A lot of people seem to not understand or misunderstand why I chose Quilt and not Fabric or Forge, so here's the long version of why; it's not just about the Fabric and Forge devs being bad people: I don't have any problem dissociating a project from the person behind it when that project is the best there is, however, Fabric's lead dev's transphobia genuinely got in the way of code contributions that would've been great additions to the loader's API (because some of these contributions were made by trans people). Certain systems like the custom biome, dimension or multipart APIs of Fabric have a lot of problems and sometimes straight up don't work, while these issues have been fixed on Quilt. For Forge, it's not so much about the devs being bad people, it's more that the way Forge does things genuinely got me to quit modding before I switched to Fabric when it first came out. If you're upset about the mod not being available to you because you don't wanna use Quilt, I can understand that. However, please also understand that if it weren't for Quilt, I probably wouldn't have updated my mod anyway, so you're technically not missing out on anything! I don't really have to justify myself for using Quilt, but I hope this gives you a little more insight! 🐀❤️

@F3llNouzy

11 ай бұрын

based

@LinuxPlayer9

11 ай бұрын

Je savais pas pour la transphobie des devs de Fabric. Mais d'après ce que j'ai compris, les mods Fabric peuvent marcher avec Quilt et vice versa. C'est un peu dommage pour Fabric. Mais bon l'opensource ça permet aussi de pouvoir dériver les projets quand c'est nécessaire. C'était déjà arrivé avec PolyMC qui a été fork en PrismLauncher. J'espère qu'un commun accord sera trouvé quand-même, ce serait dommage d'avoir des mods incompatibles avec Quilt et vice versa, surtout si ça renforce la position de Forge qui était là avant les autres.

@dan_asd

11 ай бұрын

i love you maid i mean rat

@PEK-97

11 ай бұрын

It's still a shame that you effectively killed off the Forge port by bottomtextdanny. To me, the moral of the story seems to be "watch out for mods licensed All Rights Reserved". You see, we have this wonderful modloader called Quilt because Fabric uses the Apache license so it can be modified and redistributed. I am not in the minecraft modding scene so I can't comment on Fabric dev's transphobia, or how horrible their API is. But what I can say is, their attitude to software licensing is in stark contrast to your decision to lock the mod down to Quilt and preventing others from porting it.

@varion_

11 ай бұрын

I understand this reasoning, and support it entirely. However, what is the purpose of locking down your mod and not allowing people to port it to Forge? Not wanting people to port it to Fabric for your own reasons makes sense, but why not Forge?

This really makes me realize how much ambience is missing from Minecraft.

@CallmeRon577

11 ай бұрын

Yoo Mogswamp

@thegreatsamurai5016

11 ай бұрын

ayyyyyyy mog

@ramsey2155

11 ай бұрын

Isn't the waterfall effect a bit too much?

@xenolion339

11 ай бұрын

What minecraft needs the most is optimization

@sgrey9181

11 ай бұрын

Hi mog!

Dude! I really wish they would add something like this to Minecraft, just the waterfall effect has me drooling 😭

@r4tmaid

11 ай бұрын

you can always download the mod 🐀

@moistsocks2188

11 ай бұрын

@r4tmaid i cant unfortunately cuz i play on xbox and dont have a pc 😭

@xsmallmusic2174

11 ай бұрын

​@@moistsocks2188bedrock moment 💀

@moistsocks2188

11 ай бұрын

@@xsmallmusic2174 😭

@laserfoxpro

11 ай бұрын

@@moistsocks2188you should def save up for a pc thats like the best way to play games

I got some ideas for ambience if you’re willing to hear them: -Warped and Crimson forests probably should have some spores. How are they going to reproduce? Perhaps if they were also glowing yellowish it could tie into the shroomlight being the main reproductive part of the trees, like a puffball. -Bedrock Fog or Smog used to be a feature in the early days, it was a cool little detail that made you feel like you were in a very pressurized bottom of the world. -broiling water at the tops of bubble columns, or magma vortexes could also have little whirlpools -the eyes in the dark could have a very low chance of being the same shape as the player’s eyes; a homage to when we were all afraid of herobrine

