Why no punishment for police and judges ? For wrongful detainment.

@meenakshiprasad3945

8 күн бұрын

Add lawyers into the list who protect criminals

@natarajamnarayanaswamy5329

8 күн бұрын

And lawyers should be jailed for asking adjournments for flimsy reason

@VermaRajinder

7 күн бұрын

Why no Punishment for Defence Lawyers who actually misrepresent the case by creating iffy legal hurdles ------ The Delhi ka KanjarWal case is a classic Example !!!

@VermaRajinder

7 күн бұрын

​@@meenakshiprasad3945.... Absolutely !!! 👍👍👍

@wiseremedies4610

7 күн бұрын

Even after the criminal conspiracy by the police is proved.

Our innocent people is in jail. Crime has not proved yet What should we do?

@meenakshiprasad3945

8 күн бұрын

These people discussing are for rich criminals

@rajindersinghsaroha1965

7 күн бұрын

There should be Time Limit for Law enforcers to prove the Crime

@johnpinto8936

7 күн бұрын

​@meoo koi ui hai 😅 😅 😅 😁 ji huenakshiprasad3945

@johnpinto8936

7 күн бұрын

​@@rajindersinghsaroha1965mom mi 6ï hu

@Buzzbuzz206

7 күн бұрын

Your discussion was very interesting. You are all senior learned lawyers. Your opinions are spot on. Instead of discussing, what can you do to change the laws as per your discussion. We are laymen. We cannot do anything for a change. You can. Will you?

The common citizens of the country is losing faith in system of justice in the country. Because they fail to understand the technicalities of jurisprudence etc. so wonderful information Sirs

Excellent informative discussion !

Common man is afraid of courts, and is told to avoid courts if possible.

@kfr7867

3 күн бұрын

Even if you are someone who has been wronged , it takes years for the final verdict on it 😢

@raravamudan4002

Күн бұрын

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused. Liberty for the accused is the priority not the victim. The more comfortable a criminal is with law the more liberal the country. Who is comfortable with courts the criminal or victim just find out .

@athensmajnoo3661

11 сағат бұрын

100% true.

Salute you Adv.Kapil Sibel sir, for taking initiative to educate people about their constitutional rights 🫡

@raravamudan4002

Күн бұрын

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused. Liberty for the accused is the priority not the victim. The more comfortable a criminal is with law the more liberal the country. Who is comfortable with courts the criminal or victim just find out .

Dr Singhvi is right on dot saying ' Need. for Arrest' should be apply first and foremost over ' Power of Arrest ' : vendetta, curruption , extortion , cannot be ruled out in such a situation ...

What you gentlemen are debating and discussing is absolutely justified but the big problem and stumbling block is that the Supreme Court seems like lacking the strong will to review the new laws before its being implemented. People have been observing that Supreme Court is losing it competency and credibility. People are losing faith in law and the judiciary. As the highest Court in the country the Supreme court should start keeping its house in order and keep a close eye on the lower courts. High time Supreme Court start wining people's faith and confidence by discharging its real responsibility and accountability for which it was sworn for. Maybe go a few extra mile.

It is really an honor to see three brilliant judicial minds discussing most important topics. Very informative lectures for every Lawyer. Thank You Kapil Sibal Ji, Thank You Mukul Rohtagi Ji, Thank You Abhishek Manu Singhvi Ji.

@tarunkumarsinha1301

8 күн бұрын

Thanks all of you for this discussion.

@chunaramanju

7 күн бұрын

But A head of police and investigation deptt with law background should 've been joined in this panel so that police facing problem in nabing culprits can counter the allegation of this panel for police atrocity in arrest measures

@vandanatelagi5772

6 күн бұрын

Good idea 💡👍! Kapil Sibal Sir must bring police too on board. It will be revolutionary.

@mallikk7445

6 күн бұрын

I don't understand who decided india top lawyers ? Or costly lawyers ? There are I think many honest legal top lawyers, but unfortunately not propelled them to spot light !!

