If you want an in depth analysis of each of them as a performer join my patreon to gain access to my discord server, I also have MV reactions and other fun stuff coming up soon in there 🥸🤟✨ patreon.com/TiredMarley

Haobin can literally slay any concept lmao the perfect man + the musical/stage genius is a powerful duo

@yourmom4942

Жыл бұрын

AGREED

cant believe haobin are the most centers to have ever centered and we get them in the same group

Before I watch, if you do not refer to Mr. 7 as Groovin, I will not hug my kitten EDIT: Ahh, so the groove does continue ☺️ Also, I got too caught up with watching and just wanted to show appreciation for your appreciation of Taerae’s vocals in “Switch”. Everybody brings up “Man In Love” but “Switch” deserves a ton of respect for what he and PHanbin did vocally

I think u did Ricky a bit dirty lol. His stage presence is really captivating so even tho he’s not the most skilled in dancing, singing, or rapping you just can’t take your eyes of him. Also for concepts I think he like slayed the stages he was in for the most part: hot summer, back door, over me, rush hour these are like cool/sexy concepts but I think he can improve a lot!

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

I agree though? 💀

DAWG TRUST ME THE CONCEPT RICKY WOULD'VE SHINED IN THE MOST IS BRIGHT/CUTE. at the pyjama party stream he performed say my name and when i tell u him doing a bright song and dance fits. IT FUCKING FITS. he was smiling the whole time and he just looks really good performing something like that so i rlly hope we get a smn or jelly pop ricky performance.

@jlprizm

Жыл бұрын

Ricky can definitely pull off cute. His best asset is his stage presence. He’s captivating.

3:55 “resident church boy, amen or something” 😭💀

Might be an unterrated opinion, but I think outside the stage Gunwook gives me more maknae vibes than Yujin. Yujin looks younger, of course, but Gunwook just acts more cute and adorable. Yujin's character being directed at an older audience (considering he is a minor) definitely doesn't sit well with me either

@onetrickponysona2613

Жыл бұрын

and then there's a fake maknae matthew 💀

@renatadeoliveira8486

Жыл бұрын

@@onetrickponysona2613 He's the true maknae in my heart 🥸

@renatadeoliveira8486

Жыл бұрын

@@gamerxarmymultistan Not sure who you're talking about, but aside from pure speculation, none of the treinees confirmed their sexuality, and if any of them are in the lgbtq+ community, I don't think they'll be revealing that any time soon

@gamerxarmymultistan

Жыл бұрын

@@renatadeoliveira8486 oh okay thank you

@psychedelicacynical

Жыл бұрын

we all know gyuvin is the real uncontrollable chaotic fake maknae 🤣

1:50 “I’d rather you do it in the house” broo😭 so accurate 3:44 did not lie plzz 4:58 taerae never beating the old man allegations I was half expecting rickys skill to just say rizz There is NOTHING our mother sung hanbin can’t do frfr

ima be so serious i dont think gunwooks weakness is vocal at all. hes actually quite high in the vocal tier list compared to everyone else in boys planet (hes literally top10 overall its crazy how good he is). that being said, hes just an all rounder and no weakness present honestly i like him better as a vocalist and dancer (like in jelly pop my guy SHINED)

taeraes facial expressions are so good, honestly make up for the fact he’s not the strongest dancer

i agree with gunwook. He overall okay. He top 10 vocalist of the show, he one of top dancer of the show, he probably top rapper in the show because he rarely show his vocal and rapper most the time, i guess vocal is his weakness because HE NEED SHOW HIS VOCAL

@miam_k

Жыл бұрын

gunwook is probably top 3 rappers of the show he was chosen as the best rapper out of 45 contestants in wild idol and was complimented by so many rappers, he’s THE main rapper no doubt

