On the last point: It never ceases to amaze me that we've known how to build walkable, livable cities for thousands of years, but suddenly after WW2, the popularization of the car makes so many people just forget how to plan properly

@dr.zoidberg8666

2 жыл бұрын

It wasn't that people simply "forgot" because there was a new technology. There were unimaginable fortunes spent on propaganda & lobbying to _make_ people forget. The extent to which the auto industry went to destroy public transit & reshape the collective consciousness in the US is mind-boggling... Like so many things in American history, the public good was destroyed to supercharge private profits.

@MaycroftCholmsky

2 жыл бұрын

@@dr.zoidberg8666 don't forget there was also an ideological struggle during cold war, in which "the american dream" of private households with their own backyards, garages, cellars and driveways were proposed more as a counter to the communist communal housing, however more costly and uneffective that kind of deurbanisation might be.

@dr.zoidberg8666

2 жыл бұрын

@@jaredrl06 That is _literally_ not true. We built walkable cities for humans & not cars. We built robust public transit. We built vast rail systems. The Auto lobby destroyed it all so that they could corner the transportation market at the expense of everyone else. Edit: Here's a brief/entertaining explanation of the process: kzread.info/dash/bejne/oYOo1tipmq3ccdI.html

@eclogite

2 жыл бұрын

@@jaredrl06 actually, a lot of older North American towns were built quite walkably, and were subsequently converted into highways and parking lots. One good example is London, Ontario

@JonCole

Жыл бұрын

@@jaredrl06 this is a really great demonstration of the aforementioned propaganda working its magic

A lot of old cites in Europe are in the in bend of a river: in old times this was a easy way to be protected from 3 sides from an invasion. Luckily today flooding is a concern of higher interest.

@xxx_dat_bo1_xxx

2 жыл бұрын

Well they did surround themselves with large walls that could probably keep the water from a flood outside the city.

@ANTSEMUT1

2 жыл бұрын

A lot of European cities also had canals and that can help with flood mitigation.

@magiv4205

2 жыл бұрын

The old town of Bern is a classic example of this, the river Aare makes almost a full loop or noose shape around it, and the narrow open side used to be one massive star fort. Some of those fortifications still stand today, even though the city has now multiplied in all directions.

@Cecilia-ky3uw

2 жыл бұрын

Constantinoples strategy was not a river but a whole strait

@landlockedcroat1554

2 жыл бұрын

and having nowhere to flee

As someone interested in worldbuilding and learning more about the existing experiences of sustainable living, your channel is very informative!

@juansnyders7323

2 жыл бұрын

Literally the exact some reason I clicked, I literally didn't know any of these things. My head just went boom.

@RikThunder33

2 жыл бұрын

me. xD

@munchkinmeep

2 жыл бұрын

Worldbuilding squad! Yeaaaah

@manfreddanvers3213

2 жыл бұрын

World Building Supps

@soulextracter

2 жыл бұрын

If you haven't already, also look up Artifexian

As someone who lives in a tropical zone, you do have to worry about the sun facing side, but for the opposite reason. Basically rooms that receive the sunlight till' sunset become impossible to be at. Walls get warm, air gets hot (fans you send you hot air) and the place super uncomfortable. Great video btw! :D

@edi9892

2 жыл бұрын

I live in central Europe, and it frustrates me that they forgot about the value of head space in rooms and the ability for a draft dragging out hot air! Even after they switched from open fires to chimneys they managed for houses to stay cool, but with the 20th century, they tossed aside all common knowledge and now, I can get up to 40°C and we have no AC! Plus, being 7ft tall, I miss the ceiling height of older buildings...

@CulturalBarbarian

2 жыл бұрын

In north Europe, houses are built to keep warmth in. You can imagine how bad the summers tend to get in the sun facing side. I don't think you even care about which side faces the sun during the winter, because it is more about snow reflecting light all-around than the few sunlight hours that don't warm you.

@edi9892

2 жыл бұрын

@@CulturalBarbarian I tell you something funny: I currently live in Switzerland and snow is rather rare! There is bamboo, palm trees, and even some banana trees planted by my neighbours! Especially, the latter must be protected from the cold, but it's feasible. I just wonder why people plant things ranging from plants found in the Mexican desert, to swamp cypress. Neither of them are optimised for the climate. Also, it fluctuates a lot from very dry to very moist, which makes it tough even for temperate plants.

