What do you think the main character is feeling Guilty about? Were they a high ranking member of Playtime Co.?

@FSaLP24

4 ай бұрын

I think they were once an orphan at Playcare, but when they grew up they became the Head of Production

@TRG_R17

4 ай бұрын

​​​​@@FSaLP24This doesn't make sense. For one, the orphan kids wouldn't help playtime co torture and test more orphan kids. The evidence I have for this is it clearly shows in the arg and tapes that every orphan kid hated the playtime employee. That's why in the hour of joy, they kill every employee that was in the building. For two, if the main character was an orphan, he/she would be looking for other orphans, not other employees that are good and not. My evidence for this is, it keeps getting repeated we want to find just the employees. Miss delight brought it up when Barb told us what he thought we were doing in the school. Poopy brought it up when she showed us the hour of joy. Lastly, it makes more sense for us to be an adult that got hired as one of the higher ups of playtime co, doing the test on the orphan kids, and having guilt for doing them. The evidence I have for this is in project playtime, we play as a higher up, talking to a bigger body that tells us we are why they exist. We know it can't be the doctor since around project playtime, he would be dead by probably the prototype. We know it's not Leith, since he's the one sending people to the factory to continue the bigger body initiative. We also know it's not any other higher up, since they would have probably died in the hour of joy, leaving just our main character, one of the few survivors of that event.

@JeordieChef

4 ай бұрын

I think the kids are still alive and that’s where poppy is taking us. She says “all of us” a few times and that must mean more than kissy, Ollie and herself. I imagine the main character felt bad for the children who were being horribly treated by playtime. I think he made the toys go mad to kill the evil scientists and workers but feels guilty as some workers and scientists weren’t evil but were also killed during the hour of joy. It is also possible he feels guilt for killing huggy as there was most likely a child inside of huggy and huggy only attacked bc he was starving and that’s why he saw huggy in his dream. Also maybe he feels like he should’ve died with the others and feels guilty for living while his friends and coworkers were killed.

@PlatonAndHisChannel

4 ай бұрын

Yes they are a high ranking member because when we come out of the slides in chapter two you could see another slide with the letters all mixed up on the floor and that is actually the name of the player mixed up

@Phant0mPers0n.

4 ай бұрын

I think he feels guilty for running away and letting all those people die and never mention it to the public letting the guilt consume him and making him travel back to fix his doing

I believe when the voice says that the protagonist murders and pillages, they’re referring to the toys that the protagonist has taken down as well as the parts of the factory they destroyed

@GamerMage2k-kl4iq

4 ай бұрын

I agree

@Jazzatic2011

4 ай бұрын

I mean i too think its about huggy and mommy being affected. However... what parts of the factory have we really destroyed?

@wolf0220

4 ай бұрын

I agree 😊

@wolf0220

4 ай бұрын

@@GamerMage2k-kl4iqsame

@Waffle_ShortBoi

3 ай бұрын

Agreed 👍 but I think he still was responsible for something bad...

The protagonist is probably innocent but felt guilty for leaving his coworkers before they died or … maybe he was the one paid to not tell it all

@Ayakachannn

4 ай бұрын

I like this theorie

I'm thinking the protagonist was a scientist that just didn't show up that day when the Hour of Joy happened. Poppy even says that the protagonist didn't do anything wrong.

@scrambledEgg69

4 ай бұрын

I’m thinking the protagonist is Rich from the VHS tapes. We know that not all PTC employees know about the BBI, and we know that Rich isn’t exactly happy with the company in his tapes. What if Rich got fired/quit shortly before the Hour of Joy happened?

@ahmedmongy5557

4 ай бұрын

@@scrambledEgg69 I don’t think so because in our dreams we heard that our presence was demanded on 8/8/1995 the day the hour of joy happened so either we just got lucky and didn’t show up that day or we were involved in the hour of joy and knew what was going to happen

@AnonymousEnigma19

4 ай бұрын

​@@ahmedmongy5557that's been my theory, because I think maybe once upon a time the protagonist used to be an orphan at this orphanage and knew all the children that became the bigger body toys but he was one of the lucky ones that got adopted, he came back to work for playtime Co in order to help orphans like he was help but he found out about its darkness and it disgusting he came across the Prototype and he planned with the Prototype the hour of joy but the sad thing is I don't think either him or the Prototype wanted it to go that far because I think the plan was for them to use the chaos in order to help the children Escape.