@rigimanchauhan2216

Жыл бұрын

So we have 3 aces Hao Bin wook

Flashback to when they gave gyuvin all stars and hanbin 3 stars LMAO

@vernonIover

Жыл бұрын

u look like a gyuvin anti. hanbin deserved 4 but so did gyuvin like did u see his performance??? plus his confidence when he asked to show another dance as well

@suspicioussloth

Жыл бұрын

Not a gyuvin anti at all. Love him for his personality but I have to say his performance was a bit overrated on the show. This comment was specifically targeted towards how the masters did not have a consistent scoring system though

@meina5433

Жыл бұрын

its so weird cos gyuvin didnt show off any vocal skills whereas hanbin showed both vocal+dance and his dance was for sure at the same level as gyuvin LMAO love both tho

@suspicioussloth

Жыл бұрын

Also they hinted that gyuvin got all stars because he was able to show his skill when he danced to reveal which is fair. But when hanbin showed his skill in the whaacking battle they didn’t consider it while scoring him?

@meina5433

Жыл бұрын

@@suspicioussloth yea frr, same with gunwook! the fact he was 3 star is ridiculous

Am i the only one who sees mother chunha in Matthew....maybe in the future mnh will debut him as a soloist and ngl he has the charms and skills to be a solo performer imo. His vocals skills weren't even fully showcased in the show but he seems like someone who keeps improving in every area of performance. Plus he has a distinctive dance style of his own. You can tell he's a self-taught dancer who later joined agency to get trained. I feel like he will have more chances in the future to show his vocals.

@CR-ug3be

Жыл бұрын

I can see him go solo in the future too. He has the presence to hold his own. I really hope people stop underestimating his performance skills.

@jlprizm

Жыл бұрын

I’ve been thinking about this as well lately. I can totally see him as a solo act. He has the vocals, dance skills and charisma. People are naturally attracted to his charm and he could definitely make it work and be quite popular.

@snl4183

Жыл бұрын

Matthew is talented but I see him as someone who’ll shine more in a group than solo.

5:08 YASS GUNWOOK MY BABYGRILL

@thethingcalledlisa

Жыл бұрын

As someone who has thought that for a long time I’m very happy that people finally call him out for being the babygirl of the group

I completely agree with everything but I think that a skill that Jiwoong has other than his visuals is his voice. LIKE HAVE YOU HEARD HIM IN HOT SUMMER!! Plus I have seen some of his predebut covers and he has an amazing and angelic voice. His dancing hasn't really stood out for me except for the dance break in love killa. (This is just my personal opinion)

I’m still sad over how I came to this channel for weekly Boys Planet content and now we’ve come to ZB1 content alr 😭 it’s been too fast

@thethingcalledlisa

Жыл бұрын

The evolution from judging the trainees because they can’t get the damn signal song right to a guide for Bep1er, it has been a wild ride but a very great one

Outstanding Performers: (1) Hanbin (2) Gunwook - they excel at every single concept and hold your attention. Hanbin is nuanced. Standout Performers: 3) Zhang Hao & Matthew - Not super versatile, but Hao is the best in the group at dark/sexy, Matthew at cute. Good Idol Performers: 5) Taerae, Jiwoong, and Ricky - all are charismatic scene-stealers who go viral, but Taerae struggles at dancing, and Jiwoong and Ricky aren't as skilled as the performers above. They're stan attractors, like Felix from Stray Kids. Average Idol Performers: Gyuvin and Yujin. They're outshined by Hanbin as dancers, and while their dancing skills are on the same level as Gunwook, they aren't as charismatic, as versatile conceptually, or as skilled in singing/rapping. They both had amazing stages tho (Kill this Love and En Garde for Gyuvin, Say My Name Backdoor and Law for Yujin). They are just as talented and debut-ready as any experienced Big 4 trainee.

@peachyjin9145

Жыл бұрын

Gyuvin and yujin are stan attractors too. Like most korean fans probably voted for them mostly because of their visuals.

