Ningning and winter have insane breathing technique, truely speechless. Winter always amazing in her control while singing...😂😂😂😂

@MYBLINK_w

11 ай бұрын

Agree

@HumanBeing402

11 ай бұрын

masterpiece 🎉

@usernn777

11 ай бұрын

*ningning

@hibunny78

11 ай бұрын

@@usernn777 ?

@chouxpastryheart19

11 ай бұрын

???

aespa doesn't need autotune, autotune needs them.

@WHITESWAN_SWANLY

11 ай бұрын

They need autotune to cover their ugly voice. My songs and my vocals are way better than them

@Eu_amo_o_Newjeans_e_o_skz

11 ай бұрын

Yesss

@ren-A154

11 ай бұрын

Fr

@asrianatriani7648

11 ай бұрын

fr!!!

@mw1603

11 ай бұрын

Yess

Woah those girls have such RANGE. Winter completely matched the vibe of the song, Giselle added that extra spice and uncertainty, Karina somehow connected those two with her voice and Ning Ning’s voice came as the final touch ❤

@violett_nightt

11 ай бұрын

PERFECTLY DESCRIBED.

@hefeibao

11 ай бұрын

Well put!

@a.a677

12 күн бұрын

the perfect group

Winter and ningning are Not even struggling they are literally so relaxed

@a.a677

12 күн бұрын

best main vocalists

FINALLY we get recording content!

@froggul1519

11 ай бұрын

yeeaahh

@tammmmm

11 ай бұрын

Im not the only one waiting for thisse

@bellissimyoi

11 ай бұрын

I'VE BEEN SAYINGGGG OMG I'M SO GLAD

@untitlee.d2351

11 ай бұрын

YASSSS!

@Ari41100

11 ай бұрын

yess😭

they all have great vocal tone and winning's vocal powers are no joke. I love how they sing those low notes so much

Ningning’s vocals WOW

Winter got the most SM vocal vibe ever. Just sounds soo solid and controlled. They all did great though, I know they can all sing.

I can't believe they managed to get Naevis in the studio regardless of her busy schedules. Aespa slayed

This is why aespa is the best vocal group of 4th gen! No one comes near on aespa when comes of timbre/tone, dynamic, harmonization, phrasing and delivering expressions! Queens

@hatdoghatdoghatdigididog4363

11 ай бұрын

nmixx

@5106530

11 ай бұрын

@@hatdoghatdoghatdigididog4363 nmixx does have lily, haewon and maybe sullyoon but that’s not enough. They got that cheap vibe. Their musics and styles are not fancy and elegant like other groups.

@lovy3003

11 ай бұрын

@@hatdoghatdoghatdigididog4363 their main vocalist might surpass winning in tier and terms of belting but they will never outshine them I different aspects.

@dco.2209

11 ай бұрын

​@@hatdoghatdoghatdigididog4363 nmixx has only two members. But aespa as a whole group are the best in vocals for 4th gen. Even Giselle who isn't a vocal sounds better than a lot of other kpopers.

@ashtoncooper5478

11 ай бұрын

This whole comment section is not it. Aespa and Nmixx are BOTH vocal queens, but this video is about Aespa so let’s not compare, and let’s not insert other artist here. CANT y’all be mature kpop fans for once 🤦🏽‍♂️

ningning's part is so addictive🥹🥹 when she starts harmonisizing it's so smooth and perfect

Aespa got that fancy and elegant vibe. Their voices, styles and music are so fresh and modern. 👍🏻

@AI_00

11 ай бұрын

agree. though im not such loyal fan but I always listen to their discogrpahy.I cant get over with their discography.

Winter's voice fits these lower tones, also her name fits her chilly voice

OUR FIRST RECORDING BEHIND I AM THE HAPPIEST

@Smiler445

11 ай бұрын

There was one for Dreams Come True

@luuoanminhnhut6061

11 ай бұрын

@@Smiler445 but just not full

@WHITESWAN_SWANLY

11 ай бұрын

My songs and my vocals are way better than flop aespa

@nilnamuna7040

11 ай бұрын

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY mang eak🥱

@kayzebx8660

11 ай бұрын

the dreams comes true erasure😭😭😭

giselle recorded everything so fast 😭

The combination of a producer who knows what they want and gives positive feedback, along with 4 amazing talents that will try whatever is asked of them has made a really addictive song.