@planetoforts

11 ай бұрын

I haven't heard of somebody talk about Herobrine in years. And yes I like the ideas

@lokiijustwannasleep7865

11 ай бұрын

wait the bedrock fog got removed? i honestly thought it was still there lol, i havent paid enough attention

@YounesLayachi

11 ай бұрын

The void fog isn't a bedrock feature. Quoting the wiki : _"In prior versions of Minecraft (specifically Beta 1.8 Pre-release (2011) through Release 1.8 Snapshot 14w34b (2014) inclusive, up to its removal in 14w34c), a thick black fog was introduced. As the player descended below Y=17 in the Overworld, this fog would start to appear. As the player traveled deeper, the fog at the edge of the render distance would become closer until the player reached the first layers of bedrock, where visibility was reduced to just a few blocks, beyond which was complete darkness. The gray void particles appeared below Y=17, as well as in the void._ _The existence of this fog depended on a lack of sky lighting. If vent holes were opened up to allow sky light to enter an otherwise secluded underground space, void fog would no longer be present so long as the player kept near this sky light source._ _Void fog was removed late into 1.8's development for performance reasons and general community distaste"_

@TheFluffiestBoi

11 ай бұрын

One thing with the chorus flowers, you could do the same with cherry tree petals too!

@feesh8551

11 ай бұрын

@@YounesLayachi they probably meant bedrock as in the block bedrock like you also said

Honestly, this is one of my favorite mods on the scene right now.. well done!

@EnderHero

11 ай бұрын

It's amazing, I wish some of it was in vanilla

@natycrap

11 ай бұрын

Dude effective is not small anymore, and thus, I agree

@HolyCrossed

11 ай бұрын

Yo SystemZee

@eternalstudios1

11 ай бұрын

I wish there was a bedrock version 😢

@THECOOLSUCHOBR

11 ай бұрын

I wish mojang added these but change the waterclouds because it is a bit too much for me

It feels kind of nostalgic to see him talk about minecraft splashes... Even though it's only been a year since the first video on effective

@pitlysYT

Жыл бұрын

Don’t read my name

@calxcalibur

Жыл бұрын

@@pitlysYT It doesn't show your name, it only shows your @ now

@Qenwolf

Жыл бұрын

@@pitlysYT i never leanred how to read

@jacquilineaguilar822

Жыл бұрын

A

@ArklonVangreeg

Жыл бұрын

@@calxcalibur hes dumb :)

For the eyes in the dark you should make an option for them to appear on full moons

@sebastianjost

11 ай бұрын

I feel like the eyes color should also be randomized a bit. At least yellow, red and maybe green eyes could be some nice variations.

@fragment__

11 ай бұрын

And maybe so that when you look at them directly from a distance they disappear, to get that spooky scare

The hypnotizing effect of the glow squid is literally what we were told it would do and we need that in vanilla. It’s so damn cool!

@mosshivenetwork117

10 ай бұрын

Mojang scam.

@tabcaps5819

Ай бұрын

Drowning in an underwater cave is now 200% more likely

The chests opening randomly from the soul sand underneath is such a great idea!

Bro made glow squid 10x more interesting, just imagine what map creators could have done with that. Like press a button that summons a invisible glow squid at an enemy’s location and boom you have a targeting system

@EnderHero

11 ай бұрын

Super creative

@KierKier389

6 ай бұрын

turened the glow squid into the mesmer from subnautica

I would love to see falling leaves from this mod that can interact with the water like the chorus petals

@user-zt2fq2sx6t

Жыл бұрын

leaves with flowers (such as cherry and azalea) could be nice with that yea, great suggestion

@hamtaro4620

11 ай бұрын

​@@user-zt2fq2sx6tyeah I was thinking about that too!!! That would be really sick

@stumonster6091

11 ай бұрын

If nothing else you could put one of the chorus fruits in the middle of a cherry tree and it should look similar enough.