@peachyjin9145

Жыл бұрын

I think gyuvin and yujin would be on par with taerae, Ricky and Jiwoong. They're good at something let's say yujin and gyuvin at dancing but they're not as skilled as others, they have unique vocals but lack still lacking compare to the others. for example like you say how taerae struggle at dancing, but he's a good vocalist. Personally, i like ricky's vocal but it's not main vocal worthy so i agree with the way you label him.

@zackwilson8701

Жыл бұрын

@@peachyjin9145 I totally buy that! Jiwoong, Gyuvin, Ricky, and Yujin are all really similar in that much of their appeal is visual and due to stage presence. Putting them as the same tier makes sense, even if my personal bias towards Jiwoong makes me want to put him in a higher tier. Taerae is sort of unique in that he's objectively main vocalist material. It gives him that "it" factor. When he sang in Hot Summer and Switch, he really stood out more than most of his group members for his singing and stage presence. I'd put him below Shanbin, Gunwook, Zang Hao, and Matthew, but in a higher tier than the four boys above as a performer overall.

@zackwilson8701

Жыл бұрын

@@peachyjin9145 Good point! They both have a similar appeal as the boys from Enhyphen: Gyubin reminds of Sunghoon and Yujin reminds me of Nikki.

@nicolev990

Жыл бұрын

Gyuvin wasn’t in kill this love, he was in love me right, or did you mean love killa? (which now that I think about it ktl and love killa are very similar names)

I wholeheartedly agree with Taerae being a mid performer but somehow it feels illegal, idk why but it feels incredibly rude (maybe because he does have that charm of some lost old guy who just loves his guitar more than anything) But I’m so ready for Gunwook to decide to make him his gymbro because it’d be the cutest thing ever and he really does seem fragile Btw Haruto is trying to compete with this channel by trying to be the best boys planet related editor (how did WakeOne approve of that Instagram post to be on their official trainee account? They really should give them their own account)

bro your honesty is killing me😭😭

Marley spreading the log1(0) agenda

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

Jail

@nicolev990

Жыл бұрын

✨ Stan log1(0) for clear skin ✨

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

@@nicolev990 💀💀💀💀💀

@gunwooks_planet

Жыл бұрын

getting ptsd from algebra two ☠☠

Definitely gonna disagree with Ricky as a low tier performer. People perform to be captivating. Many people are captivated by him on stage, even if his visuals and natural charisma play a huge role. He is at least a mid tier performer to me lol.

@thethingcalledlisa

Жыл бұрын

The problem with stage presence is it can be extremely subjective for example I find Jiwoong pretty boring (or annoying to watch in case of Back door - eating his shirt and therefore muffling his lines - or love killa - I can’t with his pronunciation) whilst others genuinely adore his stage presence whilst I really enjoy watching Taerae perform (due to how happy and excited he looks during most if not every performance) eventhough a lot of people find him boring I’d also put Ricky in mid, he was just somewhat unlucky due to him constantly performing with really talented performers whose existence is pretty distracting - respect to the people who can only look at Ricky through the entirety of over me ‘cause I can’t look at anyone except for Chen Kuanjui and Zhang Hao shortly before, during and shortly after the dance break (I may be a bit too fascinated by Kuanjuis dancing)

@snl4183

Жыл бұрын

Ricky is talented but didn’t stood out to me in any of his performances. They were all like the same stage. He was like that actor who always looks the same despite playing different roles

im so glad my husband taerae is gay omg

0:20 yasss Gays Planet

@celinemenon544

Жыл бұрын

Oh really

We are called Zerose now

i feel like gyuvin is actually a strong performer in person considering he got higher on-site voting than gunwook (en garde) and jiwoong or matthew (love killa). some ppl say its visuals/popularity but that doesnt make sense if you really think about it cause the other members i mentioned are very popular in korea too and have popular visuals. i just cant see gyuvin getting the most votes twice in a row based on that alone if the others’ stage presence was way better. he also was a contender for the killing part in en garde so i feel like the other trainees mustve thought he was a good performer too.

