I forget where the quip came from: "Hamlet isn't so great; it's full of cliches you hear all the time."

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Ha, I love that! Very witty and perceptive quip!

@laurenhahn101

Жыл бұрын

That's a very old joke...

@neosapienz7885

Жыл бұрын

That brought a smile to my face. 😊

@nelsonx5326

Жыл бұрын

Yogi Berra.

@mgmartin51

Жыл бұрын

“Beethoven isn’t so great. You’ve never seen his face on a bubblegum card, have you?”

I just discovered you tonight and already watched about 15 of your videos. I have to express my gratitude for your efforts and for sharing your inspirinig insights with us. You, sir, are a great great man! Thank you!

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

Wow. Thank you :) I really appreciate that - let us know if you have any videos you would like to see!

@colinellesmere

2 жыл бұрын

I have also just come across this channel. A fantastic service. Great natural delivery.

@josuelopez1500

2 жыл бұрын

Yes! Benjamin is extremely binge-worthy! Also, his videos should be rewatched as much as he insists we ought to reread the great novels. 😅

@rosannavitale9922

Жыл бұрын

I, too, have just discovered this channel. Thank you. Smiles,

@Jimbodisfan

Жыл бұрын

Good morning from New Jersey! Found your channel and subscribed. Thank you for sharing your difficult books. I'm going to add Jose Luis Borges and Shakespeare to my "to read" list. I've actually read Anna Karenina, which was a great book because you care about the characters. Or maybe you don't. I found Anna to be both pitiable and deserving of her fate.

Hello Benjamin ! I am a Moroccan poet and I taught British and American Literature to English teacher trainees. Interestingly enough I discovered you through my son who has just read Wuthering Heights and sent me your video on it . It was one of the books I taught 40 years ago and had my then students to work on 14 different reading tracks on that novel. Only great novels can stand deep analysis. I truly appreciate your great depth and your keen sense of analysis along with your sensitiveness and genuine knowledge of the world literature. I also really the simplicity and directness and passion with which you present your videos far from any presumptuous academic attitude. Yesterday I watch your video on Dickens since I have a workshop on Dickens with school kids in three weeks. This video on difficult writers really helps apprehend writers generally categorised as difficult. Isn't difficulty a nice challenge for a teacher or a reader?

@patd.3368

Жыл бұрын

@hafsa Bekri-Lamrani…great teachers…and I am sure that you yourself are one…always recognize their own…you are all alchemists!!!

@hafsabekri-lamrani9174

Жыл бұрын

@@patd.3368 Thank you fir your appreciation!

A writer that is quite challenging that I love: William Faulkner.

@camofrog

Жыл бұрын

It helps a lot to know what you’re in for with him.

@sherunswithscissors

10 ай бұрын

I couldn’t read Faulkner for years. One year I took some of his books with me when on holiday and couldn’t put them down. What a feast!

@arinzedike9693

2 ай бұрын

Can anyone please recommend a good novel by Faulkner?

@storiedworlds6261

2 ай бұрын

@@arinzedike9693 For me, the best place to start with Faulkner is “Light in August”; great novel. “As I Lay Dying” is suggested by a lot of people. My favorite Faulkner is “Go Down, Moses” but it’s technically not a novel. That should give you enough to start with. Happy reading.

@talastra

Ай бұрын

@@arinzedike9693 I found the second and second to last chapter of Light in August very baffling as a high schooler, but not enough to put me off Faulkner. Along with The Sound and the Fury, and Absalom, Absalom, I always want to recommend the Snopes trilogy (especially the third book). Like most trilogies, the middle book is maybe the weakest. Also, Knights Gambit is a collection of stories about Faulkner's country lawyer, Gavin Stevens. Light in August does have one phrase that I never forget from Faulkner: the "hookwormridden heirs-at-large"

The trick for me reading Shakespeare is I focus on one character and imagine I'm acting that part. I know I can't act, not even interesting in it, but reading his plays is easier for me if I act out one part in my head.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

I love that approach, Minerva! What a wonderful way of connecting to Shakespeare. You're living the roles! :)

Are you a fan of Cormac McCarthy? I'm admittedly not well read. I read in school, but for whatever reason stopped after. For my 31st birthday a couple years ago, my partner bought me a copy of The Road by McCarthy. I had heard about it in passing. The ending made me weep. I've never had a piece of media hit me in such an emotional way. I've read everyday since. I'll forever be grateful to that book for making me love literature.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

Huge fan! I'm currently planning a podcast on The Road, and Blood Meridian is on our book club schedule in a few months - we'll deep-read it over 8-10 weeks. If you could see my bedside table, you would see No Country for Old Men splayed open. I'm not surprised McCarthy made you fall in love with literature, Miles - he's a master! And a personal favourite of mine :)

@MilesWilliams88

2 жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy Blood Meridian is so good! It was a tough read for a dummy like me, ha, but I read it twice back to back. I recently discovered your channel, and have been binge watching your videos. Great stuff! Keep it up.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

@@MilesWilliams88 Oh, it was a tough read for me too. I had to put the book down several times and try again. Thank you for the kind words, my friend, I appreciate them - it's great to have you here :)

@talastra

Ай бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy Blood Meridian is very gorgeous, and the book where McCarthy finally finds a space to explore the notion of evil he'd been after. The Orientalism is unfortunate, and the nihilism is disappointing, the narrative is ultimately too beholden to the Glanton bang, and he's only a Cancer, not a Pisces--but the prose is still fantastic. His "Outer Dark" is an excellent early attempt (a more compelling read to me), and I've felt that his Suttree is unduly neglected. I never got around to reading anything starting from "All the Pretty Horses" onward though. Don't know why he didn't get a Nobel prize.

How did I ever get along as a book dork without your channel? You're doing a great service to book lovers far and wide, the classics have always been my favorite but I rarely got to discuss them with other literature geeks. Every time I finish a classic I feel more kinship for my fellow man across time and space. I have done what you recommended by imagining the characters are real people and the author is alive right here in front of me personally handing over a copy of their book. It helps remind me that the authors were real people with real intentions.

@brockatgmail

8 ай бұрын

It’s like time travel… you hear the language,visit the places, travel time and space virtually 😊😊

I began reading Proust when I was around 20 or so and thought I was intellectual. I gave up after 30 pages and ended up selling the book at a flea market a couple of years later. Now when I’m on the wrong side of 50 I’ve finally come back to Proust and love reading him. I work in the stressful world of IT and 5-10 pages of Proust in the evening really clears my mind. You can’t get any further away from my day job than Proust. As you point out, the key is slowing down and letting the book take the time it requires. So I really think you need to read ”difficult” writers at the right moment in life. Then they are perhaps not all that difficult. The exception is Joyce who I will never get my head around! I started out with Proust an e-book, but it just felt wrong. I didn’t want a paperback edition either, which is the only one in print here in Sweden, so ended up scouting the second hand book shops and again bought the same edition I had sold 25 years ago. I am close to end of The Guermentes Way, but think I will a break before going on to part IV. Do you have any suggestions?

@gracefitzgerald2227

Жыл бұрын

After I read Guermantes Way, it took me over a year to pick up Sodom and Gomorrah. It was a much easier read. Now I’m listening to the audio and I can keep up in the salon’s with the gang and roll my eyes when someone is being ever so clever(so snobby). Next book is super saucy! Hope you’ve picked it back up.

