Amazing, this is what we should learn in unis

@rabeash711

5 жыл бұрын

Your channel is amazing too 😍

@simonriley7750

4 жыл бұрын

Too bad we don't. Almost getting master's degree in control engineering and all we have done practically are 3 lab exercises with total lab time of 10h. put into perspective, it's 2 days worth of theory classes (3% of the whole semester)...

@qdav5

3 жыл бұрын

Agree. Control classes almost always start with the assumption that your plant model is linear, time-invariant and known. And even more so with advanced classes. A lot of professors seem to get side-tracked with all of the elegant mathematics and neglect many of the practical aspects of control system design.

@heithemboufrioua7237

3 жыл бұрын

mr walid your channel helps me a lot thank you so much

@nrdesign1991

3 жыл бұрын

@@qdav5 Exactly this! But this isnt the real world, only some abstracts to get you started - The same thing was trigonometry in school, completely abstract and seemingly impractical. Putting it into practice, and it starts making sense.

Please do more of practical things. The stuff at the beginning is exactly how I felt out of the Uni.

This is pure gold

Brian, thanks for another great video and for highlighting the Temperature Control Lab. It is great to see how control system theory works with real data. You've done a great job fitting an overview of controller development into one video.

@WalidIssa

6 жыл бұрын

Great work to you as well

This was an incredible overview. Loved how you build it up starting with an open loop, adding the closed loop, and showed the graph giving a real sense of the value of characterizing the system, and showing how feed forward and model predictive control can be used too (many questions on these). Superb content. Thank you!

I liked it. The beginning aspect of the video explaining the setup was fantastic.

GREAT video! It really helps to see a real-world application of this subject. This has really helped to solidify my foundation. Thanks again!

After all the control classes I've attended to....your videos still amaze me. What a great way to teach!

This is the best content I have ever seen in youtube for the control theory's sample applications. Keep forward with practical applications sir. Thank you.

This is brilliant. Would love to see more!

This is perfect. I would love to see more practical videos like this. Bridging the gap from control theory to real-world application is something that is hard to find and I personally learned a ton from this video. Your videos are great, man. Keep up the good work.

I am really looking forward to seeing your book getting published! Great video, I would love to see more videos like that in the future! Keep up the good work!

Thank you so much, Brian! As a senior getting ready to graduate (and struggling in my controls class), I really appreciated the way you bridged academic knowledge and real world experience.

Hey Brian, I've been watching your videos (and supporting your Patreon) for a while now. This is truly excellent. Your videos have already helped to bridge the gap between theoretical and practical applications of control theory and this video took it to another level. Based on the feedback in this comments section, I definitely think that doing things like this are what people truly want to see. I'd love to see more.

Great video, Brian! I used to watch your videos while I was a Bachelor's student, and I still watch them now as a PhD student (in Control Engineering)!

Great video! I'm so glad you tied in all of the different aspects of the system like heat transfer, the controller, optimization, etc. This tied together many of the things I've learned in the past year at school.

Thanks. I studied Automatic control at University, but pure of theory and math. Your video opens my eyes :)

Hey Brian, you're a legend. I think you're doing the most for Control Students all over the world, your videos often address all the issues I have in my head, they answer questions that my lecturers often don't care about. I loved the one on Laplace and this has quickly become my second favorite. Words cannot express how much I think of you but thanks man!

Probably the best video about Control theory in the whole internet. Amazing work, one day I will give it back too. Thank you!

I really love your videos, all of them, doesn't matter if it's theory or practical applications, they do help me to see the connections between paper and the real world. When you talked about how it was for you right after you graduated from university with that mindset "there has to be an optimal solution", it really resonated with me. Hope you're doing well man, your work has a good cause. Greetings from Mexico!

Amazing video! Literally shortcuts years of learning that a student usually would need to actually understand how to apply controls principals in a real life scenario. I wish this is how they taught controls in universities!

I have so many tabs with your videos that I feel I will never end them. Thank you!

Great video (even considering your super-high standards). You said it'd be a marathon... but the pacing was great, and you had me on the edge of my seat the whole time! I'd love to see more videos in this series demonstrating different controller design techniques with actual hardware. Having a real system responding to the controller makes it so easy to visualize and contextualize everything. Thanks for all your hard work.