@edi9892

2 жыл бұрын

@@CulturalBarbarian also, modern homes completely disregard sun, wind and rain direction. They only care about how to cram as many buildings into a street as possible. It's not uncommon that you drive to work and once you leave the garage the sun blinds you and the ramp is slippery and in the worse case connected to a frequented road or has some stupid S curve to it. We can make absolutely great designs and build to last centuries, but 99.9999% of the architecture is junk food level.

@BeautifulEarthJa

2 жыл бұрын

Exactĺy. I was thinking we want to do the opposite since we neee to keep cool.

Here in southern Brazil where the landscape is composed by grassland and smooth hills, people used to build on top of hills because that's where they could watch their cattle in the surrounding area, my family was one of them. Also, lower areas get frost more often in winter (cold air flows downards) which kill crops, and may have deficiency in wind flowing which made the place hotter during summer. River sides also have higher humidity and attract a lot of mosquitoes and insects while hill tops are more hospitable. Water, however, was always a problem. Most of the cities built around these parts are located on hill tops.

@beskow1500

2 жыл бұрын

Casarão dos Patrão no alto da coxilha

@DaDunge

2 жыл бұрын

You can solve the misquito problem by putting up bat houses. Like birdhouses but for bats, size them for insect eating bat and they will keep your mosquito population down.

@JohnDoe-cu1wd

Жыл бұрын

@@DaDunge Do you have any reliable source where i can find information about it?

@jasonreed7522

Жыл бұрын

His reason for not being on a hill top is wildfire defense which isn't very applicable in some environments/ecologies.

@henriqueanjos8532

Жыл бұрын

É os guri dos pampa

Building near a river: It is also worth noting that over time rivers will change course. When a bend in a river reaches apex it will start to erode the inside of the bend and whip away a sand bar. It is natural for rivers to change course over time. It has to do with the fact that water flows in a wave pattern and this is evident in the constant bending of a river back and fourth. This is also affected by the type a land the river flows through.

@Lochness19

2 жыл бұрын

My home is on the outside of a riverbend. It's not a bad place, but you do have to keep in mind that the river will try to erode away at the steep slopes that tend to occur there, so you should build all permanent structures a little ways back from the bluff.

@ericolens3

2 жыл бұрын

Its weird, but I live in baton rouge part of Mississippi but once you get up to the north of BR, LA/Mississippi state border its more steep lands to the east of the river and plains to the west. Im sure that 500 years plus ago, back when the river could sway back and forth this this narrative may have be shaped so that east of Mississippi would be plains and west of Mississippi would be bluffs/steeper lands. Idk, maybe the Appalachian plays a part of this. I just know somewhere in my heart that the Mississippi's main flow should be down the atachafalya, but BR and New Orleans means theres more financial incentives. Also the homes/cities between Lafayette and BR would be flooded and BR would lose its port status, likewise with NOLA. But at least in this hypothetical world, they wouldn't flood. Im not too sure about the ebb and flow of Mississippi outside my state just yet. Theres so much more geology I'd love to delve into, especially the way the river flowed before we geo engineered the river and its tributaries.

@BeteSpatioTemporelle

Жыл бұрын

Times are like rivers : calm and strong, or turbulent or fast. I wish I knew better chaos' theory because there is a trick with those flows, but I don't get it.

There's a couple of things that I love about your videos. Firstly, you explain everything in an easily comprehensible manner and keep it concise. In addition, you always have great visualisations to go along with it. You're a great teacher Andrew!

@calebghormley2322

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed. That was very educational.

1:50 this is mitigated in very wet and relatively cool climates such as those found in northwestern Europe, the British Isles for example where wildfires are very rare, incredibly small and typically a result of extreme mismanagement. You can see this in more traditional anglo-saxon settlements, often on top of canyons and hills in wetland and floodplain landscapes. Using the floodplain for rich summer grazing then bringing livestock back to the uplands during the wet winters. They never suffered from wildfires, it's too wet for that.

@TheIrreverent

2 жыл бұрын

That's a good observation but I'm not sure it applies anymore. I live on the west coast of North America, in the Pacific Northwest rainforest, and already we're seeing drastic climate changes that make it so that our coastal rainforests are burning for the first time now. As far as planning sites go, this needs to be included in the calculus for these areas as they shift away from that "very wet/cool" status in the summer months.

@anonperson3972

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheIrreverent Absolutely agree and it is a major concern in the 25 year environment plan the UK government has created. But in Britain we are predicted to get even wetter than we are. One main concern is with flooding. So I think it would make sense for us to build more in the uplands. Especially when we have historically built far too much in the lowlands and created a massive flood crisis....

