I don't have a 7800x3d, I'm not looking into fans and coming solutions right now, but ... Your videos are such a treat, the delivery, pace, editing, clarity, structure. You're doing an awesome job.

Great to see the 67mm coolers review - especially the new IS-67-XT which I'm considering to purchase. Your videos are always very informative and helpful. I would love it if open bench tests are also provided. It would provide a good evaluation of the maximum cooler capabilities and also allow for comparisons with other open bench cooler data widely available.

It's funny u helped me find the most compatible cpu cooler for my itx three years ago and now for my brother I found u again only having the most in depth video's of the more fine tuned and alternative cpu coolers or any combinations of computer tech. Thnx for your help!

Thanks for this test as a fractal terra user this helps alot! Great video as always

Discussing and showing the mounting orientations is so helpful for build planning. Thanks a lot!

You tempted me to build my own NP200P back in the pandemic, now you are tempting me with the Terra!

my goat teaching me everything i need to know for my upcoming fractal terra build

I'm prepping for my first mini ITX build and been binging these videos. So much useful information in all of these. Also, love the taiyaki shirt. lol

@tianlamian

6 ай бұрын

doing the same now what builds did you end up with?

Long time fan! Awesome content❤

Wow, I'm shocked these work as well as they do. This speaks to all partners: AMD, ID Cooling, and Fractal Design. Quite impressive!

I was looking for this comparison somewhere days ago and poooofff your video came out today haha thanks for this

@MachinesMore

9 ай бұрын

Glad I could help!

Thanks to your videos of the NR200P case, I switched from a Dan A4-H20 case to the NR200P. My 4090 GPU temps dropped from 80c to 63c. GPU is mounted at the bottom, with glass side panel, and to get the temps this low I installed Phantek T30 fans at the top, plus I taped over all the vent holes on the other side panel, back and top of the case to maximize air flow from bottom to top.

@MadelnOahu

2 ай бұрын

When done right, the nr200p with the glass panels works amazing! Using the axp120-x67 with a 25mm fan and set the top fans to gpu temp. I blocked off the vent holes left side of motherboard so that the only entry for air is throught the bottom vent. It works amazingly well and my gpu fans dont even spin, i suppose its because since ive blocked off all entry ways for air that the only way is through the heatsink of the gpu that it cools it off well before the gpu gets up to temp.

@Tech2C

2 ай бұрын

@@MadelnOahuWell done! Yes, with the side vent holes closed off the airflow from bottom to top evacuates the heat efficiently. I don't understand why more case manufacturers can't get this simple principle right!

those side panels causing more noise is a deal breaker for a case this expensive

Please machines & more! Give us a test review of these coolers with the noctua A12-15 ans A12-25mm fans.

love your channel!

I really like how you are testing these on ryzen processors. This is probably the best way given the boosting behavior

Curious what you recommend for the best sub 55mm cooler for the 7800x3d! Great video as always

Its a mystery why you don't have more subs. Thank you for the very informative content.

Another excellent video! With a 7700 in a Terra I went from L9A with the fan duct to L12 Ghost with the stock fan. I’m still getting idle temps around 50-55 and gaming spikes to ~85. Is this to be expected with an L12? Or could this indicate I haven’t attached the cooler correctly?

Hi, great job! Thanks for sharing with us. Do you have in plan tested "Deepcool AN600" (TDP 180W)?

I wonder if using that noctua foam isolators between the fan frame & the side panel will reduce the noise.

You're in my head I have the AXP 120x67 and was thinking ofupgrading to the 7800x3D

@juliosalguero4638

8 ай бұрын

I have a deepcool an600 in fractal ridge with a 7800x3d that I built for my cousin and cools 7800x3d so well. Most games are between 60-70 degrees. The only games I see push above 70 degrees are the farcry games.

Would love to see a comparison against i55 with a 25mm thick fan

Also is67xt has extra mounting bar for AMD different install orientation

Hey man I just want to say thanks. Had a L9I which was a terrible idea for m 13600k. From your previous video I switched to the LS-12 Ghost edition and its perfect. There's no turbulence, its quiet and cool.

@bensteelemusic

5 ай бұрын

Nice, which GPU do you have?

@TheHornet79

5 ай бұрын

@@bensteelemusicAsus Pro Art. The 3080

I wonder how they would perform with the same fan! Might be worth a comparison to see which heatsink is the best. (I always tend to swap the fans out for my slim Noctua fan anyway!)

@EvernooBE

9 ай бұрын

I completely agree with that, these should all be tested with the same fan to truly know how good they CAN be. Swapping out a fan is easy and I always use my go-to Arctic P12 fans. Test them with Noctua's A25 to make a fair comparison. Stock fans are too ofter trash-tier.

@Dr_cHeNGo

9 ай бұрын

Please machines & more! Give us a test review of these coolers with the noctua A12-15 ans A12-25mm fans.

Would like to know what settings you have the spine in so that I can possibly run one of these without the turbulence. How far away would you have to set the is67 and in what position? Also what size GPU thickness would remain comfortably?

I have a BS3 in my Terra, didn't realize they were end of life. I did swap the fan with a Noctua 120x15 chromax, would love to know how all 3 compared with the same fan.

Ugh, I went with the 207 Slim XT. Wish that I would’ve researched more.

Do you reckon this data will translate to other similar cases such as the ZX-1?