@hikaruyuugure6900

4 ай бұрын

It is heavily implied that the protagonist is one of the executives. Poppy notes the protagonist did nothing wrong. She sees the hour of joy as sensless slaughter and the experiments as horrible. So the protagonist is not involved in either happening. Innovation was Doctor Harley and then Laith. Harley was gone prior to the hour of joy and laith took over. Laith is the one sending specialist in in project playtime so he survived the hour of joy. Playcare was stella and research was eddie. We do not know who the head of production was as their name is blocked out in many ways every time hey are noted. As poppy says the protagonist did nothing wrong then saying they are laith would not make sense. He was proud of his work much like the doctor harley was. They where the ones in charge of turning people into toys. People not children since thomas was turned into a toy after he had cancer as a employee. If innovation leads where the ones in charger of the "bigger bodies" project which was turning people into toys then one can assume production was literally just making real toys. Not monsters. Since monsters where handled by innovation and playcare. It would make sense that production knew nothing as was the ones making toys and commercials. The good face of the company. The prototype and catnap loved the kids. The other toys wanted to eat them. It would make sense that the prototype would show mercy to one whom only truly worked for the joy of the kids and knew nothing of the truth until the end. Last is that in project playtime which is after the hour of joy... laith has the players collect parts to rebuild a relic of the past. Relic?

@scrambledEgg69

4 ай бұрын

@@ahmedmongy5557 responding to you but in juncture with Hikarus comment, maybe Rich/Us were head of Production? We learn in a VHS that Stu is retiring and thinking of giving his job to Rich. We don’t know Stus job exactly, but from how shocked Rich sounded, i think it’s safe to say Stu was pretty high up within the company. We also have Poppy tell us that *we* did nothing wrong, that we were innocent/blind to the company’s true intentions. We also know that the BBI was a ‘need to know’ basis’s, so maybe Rich/us/stu/whoever was in charge of toy production (actual toys, not monsters) had no idea what was going on?

It would be interesting to learn if the Protagonist is either Innocent or Guilty.

@lulu.boa.

4 ай бұрын

its like ur the judge

@featherguardian6023

4 ай бұрын

@@lulu.boa. I’m saying this as a Compliment as in Playtime Co. sure there were People that did Horrible Things to the Experiments but not everyone knew about the Truth

@azaleamartinez1048

4 ай бұрын

Judging from the dream sequences in chapter 3 I think the protagonist feels guilty for what they done

@lulu.boa.

4 ай бұрын

@@featherguardian6023 woops sorry i forget to put /pos 😭😭

Judging by the footage of Huggie, it appears that the hero was an employee of Innovation, and was part of The Coucil of Playcare, and that he was dissatisfied with his work there. The child's body was most likely planted by the hero as revenge on Ludwig and company for what he had to do at Playtime.

@GamerMage2k-kl4iq

4 ай бұрын

Ooooooh! That’s a very good possibility and could definitely explain that part of the dream sequence!!!

@Jazzatic2011

4 ай бұрын

Oh I didnt even think about the protage planting the body to be found at elliots house to get the company in trouble.

@tomasrolter6729

Ай бұрын

@@Jazzatic2011 Because that's what made me wonder why it was so important for the characters that the body was found. (Sorry it's late.)

I think the protagonist is definately Stella at this point. For sure. Her entire story has been unfolding before us in magnificent fashion in every single chapter, and probably for the purpose of it pointing to her as the protagonist. She was so utterly naïve and played blind into the hands of the scientists and lab workers for quite some time as evidence shows, helping test and select children, but unsure as to why she's doing this and to what end. What I think is, after she found out the horrible truth of what playtime has really been doing to the orphans, she agreed to help the prototype and other big bodied toys to break free through the hour of joy. She helped put it into motion, and she was supposed to be present the day of..but she never showed up. This also might be why the bigger bodies are hesitant to actually go through with straight up killing her, such as Cat Nap and the prototype. Always writing 'GO BACK.' 'GO HOME'. 'LEAVE.' Catnap doesn't try to kill us until we've ignored all warnings and went too far.. They still respect her for helping them as much as they did to set up the hour of joy, yet still angry she wasn't physically there for it. She feels immense guilt and horror for the pain she inadvertently put the orphans through, explaining the writing and the backwards audio.. She came back to now help in any way she can. She wants to be free of her guilt and finally face the truth.

@GamerMage2k-kl4iq

4 ай бұрын

Oooooo. Now that would be interesting!!!