This is what I want to learn. It's very hard to tie the theory with practice when all you are fed is the mathematics and simulation at best. To see the implementation on an actual hardware and you reasoning through the problems made the theory much more clear. Thank you so much! Your videos have helped me a ton.

Fantastic video. Very well done. Love the detail and the effort put into it. The length was perfect for this topic.

I'm so glad and fortunate for people like you, thanks! Hopefully one day when I am more knowledgeable I will also share my experiences as you have done for me. :)

Also, really appreciate you setting the stage with the career questions you were trying to answer. That's very helpful.

This is leaps and bounds better than any paid course I've ever seen!

This was so useful! And the pace is okay actually Please keep making this type of video!

Amazing video, you walked thru my college knowledge and brought me back where I am working now as onboard ETO, A lot completely I meet here starting from basic PID up to Calman filter. The best engineers always have a strong mathematical knowledge, I can see it now after 11 years onboard.

Awesome! This video really helped me understand how to approach my MSc project. Thank you! Also, great work on the textbook.

Oh wow! This is really amazing and inspiring stuff. I'm studying EE with a specialization in Automation and this is really inspiring to me. I passed control theory and now I'm taking digital control and I'm loving it! Please continue this series of desgining real stuff!!

Hi Brian, It's first time I am watching your video and I must admit, it give me quite a good understanding. I have much clarity now how to approach my control system problem and model it into the Simulink. Thank you !

Brian, first of all thank you for making such an informative video; which I found is a perfect blend of theory and practical aspect for building control systems. I would suggest you to continue this series with implementing advanced controllers(like MPC, Optimal and robust controllers). It would be great of you to explain the orange box to beginners so they may get an overview of communication between computer and arduino board. In the end, a big thumbs up for your work !

Great video . I really like the way you analysed a practical problem and then showed the use of tools and control theory you can use to design the controller .

Fantastic, I myself have used this device for learning control theory in the context of chemical processes at the undergraduate level. It is refreshing to see the benefit of using this device from another perspective, and I learned a couple things I didn't know about the overall control system design process. Thanks for this excellent lecture!

I find your videos quite inspiring! I really liked this one, its nice to show, from time to time, how things are done "in real life" to add some spice to the theory.

I love this style of video! It helps me understand my EE classes much more clearly

Brian, amazing explanation. I watched it without a blink. Please keep up contributing exactly this kind of beneficial content more!

This video is an amazing video demonstrating a bridge between theory and practice. Thanks for making this!

This is brilliant - it's this bridge over to applying the knowledge that schools and unis are missing. Thanks, and please keep the vids coming!

I'm at my freshman year as a control and automation engineer and this video was so helpful to foresee what I will do in the real world with all those theorems. Please keep making like this kind of videos. Thank you so much!

This was so helpful and informative! I'm working on Battery TMS for an EV application and I was super curious as to how a practical control system would be developed for this application as well as other real-life applications. This video definitely answered a lot of the questions I had!

This is phenomenal, thank you! KZread is awash in content created from limited understanding in the workings of whatever systems they are attempting to instruct on. This video serves as a first class example of the much needed filling that huge void; Knowledge in the field, examples, real world application, use of various tools, and information clarity. Thank you for this. I highly anticipate your content.

As always, I love the ease with which you explain control systems! Very well illustrated; it strengthened my interest in control systems. I truly appreciate the efforts you put in making such videos. Thanks a lot!

Thank you Brian. This really helped in getting an overview of all the critical steps involved.

Man you are great. please come with more of such problems.

This is amazingly well structured video with flawless narration.. thumbs up!! Thanks

Thanks, Brian. Great description of modeling the plant, in a practical sense.

I really appreciate you going through this process and discussing how the practical aspects of control theory that I never got to experience at University!

We need more of these! Thanks a lot for all the awesome videos you posted

I am currently struggling in tunning PID for my drone. Now I feel I know how to approach like an engineer. Kudos for this video. I have started liking control engineering.