I might have missed it but what spine position do you have the case in? I'm considering the IS-67 and already bought my GPU I want to know if it would fit. It is 2.7 slot card at 55.88mm thick. Will the IS-67 fit, or should I go with the IS-55?

I wonder if this cooler will be able to cool my 7500f at light browsing without spinning up the fan

Question, which performs better. IS-67XT, or IS-55 with 25mm fan? They are the exact same height. One has more heatsink and one has more fan. You're one of the very few creator that has both coolers.

@bsauce5889

6 ай бұрын

I'm considering this too. Trying to decide between the 67 and 55 also

@ThousandBlade

6 ай бұрын

@@bsauce5889 I found out through other sources that more heatsink is better by a very small margin of 1 to 2 degrees.

How similar are the heat sinks? The coolers seem nearly identical. From my research the fan pn the id cooling fan has higher cfm and statoc pressure. Maybe thats why it wss a tad cooler.

Any benefit with 25mm fan in terra for those using it in setting #1?

Very interesting comparison. I’m curious if having some kind of shroud from the fan to the side of the case like the one Noctua makes will help reduce noise

@MachinesMore

9 ай бұрын

You know… it’s worth a shot! Let me try it.

Can you please test both of these with a Noctua fan instead?

What about Deepcool AN600?

Would also be interesting to see the Deepcool R-AN600 compared to these

I am planning on building a mini ITX build with the axp90 -x53 do you think if i lap the cpu or delid it it can cool it enough to stay sub 85 c on a undervolt

For anyone coming here to settle the decision, I have experience with both of these coolers. I have a terra/is67/12600k and a terra/axp120-67/12400f. The 12400f is quieter, but I think it's because I switched the fan to an nfa12x15, and the chip just stays cooler because of the power requirements. The 12600k is on a z690-i strix and the 12400f is on a b760-i strix. I'm going to get rid of one of the green terras, and get a black one. The black one will have the b760-i/12400f/and will probably try to get a nfa12x25 on there, since there is still a fair bit of room left over. They're both great coolers, like M&M showed. I think the build quality is better on the ID cooling one. The packaging, unboxing, and mounting hardware all just feels more premium on the ID cooling, however, the thermalright does keep those thermals right! Just get whichever one is cheaper, or get the ID cooling if you want a black one w/o RGB.

Just ordered the ID cooling 67 xt. Anyone have any problems with it?

I find the L12S is great, maybe the AXP120-67 if you don't mind the noise for >140W

@thunderboltlightning6010

2 ай бұрын

The L12S has compatibility problems with most modern mid to high end ITX boards.

Hello, I can see that you've done quite a few test specially on Terra case. Have you made sort of a graph for the best SFF CPU cooler? I was planning to buy Noctua NH-L12S on 7800x3d with B650E-I MOBO. I would be grateful if you could let me know how NH-L12S is comparing with these (specially noise level placing the fan undearneath the sinsk). Kind regards, E

@bensteelemusic

5 ай бұрын

I’m looking at the same setup. Just from research, I think the L12A has even better cooling performance, and lower noise due to the fan being under the heatsink, not next to the side panels for example. Plus Noctua fans tend to be the quietest. But in the Terra if you need that extra 3mm or so on the GPU side, I’d go ID 67

Hallo sir, im using the Thermalright SI-100. On desktop im between 40 - 55 degree and gaming 55 - 75 degree. Is this fine or will this kill the longlife durability?

holy I may as well stick a vornado on that

Goddamnit, just as I've bought AXP120-X67 3 days ago 😢

should have shown the graph comparing these to all the other coolers from the last video....

I’m using a axp90 x47 fc and it works amazingly. 67mm overkill imo

No matter what, I think a Noctua 15mm or 25mm fan is the best configuration. I chose a 25mm with a 7900xtx with my config but it wouldn't work with a 4080 for example. A 25mm will work with a 4070 at most.

@HypaHypa69

8 ай бұрын

Which 7900xtx do you have and which a lot did you set your spine to? I’m running a simmular setup on spine setting 4…I don’t think I have enough clearance space for 25mm fan

@mannylupercio8194

8 ай бұрын

@@HypaHypa69 The ref was an easy choice since I build in ITX cases only.

noctua l9x65 a ton quieter, even at up to 1800 rpm, maybe try that one

Yikes, the noise frequency (not just the boosted level) with the fans next to the side panel - intolerable!

👍👍

id cooling is insane lol , it even comes with little box for small parts , also it is the cheapest among these 3

めっちゃ気になる・・・たい焼き

axp120-67 inside terra has terrible turbalance

@kinanhloubi1935

6 ай бұрын

which cpu are you using it ? and did you change the cooler by now ? i am building the same setup but with intel 14700.

just use a juishark cooler....

@levispartan1993

9 ай бұрын

my bad its 92mm

When will these hardware manufacturers wise up and change the design so that we actually mount the CPU to the cooler first and then install it onto the motherboard. This idea of putting the CPU in the motherboard, applying paste, and then blindly placing the cooler on top of it, is ridiculous.

たい焼き素敵❣️

lian li dan h20 it's better at a similar volume

@MachinesMore

9 ай бұрын

Absolutely if you are liquid cooling!

@HowDareYouu

9 ай бұрын

@MachinesMore but still. Same case volume. Why wouldn't you want this option... Terra is too much design but not enough compatibility in my opinion. Maybe V2 will be better

Use rendering to test cooler performance? Lmao