@anon2427

2 жыл бұрын

@@TheIrreverent forest mismanagement is a major contributor to the wildfires though. When you don’t clear dead trees out from the woods it becomes a tinderbox

@runningfromabear8354

2 жыл бұрын

@@anonperson3972 Not only wetter but the winters are going to be a lot colder. Once the Atlantic is disrupted, it's going to get a lot colder. London is further north than Quebec City, Winnipeg and Calgary. It's been a long time since the UK saw winters that reach -40 degrees centigrade.

@poetsrear

2 жыл бұрын

@@anon2427 depends on the biome

This'd make a perfect prehistoric, semi-educational 'city-builder' game. You'd have fun growing a small community while also learning the hard way that building on a floodplain at the base of the north-facing side of a mountain wasn't the best idea. Such games do already exist in abundance, but there's usually limited consequences for building anywhere you like.

@player_8008

Жыл бұрын

i would love a game that functions like this but also like one hour one life, where essentially it would be 3d and it would simulate living in a small community(with other players) and throughout the course of your short life you support the village and have to take factors like this and more into account if you wanted your community to be successful.

@LeonKommando48

10 ай бұрын

Have you got any recommendations?

As a Western-Norwegian: "Let's build on all the worst locations we can ever think off" But finally I learned why they never build houses ontop of the hills and mountains here! I have always wondered why they'll build a 50-man apartment complex on a rocky 45 degree mountains slope, rather than placing it ontop of the mountain instead. You should Visit Bergen sometime, or Norway in general. Especially along the west coast. They seem to have gone against everything you said and opted for all the worst options xD

@juleeanng

2 жыл бұрын

lol

@BeteSpatioTemporelle

Жыл бұрын

Mountains in Norway ? Too cold. I prefer the South of Europe ! :-)

@qalbihodon721

Жыл бұрын

In Norway weather it is not easy to live and build cities top of the mountains!. Because winters people can become isolated from the snow and slippery conditions.

@Ullmannite

Жыл бұрын

I think Bergen, simply outgrew perfect settlement placement. The older houses are more or less south facing, close or at the slope break. Bryggen and Festningen are a matter of protecting and controlling the habour. Houses in Laksevag for example are all newer. I think considering their constraining topography, they did pretty well.

@Pigen_

Жыл бұрын

A Norwegian sees this video and just goes "Alright, bet"

"But we are really talking about normal people here", best line in the video, Andrew! Anyway, always super informative. The PDC is getting better and better, congrats!

@beskamir5977

2 жыл бұрын

The slight pause and glare at the camera right before the delivery of that line was even better.

@RavenwoodAcres

2 жыл бұрын

I too laughed hard to that comment!

@musashiwebb

2 жыл бұрын

His delivery was effortlessly hilarious!

@dynamicworlds1

2 жыл бұрын

I will say that cities were often built at the top of hills for the same reason of defensive advantage, but yeah, if you're not building walls battlements that doesn't apply. It may be a good choice if you're in a very wet and flat area, where the risk of fire is low and basically everywhere nearby is floodplain, so every bit of elevation you can get is good, but that's more for when there's so little hill height to begin with that people are going to start questioning if it's big enough to call a hill at all.

@dexterwilliams4289

2 жыл бұрын

LMAO!

Note: Villages and towns are very commonly found on hilltops. This is because even though the hilltop is not the best site to build in terms of accessibility, it is a highly defensible position. And in the past, that was often of essential importance. Furthermore, fortresses and castles, which are also commonly found on hilltops, often tend to develop settlements around them. So even though hilltops are not the most optimal sites for settlement in many regards, they are nonetheless one of the most common sites where people settled historically.

@davidvondoom2853

Жыл бұрын

If all the nearby forests have been clearcut, then there is not much risk of wildfire.

@rogerwilco2

Жыл бұрын

Rome was built on seven hills.

@marshalljohnson6976

Жыл бұрын

@@davidvondoom2853 Actually yeah good point

@RyumaXtheXKing

Жыл бұрын

In Europe basically every hilltop had a settlement in ancient times.

@datdabdoe1417

Жыл бұрын

@@rogerwilco2 well, it grew to envelope seven hills. Originally it was built on the side of 1 hill, facing toward the river Tiber. Once you start getting to the stage of City building, most of this advice becomes irrelevant, only things like exploiting sunlight and staying away from floodplains remain useful.

As someone who has a Degree in Outdoor Education, and a Sub-Major in Geography, I am very impressed in the detail and accuracy of this video. I do not know this mans background, but he has a plethora of knowledge in this field. Well done!