@Find-Your-Bliss-

Жыл бұрын

One Hundred Years of Solitude Bel Canto Angels and Insects Just for a break!

@jackiepike1466

Ай бұрын

I suggest taking a break with a short tale by Edgar Allan Poe. Nothing to do with Proust, but Poe's use of language and imagination are sensational.

Just finished Seamus Heaney's translation of Beowulf. I cried my heart out.

@skeovkp48598

Жыл бұрын

Oh I absolutely loved this too. To feel a connection with those people from so long ago was amazing.

I always find Moby-Dick at least moderately difficult. Definitely demanding. But never a slog.

I recently discovered you and am thrilled. After being an avid reader for years, I stopped reading much of anything. Listening to your videos has given me a new start. Now that I'm 71, I'm going to revisit many of the books I've read. , it's time for a new perspective.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

I'm so thrilled that you're here, Mindy :) And I couldn't be happier to hear that you're enthused to re-enter the world of great literature! Thank you so much for such a lovely comment!

Pierre Bezukhov will always live in my soul. War and Peace affected me more than any book I'd ever read and I just couldn't stop thinking about it after I'd finished. So I'll be reading it again along with you this year. There are so many classics I haven't read though. I used to read tons, but somehow that dwindled away as I got older (I blame the internet which didn't exist in my youth). I regret that now, so I'm on a mission to make up for lost time. I just discovered your channel, and have binge watched loads. So along with my daily reading I now have a goal to watch one of your videos every day. I'm so happy I found you!

@bradbowers4414

Ай бұрын

I also love War and Peace. One of my favorites. I need to pick it back up again this year.

Thank you for this video, Ben. One of the many interesting thoughts you shared stood out to me because it happened to me, long before I knew you and most likely before you even had read your first word. In the 70ties for the first time I read H. Manns two volumes of Henri Quatre. (Montaigne appears in there and showed his kind character and free spirit) . Ever since I’d see Catherine Medici, her face half covered by a curtain looking down from one of the upper windows of the Louvre when I walked by. These books! One really lives in them. Fairly voluminous but towards the end one wishes he’d go on and on.

This is so amazing. So glad I found you. The advice you give to slow down and reread is important. I don’t often revisit texts because there are so many to read, but that is problematic since many great works demand rereading.

I struggled with Melville's "Moby Dick," but just finished it after three earlier failures at different stages in my life thanks to your and Harold Bloom's deep praise of the work. It requires an immediate re-read, I believe, to absorb it properly. So many different voices, some of which I could not decipher. It's narrative style shifts so often as well. Other difficult reads in my life: Faulkner's "As I Lay Dying." That required another immediate re-read, and has frightened me off other Faulkner, to date, sadly. Anything by Pynchon is a challenge; but I found him rather witty when I read him in college. I failed at Palisser's "Quincunx" when I first attempted it (I picked up from a recommendation and found it dull then), but I think I've gained enough patience and reading experience for it now. I do believe a modern pinnacle might be DFW's "Infinite Jest." I have it, I did venture a couple pages when I first bought it but set it aside. I realize that it might take a few months to complete. The Bible. Might that be the beginning of Harold Bloom's "Western Canon"? You've an impressive body of work here on KZread. You are an inspiration to anyone who wants to elevate their reading into the classics.

Thanks so much for all your insights. I've enjoyed your work so much for the past 3 or 4 years, and I'm always excited to hear what you have to offer or suggest. You are so tactful and intelligent that you give me a kind of solace and deep understanding after such (very) gratifying books/novels. I doubt I would be able to continue reading so deeply and happily without your perspective and insights. All best regards for a marvelous new year. I very much look forward the coming year! Rob in NYC

Your channel is a blessing for book readers! Still waiting for my mail of 'In Search of Lost Time' and can't wait to tackle it, slooowly 😉

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you, Adit :) I really appreciate that! Let me know what you think of Proust!

@aditmaryadi6678

2 жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy Yes I will! I knew Proust from another booktuber. But decided to purchase it because of your 'How to Read' video 😊

@davidcopson5800

Жыл бұрын

He should focus on religious books. That would be a blessing for us all.

What you said about “… Tolstoy wants you to keep the characters in your soul” resonates so deeply with me. The first piece of literature i have ever read at the age of 6 was Martin the Cobbler, a parable by him. And i always, always go back to those parables, whether it be “what men live by”, “god sees the truth but waits”, “walk in the light whenever there is light” etc etc… these stories shaped who i am today!

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

That is such a beautiful appreciation. How amazing that you were treated to Tolstoy so early on, and you still return to his works today!

You're very welcome, Benjamin. All your videos look interesting. Newly subscribed, I hope to view as many as I can. Thank you for taking the time to make them, and, in my opinion, by making the world a more literate, better place. A 74 year old American, my favorite poet is Philip Larkin; my favorite novelist is Barbara Pym. Shakespeare is the best!

Gravity’s rainbow has to be an all time (equal parts) phenomenal and difficult novel (if you can even call it that)

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

I completely agree!

@DanBlabbers

Жыл бұрын

I completely agree, I read about 75 pages and was very overwhelmed I put it down. Still greatly enjoyed it and have a lot of respect for it. It felt to me like I was reading it but not processing it fully and felt it a shame to continue reading it I’m not absorbing it completely.

@malexander4094

Жыл бұрын

I'll read it a 4th time next year. What I realized the 1st time is that you almost need to approach it like you are taking a psychedelic drug: that there's an intense come up, then an eventual plateau, and finally a steady if occasionally rough comedown. Ultimately, I also think the best way to approach it is as "a hippie novel." When you realize a lot of the major elements are about the devastation & also hope of renewal in nature & the earth, and what our species is doing to it, then a lot of things make sense. The other thing about the novel, and partly what makes it well-loved by those who finish it, is that the novel's core themes almost require that it be so wild & encompassing. It has to be both entertaining & difficult, beautiful & horrifying, bright & dark, because it's central gift is a treasure chest surrounded by traps.

@malexander4094

Жыл бұрын

@@DanBlabbers Don't be ashamed! I've read it a few times, but it took patience that 1st time. I established goodwill with "Vineland," which I highly recommend, and then of course "Inherent Vice" with its film adaptation. (I do *not* advise "Lot 49" ...yes it's short, but it doesn't give you the best of Pynchon's characters, humor, heart, or prose.) What everyone who finishes "Gravity's Rainbow" seems to realize is that Part 1, "Beyond the Zone," is a trial-by-fire. The book is like taking a psychedelic: the first part where people put it down is only "the come up." You hit the plateau in Part 2. But Pynchon definitely frontloads the hardest part of the novel. You have to pass its test. The novel isn't trying to be obscure: but it needs to "break" you a bit to ride its rewarding wavelength. One piece of advice I give is to think of it as a hippie novel...perhaps *the* hippie novel. It's fundamentally a novel about the earth, about nature, and what our species has done to devastate it, in order to also kill each other...but also the hope of renewal we have in it. It's through the lens of the 1970s, but set as an apocalyptic "end of the world" battle near the end of WWII.

@jeanlobrot

Жыл бұрын

@@malexander4094 as someone with a passion for psychedelics I completely agree

Reading Nietzsche is a particular pleasure of mine. Reading him requires multiple reads.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

You're so right, Brennan. He needs to be a lifelong companion!