@icespa2729

8 ай бұрын

agree.

winter giving the totally different note than the demo one and making the director shock is so cool! this girl is beyond amazing! I believe in yyj's pick

@a.a677

12 күн бұрын

she elevated the song so much

Their vocal talents are undeniable. But I gotta talk about Giselle, her voice is so versatile 🥹

@taengoonim

11 ай бұрын

For real, not once I doubted why sm picked Giselle and be part of aespa, even the members acknowledged that it was her who made their group clicked

@aechuuu

11 ай бұрын

Yesss !!

@reinesss13

11 ай бұрын

True! I was mesmerized when she sang the first word. Her voice is beautiful.

@atsiepxs471

11 ай бұрын

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Winter’s voice??? Very raw and just like the real audio no difference

all members of aespa have such distinct, pure and amazing voices. this song always gives me goosebumps because of just how talented they are.

See how Winter is in control of her voice, she even changes notes to make it more better like she will suggest to change it. That’s Winter for yaaaaaa.

One of my most favorite content every comeback is the behind the scenes of their recordings. I just love their raw vocals so much.

@untitlee.d2351

11 ай бұрын

literallyyyyy

@alalani_r3i

11 ай бұрын

"their recordings" this is their first recording behind wdym they did it with Dreams Come True but not in full version tho and it's only for documentary

@lunariaflora

11 ай бұрын

@@alalani_r3i maybe they mean sm artists in general? it is something i really enjoy too as a pink blood!

I will never stop praising Ningning's vocals. She sounds incredible 🥰

Winter vocal is no joke, I like her vocal so much

@pykemid3954

11 ай бұрын

when i first heard her vocal when she came out i KNEW she was not to play with!! top notch

Finally! I mean, why not record all the musics behind the scenes? There's no cost, shows how beautiful they can sing and is more content to the fanbase.

@pinkgangsta6157

11 ай бұрын

Maybe editing the vlog take so much time. SM should hire more editor for their content bcs there are so many SM idol with so many content. Also their social media staff always late to post something their project etc. Fansite is more faster than the staff 😭

@webmasterd

11 ай бұрын

recording is not the issue. if you have ever edited a video you will know it takes a lot of time to edit. Lol.

@reinesss13

11 ай бұрын

Maybe they have it but it takes time for them to edit. Just a reminder that they just uploaded all the mv/track videos behind the scenes too. They already giving us a lot of content. Be grateful that SM even dropped this bc we didn't get something like this on Girls era.

@serigalaberbuludomba

11 ай бұрын

We can always wish🤞🏻

@dhhan68

11 ай бұрын

If you were doing something serious and if there were couple of cameras which capture your every moments, then will you do that naturally? Cameras mean others eyes watching us. According whether you knew the cameras watching you or not, your behavior will be different. That's one core of Quantum mechanics. I also want their recording behinds, but I want sometimes not always. I don't want Quantum physics tame those girls very often.

SM artists are really untouchable when it comes to vocals. You know they've been through crazy vocal training and grinding. They know their strengths and weaknesses, they know basic techniques, embraces their tones and placement varieties. Their productions are always the rawest ver of the recording, so they got nothing to hide and sound exactly the same live

@taengoonim

11 ай бұрын

Trueee, nothing beats sm with this type of content

@hefeibao

11 ай бұрын

Yeah, if you heard Ningning's pre-debut stuff, you can clearly hear how much progress she made with that training. She's phenomenal now.