@novamoin246

Жыл бұрын

I respect your opinion. I just wanted to add that Matthew and Gunwook were part of a group of trainees the knetz called "Landmines". These were trainees which were the most hated; knetz did not want them in their perfect lineup. Meanwhile, Gyuvin is part of F4. In a randomly picked out live audience, they would not win over Gyuvin. They debuted because of their strong one-pick.

@vernonIover

Жыл бұрын

@@novamoin246 ok but he still won over jiwoong in love killa when jiwoong had the killing part, was showing his abs, part of f4 and is popular in korea. he has pretty decent stage presence as well and gyuvin was still able to get more votes than him. i just have a hard time believing that gyuvins popularity could carry him to the win in that situation if he didnt have pretty good stage presence. hanbin was the most popular trainee in korea by a landslide and part of f4, and that wasnt enough for him to win over hao in tomboy or hui in love me right, AND hanbin is a good performer. i thought it was just popularity too at first but i started to think about who won the on-site voting each mission and who their teammates were and it simply doesnt make sense to me that he just has terrible stage presence but still was able to win cause knets like him. i feel like mnet did gyuvin a disservice with international fans by focusing so much on his visuals because then ppl think he must not be talented enough to talk about that. he is a strong dancer, good rapper, stable live, and has good stage presence. he wasnt even one of my top picks but its getting exhausting seeing ppl constantly undermine his talent or underestimate him.

@novamoin246

Жыл бұрын

​@@vernonIover The first group mission happens before the first episode is aired. Therefore, the people do not form their favourites or opinions that strongly. So at that point, Hui was more popular than Hanbin. For example: In Produce 101 S2, Kwon Hyunbin, a well-known model at the time, (the weakest performer in his group) won against Kang Daniel, Ong Seungwoo, Minhyun and Kim Jaehwan in On-site votes in the first mission. Those 4 later joined Wanna One with Kang Daniel as the center while Hyunbin got eliminated. In the second mission for Love Killa, it should be noted that Jiwoong is a BL actor in a conservative country. He is also very old for an idol. Gyuvin is more likeable to Koreans than him. In Tomboy, Hao was underestimated. Most koreans would not have voted for Hao if they knew he would win against Hanbin. People were also worried about what happened to Xiaoting last season. I am not undermining Gyuvin's talent. Gyuvin is very lovable and hardworking who has many admirable traits. He choreographed Love Killa dance break and wrote rap for En Garde. The examples you gave were not appropriate unfortunately because it does not take into account the unfair situation of other members. The On-site voters are really not the best judge of talent. Soyeon from G-idle called it out in My Teenage Girl. There was also strategic voting by fans taking place after first mission.

I guess we're all gonna pretend Taerae wasn't good in Back Door Like hes not a great dancer sure but I didn't think he felt too out of place there? I love all of this though, even when you're pointing out flaws it still felt positive and you're totally right, with the weaker performers, this is our chance to watch them improve and grow!! I just know they'll be unstoppable

The way you roast them and be like 'stan to see them improve' is actually me promoting the group with basicaly none of my picks there lmao. And the way rap is jiwoong's weakness when he used to be a rapper in his old group 😭 1:07 love how wang zihao is the actual standard cuz facts only

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

💀 it's an objective guide I'm not just gonna praise everyone and ignore the things they lack at, I love them for who they are including their shortcomings

@larissaterto1275

Жыл бұрын

@@tiredmarley i agree with the whole guide actually, since I watched the whole show it's a mix of knowing this is one of the best dynamics to come out while thinking the incredible combinations talent-wise that could be made lmao

7:01 I have to disagree with you on this. Everyone loves to reflect on his pr video and act like it’s his entire personality, which is not the case. It’s also not his entire concept either. I’d more specifically say his best concept is sexy. What he lacks is versatility. That being said I don’t think he’s completely unable to do refreshing and cute concepts given his naturally cute lovelicky personality but I’d like to see it for myself.