@DressyCrooner

Жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy I am so happy I discovered him as a 13-year-old. He has been my faithful companion these many years.

@damianbylightning6823

Жыл бұрын

But Nietzsche isn't necessarily difficult. Understanding certain things does require deep study and lots of thought and rereads, but all that is a pleasure - he is a very clear and often captivating writer. Your average reader can engage with him - and scuttle off for further reading on specific matters - was Nietzsche a Stoic/why was he opposed to the Stoics? What is he saying about free will and does that make him a determinist - if not, why not? These are issues that undergrad level students should not struggle with. His writing is always clear. Sometimes people need to be told the obvious before they see it - such as humour in Nietzsche, but they are able to spot it once they're told about it. I never spotted much of the humour until it was pointed out to me. His camp followers have been difficult, charmless and total bastards though.

I think the Chekhov line was, "Don't tell me there was a fight, show me the moonlight glinting on broken glass." It gets to the controversy of showing versus telling in fiction. The purist wants everything shown; telling is a sin or something. But I have heard that it has to be a balance. If you are showing too much your pacing is going to be slow as mud. Thanks for keeping literature alive in the video game era! I have heard many times that "Gen Z" is getting back to the literary arts. I hope so!

@alexandra.v

Жыл бұрын

Well, I consider myself as a late Gen Z person and I really appreciate good books. I want to read some deeper literature than I read before. I simply love how this man expresses himself, he really loves literature and I want more of him. I also wanted to write a book but I gave up because it is too time-consuming and the subject is quite irrelevant.

So happy to have found your channel! I took a look at the titles reviewed and they are either books I love or books I want to read but fear has entered the picture. I'm going to get started and leave the Booker list for now.

Benjamin, one of my favourite difficult authors is Marie-Claire Blais, specifically her series Soifs. The first book is translated as These Festive Nights. Each novel is one paragraph featuring some very long sentences. I always read them aloud which makes the music of the words come to the fore. I have just begun to watch and to listen to your videos and will continue to do so from now on.

I’m reading Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Investigations. I have the version in both German and English. I’ve been finding very subtle differences between the two, which lends to the difficulty. To address this, I highlight the differences and then research the German phrases to get a sense of their deeper meaning. I recommend reading a text in the original language, if you can. This approach forces you to step into a different culture, which increases the richness of the journey.

It is ten months since I first followed Virgil and and Dante into the Inferno. I am now on Canto 4 of Paradiso. I will read this work for the rest of my life. It requires a detailed understanding of 13th and 14th century Italian politics and the medieval intellectual and spiritual milieu. I have never encountered a work that required me to read three different translations simultaneously, as well as Aristotle, Ovid and Virgil. Yowzah! Glad I am retired and ave an bundance of time for it.

Your mention of Aristotle reminded me of Chrysippus and how unfortunate it is that so very little of his prolific work has survived. I just discovered you this evening. You’re a fascinating speaker and I’m excited to explore all of your videos.

Thank You for the channel! Great to see someone so enthusiastic about litterature which I also love.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, Anna :) I really appreciate that!

I am happy to announce that after fifty years of trying de rigeur, I have finished Proust's A la recherche du temps perdu, during the pandemic quarantine. I trod onwards with determination, though frequently tempted to despair. But then I reached the scene where the Baron is denounced by his protegé, the young pianist. Wow! I didn't see that coming! Three or four of the major characters experience character development in that scene. For hundreds of pages the the Baron appeared as a talkative boor, but suddenly he is silenced in the face of slander, and at last the Queen of Naples, his cousin, returns for her fan, sizes up the situation and leads him away on her arm. What a narrative tour de force! So the hard books do give good payback, n'est ce pas?

I will only read books written in "plain English" because reading becomes unenjoyable when I'm unable to read at the same pace as my inner voice.

When I first tried Ovid, I found it very strange. Really helped to have expert guidance, and now I love reading Ovid. I've heard you really have to understand high German to fully appreciate Goethe, people say it just doesn't translate well. My first foray into Tolstoy, years ago didn't go well, but then I tried another translation and was entranced almost immediately. I took a university course covering writers like Aquinas, Dante, More, Donne and Milton. Such a great experience and I feel like I would not appreciate them nearly as much had I just jumped in myself. Still haven't braved Joyce. And I struggle with Thomas Hardy, mostly because his books are just so. relentlessly depressing.

@Nick-qf7vt

Жыл бұрын

I wish I could take a course like that! Yes, Hardy is pretty depressing. Another really depressing one is Stoner by John William's

Thank you for your channel. I finally have somewhere to go and hear about my favourite books. I appreciate your insight and presentation.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Aw, thank you, Roza. I really appreciate that, and I'm so happy you're here with me :)

Hi Benjamin, I stumbled across your channel yesterday, and I absolutely loved the content. All the videos that I have watched so far were very good. I especially loved the ones on Dickens and Tolstoy. Keep up the great work buddy. :) :)

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Hi Arijit :) Thank you so much, my friend. You have made my day. I'm so happy to have great lovers of literature like yourself here with me! Dickens and Tolstoy both hold a special place in my heart, so we'll definitely have more content on them in the near future!

The best way to read Proust is just to open it to a random page, and read a paragraph. It’s always perfect.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

I completely agree with you there, Susan. His passages are like little journeys, or paintings, even pieces of music in miniature rendered in prose. Opening to any page randomly is such a joy :)

I loved this video, your insight into ‘difficulty’ is helpful and constructive, thank you. I’d love to hear your opinion of Borges Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote. That story absolutely blew my mind when I first read and I read it in almost constant rotation for a year, running about telling all my friends and family to read it and quoting my favourite sentences. Books can be so amazing.

Bruno Schulz - he was my first difficult writer and thanks to him I fell in love with difficult literature. I read Schulz just after the high school when my favourite genre of books was fantasy (still is! but even since I diversified my bookshelf), so what amazed me my sound a bit childish. Schulz writing was for me all style no substance. By substance I mean any kind of story, something I took for granted at that time. Yet, I didn't have any troubles with reading Schulz, I was simply amazed by his writing style and this surreal world he painted with his words.

Dostoyevsky's Demons is a difficult but rewarding read. So much is going on in it. Whenever I pick it up, I do actually find something interesting to think about no matter where in the book I am, and yet it's hard to follow everything going on and all the characters.

@alexdegross6248

Жыл бұрын

My favorite novel of his. Changed my life. Atleast “ demons” has a coherent trajectory.

@EmilynWood

Жыл бұрын

@@alexdegross6248 I'm working on reading the rest of his books--I've only read Crime and Punishment, some of his short stories, and most of The Brothers Karamazov, but I'm excited to get to The Idiot after I finish my read-through of Demons. Loved Crime and Punishment.

@Nick-qf7vt

Жыл бұрын

@@EmilynWood Notes from Underground as brilliant as well. House of the Dead is also a fantastic autobiographical novel

Winston Graham's Poldark series is AMAZING. He also demands that you live the story. His character development is a steady growth throughout the series., and his characters stay true to their written characterizations throughout. I'm not speaking of the Masterpiece Theatre series on PBS - although that was well done. But reading Graham's words - he brings you into the Cornish landscape - you can hear the gulls, you can smell the sea. You can envision the angry storms crashing against the cliffs. He brings the French revolution and the resulting Napoleonic Wars, up close, as they effect the economy of Cornwall and the life of its inhabitants - all while keeping the continental conflicts in the background. His descriptions of the ships, their crews, and the shipwrecks are palatable. His description of the 1790s - 1800s attire is well detailed. All in all, the writing is phenomenal! I highly recommend READING the books. Or, Audible has the entire series in an audiobook - the reader does a beautiful job changing his voice for each character.