@hamtaro4620

11 ай бұрын

@@stumonster6091 oooh nice idea

@beveled_eggs1298

11 ай бұрын

There actually is already a mod for this on fabric. It's called "falling leaves" I've used it for forever

It’s a crying shame that these effects, and features aren’t in Minecraft by default, and are a great, big, missed opportunity on the dev team’s part… These effects are truly gorgeous, and makes Minecraft look, and feel, even more alive than it ever was before!

@UnDazzled69

11 ай бұрын

So true

@raptorzeraora2632

9 ай бұрын

or on forge

if you’re willing to take suggestions, why not give the ancients plants special particles? The torch flowers could disperse little glowing petals that look like embers and the pitcher plants could make insects fill the air (like fireflies, blowflies, literally anything, maybe even butterflies and locusts). I think that’d be neat and add something of an incentive to babysit a dinosaur beyond babysitting a dinosaur.

@bunLuna

11 ай бұрын

the mod isn't out yet for 1.20, would be a cool addition though!

@mrlampy

11 ай бұрын

@@bunLuna I probably should’ve mentioned I’m suggesting this for the next version

@Azaelris

11 ай бұрын

@@bunLuna oo i hope it comes out soon i really wanna utilize this mod in my 1.20 playthrough

That effect where particles from chorus plants fall on the surface of water stick to the surface should be part of the vanilla when cherry tree particles land on water.

@sltrskid

11 ай бұрын

alas the minecraft devs only have the willpower to add like two mobs, one biome, and a few blocks that should have been added three updates ago

@gumkl

11 ай бұрын

@@sltrskidits hard to makes updates that make everyone happy, especially people like you

@Vaxedia

11 ай бұрын

​@@sltrskidyou sound like spoiled kid ngl

@sltrskid

11 ай бұрын

@@Vaxedia it's not spoiled to want something more than what solo modders have been putting the game since 2015

@Vaxedia

11 ай бұрын

@@sltrskid they can't just add random things that players want in one update. One is ocean themed second is mountain etc. And everything has to be carefully planed without changing Minecraft too much.

Most of these need to be in the base game. It would make it so much more immersive.

Man the three people using quilt must be stocked.

It seems that he never stops his roots growth. It's nice to see this mod again, so simple, yet so delightful. Cant wait for 2024 where he makes the end have an entire ambient upgrade.

9:41 I can only imagine what chaos would be created if you ever decided to make an ultrakill-like mod

@Sucullentbutter

5 ай бұрын

**tenebre rosso sangue intensifies**

@rainb4w194

17 күн бұрын

Rat prime

I love the rain on particle and splash effects. I think the cascade particles need to be toned down and possibly needs to be more reliant and the height of the waterfall, so that it isn't so overdone on small water flows. I also really like the chest opening and bubbles.

I loved a mod called matmos back in the day. Just the sound additions made it so cool to me

I've been waiting for that Ultrakill reference since the video with the rideable rockets that look suspiciously like the rockets from Ultrakill, very great job with the effects Rat :)

Very cool overall. The water effects can be a bit too intense/big I think. Especially when visually there's just a one block drop, I don't think there should be any particle effects at all. The mist is also a cool addition, but improving the effect so that it isn't as clearly "layered" and rotating would make it a lot better imo. Other than that, really cool. I think it's gonna be a standard addition to many modpacks.

@Kibbies

11 ай бұрын

I def agree with the big particles thing, far too big but the complexity and the adjustments is definitely an amazing feature

@ryanmcmanus7273

11 ай бұрын

Maybe it would be fine if it was small but many of them on the boarder of the interaction

@Markel_A

3 ай бұрын

Been using the mod for a bit and came here to say this. The cascade particles are completely opaque meaning they're completely blinding. When trying to fill areas with water it's a total dealbreaker. I think if you could tune the opacity via the config this would be much better.

I think the new ghast fireballs look too similar to the blaze fireballs and also feel a little weaker than they should. I feel that making them a tad bit bigger and also more reddish would help sell their power much better and also differentiate them from the blazes. Also, adding a cool ripple effect and maybe a short explosion-like sound effect to parrying could make it even more satisfiying to parry fireballs.