@sboy2044

4 ай бұрын

CatNap acts like an actual cat, silently stalking his prey before attacking. It’s said multiple times that the player doesn’t know happened to their co-workers.

@TackyAnimootions

4 ай бұрын

@@sboy2044 Respectfully, no, that verbiage was never used. What was used was 'Find out what happened', which makes sense considering our protagonist was sent a sudden mysterious letter allegedly from said coworkers, saying 'We're still here.' Naturally, they went back to playtime to find out what happened considering the contents of that letter, it still adds up to the theory and holds strong.

@sboy2044

4 ай бұрын

@@TackyAnimootions But according to your theory wouldn’t Stella know what happened?

@Starvaze

4 ай бұрын

If we're Stella? Then where the heck is her encounter dialogues. With huggy Mommy and catnap?

I think the protagonist could be an escaped bigger body, as they might have technically "worked" at Playco and thus be recognized by other toys. Ollie wouldn't group him with the kids though, so his comments about the kids living here makes sense. And he should have been at the hour of joy to help punish the employees, not to be punished. So now he doesn't deserve to be back. And basically what we have is a toy civil war as the utopia they cooked up without humans has basically turned into a worse sort of dictatorship. So this whole time the protagonist could be trying to save other toys and not the human employees.

@CanyonALynn

4 ай бұрын

I like this theory!

@Yume-AW

4 ай бұрын

This makes so much sense now…maybe you’re right!

@cathy94333

4 ай бұрын

I thought this too but then one of miss delights comment referred to us as human I believe

@GamerMage2k-kl4iq

4 ай бұрын

It’s possible that we seem so human when we’re not that we can easily be mistaken for a human by those who don’t know we’re actually a bigger bodies toy

@thisismywill

4 ай бұрын

@@cathy94333 Yeah she definitely says "other humans" and there's plenty of evidence like the missing name over the door or the office with the guilt message to indicate we are human I guess. It's possible we are just a human trying to save the kids the prototype saved via Catnap from daycare as well, and he's kinda just guiding us there. I think they did a great job on the lore.

Given how they are the sole survivor and the radio says “you’re presence was demanded and you weren’t there” I think the protagonist KNEW the hour of joy was going to go down but they felt to guilty to warn the others, while also to cowardly to face the consequences. Which sparks their commitment to coming back when the note is sent

I think the toys don't care if we are guilty or innocent they just want the protagonist dead. One of my theories was what if the protagonist used to be an orphan in the orphanage in the past and then ended up working as a worker. But instead of working as a normal adult instead they were a superhuman test subject to make sure the poppy formula works because our protagonist can die and come back, get injured and live with some damage. It would be an interesting twist. Well whatever it is the Prototype wants us. Because why would Poppy say we were tortured?

@kamyraheard1887

4 ай бұрын

I doubt he is a orphanage the orphanage didn’t open until later years into the Poppy Playtimes Franchise.

@elenatheartistandgamer2001

4 ай бұрын

@@kamyraheard1887 True, but who's to say they didn't collect kids that are 12 and older? It'd Still be messed up regardless. But I can see your point.

@Jazzatic2011

4 ай бұрын

You and I both think poppy talking on revenge of those who tortured “us” is weird eh

@elenatheartistandgamer2001

4 ай бұрын

@@Jazzatic2011 I mean yeah like why would she even say the protag was tortured it doesn't make sense to me. I mean we can wait for chapter 4 or we can ask the Dev directly but I don't think they'd spoil us like that. :L

Guilt haunts you, he definitely knows about the experiments and may be a scientist but he feels remorse

What are more curious about is if we are an ex employee? Why are we so small? Because remember in chapter 1 when we walked past a turntable were the same size of a child

@jazzputmon9990

4 ай бұрын

Part toy part human I think

@cassandra2382

4 ай бұрын

I’m probably reading too much into it, but my twelve year old brother is taller than me and I’m considered “child height” at 5’2 even though I’m in my 20s. Maybe the protagonist is a shorter person. (Probably not though lol)

@gabriellecollier8127

Ай бұрын

If the protag is that small, they are probably female.

@gabriellecollier8127

Ай бұрын

They could be a woman.

What if the player is actually a bigger body and one that looks like a " perfect human "?