The authors I find the most challenging and difficult to read are Marcel Proust, Fyodor Dostoevsky, Leo Tolstoy and Herman Melville. But they are also incredibly rewarding, and they are my absolute favourite authors. Their books haunt me and will stay with me for life. I have yet to read Joyce's Ulysses, I am very intimidated by this book, but I am willing to get a copy and read it. Benjamin I am so glad that I found your channel. I have been binge-watching your videos ; I love and appreciate the passion you have for literature and the effort you put into sharing your passion with us. Keep up the great work ! Greetings from France 🌹

After many years of procrastinating, taking out and then returning War and Peace from the library, unread, I decided two years ago to give it another try. I bought my own copy, Anthony Briggs Translation, and then forgot all about it again. Three weeks ago I decided it was now or never - I would commit myself to one hour's reading every night while listening to the same version of the Audiobook at the same time. This decision is a game changer for me, as I set the book at 1.65 x pace - it slows my usual reading speed somewhat, but I've found that it gives me ample time to ponder over what I'm reading, stopping to Google additional information on some battles and war terminology, also looking up the meaning of words new to me and making annotations as I go along. I thoroughly enjoy the experience and find myself re-visiting some thoughts and ideas in my mind in the following days. Should've done this a long time ago!

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

impressive

@erina2600

Жыл бұрын

That’s a great idea actually!

A recommendation for this section: The Uruguayan writer Juan Carlos Onetti. Very good stories, tremendous novellas. Difficult but very rewarding. Bonus: Felisberto Hernández's short stories (Uruguayan, as well)

Great observation! I am blown by the depth of your perspective on the mentioned writers and their books! Thank goodness I came across your Channel. Thank you so much for such an impressive video❤😊😊

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Thank you very much :) That's so kind of you to say! I'm happy to have you here :)

@stefan3876

Жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy My pleasure!!🤗 Please keep them coming. Will look forward for more such thought provoking content from you. 😊😊

Benjamin, thank you for these videos. So helpful and insightful. Your voice is so good you could read a book; audible should call.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much, Lorna :) That is so kind of you! It's actually a little dream of mine to do narrations for my favourite novels, short stories, and poems. So hopefully some day! 😊

I came by your channel and immediately subscribed. I like how you talk about classics ( as a classics nerd), I hope you make a video about Dante's Inferno and Shakespeare's Anthony and Cleopatra

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

Thank you for watching :) I have plans to do both of those masterpieces!

@simoocean5284

2 жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy I hope you do it very soon because I need them for my second semester exams

I started reading Faulkner when I was 15, and still binge on him now, 51 years later. "As I Lay Dying" and "The Sound and the Fury" are dearest to my heart. The latter appears on many lists like yours.

@Alexander-tj2dn

Жыл бұрын

Boring

@jgirlLVR

Жыл бұрын

@@Alexander-tj2dn Thou hast spoken.

@Alexander-tj2dn

Жыл бұрын

@@jgirlLVR ha, ha

I recently read Cervantes The Ingenious Gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha and I find it very difficult to follow and to understand. I really appreciate your podcasts and generally what you do. Thank you a lot. I wish I have "meet" you earlier but I guess it's better late then never.:))

@BenjaminMcEvoy

3 жыл бұрын

Choosing the right translation of Cervantes is extremely important. There are dozens of popular translations and they all differ wildly - with many of them being awful. I first started with the Motteaux translation and had to give up on the book. It was unreadable. Then I found the Rutherford translation and fell in love and laughed out loud! It was a whole new experience and became one of my favourite novels of all time. Rutherford and Grossman are the translations to choose :) Thank you for your kind words, I'm so happy you're enjoying the show!!

@rutolteanu3828

3 жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy The thing is English is my second language and I tried to read it in romanian which is my native language.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

3 жыл бұрын

@@rutolteanu3828 Impressive stuff!! I love Romania btw :) great country.

Thank God someone well read finally said Shakespeare is difficult to read! I feel dumb all the time .

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

Incredibly difficult! If you're reading him, he's for you though - so you're definitely not dumb, my friend!

@markjacobs509

2 жыл бұрын

I thought similarly, then I joined the 2020 Shakespeare Project that tackled all of his works, a week per work, in less than a year. After a few plays, you reach a point where you get accustomed to the language and style, then it gets easier and you can consider the depth and breadth of his work. I also reached a point where the plays became repetitive, particularly in literary devices and plot. As a Yank, what I find difficult in Shakespeare’s Histories is the references to the same character by his family name or his estate name, particularly as the estate names change depending on either inheritance or a change in which faction controls the kingdom.

@aamnainfebruary

Жыл бұрын

No Fear Shakespeare by Sparknotes is the key

@leoquesto9183

Жыл бұрын

Hang in there. One way to approach his works is to become immersed in the smallest morsel that catches your interest, a fragment as small as a sentence (or two), and familiarize yourself with its parts, live with them. Take your time. There’s no rush. It will speed up as you go. If you do this repeatedly, your capacity for learning the shapes and content of the Bard’s word puzzles will come and begin to feel natural to you. Soon you will absorb an enormous amount in the way of his elastic toying with syntax, meaning and cadence. It will come to you. Keep at it and you’ll notice that your ability to anticipate his rhythms, schemes, and shapes will be met with amazement and surprise in the amount of variability he tucks into them. It’s alien for a short time only. It will come. I hope this helps.

@scandalfrb4154

Жыл бұрын

I realize this doesn't work for everyone since not everyone wants to act, but getting cast in a Shakespeare changed everything. First rehearsal where we were on our feet (I didn't happen at the table read) was like visceral click for me from struggling to getting it.

Decided to tackle Proust, in search of.... I imagine it will take years for me . Looking forward to it immensely. Thanks for your tips Ben

@phakada3787

Жыл бұрын

It’s better to take some time in between the volumes, you’ll find yourself thinking about it after you finish, the more you think about it (within reason) before reading the next volume the better.

Rayuela by Julio Cortázar is definitely a demanding book as well. So many references, so long sentences and lots of metaphors. Freaking love it.

@danielcastillomolero4253

Жыл бұрын

I'm just reading Rayuela now. I am a native Spanish speaker and wonder how is it possible to translate into other languages. Are you reading It It English? Must be a real chalkenge.

@ignacio27

Жыл бұрын

@@danielcastillomolero4253 Fue traducida al inglés como ‘Hopscotch’ por Gregory Rabassa, mismo hombre que hizo la traducción de Cien Años de Soledad que el mismo García Márquez reconoció como "superior" a la original. Su versión de Rayuela ganó un premio

@TheWaxlemon

Жыл бұрын

recently read bestiary and fell in love with this guy

@davidcopson5800

Жыл бұрын

That book had me jumping around all over the place, especially over chalk lines on the pavement.

one of the first things I tried to read when I got into reading again as an adult was "notes from the underground" by dostoevsky, and even though it was short and now I can read dostoevsky fine (tho I never finished that one), I felt genuinely dumb trying to read it because I kept having to go back to understand what he was talking about or I'd just space out during the longer monologue sections lmao

I found it helped to take a class when I was reading difficult books. In college I had a couple of Shakespear classes and wound up reading a good portion of his plays and sonnets. I enjoyed it and understood it quite well thanks to an excellent teacher. Not sure if it would have gone as well without that guide.