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks Clark. I studies Ecological Design at Prescott College in Arizona, and got a masters degree in Horticulture. But have primarily studies all things about Permaculture in the 20 years since college. Permaculture is a multidisciplinary design science that delves into a great many topics related to designing sustainable human settlements.

@clarkh4133

2 жыл бұрын

@@amillison amazing! Thank you for bringing knowledge to people about this area! Keep it up

Your point about the inside of riverbends being natural floodplanes was eye opening to me as a Dayton Ohio native. In 1913 our entire downtown area was (and most of it still is) on the inside of a bend directly down river from a confluence of the two largest rivers in the area. Naturally, in 1913 the entire city flooded and we ended up having to invent a revolutionary levy system just to make up for the fact that our founders weren’t exactly thinking ahead.

You answered a question I have had for decades. I Studied the settlement of my home town and could never figure out why the homesteaders picked the place they did for their house. Thank you.

The slope break idea is basically how Seoul started. Mountains to the north, river to the south, far enough from the mouth of the river to get fresh water yet downstream enough to carry shipments via tidal flow. Its low, wet subsistance farms occupied both sides of the river floodplains, including where today's Gangnam is. The oldest city center is probably the most resilient place to seasonal rain and flood in Seoul.

5 Worst: On top of a hill or mountain is quite decent defence. Now in modern times it`s unlikely you have a relatives murdered or enslaved by a raid. Like the vikings did. Or the cosairs. Or riders from the stepps. Or knights during feuds/war. Depending on time/place you should account of other humans as a threat. Then diffrent placement makes sense. Like building building on top a mountain. Or in a flood plain to take nr. 3 Venice - maybe that part of the settlers were survivors of plundered rome had something to do with it.

@younes2415

2 жыл бұрын

Venice was protected by a salt water marsh. This way it was protected from land and it had access to the sea for trade and transport, the Venetians became famous traders and Venice sold salt which was a very expensive and useful produce.

@Argonnosi

2 жыл бұрын

Flooding is really the trick. Around where I live, forest fires aren't an issue, but flooding is and in a flood the best place to be is the top of the hill.

So valuable! It's a shame in recent development this knowledge has been ignored due to technical progress. But nature remains stronger.

@1x0x

Жыл бұрын

or its because people dont build their own houses anymore they just buy them from a developer that doesnt give a shit about them

I've been on KZread since 2007 and I believe this is one of the best channels I've ever stumbled upon. Your quality of work is excellent and the way you visualize the information is very creative and unique. I'm actually pretty blown away.

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks so much! I hope to make a lot more videos in the coming years.

Number 4 is actually useful for tropical climates too because we have to AVOID sun as much as possible, so that's the place to run away from

Came for D&D world building: stayed for the real world trivia!

And exactly that lesson around 6:00 was learned again at terrible cost this year in germany. People having complacently settled on the inside of a bend in a river, in a steep valley. Then torrential rain came and had the river cut straight through and over those low inside banks, flushing away whole villages .... particularly those buildings built more recently, disregarding that rule. Quite a few very old houses were (more or less) spared because they were placed properly, escaping even a 500 year flood (pre-climate change, that is).

@HakunaMatata-os1og

2 жыл бұрын

9:51 exactly

@tonyduncan9852

2 жыл бұрын

I'm all for building on the flood plain - as long as they're compelled to use stilts. No problem.

@DaDunge

2 жыл бұрын

A lot of European cities were intentionally built on the flood plain and evne had ditches that could be intentionally flooded in the last direction all to make them harder to attack. Of course old houses of flood plains are all built with a fair bit of extra foundation to prevent flooding.

The effort put into this video is incredible! Love these little plants and the topographic map! Best channel on KZread.

In spent an year living in the US a few years ago, and it stroke me as a very que thing the way most people live far away from the city center, with very large properties. It does look very nice with the amount of trees in these areas, but it makes it basically impossible for someone to live there without a car, and a public transportation system generally inexistent due to how ineffective it would be in this setting

@freewheelinghorn

2 жыл бұрын

look up the channel not just bikes to learn even more about how US development is stupid. great channel

@asoka7752

2 жыл бұрын

@@freewheelinghorn because US development is all about sending white people to as far as inland, and force them to breed rapidly. that's how they captured the native lands. they still have the same culture.

@jadedandbitter

2 жыл бұрын

Because F--k other people, that's why. I had a house burn down in the city that was three houses down from the idiots who set their house on fire. And then theres the crime and noise...screw that. I will likely never live in the city again.

@Petra999

2 жыл бұрын

@@asoka7752 what the fuck are you on about...