@CanyonALynn

4 ай бұрын

Interesting... 🤔

@InvyTheGamer

4 ай бұрын

Well, he isn't very bigger, maybe he's part of the SBI? (Smaller Bodies Initiative)

@codesymbi

4 ай бұрын

This is exactly what i've been saying since chapter 1 Not exactly the Bigger Bodies part but the fact that we're also a toy

@GamerMage2k-kl4iq

4 ай бұрын

I actually do like this idea! It does explain a lot about us in game

@sboy2044

4 ай бұрын

Miss Delight recognizes them as a human

Many people think the player is Rich due to the fact he has every tape in every chapter. One tape in chapter 3, we learn another worker is retiring soon named Stewart. He talks about giving his job to him when he retires. I think his job was higher up and he knew about everything happening. So my theory is that when Rich got his job, he found out what was going on and was too freaked out to go to work on the day when the Hour of Joy.

@MrDumbass66

4 ай бұрын

That actually makes alot of sense

@heartroll8719

4 ай бұрын

@@MrDumbass66 thanks ☺️

@Dave-gk6si

4 ай бұрын

That makes no sense

@heartroll8719

4 ай бұрын

@@Dave-gk6si how? It makes sense.

@Dave-gk6si

4 ай бұрын

@@heartroll8719 The player is in his late 20s. He’s young.

I think the main character is dealing with survivor guilt. I mean how would feel that one day you weren't at work and the next day all your co-workers end up dead. 10 years is long time trying to move on. I don't think main character knew the horrors that were taking place. But since the player was a Playtime worker, they deserve to die with everyone else. I think one of the doctors who did the experiments is alive and they got out somehow and they were the one who put the body at Ludwig estate that way it would take the heat off them and they would come back to finish the prototype themselves. And thanks to the main character getting rid of the prototype servants (Mommy long legs, Catnap, etc.) the doctors can.

I think it is interesting that so many toys recognize the protagonist as working there. It could be an indicator of the protagonist's role in the factory. Suspecion is on a well known role in the factory (such as an executive) or a role that interacted with the living toys (such as a scientist).

5:14 Yes yes yes! I thought I was the only one who thought that it sounded like the protagonist was getting caught in the middle of something by the police. It just makes sense. It leads me to theorize that maybe the protagonist had something to do with how the organs were harvested. Also does anyone else think it’s possible that maybe our protagonist was running from the police and ended up trying to hide out in the Playtime factory? We get a lot of imagery of the forest in our flashbacks and hallucinations. Plus not once through these dreams have we seen a car. So he was on foot most likely. Thanks for pumping out these theories by the way! They’re awesome

this game has me in a chokehold lore wise. i keep going down youtube rabbit holes with theories regarding the game. i love it!

In the nightmare at the room where it has "Guilt Haunts You" scratched into a chalk board, I feel the room itself has a chance of being the Player Characters office in the Factory. Cause how else would you rationalize a room that doesn't match anything else in the rest of the nightmare even Nightmare-Wuggy's room is different, and why would else would "Guilt Haunts You" show up in that room? It's almost as if it's taunting you. Also I think the backwards radio message was more referring to the Player showing up twenty years after the Hour of Joy and had just started killing and breaking things left and right since walking through the doors.

Ever since Mommy long legs revealed she knows the protagonist worked at Playtime Co., I've kind of just accepted that the protagonist is a dead man and there is no escape, regardless if he's guilty or not. Wait, how was it revealed the protagonist was male again?

@greydummy2702

4 ай бұрын

Poppy playtime refers him to it

@ivangarduno630

4 ай бұрын

​@@greydummy2702nop she refieres player as they

@greydummy2702

4 ай бұрын

@@ivangarduno630 with they she meant the employees, Not only the player, I mean the game not poppy herself

@ivangarduno630

4 ай бұрын

@@greydummy2702 nop it's explicitly referering to the player

Player just wanted his last paycheck

@huebcite5016

3 ай бұрын

LOL 😂

Did you guys forget the dialogue Mommy Long Legs said to the player in her Ch. She sad how the workers left her here all alone, and then said if there’s anyone that deserves to be left and rot here it’s us, the worker.

I never heard anyone point to us being the body planter. This is an intriguing idea and I like how you explain the out of place radio voices such as dont move.

This game definitely took inspiration from Bioshock and i feel a twist villian and also the player characters identity reveal is going to come in and be such a mindf*ck

There’s part of me that’s starting to think that the protagonist was made into a toy but maybe looks human enough to pass. Dogday called the protagonist “Poppy’s angel” which could just be a metaphor but what if the protagonist is actually a toy meant to look like an angel?