@thomasthomas9339

4 күн бұрын

When new laws are made Supreme Court must study it and the common Man's freedom is cut then the law should be canceled. Now a days seeing that any person can be booked in PMLA case and dragging to jail even without any proof of guilty. Before dragging into jail even nothing is told about the persons guilty, this must be stopped. First give proof of guilty by the Police, ED, CBI, IT any Department to the persons alleged guilty, then take further action. The Court must punish the person/agency who is dragging people into custody without giving any proof and proving the allegations is only by who is dragging the people I.e. person/agency, the I think more than 70 to 75 percent case will come down. The responsibility of proving the allegations is only on the person/agency and not by the dragging innocent people. Look forward to a smooth Laws and the working of our agencies the Law makers and Courts for the vast interest of people of India and peaceful life.

Top conversation about lawful course of action.Any revison of laws should be better and not worst than colonial laws.only change of English words to Hindi words is not improvement.Before any law is to be introduced,it must be discussed with Supreme Court Bar council and the team of Supreme Court Judges before tabling in parliament to pass.Unfortunately,you are discussing after it is passed in parliament and Supreme Court donot interfere and it is implemented. The jails are filled with accused without even trial for many years.Can you help these prisioners to get bail sothat only convicted persons to be kept in prison. Please do some thing for the poor prisoners who have no money to apply for bail and lawyer support.

The new criminal laws coming into force w.e.f. 1/7/24 is that punishment will start immediately from the date of arrest of the person without proving it that arrested person is guilty or not then what is the role of the Court. If ultimately it is proved that person is not guilty then question is what about the person who has been kept in the jail for considerable period who is innocent? Secondly what is the situation when accused is kept in jail till the trial is concluded and if trial is concluded after 10 year that means accused has to stay in jail for such long period of Ten years?

@raravamudan4002

Күн бұрын

True the accused is most precious person and he should be protected. Who cares for the victim no money no power and no time to give to the court for 30 years.

आमूलचूल बदलाव और जनता और समाज देश काल के अनुसार ही कानून बनाने चाहिए और जनता को सबकुछ सरल भाषा में मालूम होना चाहिए। तभी सही मायने में जनतंत्र होगा जनता का राज होगा।

Where is the remedy for a wrong imprisonment? What is the punishment for an illegal arrest?

@vandanatelagi5772

6 күн бұрын

Opposition and people of India must demand severe punishment and exorbitant fine for wrong cases and illegal arrest. I think USA has such law in place.

Senior lawyers each word is highly appreciated. But the present day government with dictatorship quality, everything will be in turmoil. However such discussion is taking place.

@vandanatelagi5772

6 күн бұрын

So let's hope for restoration of sanity. If we people provide support, Kapil Sibal Sir et al can achieve it for the nation 🇮🇳.

Isn't it too late to discuss it. Such discussions should have started before these laws were scheduled to be brought in the Parliament. Those Colonial laws gave the citizens a lot of protection in the form of Criminal Procedure. All these protections are gone now.

@sudhanshumishra550

7 күн бұрын

Modi did not bring this law in public for discussion. They directly passed it and that too without discussion

@vandanatelagi5772

6 күн бұрын

At this age , Kapil Sibal Sir has put together Dil Se. It's not a joke to organise such discussions. Most importantly, no one will be bold enough to take such steps. Everyone including CJI only selfishly thinks of saving his skin and enjoying holidays rather than serving the nation 🇮🇳. We should be happy that such senior persons have decided to take a step towards healthy debates to speak up. Thank you Sir and hope the citizens at the right time will stand together in solidarity with you for reforms this nation 🇮🇳 requires. May God help you to achieve the great rehauling that you speak of is necessary in the entire system of this nation 🇮🇳.

Yes, this attempt to discuss is a "tip of the iceberg"! We wish you will do more such discussions!!

EXCELLENT DISCUSSION

Thank you so much Sir Kapil for bringing so important issues in your program/Regards from Stockholm

Dear delegates ...awesome discussion made by you people, these topics brings the vast amount of awareness about laws and Constitutions and liberty. And more and more for the young talent lawyers could learn from the seniors thoughts . I am sure that this kinds of healthy discussions and debate will make India in future a Great Nations . We all following Mr.Kapil sir. Thanka

We are always with neutral, bold and intellectual media.❤😂🎉.

Stop all criminal, UFC law

Fantastic discussion. Touched a range of issues, what could be improved and how, where the problem originates, why has it become systematic. Educating and may I add empowering, because knowledge is power. Right argument starts with right knowledge and right thought process and width/range of thoughts add robustness & clarity to the argument. The panel and the moderator, both did an outstanding job! Thank you so much for this enlightenment..