@Petra999

2 жыл бұрын

Go live in central New York City. You'll love it there with all the people 😉

Your videos was extremely clear, and I love how concise you made each point! I'm in college studying urban planning, and sometimes I get caught up in all the complexities of modern society, like affordable housing programs and such, that I forget the roots of where and how housing should be built: not everywhere! Again, awesome and informative video!

I love the inputs about clustered housing and I agree. This may sound like a strange input, but in order to move this direction, we need to address noise control. I'm a real estate agent and investor - I also have had the luxury of living in many different countries including Germany and South Korea. Americans are noisy and disruptive... Many buyers are looking for a location that provides peace and quite. We need to be able to provide that serenity in our villages without loud music and noisy vehicle exhaust.

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

Funny observation. Thanks for sharing.

@odyseus090

2 жыл бұрын

Not just bikes did an episode about the noise the car makes and how cities around the world differ in this.

@Arielelian

2 жыл бұрын

The culprit of this trend is America’s hyper-individualism. Most cultures have a degree of communal respect, in that they see themselves as part of the greater community. Americans do not. So we get the mindset of “I can do what I want, how I want, when I want.”

@jadedandbitter

2 жыл бұрын

@@Arielelian which is an AWESOME mindset.

@Petra999

2 жыл бұрын

@@Arielelian hell yeah brother 👍

Thank you. This answers so many questions for my future tiny house and permaculture dreams.

A very well articulated piece of content regarding homesite selection. Thanks for putting this out there.

Ive watched half of this video and had to stop to like, subscribe, and send the link to some friends. What a fantastic content, super easy way to make complex things easy to be understood, and absurdly valuable information! I plan to watch all your videos before buying my land and starting my permaculture project!! Thank you so much for sharing this with us!

6:30 During the Recent floodings in Germany, one Part of a Small town was completely wiped out when a great flood happened, That part was on the inside of the River-bend and where it was there is now a Giant area filled with rubble and debree. Say'd area had no Protection against flooding (no drainage/ overflow tunnels) and the bridges leading to the Area were not designed for Major floodings, as such during the flood, they functioned as Dams after being filled with debree, only to break and cause a catastrophy downstream. I visited the area a couple of times and it will never be the same. Hundreds of years of culture gone in 1 day. Don't build inside the River-bend Look at satelite-images of: "Germany (Eifel) Flooding 2021 before and after" If you want to see it.

thanks man, this video was very useful. Me and my buddies were, you know, just hunting and gathering, minding our business and Greg (a member of our group) started talking about putting grain in the soil to get more food. We were really worried about the acampment location and now we have a good ideia on where to start!

I'm really glad KZread recommended this channel. This video was so beautiful, I love learning about human behavior with respect to the environment and how it can be best used.

What an absolutely fantastic video this was. It's not often that someone can teach me something I've never heard of or considered before in this space, and you just did it for 10 mins straight. You are quickly becoming one of my favorite channels.

Idk how or why KZread recommended this video for me but I'm so glad it did. Such a cool thing I've never thought about and your topography table thing is such a great visual aid. Hope to be seeing more of you!

The additional .1 millisecond pause and blink after referencing the high ground, I love it 2:22

Love your model visual backups. Great video as always. Another consideration is temperatures. Top of the hill is windy and cold in winter and can be hotter in summer (could be a problem) and down near the river, apart from flooding is much more colder, dank, misty. A comment from your wildfire video: The river Y is what I meant about the forest being shaped in a y. It tends to lead the wild fires around the houses and not directly towards them.

All of the good places are already taken. And in case ye are wondering, the best places are at the estuary of mayor rivers, or slightly upstream of on an island in the river.

This was the first time of getting a video from this channel, recommended to me and at first, I clicked on this, because I thought this was going to be about the videogame "Minecraft". Then I saw the bird's-eye-view of your table and I was instantly interested in learning more! I'm so glad I stayed and watched this, because I learned a lot from this, you explain everything in such a clear and logical way, WITH actual, physical props, I loved it! I've subbed, hoping to learn more! Thank you so much for making this type of content!

just discovered this channel. the quality and the knowledge is so great, omg i'm going to watch everything thoroughly

Incredibly insightful, and neatly presented. Thanks Andrew!

4:55 Fun fact: The German city of Hamburg is most likely named after this. Ham is an old German word for riverbend, so Hamburg means "castle at a river bend". So next time you're at McDonalds, you can feel smart for knowing how your foods name originated in settlement geography over a millennium ago.

