind the drummer? One awesome bassist enjoying another?

@ewyss9206

Жыл бұрын

No, might be the late Michael Kamen, the guy who did S/M with Metallica...

John to late the hero it jams

@5jerry1

Жыл бұрын

~ Too *

The Ox!

That snare drum sounds like a tin of sardines...

What the hell happened to the audio? My 22 year old VHS copy I recorded when this first aired on The Disney channel sounds better then this, It's very clear, but it's all over compressed so nothing has any power

@Djarra

6 жыл бұрын

When it was uploaded KZread compressed the heck out of everything, because fact then they could handle it.

@cameroncooper4175

5 жыл бұрын

It sounds like a mix taken straight out of the board, totally dry with no ambient sound.

@ProSimex84

3 жыл бұрын

Your vhs has the audio quality of a reel to reel, youtube is shite.

If. Any. Band. Was. 2. Fight. Da. Who. U. Would. Have. Got. Ur. Azz. Kicked

Needs a re-mix. Turn up the bass!!

Simon Brunsick is a world class drummer, but it is weird...it sounds too professional, yet somehow stale. It misses the manicness/the beat/heart call it what you like.....Of the early Who!

toooo much fuzz on that lead

who's on drum ?

@D13fs

Жыл бұрын

Simon Phillips

@sylvaindubois9508

Жыл бұрын

drummer of the late show with David Letterman ???

@D13fs

Жыл бұрын

@@sylvaindubois9508 No, just google him yourself for more info.

there no Thunder!! the song is ruined.

Wasp covers it better

@BobInKC1

5 жыл бұрын

lol

@russlund2507

4 жыл бұрын

@@BobInKC1 riiiiiiiiiight

@shanetobias291

2 жыл бұрын

The who doesn't cover it !! The who created the song you dunce!!!

@brianj9262

2 жыл бұрын

@@shanetobias291 let me use small words so you'll understand, wasps cover is better than the original. Who uses the word dunce? How old are you?

@juliebryne2903

11 ай бұрын

No!

The simplistic cd simultaneously carve because ravioli relatedly wonder than a sweltering soup. scarce, yellow skate

Guitar sounds fucking appallingly bad...

@5jerry1

Жыл бұрын

~ Like a transistor radio between AM stations.

This sounds horrible. No guts to it. That guitar player butchered his part....

@ronkonkoma7718

5 жыл бұрын

The upload does not mean the performance sucked. It isn't even 480p for better sound online. I don't recall bad sound on my VHS from a rebroadcast.

Terrible sound! Makes it sound like literally EVERYONE is playing tinny toy instruments bought that afternoon at Walmart! 😢

Bad drummer!

@jabold

Жыл бұрын

I'm really disappointed with Simon Phillips here (and I'm a big Simon and Who fan. And a drummer). He's playing a standard, straight beat. The song does not require that. It's not what Moon originally played on Quadrophenia. It's like trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. Not going to happen, sounds like crap.

The rhythm guitar spoils the sound . The guitar player is not Pete Townshend , giving space to John's bass.