I’m not surprised that winter can sings this song so easily.She’s been eating the cd all days even before they debuted🔥🔥🔥

Aespa: 🗣️ The producer: 😍💖🫶😮🥰💯🤌👌🤘😻 especially she cheered up for Gigi all the time how cute is she and the interactions btw her and the girls

I really like the sound of winter, sounds soft and cool

Knowing that they are very powerful, watching this behind-the-scenes recording completely confirmed this point

@dftfexo2076

11 ай бұрын

P

Giselle is the hidden talent of aespa. Her vokals are insane

Winter's perfectionist side really shines through in this recording session. No wonder she's such a great vocalist.

welcome to my world perfectly suits giselle and winter's voice. so satisfying to hear their raw vocals!

9:17 thats aespa main rapper btw AMAZING SINGER

나도 이 노래 진짜 취향ㅠㅠㅠ 에스파스러우면서 몽환적인데 뭔가 엄청 숲냄새 날거같은... 4명 다 너무 잘 부르네ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅜ

Ningning's baby noises after she gets complimented is so cute haha. We need to compliment her more

Winter’s raw vocals here sounds exactly like the produced version 😮

@Xrey-ek5sh

11 ай бұрын

They recording for their final version, why you think they’re in the recording studio 😂🤣

@sabrina-fi7wz

11 ай бұрын

@@Xrey-ek5sh she says her raw vocals are close to the studio version meaning the final version on the album.

@pinkgangsta6157

11 ай бұрын

I watch music producer react to behind the scene like this and get said their vocal is so perfectly on tune. So there is no much editing their vocal.

@pinkgangsta6157

11 ай бұрын

Also he said, this kind of singer is editor (?) Fav bcs their works can done faster and easier 😂

winter's voice is really soothing

They are all so amazing but Ningning and Giselle's tonal colour and vocal quality was so impressive! Especially Giselle's as a member who is often overlooked for her vocal ability. She really has such a lovely voice and adds so much depth to aespa's songs.

I really like the way Gigi emphasized the "welcome to my world part" near the end

damn winter sounds unreal. like genuinely can't comprehend how someone can sound like that.

Oh damn! Winter was recording so casually like it's nothing, look at her just crossing her arms, hands in her pockets, 😳 as expected of my ult ❤🥹

와….. 레코딩… 스엠사랑해.. 드디어 에스파가 레코딩 비하인드를 내는구나… 우리 애들 완벽해… 진짜 잘해.. 원래 잘하는 거 알았는데 더 잘 알게됐어….

@moenway500

11 ай бұрын

There is also dreams come true recording behind.

@ISTJ_0723

11 ай бұрын

스엠이 드디어 정신을 차렸어요..

@anwjr92117

11 ай бұрын

진짜 이리 잘하는 애들을… 이번 컴백 진짜 최고이뮤ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

@LOVER_0831

11 ай бұрын

그니까요 스엠이 드디어 머리라는걸 썼군요… 앞으로도 이렇게 부탁해 스엠

@ooowoo140

11 ай бұрын

드림스컴트루때도 있지 않았나여....? 원래 잘하는거 너무 잘 알고 있었음ㅎㅎ

them doing the backing vocals omg ningning ate so hard i genuinely enjoy this bts

Our slay Ningning

_Can we appreciate their BEAUTY for a sec too? Their light makeup visuals are absolutely jawdropping! Personality, beauty, vocal; THEY FALL FROM HEAVEN telling you!_ ✨💖

@hk_8704

11 ай бұрын

stop spamming

@aeD4RK

11 ай бұрын

​@@hk_8704 what spmming? Making multiple comments ain't spmming, it's only spmm if it's melaciouss. I am praising them, come on!