Just discovered this channel and joined, great stuff!!

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, John! :)

Jane Austen was a Capricorn, Shakespeare was a Taurus, and Hugo was a Pisces. Ben your work is fantastic and each to their own when it comes to the zodiac, just do some rooting around. Keep it up, your recommendations inspire me immensely.

@marcsmirnoff936

Жыл бұрын

That's just (& civil) criticism. And it hits me that this isn't the first time I've encountered a proponent of the zodiac with more confidence than accuracy. Sorry if that sounds harsh but it's true to my experience (not speaking for others).

@davidcopson5800

Жыл бұрын

Jane Austen was a Sagittarius.

@marcsmirnoff936

Жыл бұрын

@@davidcopson5800 She was a better novelist than Sagittarius, Capricorn, or Pisces.

My favorite difficult author is Plotinus (I feel OK bringing him to the conversation because you mentioned Plato). Reading Plotinus is kind of like reading Plato, but without the characters and narrative that Plato uses. Additionally, a lot of Plotinus is clarifying his own understanding from that of other contemporaries who might be Stoics or Aristotelians; if you don't know the nature of the ancient debate it can be difficult to follow. But there are times when Plotinus's writings soar into celestial realms that usually only poets access and when that happens it makes the effort of reading him completely worthwhile; it offers the reader a glimpse of eternity. For that reason, Plotinus is an author I regularly reread. // Thanks for the video.

@eugeneylliez829

Жыл бұрын

I couldn't agree more on Plotinus. And I highly recommand _The Divine Names_ by (pseudo) Dionysius the Areopagite, because it is a good "sequel" of that glimpse of eternity. A unique difficult but magnificent book.

i agree with you about the waste land, but four quartets to me is a work of absolute genius

I agree with most of your list. Most hard-to-read books end up being gems when you crack them. Often, you just need a Rosetta stone. For instance, I had a hip young lit professor at Ohio State. She likened *Ulysees* to a series of Monty Python skits, and read some passages to show the humor. That allowed me to work through it... and actually "get" it. I was only twenty, and probably knew less than 1% of Joyce's references... and yet I read it and understood the story... and laughed. That said, there are many hard books to read. For my money, the best contemporary ones that take serious work are Pynchon, Umberto Eco, and David Foster Wallace. I also loved *JR* by William Gaddis, which took me several dozen stabs before I could get past past the first chapter. It was hilarious, told in "stream of audition..." No thoughts, no stage direction, no description, just dialog that you had to piece together into a story. Also, I've recently added *Lincoln in the Bardo* to my list of favorite books, and it's quite hard to read, As to philosophers, why stop at Aristotle? Many, such as Kant, Spinoza, Hobbes, Locke, Nietzche, Spencer, Hegel, Wittgenstein, etc. can be impenetrable after a few pages. Even the "worldly philosophers," AKA the classical economists like Smith and Marx, can be hard to read. Oh, and then there are the *Upanishads.* Brilliant, thought provkoing, and hard to understand. And much of the Buddhistic Pali canon, hard to read because it's often dull and repetitive, yet absolutely structured and coherent once you begin practicing Buddhism. Oh, and Jung. And the *Masks of God* books by Joseph Campbell. And *The Ecology of Freedom* by Murray Bookchin/ Etc, etc. I often hated these books. And yet, I'm glad I took the time to read them.

Tristram Shandy is a trip down in 18th century lane and a postmodern novel 4Runner. It's a little difficult until you get used to the 18th century language, it's also hilarious and makes one think about the construct of the novel as was before him and has become in our modern day.

@thedativecase9733

Жыл бұрын

I couldn't get to grips with Tristram Shandy until BBC Radio 3 did a dramatisation- which was brilliant. I got my (stolen) copy of the book down off the shelf and metaphorically gobbled it up. It's now one of my favourite novels. Sometimes you just need a way in to a "difficult" or "boring" book.

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

I remember attempting to read this book when I left France , and after a few weeks of efforts, I started to get the feel of the style and enjoyed the novel greatly

@bad-girlbex3791

Жыл бұрын

That black page...can only imagine what readers of the time thought about it, lol.

Hi, I have come back to this as I do with a lot of your videos. I just wanted to say that as a non-native speaker of English I find Ulysses to be simply unreadable. It's one of the books that I want to read so badly but so far, I think, I have gone all armoured up at it for more than a dozen times but I put my guard down after a few pages as it is notoriously difficult. Over the years, I have realized that my language has improved quite a bit and an indication of it is that I can now read and enjoy books like Gibbon's history of Rome; and the only work by Shakespeare that I have read so far is his comedy "Love's Labour's Lost" and I enjoyed it to the bits. But just can't seem to get my way with Ulysses. Perhaps I need to read more before I am able to have another crack at it.

@jojodogface898

Жыл бұрын

Joyce is challenging even for native English speakers. I would say, take Ulysses slow and just try to enjoy it. You wont understrand everything but thats ok, you're not suppossed to, at least not on a first read thru. Just have fun with it and pick up what you can. Also, look out for puns, Joyce loves them. Then, if you want, pick up Finnegans Wake. That book is so difficult, I don't even think being a native English speaker would give someone an advantage

@josephgrinton841

9 ай бұрын

I found Love's Labour's Lost to be one of Shakespeare's most difficult plays and I'm a native speaker who taught English literature in a grammar school for some years. I've read it three times and watched a DVD of a performance at The Globe but I still feel there is much in it that I've not understood. I definitely didn't laugh. I never managed to finish Ulysses either. I think I threw it away. I can no longer find it on my bookshelves.

Benjamin thank you for contributing to my life it’s a joy to listen to you the grate love that you profese for all this Master pieces I really Love Love difficult reading ……it leave you with a legacy of knowledge……I have the same kind of love for books like you do I never thought that I would find any other and here you are Blessings Benjamin you made me happy 💖👏✨

I'm really pleased I came across your channel. Your videos are excellent! Thank you.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

That's very kind of you to say :) Thank you so much for being here!

This excerpt by T.S. Eliot was in Jordan Peterson's TED Talk titled Potential. "We shall not cease from exploration And the end of all our exploring Will be to arrive where we started And know the place for the first time"

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

Nice :)

@EcopiuM

2 жыл бұрын

Peterson is a flop

@DressyCrooner

Жыл бұрын

Four Quartets.

I don’t know if TS Eliot is a bad person, but Prufrock seems about as good as a poem can get to me. And with a straight face you said your favorite authors are all Pisces…even if born under a different sign! 😂 Not intending to be a jerk-I enjoy your videos!

Borges (bore-hace, roughly) has always been one of my comfort-reads. I can see why many people might find him difficult and strange, but I've always found him at once stimulating and familiar and comforting (maybe because I grew up on fantasy and sci-fi?). He's also often quite funny if you can get on his wavelength. I appreciate that you mentioned Austen. I think she deceptively presents her work as simple and easy, and most people seem to take her at her word, and so dismiss her. Also, as with Swift, I think you can't fully appreciate her aims and achievements without being somewhat familiar with the literary context/conventions of her time.