@niknaxgod

10 ай бұрын

Second that 👍

@helphelphelphelpmehelphelphelp

9 ай бұрын

It doesn't look solid, I feel like ghasts fireballs should be solid

This is so cool! I really like how customizeable it is with the menu youve made, being able to pick and choose what you want is so good

loved the ultrakill reference, you should make a mini-mod letting you parry everything it would be hilarious

@Dirkkerm

11 ай бұрын

ULTRACUBE

@Cat-uv7dy

11 ай бұрын

Better idea: gabriel body pillow

@trampoline11x

11 ай бұрын

@@Cat-uv7dy better better idea: Parry _with_ the gabriel body pillow

@Cat-uv7dy

11 ай бұрын

@@trampoline11x if you’re gonna do that, you may as well throw in the style meter

@user-hz6he5qc5i

11 ай бұрын

It should be named "Parry everything!"

I love how you succeeded into making Glow Squids work in ways that Mojang showed in their Minecon mobvote showcase, but failed miserably to code the hypnotizing effect on their side. They're like Mesmers in Subnautica and I love it.

@KierKier389

6 ай бұрын

exaclty

@syd6654

4 ай бұрын

I feel like it’s less couldnt code it and make they were just too lazy to actually do it. As expected with Mojang

@LineOfThy

2 ай бұрын

All yall are wrong

I genuinely had no idea you made effective. I have been using it for years and watching your videos for months and it somehow never clicked. One of the coolest Vanilla+ mods I have seen in a long time

holy shit, these effects are all so nice!!

"As a little bonus... Ultrakill." Magnificent.

this stuff matches vanilla minecraft perfectly, imo. god these are lovely.

The ambiance is looking even more ambient, It's awesome seeing this mod get an update. Overall, well done!

That's genuinely incredible, I wish it was easier to make mods like this into datapacks

my first exposure to your work was illuminations (big ambience fan) and man it is CRAZY how much more magic youve brought to casual gameplay here. so awesom ^_^

@r4tmaid

11 ай бұрын

PJ I didn't know you were the ogiest of OGs

@ghostpajamas

11 ай бұрын

@@r4tmaid since ~10/13/21

The colored mist reminds me of the smoke bombs we use at my grandparents’ on the Fourth of July. It’s always fun just shoving a colored little smoke bomb into the sand and watching the color flow out. We can’t go this year, but MAN that brought back memories

Oh my goodness, I love what you have done!!! I am installing this right away

This one of the most impressive ambient mods I have seen, keep up the great work!

9:42 these guys actually played way too much ultrakill

Maybe, a way to improve the mist clipping is to have it always show on the first layer above blocks and entities, but then have the opacity controlled by how far an actual surface like a block or entity is from the camera/view. And if a position is truly above a surface, always make that part 100% opacity.

So excited to play with this mod when it’s ready for 1.20 it’s the whole reason I made the switch to Quilt. Great work can’t wait to see what you come up with next.

Im so happy to see this mod grow! I loved it since it came out! Incredible modding skills.

He literally could be working at Mojang

Really cool features! I love that this mod adds a few reasons to not use max gamma!

The petal effect NEEDS to be added to normal trees too, it's probably my favorite effect out of all of these but I pretty much never even touch chorus flowers so it's sad to see it be so rare

This looks like such a wonderfully brautiful additon to the game! Definitely going to ve adding this to any packs I play in the future!

my favorite changes are the ghast fireball ultrakill reference, screen shake, and spectral arrows. the others are still awesome.

Quick suggestion: could you add falling leaf particles that also work on modded leaves? I know other mods that do this exist, however I doubt they also make the leaves land on the water surface like you did with the chorus flower particle effect. All in all, I love your mods and this one is definitely one of my favourites.

@r4tmaid

11 ай бұрын

Love that idea, but I already know a mod that does this very well, and I wouldn't want to step on their territory

@fisch37

11 ай бұрын

​@@r4tmaidOooo, what's it called?