Another thing is when you're knocked down and have flashbacks in the playcare before the hour of joy. Showing you were there in the facility. You knew what was going on and worked on it.

I speculate the Protagonist most likely knew about the Hour of Joy was to happen and for some reasons was expected by some (the Prototype or the higher staff of the Playtime Co.) to be there, either to aid the staff or the toys, or to even be punished alongside the former for his/her employment at the Playtime Co. (like "you realize you were aiding them to commit horrible atrocities, help us take revenge, but you must pay for your crimes too"), but at some point fear took over and the Protagonist decided not to appear at the factory. I also theorize the Protagonist might be a humanlike toy created by the Playtime Co., that came out perfectly human to become the company's employee. Perhaps that's why the Protagonist was expected to be there during the Hour of Joy?

Is it just me or does the radio sound like Dogday

@Starvaze

4 ай бұрын

Reuse voice acters...

I wonder if our character was a fall guy who took the fall for the murder of the child found in Elliott estate. Why else would he go back? Maybe if he had nothing to lose he figured "fuck it" and decided to go back xm

I think we can be Dr.White that we first heard of in 3 chapter. He was working with kids and personally choosing next for experiments. I saw someone theorize that his name is reference to book Dr.White where dog helped very sick children .Maybe he chose sick kids in hope that company was helping them not aware of what kind of help it was . To why I think we are him: Mommy Longlegs already knew who we were and so Miss Delight .But the difference is that she sounded like she just saw someone who was around some time ago.And could we and her be around? Children from Playcare. Also , in hallucinations we were haunted by the orphanage and kids and not labs or other facilities. Maybe our kindness was the reason why dolls(kids) didn't show hostility unless we went deeper/broke the rules .Hell ,maybe one of them even warned us about mass murder so we could be safe!

Now I see why prototype killed catnap. He wanted to give catnap quick and painless death unlike protagonist who violently killed huggy and mommy

I think it's Rich. He was the only person who showed any concern about the children.

Are we sure the protagonist is a he? He could really be Stella, the lady that was in charge of the orphanage. Also, I think a lot of the workers were former orphans that had to grow up and eventually work for Play Co. So, that would mean that former orphans were experimenting on the orphan children that were there in 1995.

@dynasty701

4 ай бұрын

I really like the theory that we could be playing as Stella. And I agree, we must have been former orphans there that grew up to eventually work (and rise up in rankings) at Playtime Co.

@Neku628

4 ай бұрын

@@dynasty701 So, in a way, the employees are also victims of Play co.

@SparkDost

4 ай бұрын

@@Neku628 stella is already transformed into a toy name poppy how we can play as her!?

@jayceedior8291

4 ай бұрын

​​@@SparkDostI don't know, but I personally believe Ludwig's daughter was somehow revived as Poppy 🤷‍♀️

@Neku628

4 ай бұрын

@@SparkDost Do we know that for sure though?

I have a theory about the protagonist Although there is little to no evidence what if I were to say we were a candidate for an experiment I believe playtime co was going to make a new line of experiments but needed adults as they seem most likely more physically and mentally fit so used employees playtime saw as a “problem” so as our player was incarcerated 1006 came in contact with him and made a deal to help the prototype gain access to certain authorizations after helping the prototype commit the hour of joy he lets the player leave with the warning not to comeback causing us to be guilty for the death of his colleagues

Love your vids just got your jokes and voice. It’s soothing. It’s like ASMR.

In an unused synopsis of Chapter 1 it said the player stayed home due to being sick. If they bring back this idea is TBD

A lot would be explained if the player was a resource extraction specialist from Project Playtime. The only problem with that is PjPt’s placement in the timeline is a bit funky.

Protagonist is 100% the bad guy and returned to the factory to redeem themselves and their coworkers because of the guilt of missing The Hour of Joy. Poppy, Ollie, and Kissy are coworkers. Probably turned by the kids: the chatterbox doll, just a voice giving commands, and a weak, silent monster (mirroring what they did to the child they mangled into Huggy). The Prototype is the first kid to go. Not meant for a final product, that’s why it seems unfinished and needs to build itself. This kid was exposed to a lot of info and torture and lead kids to food, safety, power, and revenge … it saved them. Thats how it became God.