I discovered Jon Fosse when his A New Name was put on the Booker International Prize long list this year. I read it and didn’t get it. The key was to read the first two books in the Septology first. Then I reread A New Name, and wow! He comes out of Joyce, whom I like, finished Ulysses, drowned in Finnegan’s Wake. But I think he goes beyond Joyce. After all the three volumes of Septology are one sentence. For me it also includes the greatest love story I’ve read. My top choice for this topic is Septology.

What you can get from many great books will change as you grow older. I recommend rereading a book 10 or 20 years after you first read it.

I was expecting the list to include writers like Milton ( I never read him - he seems to be the bane of English majors ). I only read excerpts from Don Quixote which was dense but surprisingly hilarious - this was in high school before I had a more developed sense of satire. I've always found it interesting and surprising to find out what people from other countries read and find difficult or challenging. I've met Germans who were quite impressed that I read so much of Kafka who didn't seem challenging at all to me. They think of Kafka as incredibly existential and cerebral. Quite a few French people grow up reading Proust - it's sounds like it's kind of a young French person's awakening as a teenager to discover him. There's a great movie called "Murmur of the Heart" where the young French protagonist is kind of thunderstruck by Proust and is constantly sticking his head in Proust books whenever he is overwhelmed growing up. His older brothers are kind of roguish - they set him up in a scene where he loses his virginity and it becomes a big joke to them - even his father is in on the joke. Proust is his refuge. German kids are pretty well versed in Shakespeare - lot of it has to do with how good the translator is. It's kind of ironic that a German romantic writer ( Tieck ) is probably best known as being the definitive transistor of Shakespeare. In a very Germanic way I've heard Germans actually claim that Shakespeare is one of their own. They practically consider him German, not English!

@BenjaminMcEvoy

3 жыл бұрын

Ah, funny you mention Milton - I've literally just picked up a new edition of his poems. Like all the main epic writers (Homer, Virgil, Dante), he is difficult - but the rewards are in proportion to his difficulty if you bring yourself fully to him. Surprisingly hilarious - yes, that's absolutely how I felt when I first read DQ!! amazing, that such a classic has such power to make me laugh. That is SO interesting about Shakespeare in German. I've heard he translates well into German, but had no idea that Germans are claiming him. Hey, fair enough! The language of Shakespeare, English itself, is deeply indebted to its German linguistic parents!!

@nuckygulliver9607

2 жыл бұрын

The German psyche would have a hard time with Kafka because his work deals with the absurdity of authoritarianism. Perhaps Kafka will hit home harder to you now depending where you live since covid has turned a lot of systems into a type of fascism. Our premier in Ontario tried to make an edict where we weren't allowed to leave our houses. The police force actually refused to take it that far. I don't have 'papers' that would allow me to go yo restaurants but I know some restaurants that will 'pretend' to see the covid pass. We have to put the mask on only until we get to the table. Covid doesn't affect people that are sitting! The scientific facts are different depending which media you're exposed to. The majority prefers the science from media that is literally sponsored by Phizer telling them they MUST force everyone to vaccinate even though the CDC claims the vaccinations don't prevent transmission. I haven't seen a smile for a year and. half because people put masks over their mouthes, often driving alone or even jogging. Our culture has become Kafkaesque, so people that buy into all the absurdity will have a psychological awakening reading his work. Germany is a leader in this absurdity so the Kafkaesque elements didn't disappear after the war. They didn't teach the war in history class to Germans and even banned the depiction of a swastika. Their attitude is repressive so reading Kafka, they wouldn't relate to K, but relate to the absurd community that is bound to absurd rules that seem designed to beat the spirit down. There's no logical argument that will convince people that the 'science' doesn't talk and tell us to set up authoritarian systems that tell us all small businesses are dangerous to keep open. Even opening the small business to sell merchandise on Amazon or Facebook marketplace is illegal. We are living in kafka's nightmare. Reading him we can recognize our current world. If you relate to K, Kafka is easy to read but if you relate to all the other characters Kafka would possibly have a profound psychological effect.

@nuckygulliver9607

2 жыл бұрын

if Don Quixote was difficult you probably were reading a difficult to read translation. Some translations ruin some of the humour, which would take away something, making it more difficult.

Well said. I agree with most of it. You might have pushed me to read Borges. Faulkner is a hobby of mine. He can be wonderful and challenging.

Thoroughly enjoy this discussion, you do it so well. I was an avid reader, some years ago, of challenging (difficult) works because I knew, as you point out, they were often very rewarding. It was a strange time for me. I actually had arguments with people about books I had read, but they had not (!) Moby Dick and Ulysses to be exact. I wondered how this could happen and I now think they were intimidated by the reputation of those works and resorted to pointless criticism as 'protection'. Much better to actually read, or try to read something, and then have a valid reaction to it.

@bad-girlbex3791

Жыл бұрын

Or maybe you were just looking for that argument to give you a reason to show off your newly discovered knowledge? To say that "I wondered how this could happen" as if up until you yourself had read said title(s) you too were one of those people who had not read Moby Dick or Ulysses. Find great books. Read them. Find them rewarding. Be excited by them. But don't behave like some precocious school child just because you spent a bit of time doing something you enjoyed for what should be entirely your own interests/experiences/benefits. This entire paragraph makes you sound like something of a pompous arse.

@bad-girlbex3791

Жыл бұрын

Happy to have hit upon a nerve! 👌

The more i think about this subject, the more subjective it feels. I feel like half the battle is connecting with the authors groove. Krasznahorkai is notoriously demanding be it works for me. I’ve never heard that about cortazar but he was super difficult for me to get through. Both super rewarding authors.

@katekcampbell

2 жыл бұрын

Cortazar for sure. I have (hopefully temporarily) given up on Hopscotch.

@davidcopson5800

Жыл бұрын

Krasznahorkai needs to discover sentences. They are NOT ten pages long!

One of the hardest novels I read was ‘Cancer Ward’ by Solzhenitsyn. I attempted it a few times and had to give up … I eventually completed it on my 3rd attempt. An amazing read.

@vivianblack2951

5 ай бұрын

now try August 1914 yikes

Loved your video!!! What would you consider some of the greatest short stories ever? Thanks again!!! 😀

Now that I've dipped my heel in your channel, I'm ready to dive in! Thanks. And you're amazing! I have listened to but a few of your podcasts but I want to mention a difficult writer to me: Umberto Eco. Yes, The Name of the Rose is pretty accessible, especially to a Baker Street Irregular and linuaphile. However, I went through one page of one of his books and marked the (translated) words I didn't know. There were 400. I have an extensive vocabulary and can figure my way through most romance language-rooted words. Also, I taught vocabulary enrichment for standardized test prep to HS students and graduate school students (and teachers (for the Miller's Analogy test)). Conclusion: I'm no slouch. I can read Italian but basically at a Mickey Mouse comic book level. So, Umberto Eco, what say you? Grazie mille!

@itmac26

Жыл бұрын

I wrote the same. I'm dealing right now with The Prague cemetery.

Joyce's FINNEGANS WAKE is a challenge for anyone.

Hello, I just found your channel today and this is the first of your videos I have watched. What a pleasure it is to hear what you have to say. I added you to my subscriptions list. Thanks.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Thank you, my friend :) I really appreciate you being here!

By the way Ben, I love your videos and enjoy them very much!!!