Thank you Brian, this video is amazing! I have been looking for something like this for a long time. It's very helpful.

I appreciate the quality of your video especially the drawing, they are amazingly drawn

Wonderful demonstration of the practical steps required to solve a real-life control problem! Would absolutely love to see more! Hats off to you sir for inspiring us control engineers!

Great video, thank you Brian. It'd be great to see more videos like this!

Beautifully explained. Thank you so much Brian.

Great video, and a far better explanation than what could be given by my controls professor at University. Please keep making them and I look forward to when your book is complete.

Thank You for this video, i'm a control engineering student and this i what i need, a practical example of what i study at university

Greatest piece ever! We need more of this, Brian.

Waiting for more like this projects .....That was an epic concept man,U nailed it

it is a blessing to see all the concepts taught at school to put in action. it is even better to see while still in school :)

Very good explanation and an awesome video. Kudos to you. 👍🏼

Brian this is so good! The problem statement itself is so exciting! Thanks for sharing this

This is top tier explanatory stuff, man. Well done

Great and awsome practical application. Thank you Brian.

As a young professional I am happy for every video (especially more practical ones) that you produce. Please do more!

Brian, Thanks for these wonderful videos showing actual applications with real data! Just as everyone already mentioned, I would also request you to keep making more such videos in future too, especially on different techniques of system identification in various scenarios. :)

Thanks a lot for this video. We really lack such practical examples to play with. More of such system designing will be greatly appreciated.

Super informative! Please do such more videos.

Great video Brian! I think we all should learn a lot more concerning more practical and useful approach to engineering problems. Not only academic equations and theoretical graphs. I wish you did more videos like this - with actual examples of specific control systems. I graduated from Aerospace Engineering and your videos helped me a lot in understanding basics of control systems and then auto-flight systems.

your best, humble and kind person. Thank you.

Love the way how you explained it.

This made me so motivated to experiment with control theory! Please do more videos like this

Wow, fantastic video! Loved it!

Excellent video as always!

As always, just in time for me. This is really useful.

I really appreciate this practical video. If you have the time to include more of them in your current videos it will be amazing!! very helpful!

Trying to design a control system for a model greenhouse...heater, vents, fan...not a mechanical engineer, rather an electronics tech...so a video like this is great to understand the issues involved, and the underlying principles and fundamentals. Thanks

this is more than GOLD Thank you very much for such knowledge

It is just what I need .. thank you sir Waiting for more

Brian for Prez! Thanks for your dedication! this really helps! :)

Ever since I learned about PID controllers, I felt that something was missing -- for example, the delay. I think you explained very nicely how the "missing parts" are actually just part of the search for correct parameters! Great explanation!

Thank you, I’m looking forward to seeing next video!

I'm at school and don't have enough time to watch the video, but I'm happy that you're back to posting great educational content.

This was absolutely fabulous! Seriously man. Great Job!

this is one of the best videos on control systems , thank you

Hey Brian, I am one of your Patreons. I deeply agree with the other people who have commented on these videos. I have my masters in electrical engineering and I have learn about the theory repeatedly but the only thing I know to do in practice is tuning PID controllers. For the first time, I understand the significance of the step response and I can't thank you enough for that. Please please please post more videos of practical, even if there isn't hardware, just working within a simulator is great! Some of the stuff I would love to see are state space equations in practice.

All your videos are great, but I think this is special because after two semesters of control theory I could not answer the question of what exactly I am learning? Some equations? Math? You give me the answer to this question and give a sense to me and motivation! Big thanks!

I really enjoyed watching your video continue posting these videos that relate theories with practical.

excellent video!!!! please more of this!!

really love you sir. Your videos is more usefull and time-saving than a bunch of classes in my university

We need more videos like this. Amazing video

Good stuff Brian i will go over this and when time permits go through the exercise of the temp controller

First video I’ve seen on this channel. I like!

Best KZreadr when it comes to educational content and presentation skills

Awesome video seriously. Please do more videos like this!

This is so cool. I feel more confident in my degree now. Followed a similar approach in a project

HI I have never seen a realistic video like this before. spatially with this amount of details. It was really great

Amazing work. Thanks so much!