@Val-cl2wd

4 ай бұрын

How are you sure that the protagonist is 100% not good who do you think they are no one do we know their name no. Why Catnap didn't kill us in the beginning or in the office and he ask us to leave the playcare. If we are evil they should have finished us the right time.

Pierre is a name that keeps popping up. I wonder if we're actually him. I feel like he's important in some way. Either him or we're Rich. Rich also appears a lot in this series

Imagine if the twist is the protagonist just feels guilty because they called in sick the day the Hour of Joy of happened.

I don't think he had anything related to what happened to Elliot Ludwig, however I think he had a massive role in the experiments done to the poor orphans in playtime. Co, helping in the creation of the bigger bodies program. And I think he didn't get fired, or went on vacation, I think he just quit, his guilt finally getting the better of him, and making him leave. And when he finally got that letter about his fellow playtime. Co employes being still alive, he wanted to fix his mistakes by helping his fellow employes and helping the poor children that were experimented on. And I do think the cardboard cut outs are directly talking to our character (atleast most of them). So yeah our character is definetely a bad person. I also wanted to just say that most of the employees were good people, as most of them had no idea of the horrible experimentations and shady stuff going behind the scenes in the place they were working in, as mentioned by Poppy herself.

It could be survivor's guilt. I don't know if every single employee was in on the fact that there was experimentation. For example, the desk lady didn't understand what it meant when they put experimentation on the adoption paperwork. It meant that one employee didn't know it was going on. Clearly, the protagonist now knows what happened. But that doesn't necessarily mean he did know before the hour of joy.

NO THEY WANTED THEYRE GOD DAMN PAYCHECK

@Starvaze

4 ай бұрын

Ah, I see you're a PSTL viewer aswell

@Ducky_VR_16

4 ай бұрын

@@Starvaze yeah

9:55 you used the same script twice by accident I believe. Other than that great video and hopefully this could become your job one day!

The neighbors had to be awake at those odd hours of the night to see Elliot but theyre judging him for it😂

I hear most people assume the protag is a man, but I saw someone recently make a really compelling argument that the protag is actually Stella, and I'm lowk obsessed with that theory

@greydummy2702

4 ай бұрын

No way we playing as that psycho, Neither leith, there are 3 things that hint to protag being a man

The music in the backround is nostalgic 7:53

I think the protagonist is the bad guy due to the fact that huggy didn’t attack the player on sight, but only attacked us when we restarted the facility, he probably suspected us trying to initiate the experiments on children again and saw it as his duty to stop us. 1/3

@Hiloafer

4 ай бұрын

Mommy long legs also had several chances to kill us but decided to give us 2 out of 3 train codes(although via deadly challenges) but let her thirst for revenge rig the third game(as she stated that the children would come and never come back,and that if anyone deserved to die it’s us). 2/3

@Hiloafer

4 ай бұрын

Catnap also had probably the most opportunities to kill us due to the fact that we caught him peeking in the room, dropping us down the disposal, ambushing us and throwing us into a room,even going as far as to say “Leave playcare or I’m coming for you”, and upon powering up the door and him proceeding to slowly walk towards us even though he’s presumably much faster than us. All these circumstances lead me to believe that we are the villains of the game not the victims. 3/3. Note: sorry if my grammar isn’t that good.

@jamhh1

4 ай бұрын

thing is, why would poppy help us then? and also, why would mommy give us 2 train codes if her files said that she WILL attack any of the works near her. And why would huggy think were trying to experiment on the kids if they were ONLY in the orphanage? AND why would OLLIE help us as well? If we were the bad guys, why would kissy, poppy, and ollie help us? And we both know how much hatred the toys have when it comes to meeting with one of the facility workers related in the Bigger Bodies Initiative.

@Hiloafer

4 ай бұрын

@@jamhh1 I suspect poppy isn’t our friend because after killing mommy long legs she says”did you kill her…..good” with a attitude that sounds more satisfied than relieved(as if she was more of an obstacle than an enemy). that and the fact that on the train as we’re attempting to escape she proceeded to say we’re too perfect to lose so soon leads me to believe that she’s possibly using us to simply help her achieve her goal. Which in my opinion isn’t to kill the prototype and free all the toys, but rather overthrow him and bring the toys under her own rule.

@Hiloafer

4 ай бұрын

Just my opinion anyway

I know this theory may be far out there but what if the antagonist, that is going through the motions is reflecting on the world he created. The monsters he influenced It may be off but what if the protagonist is the Prototype reflecting on the world he created!