A difficult series was Steven Erikson's Malazan Book of the Fallen decology, each volume being a thick tome, with most being over 1000 pages (well over 3 millions words in the entire series) in standard paper back form. The difficulty is not the length - that actually makes it pleasurable as I didn't want the story to end! - but the fact that the story launches into its full complexity of plot and extraordinary characters (many many characters) without first spoon feeding the reader with any handy world building. Of great assistance to the author in this stupendous undertaking was drawing on his knowledge of legends acquired from his expertise as an anthropologist and archeologist. I read the first four or five volumes before the various backstories embedded in these volumes threw enough light to fully illuminate the first volume, with this process rolling through succeeding volumes. The richly textured and layered story unfolds in multiple continents and realms, and the numerous plot elements and extremely varied backgrounds and backstories of the main characters in this enormous tale jump back and forth across time, geography and realms, with it all coming together at the end (although leaving it open for numerous prequels and side stories). I adore the complexity of this story, and re-reading earlier volumes numerous times to clarify plot and character developments was a real pleasure as each reading yielded more meaning to, and information about, this wonderful literary layer cake.

@Barnes-ml9wg

Жыл бұрын

I just finished Malazan last month along with a few of the side novels....it's definitely not for the faint of heart. I would recommend John Gwynne to you. I am reading the Faithful and the Fallen series right now and it is probably my top 5 fantasy series I have ever read

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

seems fascinating indeed. Tempted!

We tapped out in the early 20th century, it seems. I’d add Pynchon, David Foster Wallace, William Gaddis, some of Bill Burroughs.

You discuss your favorite writers I think, not just the most difficult. I would add to your list Marquez and Rushdie but any such list contains huge omissions. I enjoyed what you have to say.

I absorbed huge amounts of Aristotle through Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Theologica (which I focused on in my studies, and read several times). I appreciated Thomas’ clarity and the quaestio formalism and it made Aristotles insights very accessible. Then I tried to read Aristotle on his own and I found it so difficult. But oddly I love Borges and can absolutely devour his short stories. Perhaps because he’s so conceptual and it works well for us armchair philosophers.

Borges was once asked who he thought was the greatest among the English authors. His reply, "Joseph Conrad". "But Conrad was Russian." "No he wasn't". "Well, what about Shakespeare?" "Far too German; all those bombastic metaphors!" Enjoyed your presentation very much. I've even subscribed.

@luisortega4991

Жыл бұрын

I thought Conrad was Polish

@alit6968

Жыл бұрын

@@luisortega4991 Conrad was Polish ,his really name is Joseph Conrad Korzeniowski.

Do you ever feel a strange yearning for the great literature to be written in the future which you will never be able to read? Perusing all of the Past Masters as well your own contemporaries can be an overwhelming task and can take you away from your own work besides. I actually prefer short stories which gives me the free time to create not only my own shorter fiction but also preferentially to indulge in the plastic arts that I love. It is just finding time for everything! Keep up the good work. Read the first part of Don Quixote by the way, and now, after ten years have passed, it might just be the right time for me to finish!

I have just started watching your videos, Ben, so apologies for commenting 2 years after you posted this, but what you say is still very inspiring and relevant. Two books I find very difficult are The Cantos of Ezra Pound and The Pound Era by Hugh Kenner. Part of the reason is that, like T.S. Eliot whom he influenced, perhaps Ezra Pound was not a very likeable man and was being deliberately obscure, as was Hugh Kenner in his meditation on Pound's literary legacy. I can't help wondering, while I'm deciphering these texts, if they are not just pretentious gibberish and that spending time with them can actually be detrimental to my mental health. With so many enriching writers to be explored, how can we know if a cryptic text leads ultimately to enlightenment or perpetual darkness? At the moment I'm hedging my bets by keeping all Pound's works at the front of my bookshelves, while the more accessible writers pile up in obscure alcoves.

Borges is about the fantastical, mazes, paradoxes, parallel lives and symbols. It's quite odd when you first encounter his style but it stays with you and it's been so influential (even for tv/film)

How fascinating that you are able to figure out the personality of a given writer just from reading his/her works. I’m always too absorbed with just the written word to notice or pay any attention to the person behind the writer😂

@castelodeossos3947

Жыл бұрын

I'm a real bore because I'm simply not interested in the author as such.

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

@@castelodeossos3947 there might be time when knowing a little about an author helps appreciating his work, but at other time, I prefer not to know! For example I would mention one of our French poets called Verlaine, the fluidity and musicality of his verses are so enchanting , versus the fact that he was an alcoholic who abandoned wife and children for a fling with a much younger man called Rimbaud.. Contrast that with a great poem from the Middle Ages 'Epitaphe Villon' which will move you even deeper when you realise it was written when Francois Villon had been condemned to be hanged for robbery (his poem was expressing such remorse and pain that he was pardoned).

Ben, Have you any advice for us Yanks on the confusion caused, in Shakespeare’s histories, on characters being referred to by either their estate names (eg: Sussex) or their given names? This is a major point of confusion for me, especially as the estate name changes person through inheritance or through a change in the faction in power.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

I completely sympathise with this, Mark. Even as a Brit, I find it confusing too. The thing that has helped me the most is finding a face to assign those changing names to. The Hollow Crown, for example, is a great way to permanently gain your bearings in the English Histories. When you read "John of Gaunt", it's a lot easier to know who that is if you can envision Patrick Stewart delivering the lines. Prince Hal becomes Henry V but I think immediately of Tom Hiddleston. The Duke of York, for me, is Paterson Joseph, and so on. After assigning faces to names, depending on how much work you're up for, you might also want to use a character as an entrance to the historical period. Encyclopaedia entries with their portraits and details of the battles they might have been in can often be quite interesting!

I was advised to read Douglas Hofstadter: Goedel, Escher, Bach: an eternal braid. Highly challenging, especially as I am so ignorant of music composition, mathematics applications and art as a whole. The complexity of the themes developed is carried out by the clarity of the writing. It will take me over a year to read it, I can see, as there is so much background knowledge I need to familiarise myself with as I plod along, but it will be a triumph to complete this challenge. You speak of kind authors, and there is one who come immediately to my mind: Terry Pratchett produced numerous novels broaching on subjects like slavery, political systems, social fabric, but they are all easy reading so maybe not appropriate for this particular video. An English author who impressed me deeply was Aldous Huxley. I read it when a teenager, not too familiar with Shakespeare as I am French, and I found the structure of Brave New World and the ideas presented quite difficult, being so different from our own literature.

Hehe a pisces here! For me, I love Four Quartets by Eliot. In fact, I have a first edition currently sitting on my shelf. I love hearing those poems and thinking about my place in life. However, I am not aware of Eliot's school of literary thought. Currently, I am going through Yale's Introduction to Literary Theory so perhaps it will be covered in the last half of the class. Perhaps you can shed some light on what Eliot's literary theories were. I know that he said that poetry should be difficult.

Homer's great work was always difficult, but also rewarding for me to read because of his lentghy descriptions.

Proust, Shakespeare, Thomas Mann, Kafka, Goethe are the most difficult I’ve read so far.

@khadimndiaye7730

Жыл бұрын

Got to add Platon

Love your take on the difficult writers and some tips on how to get into them. Thank you. I'm reading Swann's way on your suggestion and I am really enjoying it. I even loved the Combray part. I tried writing a journal, but fell into trying to write a summary! Now I'm just putting the first 2 sentences down after thinking about it for an hour. I might read the Aristotle you suggested too. As for not engaging with the art of 'bad people' concept I feel it could be difficult to follow, as by todays standards many greats had unpalatable opinions on women, other racial groups, slavery etc. Also, no one could agree about what constitutes a bad person because we all have different backgrounds. I do applaud you in your own personal choice of bete noire and note how considered the decision was to eliminate him from your own reading.