@ephemeral02

Жыл бұрын

i personally think he can be very versatile if he has confidence in himself. kick it and back door were cool concepts, rush hour was charismatic and over me and hot summer were sexy concepts. he jokes about hating doing cute things but he did great when he took it seriously in the say my name cover. i agree that his best concept is sexy and over me was definitely where he shone the most, im actually taken aback that the video said hes a low tier performer because he drew my eye over everyone else in all 3 challenge stages.

@_harley_1288

Жыл бұрын

@@ephemeral02 I always want to mention his say my name pj performance but I’ve since omitted it from my “defend Ricky comments”. I’ve only used it once as an example for him doing cute concept surprisingly well. Unfortunately others actually disagreed so much that it made me feel bad. I regretted even bringing it up in the first place. 😭

@ephemeral02

Жыл бұрын

@@_harley_1288 aww im sorry about that :(( dont let them make you feel bad, he's a person too doing his best and there's nothing wrong with wanting to support him for it

@_harley_1288

Жыл бұрын

@@ephemeral02 ty

Our Zhanghao, shining perfection 😭

Man.... seeing this video makes me miss Keita, Jay and Zi hao more 😭. This group could've been unstoppable but lets see how this line up does. Regardless, this show had the best selection of contestant that I've seen so far, all the performances are so memorable and good. I miss this show already 😂

@thethingcalledlisa

Жыл бұрын

Top18 debuting together would be so good (especially if they added some of the other eliminated trainees like the other WakeOne boys since they’ll probably stay trainees for quite a while) and there aren’t really that many things stopping them since Keitas group member might actually make it into the FB group and Hui has been in the industry for such a long time that Pentagon doesn’t need him 24/7 also they’re under cube, who to put it nicely, isn’t the greatest company of all time

wdym taerae isn’t versatile with concepts😞 bro slayed so much with his forehead in backdoor

i watched boys planet since the very first episode was released and tbh it was the only thing keeping me entertained throughout the week.. i feel like all 18 trainees deserved a spot in top 9 so i’m not really disappointed with the lineup . i didn’t really get the hype about ricky at first but now he’s my bias aside from han yujin and taerae (ok i love how you’re so honest lmao)

omg i literally love this lineup sm 😭 id say a weakness i noticed in jiwoong is he sometimes gets suddenly loud if notes are higher or is doing hard moves. its understandable but it sometimes can be a slightly larger volume increase 😅

Ricky needs more work in controlling his vocals just like jiwoong but I love both of their vocal colors.

I can't with what you put at Taerae. Sorry I laughed. Edit Ricky rapped on Kick It too. And Gyuvin rapped on En Garde. And they're potential Stan attractor too. Ricky knows how to make himself trending with the things he do and Gyuvin has a meme-able facial expressions and reactions. But overall great commentary and glad to see you're back. Edit 2.0 Someone please correct me if I'm wrong Kim Jiwoong actually debuted before and he's the main/lead rapper in his previous group based on what I heard.

@thethingcalledlisa

Жыл бұрын

Jiwoong debuted once and was in a pre-debut group, no glue about his positions thought; he also did some of the ost for his dramas (or at least for Poongduck or however you actually spell that) and they’re actually pretty good

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

Yes they all rapped at some point... Doesn't mean they're good at it

CENTERZ BEING ALL ROUNDERS YES!

THE WANG ZIHAO

why is this video so accurate 🤣😂

Thank you for this guide, which is fairly accurate (Haobin trash here 💘)... some parts of it are so mean that it's actually hilarious ROFLMAO😭😭😭💀

4:58 Something tells me you're wrong about the concept, this little piece of jesus it's going to burn our houses down with Sexy concept... I have this strong voice telling me "You'll pray and sing church songs sooner"

@seokmachuuu

Жыл бұрын

No seriously are we gonna pretend hot summer taerae doesn't exist🫠

This guide was very helpful for me

Nice video! Ofc, we're expecting some videos from you even after boys planet. Also, I love the "THE Wang Zihao". I miss him. Hope he debuts!