@DaDunge

2 жыл бұрын

Hamburger has got nothing to do with the city of Hamburg as far as I know. the concept of minced meat fried and put in bread is of mongol origin.

@majorfallacy5926

2 жыл бұрын

@@DaDunge the food doesn't come from there but the name does. Same as how you call sausages wieners even though I'm pretty sure they're not actually from here

@DaDunge

2 жыл бұрын

@@majorfallacy5926 Pretty sure the ham is hamburger is because is was originally made from ground ham.

@majorfallacy5926

2 жыл бұрын

@@DaDunge it's not and it wasn't. Burger also wasn't originally an English word, it's a back-formation from hamburger.

@DaDunge

2 жыл бұрын

​@@majorfallacy5926 Yes it is, Europe got hamburgers from America. It's not a traditional dish anywhere in Europe, at least not under the name Hamburger. I guess you could call it a fricadelle with bread. No idea wherever you got the -burger suffix from but the concept has nothing to do with hamburg. Look my family is from Hamburg no one in Hamburg claims the food Hamburger has anything to do with Hamburg. And why would we American junk food hasn't got squat to do with our fine city. Don't blame this crap on us, this is all you.

Very logical points on the need for clustered housing models! Especially the part about desiring to be spread out in order to view nature, while simultaneously destroying and consuming more nature in the agrigate. Subbing all the way.

It's Saturday morning and I am watching a tutorial on where to build a village. And I am liking it

So glad I found your channel. Best information on KZread. You'd be top of my list for a survival team.

Sun Tzu recommends that you camp on a south facing slope well up from wetlands or river to avoid insects that carry diseases. The south facing slope will get sunlight early in the day and be warmer than the north facing slope. Sun Tzu chapter 9

Andrew, this is very useful and interesting content thank you for putting this together!

Regarding castles: 1) in their day, they would not be surrounded by trees or any vegetation that would give cover. 2) another thing media keep getting wrong is that each castle is supplied by multiple towns, if not a city and each city requires multiple towns and each town requires fields. Thus, there was little nature around castles. 3) most castles were not on mountain peaks, but hilltops at best, or on ridges below the summit. Quite often they were also built on plateaus on otherwise steep slopes. Even despite the risk of floods and landslides, they preferred it over being exposed on the very summit.

I used to visit my grandpa in Corvallis every year. Very interesting info; thanks for sharing.

You Sir, are true gold! So sad that the YT algorithm promotes so many non-values over what really matters..

Petra, Jordan, is in a canyon but its location is great. Paris, France, is on all sides in a flood plain AND on surrounding hills at the same time: great location. You are talking about new settlements. Building on rocky terrain is more reliable, including in case of an earthquake.

@crypton_8l87

2 жыл бұрын

Is this a suggestion or criticism?

My first video I'm seeing of his. Love it! Also I enjoy how many times he tells us in different ways to chill out.

Very interesting video. I love the presentation with the sand table and projection map. Great stuff.

Thanks! I was just about to build a home and/or village!

IT would be very interesting to see you layout out the "perfect village" (permaculture, clustered housing, ideal aspect etc). I am working on a project like this and it would great to see your perspective on what an ideal community would look like.

I never thought I would find exactly what I've been looking for for a long time, I'm so grateful.

First of your videos I saw. It's informative AND entertaining AND relaxing. Loved it!

Well done Andrew! Thanks for this and all you do.

@amillison

Жыл бұрын

My pleasure! Thanks for tuning in :-)

Thanks for the Teachings. Just to share : Salem original name is Sailam in Tamil, We have a District called Salem in Tamilnadu, India. Meaning = Place full of Mountains

@formidableflora5951

2 жыл бұрын

Very interesting--thank you! My youngest daughter was born in Salem, Tamil Nadu.

@vivekvelusamy9194

2 жыл бұрын

@@formidableflora5951 Nice to hear. Also My wife's native.

Ok yes amazing presentation but also this sand table with the color projector is freaking genius.

i love the real world examples. they really help with understanding

Fluvial geomorphology, one of my favourite subjects when I was a school teenager. For some reason the shape and dynamics of rivers and coastlines was fascinating. Loved the video. I came across permaculture many years ago, so the ideas are familiar, but you presented it brilliantly. Also this was great worldbuilding content. Subscribed.

People live spread apart for a reason. Clustering is definitely not for everyone. But I think working towards making people responsible, in some fashion, for the production of the energy that they consume is a step in the right direction.

Just discovered your channel and I’m thoroughly enjoying your videos! Im an urban planning student and everything you said is exactly what I am learning in my classes!