I'd be interested if one day you decide to do a video about Eliot and his brand of criticism specifically, and its possible negative effects on scholarship, if you stll think this way.

Icelandic sagas are pure headache. They get quite simple and comfy to read ones you get used to their manner of storytelling and learn a bit of viking age history and culture, but before that they are extreamely hard, because the're nothing like our modern (XVIII-XXI) literature. Lots of genealogy, lack of descriptions, sudden poetry in the middle of prose. And, in contrary to most of modern literature, they almost never tell you what all the characters are thinking or feeling - you have to interprete it yourself. And in order to do it correctly you have to know their time. But somehow at the same time it's really relieving: no one tells you what to feel or think either. Author does not exist, there is just a reader and a good story. Saga of Egil Skallagrimsson is one of the best, I think. Also, Russian medieval chronicles are fun as well ("Повесть Временных Лет" in particular). They are complete opposite of Icelandic sagas, but hard to read too. Because usually they don't really tell you what happened, instead they tell you what a chronicler thought about it and compared it to. There are so many references, it's like reading a real story told by combining all kind of memes, 70% of which you don't know. Chronicles never get easier. But the brilliant thing is each time you re-read them, you find something you overlooked and had no clue it's there.

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

seems very puzzling. It reminds me of the way stories were told in the very early Middle Ages in France.

You are such an amazing Soul. It’s almost like you’re a literary Rabbi. I’m such a fan. Thank you for what you do with your time.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Wow, thank you so much, Noah. I really appreciate you being here 🙏

I'd say my "difficult writer" is Ariano Suassuna, who despite being very highly praised for his plays and cultural impact, is wildly underrated as a novelist. His "Romance de Dom Pantero no Palco dos Pecadores", which as far as I know hasn't even been translated out of portuguese yet, is one of the most rich and intricate books I have ever read. It's nigh impenetrable without a grasp of the concepts and ideas he explored through his entire ouvre, in fact, it feels like a culmination of them all. It's a long and dense epic where he brings together all his life's work and ideas for a brazilian erudite art deeply rooted in popular culture into a book which I'd easily compare to the greatest classics of literature of all time. It's very demanding, but also a joyful read.

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

aren't you tempted to translate i for English readers, as you seem to master both languages?

Nicomachean Ethics is smooth sailing and fairly straightforward for the first couple chapters, but once you get to book I chapter 6 on the forms and universals, I thinks that's the point you realize it's time to start taking this book seriously. Reading back on it now, after reading tons of other works of philosophy, and dipping my toes into the jargon they use, that chapter seems fairly easy, but man was that a struggle the first time.

As French, I agree with your point of view. Proust is generally considered as one of the most difficult French writers to read because of his style, which implies to read slowly each sentence to understand what he is describing ! But Proust's masterpiece is so original and I would say almost poetic. Thanks for your video (I think I'm going to discover other great American writers) Long live to books ;)

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

How do you think the English translation compares with the French original (if you've read both)? Proust, along with Hugo and Rimbaud, are strong motivators for myself learning the language some day. And thank you for your kind words :)

@fouquetduplessis4380

2 жыл бұрын

​@@BenjaminMcEvoy Sorry, I've never read translations of Proust, or French writers more generally. If you want to discover French, I think you can read Hugo's poetry (he could be easier to understand than Rimbaud who used words that he created himself) or Stendhal's novels : The Red and the Black, "La Chartreuse de Parme" (I didn't find the translation of title in English x) ). Stendhal essentially wrote on love, ambition and power of young men in a simple style ;)

@Alexander-tj2dn

Жыл бұрын

almost?

@nct948

Жыл бұрын

@@BenjaminMcEvoy I would also suggest Flaubert, who crafted his prose with great care - and Antoine de Saint-Exupery 'Vol de Nuit' ou 'Terre des hommes', sympathetically and poetically written.

@mjjoseph1853

Жыл бұрын

@@fouquetduplessis4380 "La Chartreuse de Parme" is translated into English as "The Charterhouse of Parma". Charterhouse is not a common word in the English language.

Finnegans Wake - James Joyce - have found it impossible to read from page 1 to he end so now, maybe once a month, I pick up my copy, read a random section, maybe 20 - 50 pages and then contemplate for an hour. Also JR by William Gaddis was difficult due to it being nothing but dialogue and sometimes found myself not knowing who was talking so I would have to go back and re-read to figure it out but truly a gigantic, towering work.

@Sr19769p

Жыл бұрын

Hi, timkjazz. I can pick up Ulysses at any page and get stuck into it; Finnegan's Wake completely defeated me. I gave up after about page 18. Glad it's not just me!

@VTownGregory

Жыл бұрын

I gave up reading 'The Waves' (Virginia Woolf) because I couldn't tell which character was speaking. She obviously did that on purpose, so I'll try again.

Your style is lovely, informative and wonderfully soothing. And I just happen to agree with every word you said. Thank you. 🌷🌹🌷

@BenjaminMcEvoy

Жыл бұрын

Thank you so much! :) That's so kind of you, and I appreciate you being here 😊

I suggest watching plays. At least first. It means less work for your brain to interpret what is happening and the intention of the dialogue, if you can see the situation it is in, and you don't have to think through stage directions. Drawback is that they usually speak the words fast. There is a torrent with all of Shakespeare's plays done by the BBC. I've come to love audiobooks as they make it less work to read as they know who is speaking and the tone etc upfront (whereas with reading often it is the "" said ). Drawback is that there is possibility of hearing just someone's interpretation. It also means I 'read' during chores etc, and helps me get to sleep. I've gotten through many more books than I could have than with actual reading.

i thought for sure you would get into the later Henry James novels (The Golden Bowl, Wings of the Dove, etc.). I'm reading Tolstoy's _War and Peace,_ and I'm not finding it difficult at all. And I think the reason is that I'm reading it on a Kindle. For some reason I think I can rip through difficult text easier on the Kindle. I don't know why. I'll see if I can keep it up.

@BenjaminMcEvoy

2 жыл бұрын

You know, having gone through his novels again recently, particularly 'Portrait of a Lady', I can certainly recognise Henry James as a great writer. Reading 'The Turn of the Screw' in serialised fashion is good fun too (if that's the right word). And nice one on reading 'War and Peace' - it has a reputation as being difficult, but it's actually very easy to get into!

@nvccru

Жыл бұрын

I’ve started James’s The Ambassadors a number of times and have given up as many. I will try again.

@nedmerrill5705

Жыл бұрын

@@nvccru I find the earlier James' novels are easier to read and comprehend, and get progressively more difficult as he gets older. Just a general trend to his writing. _Washington Square,_ an early work, is also terrific and an easier read than later James. _Portrait of a Lady_ is a favorite; it's something of a turning point in this regard. My favorite Henry James novel is _The Bostonians,_ which was roundly criticized when first published by everyone. I don't think they agreed with the politics of it. The Olive Chancellor character was a ground-breaking concept. The triangle between Olive, Basil Ransom, and Verena Tarrant is unique. The definition of a "Boston Marriage" comes from this novel.