@BlueZulfishBoiii

11 ай бұрын

@@fisch37 its literally called "falling leaves"

GRAAAH this is so cute!!!!! amazing work i love these

Dude, seeing this update is so lovely. I was nervous with my illuminations mod Ive used forever to be merging... but these updates and QOL effects make me so excited! I'm already on 1.20 quilt... but if you ever get the time to update, just know I will be right here supporting you and your work! The ripple effects may make me have more than a healthy amount of cherry blossom trees...

This is wonderful. It would be great if it was on 1.20.1 so we can use it!

Amazing work Rat! Keep improving effective and I am excited for what mods you create next! Also: I think you should do modding tutorials. I feel like it would be a good series for your channel

Honestlyl, ambiet mods like this are some of my favorite additions to minecraft. Please keep doing what you're doing!

Finally, i love these videos, this is why I subscribed

thank you SO MUCH for putting the parry effect for hitting ghast fireballs

This is soooo good !! I’d just say that sometimes the water effects are a bit ridiculous and oversized and would just need a bit of tweaking

This is mad pretty, 100% gonna be a staple of any modded play through

Thank you for your hard work! The night bioluminescence for warm oceans is such a nice touch.

I can't wait for a 1.20 version release of this! I love it, makes me think why it already isn't in the vanilla game.

This absolutely should be added to the game!!

I am genuinely considering adding this mod to my vanilla hardcore world, purely for future building projects that would look amazing with these different ambient effects. Also, I'm just a sucker for waterfall particles and mist, as well as the general vibe proper ambience can bring to builds. You can really bring life into the world more than before. You've done a great job here.

Dislocated my toe today, your video helped me feel better

There is no such thing as too many ambient effects! Add even more! This is one of my must have mods on any playthrough. I love the new effects, especially the petals on water and Skulk effects. Do the Cherry Blossom trees do the same?

Love all of these! Would be great if spectral arrows created light sources when they landed

@lightninng0

11 ай бұрын

Wait that’s actually a really good idea why isn’t this already in the game

@LineOfThy

11 ай бұрын

@@lightninng0 no dynamic light sources

Bro this is so freaking cool, if I had minecraft on pc I’d definitely use this!!!! You’re very talented I hope mojang recruits you or something

Very well made mod ! I love fully configurable mods 🤩

I will never use fullbright again, this mod looks so amazing.

The fire balls remind me of the Minecraft music video “Take Back the Night” by Captainsparkles because in the video there are fire balls with the same trail like effect (not exact but you get the idea).

As a caver (both in real life and in minecraft) i can confirm that rock+water+basically any temperature above 0°c=mist, to the point where your glasses fog up underground, even in winter, and you can't see more than 50ft in front of you, because your torch isn't strong enough, even on the highest setting, and it so means that within

that ultrakill reference came outta nowhere, great job on one of my fav mods!

This is amazing, now all that's needed is to merge Illuminations with Effective and it'll be almost perfect.. Edit: Also when will 1.20 support be out for Effective?

If you make big, kinda see trough particles I think that would make it look a bit better

This is all really nice! I’m currently running a Forge server and hadn’t heard of Quilt until a few days ago due to my hiatus. Instead of asking for the port most convenient to me, I’ll just set up a local server to start playing around with this and other Quilt mods I haven’t gotten to try yet.

Effective is probably one of my favorite mods EVER! I really like your other mods as well though, and the ones on your Ko-Fi are awesome! (Don’t worry, I paid for them on your page)

its a shame you dont maintain the Fabric version anymore, Effective 1.0 was the reason I switched over to Fabric modding I thought the splashes were a really cool addition.

@raptorzeraora2632

9 ай бұрын

its also on forge as well... however whether it will receive the 2.1 update remains to be seen

The waterfall visuals are WAY too aggressive in this mod. Need to be shrunk tons.

This is What minecraft needs to make it more alive, amazing job

You can never have too much ambience, and this just brings it all to so much life, I love it ❤

I love this stuff so much, it’s sick! On the improved particles, which do look good, it would be cool if they were voxelized or, made to fit the MC art style slightly more so they didn’t look out of place.