Thank you, Andrew, for yet another SUPERB instructional video! You are a great gift to our shared bioregion (the Willamette Valley), our shared state (Oregon), and our shared planet (Gaia).

Great video! "The only way is to lower consumption", i agree, position and clustering helps a lot, but people need heat and eletricity, cause more often work remotely. Please can you react on best place also for solar, water and wind energy generation? Also where to plant trees and which to cut :) And where to position a root zone waste water treatment :) Thank you!

@ondrejmisak

2 жыл бұрын

Ok I watched more of your videos, you have great videos man :) thanks for sharing! i like this one kzread.info/dash/bejne/mGGntMWPm72fqco.html

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

@@ondrejmisak Thanks! Some of your questions are answered on these videos: kzread.info/dash/bejne/iGeo0sOClpmwk8Y.html , kzread.info/dash/bejne/hHh3qMSfk7XJhag.html

Great video and I love the topo light table! Perfect use for it!

So great how you use your art to visualize this stuff. Very informational and perfectly combined with the visual "map" . I Wish our teachers used techniques Like this but back in the days there was chalk and a board, not very interesting and visual so it was easy to get distracted by the birds outside😅 You're next level. Thank you🙏

I wonder, for people who didn't have experience settling in new places, how much of pattern of housing was a result of survivorship bias? As in, houses with poor heating and flooding risk didn't last long and we only get to see the optimal places that survived to this day?

I'm from the Netherlands, our language does not have a word for slope...

I really appreciate your videos, always straight to the point. Hope to put most of it in practice soon here in temperate Argentina.

I don't know what this is, but I see a man saying words and playing with a real-time minecraft world generation map. I'm subbing.

Hi Andrew, what is that table with clay that does those isometric lines for you? very interesting

I know this is opposite conventional wisdom, but I love north facing large windows (in northern hemisphere) because the light coming in is not harsh (ie no direct sunlight). I know that this perhaps is bad from an energy standpoint though.

@crypton_8l87

2 жыл бұрын

me too. but personal preferences maybe beyond the purview of this video

I don't know how the algorithm got me here but this is exactly what I need since I am planning to build a house in a hill. Thanks. This is really informative.

Thank you for the clear explanation and visuals!

6:22 a German town was in the news earlier this year, Altenahr, because it was heavily hit by flooding. That town is built entirely on the flood plain inside the bend. And then people make surprised Pikachu faces...

@leto4996

2 жыл бұрын

It's not just Altenahr though. Bad Neuenahr and Schuld to name just a couple are all located on the inside of the bend. They are acustomed to yearly floods and tend to handle them very well. Also this type of flood only happens every couple of houndred years, the last one being 140 years ago so I'd argue it's basically the same as building your village on the slopes of a volcano, and a s far as I'm aware nobody tells Naples (Italy) to move away from Mt. Vesuvius. And to be fair, the Ahr valley is pretty much a canyon with steep mountainfaces on the outsite of the river bends, so its either living on the flood planes or ladders instead of roads.

@ilenastarbreeze4978

2 жыл бұрын

Flooding was less of an issue then invasion when it was made most likely

Damn this will be essential for Minecraft

if this was a class in school, I'd be in it and never bored. love your channel! although just watched a couple and skimmed through titles...so much to learn..someday id like to build a permaculture garden and house design.

Yet again, immaculate presentation. Great job!

I am living in western Ghats in india. Last 4,5 years in Ghats 1000 to 2000 people die yearly by extreme rainfall and landslide.

4:20 Another good reason to build at that part of the mountain in a hot climate is because the sun light hit less to the houses and there are much cooler, right?

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

Yes. In a very hot climate, the North side is better for cooling.

What a great surprise this channel! thanks for the content!

I'm lucky with my project in Yakima County, WA, I'm on the North slope of Yakima Ridge and the only time of the year that I lose direct exposure to the sun during a few times of the day is the weeks surrounding the winter solstice. I have a very large water shed 15-20% average grade with little obstruction on the South side of the homestead. Thank you for all the information you are sharing... this is the reLOVEution of conscious action and sustainable futures.

Your videos are sick. You're like a Bob Ross encyclopedia. I watch all of your videos and have a fragile grasp and understanding of any of this. Quick question. I saw some guy poopooing the heck out of swales on farmland in favor of a keyline plow. Can swales really F-up an area under certain circumstances? Anyways. Your drawings are great Keep em coming please. Thank you sir.