Here are my thoughts, but first I would like to mention I think you may be digging a bit too deep into the whole dream=he planted the body and was evil. CatNap's signature affect of the gas was inducing nightmares. While there is obvious guilt, the way the voices speak out and blame MC specifically is how nightmares tend to be. First up: MC was working for playtime up until right after the HoJ. The radio mentioning he was supposed to be there really tells it all. The way it's worded is that he was probably off that day for whatever reason and survivors guilt is eating away at them, not that he knew of the HoJ. -Planted Body = I personally don't believe MC planted the body, as we don't have a date of death for Elliot, nor do we really know if MC disliked him. I do believe however that Elliot died before the HoJ, seeing as the playCoTimeWhatever still existed. -pillage and destroy :)= This could be two ways. MC probably, more than likely, knew of the bigger body project. This line could either be about him destroying what's here now, or what he did/accepting while working there. -The body= I'd just like to add this here, the body missing organs and bones probably meant they were used for the bigger body. Lastly, or at least what I can remember, I don't believe the stands are anything more than filler horror pieces. They don't really mention anything that ever impacts lore, and the whole elephant theory is ignoring that the Elephant is synonymous with having an amazing memory (Which is why it mentions remembering 'you'). Them being speakers for the toys probably wouldn't work either, as we know all the smile critters are dead, yet they still have lines. (In my eyes, the MC is guilty of knowing/working on the Bigger Body, but not guilty of anything more. If he is innocent and didn't know, thats honestly just gonna be a plothole for me)

I wonder if poppy recognises our character, or will she have a misunderstanding later and become one of the boss battles

you are the only KZreadr that brings that theory into question I've been saying this since the first chapter what do we really know about our player ? just that he left right when everything went down and we don't have the answers to that question. I don't believe we are some type of hero and I think the player will die in this game after we find out what he was a part of that people know and after they kill the prototype the real colors will show

My theory is that the protagonist is the person mentioned in the Kissy Missy poster of Does and Don'ts and it says do not hide to scare (I forgot the name) and now all they got are toys hiding and scaring them. Also the protag knows how to manage everything making me think they worked in maintenance which is why all of the toys recognized them. I don't get why ppl are saying that the protag did know what happened and stayed home that day since they went to Playtime to find out what happened to their coworkers in the first place.

Yes !! I feel this completely I feel that we may be the guy that started bigger bodies initiative . If there was not proof of death that could mean they didn’t die.

I wonder if the protagonist knows the child that was found due to the picture of the child next to the radio being one of the few actually visible in the dream sequence

i feel like when it talks about guilt it's survivor's guilt

I really do wonder what the relationship between tbe player and Huggy is. Cause a majority of the chapters (at least after 1) Huggy is the only one that left and impact or is technically haunting him. He even had a nightmare version of him in this dream and even had huggy standing there menacingly in his second nightmare. Mommy, Catnap, nor did miss delight show up except Huggy. (Well the prototype did but ya know.) Even in the beginning of chapter 1 when you first encounter Huggy, he doesn't immediately attack you. Hell he even gives you a key to persue the factory. It wasn't until the player started operating everything that caused huggy to feel suspicious and stalk him. Then when he made a toy, which is the reason these creatures are in this predicament, is when he saw you as a threat. I don't think Huggys dead since we didn't see a body or any other visual confirmation....so this'll be interesting

The person who missed the meeting was the only person who offered the suffering toys a chance out. He didn’t show… so they mutinied- he was supposed to fight for their rights and freedoms- an end to the madness. That’s so sad. And it makes so much sense. The toys/kids were waiting on ‘Poppy’s Angel/the protagonist’ to save them. And he chickened outa Bs left them with no other option but to kill. And then when he didn’t ever return..: they became real monsters who are still hurt that their savior intentionally abandoned them. And the ONLY reason they don’t kill him on sight every time is because they assume the protagonist might actually still be good. So they give them an opportunity not to screw it up this time- by defeating them. And the only way he can redeem Himself is to kill the monsters he created by abandoning them in the first place. And the prototype is OUR (the players) creation. This… why it’s the last thing we have to kill. Also why Catnap was so ready to kill but not kill us. Loyalty to the kids, and more loyalty to the prototype.