Interesting discussion by the three eminent stalwarts on the implications of the new criminal laws ..I would like to add that Under the old CrPC of 1973 the detention of the accused in police custody cannot exceed 15 days in a whole.. However under the new criminal law BNSS under section 187 (2) the custody of the accused with the police may extend to 40 to 60 making it difficult to for the accused to obtain bail which is unfortunate

There should heavy compensation for wrongly dentation,in false cases excessive use of force , torture during police custody from police and government.

Our entire Judicial system needs to be revamped sir.

What an enlightening discussion!!!

This discussion on law by famous jurists is very relevant and important. But I want to say here that ordinary people have been harmed by electoral bond, like test failed medicine companies to pay the electroal bond. And the drugs of those companies had to be bought unknowingly at high prices, which caused widespread damage to the common people!

Thank you sir. Your conversation gave us an idea that lots of people like you are thinking about the people of the INDIA. All of us who have humanity in themselves can change the system of injustice. Jay HIND. 🇮🇳

Fantastic discussion Sir. The nitty gritty of Indian law , or any other law for that matter , is beyond the capacity of common men. Good that you explain it in simpler terms.

Very useful & convincable issues by narrator, salutes & thanks

Law Today & Adv. Kapil Sibal, Excellent discussion by eminent lawyers. Hope you also do another such interview of Constitutional Lawyers/experts/retd. Judges to point out the flaws (if any) in the three new criminal Laws - Bhartiya Nyay Sanhita, Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita & Bhartiya Sakshya Bill, which could prove detrimental to the common law abiding citizens or people who are critical of the Govt.

Kipal sir when an innocent person is kept under arrest wrongly. Who compensates the person arrested wongly for definitions of charector and finincial losses incurred by arrest.

Very informative video, please enlighten us with more of such content 🙏

Top conversation about lawful course of action.. Great pillars our supreme court advocacy.

Fabulous, excellent, informative. Thank you for this program. Obvioously not a boon, but a bane... When arbitrary arrests without the need.. are increased Gravly affects the people's Constitutional rights.

I was raised on a diet of watching these two esteemed lawyers on TVs and I have always been in awe of their exceptional eloquence and mastery of the English language...

@vandanatelagi5772

6 күн бұрын

Lawyers require good command of the language be it English or any other language and the ability to express well with great clarity complex thoughts with precision. It's a wedding 💍 of literature and math resulting in a deadly love combo of sensible reasoning that leave people in awe of their ability to win battles. 😂

You didn't touch upon the source & their needs to bring these changes in laws.

@kfr7867

3 күн бұрын

Who pass laws without consulting anyone !!! 😢

@raravamudan4002

Күн бұрын

​@@kfr7867all consulted just go through these process for the new laws

Excellent discussion.

Sir, It is a excellent discussion provide ample knowledge, kindly continue such efforts, great service to society and common people in the environment of dictatorship now a days.

What an intellectual meeting of great persons of our India. Salute to all of you..Sirs .saviours of our nation .special thanks to sir sanghvi sahab for his attacking with truth in the court of law ..thank you 🙏

Propounding the proponents is called the discussion !!! It these discussions are of a type that's Soothing Discussions !!!

Even when Britain had no codified criminal laws, the British introduced these codes here. Basically they can be accepted with necessary changes.

We Thank You God Be With You To Fight For Truth N Strengthen You more ,

Excellent discussion and enlightening the legal systems in our country. Great to listen to the experts in the legal field.

Excellent conversation .More such conversations are required to create awareness for people on such important matters connected with our genuine rights guaranteed to us by Constitution of India

SC after hearing this conversation between these brilliant minds in the field of law must be surely ashamed. They are the only hope to this country but … holidays for them are more important !!! by the way when are they coming back to work … just asking 😊

@kfr7867

3 күн бұрын

You have asked what is in my mind too bhai !!! 😢

Very valuablr interaction. Thanks to all🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

Knowledgeable and serious topic, Thanks Mr. Sibal sir.

Good evening and Namaste Sir.Kapil Sibal sir.Mukul sir and Singhvi sir Namaste.