@WHITESWAN_SWANLY

11 ай бұрын

My songs and my vocals are way better than cringe aespa

@victorchaudhary6219

11 ай бұрын

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY I'm better than you 🐕

@xvimie4210

11 ай бұрын

Hello everglowup aka kpopfication aka winterosy .. just kidding lmao

I really forgot Giselle is a rapper. Her voice is so smooth 🩷

Ningning's parts are heavenly. She does the most background notes. I'm proud of her💯

_Aespa's ANGELIC vocals are the medicine we need! So colorful tone, AUTOTUNE LESS, effortlessly high and low notes with great adlibs; BEST VOCALISTS OF 4TH GEN!_ 🌬️💕

@aeD4RK

11 ай бұрын

_Later a spmmer named Pruit will come and will liee that I am Everglowup. My ultimate answer to all his lies is: I would gain/profit/proof/obtain nothing by hating Aespa in one account and praising them literally thousands of time in another! Its simply illogical._ _All of his claims are like this, illogical out of context and no actual proof he can show._

@aeD4RK

11 ай бұрын

​@cyberning he still get some likes, mean around 1% people fall for his liess. This message is for those 1% lol! Thanks for the support MY. We Them Girls! ✌️

@WHITESWAN_SWANLY

11 ай бұрын

My songs and my vocals are way better than dog aespa

@Fezxo2

11 ай бұрын

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLYyou flop more than cardi b, aespa better than you

@victorchaudhary6219

11 ай бұрын

@@WHITESWAN_SWANLY I'm better than you 😂

1:30 Ningning voice make me shock 😭

Winter is so cute while recording, my baby ❄️😘🤍

winter sings so effortlessly

와 진짜 에스파, 스엠은 진짜 어나더 레벨이다 ㅋㅋ 비교 자체가 아예 안됨 ㄷㄷ 그리고 어떻게 후보정 1도 안넣은 게 저럴 수가 있지

@Jwa123

11 ай бұрын

음정 흔들리는거 음 나가는거 그대로 내보내는거 처음봐요…

Winter vocal🥰😘

BRu Giselle barely got any lines but she slayeddddd yay

@starsandraindrop

11 ай бұрын

I think she got 3rd most thats fair

@whatwhatwhat-2948

11 ай бұрын

she got more that karina?...

@myab866

11 ай бұрын

@@starsandraindrop ik but still in the mv they barely showed her

@fallengrvity

11 ай бұрын

​@@myab866 well thats not rlly related to lines tho!! she didnt get enough screentime not lines :3

@Aquaspirit247

11 ай бұрын

​@@myab866 thats not a excuse

윈터 목소리 진짜 레전드다.. 드컴추 녹음 비하인드 부터 알긴 했는데 진짜 음색 대박인 듯..

Winter’s vocal is really amazing!!!

I’M NOT GONNA STOP PRAISING YOUR VOCALS AESPA

Winter was like swallowed an autotune. Her voice is sooooo beautiful

Giselle voice is so pretty

I love how they harmonize in overall and with themselves

Winter vocals are no joke

It's wonderful to see Ningning work with such professionalism and dedication and if we add to that how beautiful and talented she is, you can't ask for more from an idol.🦋❤

SM, thank you for letting Aespa out of your basement 😭 This comeback has been amazing and filled with so much content! As a new stan, I am very very happy!!

Omg! This is what we want! Give some girls credit for doing this behind! Their voices make me feel happy~

I really love Giselle's voice please SM we need more Vocalist Giselle

bruhhhh i told y'all even if ningning doesn't have that many lines, she has a lot of hidden lines there for the blending!!!

@rizza2371

11 ай бұрын

What do you mean does not have many lines? She got the majority of lines in this song though. Like Majority, not just split seconds but 20+ sec to the second one.

I love how involved giselle during the recording, she's not afraid to give suggestions that works for her. That why its so sad to see her being push back and not given a chance to showcase her full potential. If SM cant do that for her i would rather see her leave the company and pursue her music career somewhere else.

WinNing is really the successor of TaeSic ❤️ Ning, a powerful vocalist like Taeyeon and Winter, a sweetest yet strong vocalist like Jessica ❤

Winter have everything. You dont need autotune to make her voice crystal clear.

winter "anyeonghaseyong" is sho cuteee

닝닝부터 카리나 지젤까지 와 넘 잘한다~ 윈터도 잘하겠지~ 했는디 잉??? 이정도로!?? 싶을정도로 너무 잘하네요. 노래에 실려서 날아갈듯 ㄷㄷ

Winter's voice is my favorite ❤so sweet ❤vocal queen❤

winter vocal❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Ningning's little squeak everytime she finished recording her lines 🥹

They’re all beyond talented. We’re so lucky to stan these girls. Winter will always amaze me with her incredible vocals, she’s truly one in a million, our superstar!