My theory is that when we were in the nightmare sequence with nightmare Huggy Wuggy, we were probably involved in making the bigger body of huggy wuggy and it haunts us for what we done to this orphan and we regret it for the rest of our life as the protagonist. Poppy referring the monsters that tortured us is most likely the scientists and not the monsters themselves but who knows, maybe thats the only experiment we were involved and we didn’t see other bodies being made like Mommy, Cat Nap, Boxy Boo, or Kissy. So we were fed up with all the madness that we went through and decided leave the factory before the Hour Of Joy started, then 10 years later you find a message from the workplace you hated all these years and decided to come back to hopefully find the people who tortured you and right some wrongs that happened in the factory.

*_Guilty haunts you_* Yup, we're the bad guys

@Starvaze

4 ай бұрын

"Well, no f🦆cking sh🦢t"

I think first the protagonist quit because after 10 years he came back to the factory after getting a note And the GUILT HAUNTS YOU is referring to he not only wanted to find his co-workers who could have been friends but also to right the wrongs of the past his guilt forcing him to go back and to fix everything he and some others did. And also the radio said it was a random kid that died not Eliot the body of the kid was found on the estate of Eliot

I am from colorado and just went camping below freezin

About Bron...They remembered. The Orphans remembered he's one of them, the employees.

For now, I think we are antagonist of this story but he returned to somewhat fix what we have done.

can someone tell him it's playtime company, not corporation

I'm fairly confident we are Dr. Sawyer. I mean, think about it. The radio talks about the child having missing organs and bones, which is what Sawyer used to make the Bigger Bodies Toys. If anyone were haunted by guilt, it'd be the guy who caused all of this. We also know that Sawyer was 1 of, if not the only named character who was 100% not at the Hour of Joy.

I think he’s the guy who was in the recording with his colleague, upset about the kids, he didn’t turn up so he could t do the one thing he always wanted…. Save the kids…. They knew him, but he couldn’t help…..

It sounds like Survivor's Guilt.

Do you think that CarNap was also gaslighting the player?

Meanwhile in another universe: Dogday: "hey new guy" Player: "huh" Dogday: "Dont come to school(work) tomorrow"

Ever since chapter 1 there's one thing that repeated here in chapter 3 Our steps sounds like plastic In chapter 3 is more noticeable in the school with Miss Delight where you can hear our stepas and hers sounds exactly the same The Prota surely is another toy, a Bigger Body but it looks more human than all the others, i mean, Miss Delight already looked human but with very obvious toy distinctive characteristic Also, the radio says *_Get up_* Just like Poppy says *_Wake up_* at the beggining of Chapter 2 But there's one more thing! In the last fight with CatNap, the room was totally filled with red gas and we couldn't use the mask anymore I also believe we're in a dream so we actually never killed CatNap Plus Poppy sounds very different after fighting with him Again, just like when we kill Mommy Long Legs Why she had the Hour of Joy tape? Why she says *_We call it_* if she hated what happened? Of course Poppy didn't do anything during the Hour of Joy, what she could do anyway? Kick their anckles? Doesn't mean she wasn't part of it Yeah, she said she was in the cage but, we can't trust what she says Do you think Kissy killed some employees and then turned good for Poppy? I think it's more like Kissy is obedient to Poppy I also believe Boxy was in Chapter 3 the whole time but he just never did anything There's plenty of big boxes everywhere

He was probably like one of the workers that were in the assembly line or came up with the designs of the characters or a janitor I doubt he did anything wrong

The main question is who send the letter,colored with red crayon In the first chapter

Are we playing as L.pier

I think the protagonist isn’t completely innocent. Definitely knew something was going to happen and didn’t show up and now is just going through survivors guilt.

Maybe we play as someone who created the prototype and cause the prototype it sufferings

I was wondering I never played the game but I watch a lot of video but what ever happened to the kids

We couldn't be the bad guy despite the fact that we killed mommy and huggy

I feel more like we are revenging the deaths of the innocent people

i think personally that the protagonist is harley sawyer.

No he was bad but he came back to fix his wrong doings. So he was bad at first as mommy long legs indicates it.

Imagine Elliot is the Protagonist

Playtime co. Is so Disney core

4:59 hehe

I think the player was the to suggest and pioneer the program

Could elliot Ludwig be the PROTOTYPE????

Honestly how would we be involved in this when we were sick on the day of the events also it’s not called being involved in a murder it’s called being involved with watching or listening to the news -_-

@Ducky_VR_16

4 ай бұрын

Also if you’ve watched the little Bron experiment you can tell it’s not only orphans that get tested

This theory might be true

Bro you may have a point

Comment 205