Wonderful discussion.... Thank you all of you sir

Good discussion, good discussion, good discussion, kapilji. Please discuss , discuss many such important subjects over & over again. Hopefully, top judicial functionaries take notice of these discussions and do something about it.

Very good discussion.

Some panel. An for-ever-more, all-too,..awesome, "insightful",..discussion. Conversation. Respects. Regards.

Very good programme Mr Sibbal. Very educative and informative, keep it up. Thanks

Admire Mr Sibal sir for discussing the concerns of the public 👏 ...thanks

Great initiative Sir. Best wishes for enlightening Indian citizens irrespective of their job or profession.

Valid questions raised.. intelligent discussion!!

Caption and podcast did not match

This discussion made us to think seriously ! Tk.u sir !

Very important discussion which has to be started way before.. Thanks for bringing it up.

This session is so insightful , the dept of discussion and valuable suggestions to solve the challenges and think from all perspectives be it constitutional, liberty , freedom , legislative etc ..is great to hear. Created an interest in me to understand more of law especially coming from other domain. Thankful for all 3 eminent legal personalities for discussion.

Very informative discussion.

Excellent, eye opening discussion. How about discussion on abuse of preventive detention as happened in JK after abrogation of 370 or on criminal defamation laws..

This was a great video and much needed. Pls help us common people more on such issues. Thank you Mr. Rohatgi, Dr.Singhvi and to your Mr.Sibal for bringing up such topics.

Thanks sir ji

Sibal sir you are doing a great service to the Nation 🙏

Excellent Presentation 💐 The judicial continuous training, technology upgradation in courts at all levels, new digital formats for online case filing, crackdown on possible corruption at some levels, right mind set to solve the huge backlog of cases, the creation of right spirit on justiciability for abiding faith on judiciary, speedy case trial, etc.

Laws have to be strict so that worse of the crimes can be stopped. If they become too liberal attuned with the articles of the constitution, one would not be afraid to commit the crime, and offender may go unpunished making use of the loopholes or bypass the appropriate punishment.

Learnable ❤❤

Amazing

good conversation ,,, thanks

Wonderful

Wonderful conversation

We need more people like you sir

What a wonderful discussion. For general public it is very useful. I wish our government and judiciary seriously pay attention in these matters and take some positive steps in order to minimise the day to day problems of the people of our country

Great discussion.

Thank you for the much needed discussion.

good discussion. reinvention of criminal laws is required. i have personally suffered because of this faulty system.

EXCELLENT 😊THANKS 😊

Really enlightening discussion, sir.Looking forward to listening to more of your discussions. Thank you. Common man's freedom is at stake. Awareness and constitutional changes are essential.

Sir, keep making these types of discussion videos on law. It strengthen the believe of common man towards legal system.

Thanx

Appreciate

Very interesting discussion on the issues of criminal laws.

Thoroughly absorbing discussion. Very well anchored. Especially appreciated his intervention in asking Sr Adv Rohatgi to briefly explain a Sec. 👏👏👏👏👏

Nice discussion, thanks

Really enriched.

❤

👏👏👏👏

Dear great lawyers really you are the safeguard of our constitution as some wants to destroy it

Very nice topic of discussion

Very sensible discussion looking threadbare sec of IPC

Nice and dignified discussion. 👍

High quality discussion of our rule of law

Three wise men discussing an important issue of criminal jurisprudence. Please also have an audience with prof Upendra baxi , Ravi Shankar Prasad/ Salman khurshid etc. Thanks and regards .

1 PMLA laws need to be amended with evidentiary justification without placing it in Parliament, in the Supreme Court. 2 There should not be any Difference In Justfining Matters Bench To Bench 2 There should be no variation in the disposal of cases from one bench to another or judges from one person to another, this is unjust because the Supreme Court is one. Therefore, justice should be done only according to the law of the Supreme Court. But the current trend in the Supreme Court is wrong. Such incidents should be strictly monitored by the CJI.

Good panel with a good debate on very serious issues

Public need to come out for such types of law and protest. Law is not behalf of devour of people. Good job God bless you 🙏

Excellent video content is important 👍

Depressing to learn how the apex body and the entire legal system in India has degenerated. We cannot be a leading nation in the world, with such a decayed legal system.