@r4tmaid

11 ай бұрын

The texture for each of their parts are very pixelized, the thing that gives off this feel is that I rotate them. I tried a few different things but this is as good as I could get it to look without it looking clumsy or worse. I've tried not rotating it but honestly, it just looked worse.

sadly, minecraft devs do not understand how to make their game better. they are trying to hype with huge updates with hype things, but what you have done combined with "ambient mod" for sounds, makes the game 100x better

if i wasn't used to an 82 mod mod pack id switch to quilt just for this (currently on forge) these are seriously amazing dude and the fact you do this as a hobby?? you spoil thos with quilt. seriously amazing work, keep it up!

Yo, this is ssso incredible. And i cant wait to download ir

Please make the chorus petal effect happen with all trees. Maybe not always but make a random “windy day” happen every now and then. Atleast for the new cherry blossoms

i understand why, but i'm still sad this version of effective is quilt exclusive since the main server i play on is fabric only

@CrystalClear51

11 ай бұрын

quilt can load fabric mods too...

@pup1030

11 ай бұрын

@@CrystalClear51 i know that, but i'd have to change the server i play on to quilt in order for me to load onto it with a quilt profile, and i don't think everyone else on that server is willing to go through that effort just to let me use one cool mod

@CrystalClear51

11 ай бұрын

@@pup1030 pretty sure you dont, just add quilted fabric api to your modpack then add effective and you´re good to go.

Oh you've turned something cool into something even more genuinely thoughtful. This is great

these look great!!! i remember seeing ur original video about the splashes!! i love how u made everything toggleable!! i dont play on desktop often but im definitely gonna download this for when i do!! excellent job ^_^

port on 1.20.1

make it 1.20 pls

I love how much effort goes into these mods that he makes, and I also like that he, unlike most other KZreadrs I’ve seen, also puts his mods in the description so that his viewers can download them.

One of the greatest mods and is just visual details 👏👏👏👏

Imagine only using 1.19.2 quilt And not allow ports of your mods (Common L)

@tigerboy4705

9 ай бұрын

1.18 as well, Also how is this common? And its zheir mod, they can do whatever

the real question is why the mod is not in 1.20.1 I am having a hard time without splashes :(

God this gives me so many ideas for adventure maps

Such small additions that have such a humongous effect and make the game feel so much more polished and complete. Great work

For the people wondering "WHY IS IT ON QUILT I WANT IT ON FORGE/FABRIC!!1111!!!" They said on the mod page they won't port to fabric or forge because of transphobia, racism, and they feel quilt is much better. Also they said they won't allow unofficial fabric/forge ports for the mod so the only way you're going to get it is with Quilt, and Quilt allows 99% of all fabric mods btw.

@mythicaltwinkie8216

11 ай бұрын

can we get a source on the transphobia and racism? in no way am I trying to sound rude or in support of forge, this is just news to me and would like to follow up with a source.

@skellykenz

11 ай бұрын

how is a mod loader racist

@Swirluser1

11 ай бұрын

yeah me too I've never heard of the racism and transphobia wtf

@joshuaskinner4419

11 ай бұрын

Can we port it ourselves

@Swirluser1

11 ай бұрын

@@joshuaskinner4419 the creator doesn't want it ported

The attention to detail and interact-ability with the environment really brings the game alive. I’m so excited to see future updates to this and I’d love to see some more player/entity to environment interaction effects that make the world feel more tangible.

Holy crap you make effective? Bro i love this mod.

beautiful, I love all of the effects SO much!!

I’m so glad I got recommended this video cuz this is very cool!

This is by far the most underrated mod of all time, the amount of vanilla friendly features that add so much with so little is incredible. Well done. 👏👏

I really love what you did witht he allay!!! It looks more magical

just want to say your work is amazing and has inspired me to work on some Minecraft animations in Blender, if you want I can try to send a link to a small vid or pic of one! thx R4tmaid!