Winter voice make me goosebumps

Given that all of the 4 ladies are amazing, I am really impressed with Giselle. When you look back to their “Dreams Come True” recording to this, she really knows her voice and how she can make the song more beautiful. She even ask if she can pause and put emphasis on some words in the song. She’s really growing as an amazing artist.

@reinesss13

11 ай бұрын

Agree. SM actually give her most of aespa hidden vocals on their songs. No wonder they made her immediately debut, she's a gem.

Just give winter any songs and she will eating that songs up.🔥🔥🔥she’s has such a versatile vocal colour.Indeed a vocal chameleon.😍😍

winter's voice is so suitable for this song!

Winter vocals OMG😭

Minjeong's voice❤🔥😍

Winter slayed the recording easily 👌🏻

SM은 이곡을 나비스 데뷔곡으로 준다고 한걸보면 대체 숨겨놓은 명곡이 얼마나 있는거냐....👀👏🏻

all aespa members voices are so lovely and soothing that really compliment the song. Their voices are so pleasant to listen to that gets people's attention and sticks with them.

Obsessed with Giselle's voice

다들 진짜 겁나겁나무지하게 잘하는데 윈터는 진짜...눈감고 들으면 음원인줄 알겠다 윈터 진짜 음원이랑 똑같다 못해 음원을 씹어먹음

aespa's raw vocals are the best. 🥰

winter sings very pleasantly. her voice suits this range!! so so beautiful!! i love how all of the members give different vibes to the song but when combined together, it's like a perfect mix of everything! ugh more of aespa recording behind-the-scenes pls!!!

winter vocal tone+her control>>>

Karina the main dancer also serving the vocalist. aespa is truly an all rounder girls

Beautiful winter voice

Raw vocals of aespa are the best. Shame that it took SM ENT to showcase their vocal prowess this late. Regardless, they slayed this comeback! 🎉🎉🎉

윈터가 고음만 잘하는게 아니란걸 보여주듯 저음도 울림이 남다르고 보컬이랑 화음쌓는 음색 둘다 쩌는게 걍 레전드 딕션에 전달력까지 미쳤고 더 주목받아야 할 실력이라 생각함

Omg Winters voice is so soothing to the ear 💙

SM, please do this more often. I also hope they sing this with an orchestra.

0:12 *_NINGIE: Best of 4th gen vocal!_* 🦋 5:03 *_KARINA: Loveliest vocal!_* 💙 9:10 *_GISELLE: Incredibly satisfying vocal!_* 🌙 12:01 *_WINTER: Sweetest vocal!_* ⭐ _No wonder AESPA is the best vocal group of 4th gen!_ ✨

@bevgin

11 ай бұрын

​@Zoey Zoey actually ning is better in vocal

@aeD4RK

11 ай бұрын

​@@bevgin they are all vocalist but yes, we all know NING is the best of 4th gen. Bada lee's successor for a reason!

@aeD4RK

11 ай бұрын

​@Zoey Zoey yes, all of them are just BEST this era got to offer!

@aeD4RK

11 ай бұрын

_Later a spmmer named Pruit will come and will liee that I am Everglowup. My ultimate answer to all his lies is: I would gain/profit/proof/obtain nothing by hating Aespa in one account and praising them literally thousands of time in another! Its simply illogical._ _All of his claims are like this, illogical out of context and no actual proof he can show._

@MB-nv8sw

11 ай бұрын

@Zoey Zoey benar❄️🥰❄️🥰

닝닝이랑 윈터 음색이 나를죽인다ㅠㅠ 몽환적인 분위기의 곡이라 살리기 힘들었을텐데 살리는 짱스파😻

giselle’s voice is sooooo precious i love it so much

I've always been amazed by Ningning's vocals, her vocal range is wide. I want to see her sing more, SM give her more line!