4:56 HIS OLD MAN BONES I'M CACKLING JFHKDSKKF

you've just became my fav.

Could you make a dance ranking of the members in the future as you're actually a dancer? I would love that!

We all better protect our child Yujin lmao i am 2 year older than him still i am calling him child😭 HELP!

how r u gonna say ricky's best skill is vocal when u name jiwoongs best skill visual? ricky should be visual too then, esp if ur gonna say gunwooks biggest weakness is vocal, when gunwook>ricky vocals /nm also i really liked taerae in backdoor which wasnt a cute concept per say :)

@_harley_1288

Жыл бұрын

I don’t know why they said that for Jiwoong either. But they also said the only concept Ricky is good at is being “young and rich tall and handsome”. I’d say both comments are an equal level of shallowness.

@_harley_1288

Жыл бұрын

I’m not very educated on Jiwoong’s skills so I can’t compare or tell you who’s better but I will say op chose Ricky’s singing as his best skill for a reason (I’d say either that or stage presence). It is his strongest skill compared to dancing and rapping. Ricky even said so himself.

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

@@_harley_1288 to be the visual of a group you need to fit the korean beauty standard, keep your composure often and when it comes to schedules they get a lot of photoshoots, ads and commercials. Jiwoong has experience in that field and fits the korean beauty standard well, so he is the most fit to be the visual of zb1 (and would just be a great visual for any group). And I didn't say the only thing Ricky could do was his persona, that's just dumb, what I meant is he shines in concepts that are like playing that persona (such as: sexy, elegant, expensive, etc).

I still haven't got over KTL's Zhanghao

do you hate ricky or smth

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

Actually he's in my bias line

@jeonghair4876

Жыл бұрын

@@tiredmarley interesting

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

@@jeonghair4876 💀

I love how you're subjective and objective at the same time.

CONCLUSION: ZB1 DEBUT WITH CUTE CONCEPT!!

Whenever you say zb1, Marley spawns

Honestly slay video Marleypoo -smog btw

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

You're still alive???

@r.o.n.8915

Жыл бұрын

@@tiredmarley gurl I didn't kms 💀

i agree

I’m sorry my English isn’t so good although I’m Korean I have got so much of a crush on Yujin he’s so cute talent as well and also same ages 🤣 Zhang hao was my final choose in the final voting but I am hoping that all the group and Yujin also will get lots of love and attention in the future fighting all fan and zerobaseone

The way you see Ricky and the way I see him it's 💯 percent opposite ....I respect your opinion though....he is a good vocalist but not the best in the group....that guy has a stage presence .......I have more to say about him...just lazy to type ...I wish I could record🤣...ok but he also said he wants to work hard so he cld improve ....Nd he is thankful for star creators who understands his weakness...🌹 ... hopefully our boys will work hard and do their best

I think hanbin has made smart choices in bp, idk if it was in his strategy to not showcase much of his dancing skills because he knew that his old videos would blow up (he must be a genius if he thought abt it) so focusing on vocals he proved himself as a full package also notice that all of the concepts he tried are different so we could see that he can do anything possible In conclusion get your exclusive ticket to be a predebut fan of the next it boy !

I recently found out that Ricky is very rich, what do you mean a person who claims to be rich is rich!? 😦

i know you hate ricky and gyuvin

@_harley_1288

Жыл бұрын

Don’t say that. Please stop you’re making Riyangis look bad.

@tiredmarley

Жыл бұрын

I know you have zero braincells

How are you gonna make a guide and talk sht about members u don’t like

@thethingcalledlisa

Жыл бұрын

Don’t worry this channel doesn’t just hate on people he doesn’t like, it’s mainly a weird sense of humour, also you can’t really take kpop group guides too seriously

@mvv0

Жыл бұрын

How was anything in the video even remotely close to hate?

UNLESS