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

Mattski, thanks for the kind words :-) The swales thing is really a site-specific question. Short answer: yes, swales can be the wrong thing to do in certain circumstances. Like for example, you can waterlog a field so you impede access in springtime (in the PNW where I live). I could go on a lot about what situations are and are not appropriate for swales versus keyline plows. But you have to start with the "why" first: What exactly are you hoping to accomplish for a given location?

@mattski1979

2 жыл бұрын

@@amillison I kept looking at your response's PNW, thinking, "What the hell does that mean?". I'm from North Jersey. 16 miles outside of Manhattan. Pacific Northwest with an extra W. I get it. Anyways. I've been living in Gladstone, OR outside of Portland since the spring of 16. I should know these abbreviations by now. . Permaculture really fascinates me, and I just found out about it a month or so ago. Your's certainly are my most watched. What can I say. I'm a pictures guy. Your drawings make things easier to understand. Thank you for your response. Keep em coming please.

@annburge291

2 жыл бұрын

Sick or slick?... Swales are ideal when rainfall is inconsistent. If rainfall is consistent and abundant and you can grow trees, swales aren't necessary. They can cause mudslides in the above example.

@mattski1979

2 жыл бұрын

@@annburge291I meant sick. It's like when you hear someone use the word bad but it really means good. It's commonly used in New Jersey that way.

one should not forget, that clustering is much of a cultural thing. back in the days it meant that you have to walk a considerable distance to reach your fields. still people eventually went for it. in Europe people started to cluster in the early high middle ages again after being spread out in the landscape for a few hundred years.

@jadedandbitter

2 жыл бұрын

The black death put a damper on clustering for a while, because a ton of the clustered people died.

@aaron.aaron.v.b.9448

2 жыл бұрын

@@jadedandbitter did they really stop to cluster? Didn't they just fill in people from the countryside?

@jadedandbitter

2 жыл бұрын

@@aaron.aaron.v.b.9448 you think all the country people were in a rush to fill the places of the people who had just died horrible deaths? It took a few generations. Subsequent generations moved back into the cities but my understanding it was like two generations on before urban populations really recovered.

@aaron.aaron.v.b.9448

2 жыл бұрын

@@jadedandbitter that's interesting. I did not know that it took so long. And at least to my knowledge people still lived in settlement clusters like villages and did not spread across the countryside.

@jadedandbitter

2 жыл бұрын

@@aaron.aaron.v.b.9448 it wiped out up to 90% of the population of urban areas. Affected cities were effectively depopulated, with bodies left lying where they fell because nobody could dispose of them without dying themselves. Mongolian Marmot strains of Pneumonic Plague are ridiculously nasty, with the Black Death being the all time champ. People think of the plague as being stuff like the bubonic plague, persistent and deadly but slow spreading and controllable-the Black Death was airborne with a 99% mortality rate for those infected, killing in 24-48 hours from point of infection (often without symptoms for much of that period). It went through the world like a Reaper's Scythe, fast, vicious, and sparing nobody, only stopping when it burned itself out/weakened into more bubonic prone strains. Over 1/4 of the worlds total population died. (Source: Plague, by Wendy Orent) Anybody close together just got wiped out due to the airborne nature and high mortality rate.

Great Video, great information and I enjoyed listening to the great quality music on my headset!😎🤙🏽

Wow, amazing explanation! 👏 The way you presented!

Thank you my minecraft villages will flourish

Great vid, thanks!! There’s one big factor you seem to have neglected to mention - but I can understand why you might be apprehensive about talking about it here, & I can imagine you wouldn’t want people to be too frighten… but it’s def a big consideration when deciding about where to make your house or village , and that is: you’re gonna want to make sure not to build too close to any areas that harbor evil forces. Whether that be a haunted region from which stories abound both remarkable _and_ profoundly unspeakable, or it’s the habitat of unknown monster-like creatures (which can be anything from ravenous, apex hyper-carnivorous cryptids to assorted demonic beings, phantams, & ghoulies), or even just a location that itself harbors dark forces, channeling malevolent energies from surrounding lands and amassing them as a sort of catchment basin of evil itself… then that’s PROBALLY a place to avoid putting your house or village. Otherwise thanks for doing a great job a , of video thx

Me, a brand new watcher: I immediately love that the first best location listed is at the slope break. And the reasoning is because its on the boundary of two different biomes. Such as woods and plains. Or grassland and fishing area. I play Don't Starve, which is a survival video game that involves a lot of resource foraging and management. I always build camp on the boundary of at least 2 different biomes for this exact reason. The easy access to different types of resources. It's amusing how video games can take after real life.

Soooo much info in 10mins. Thank you!

Sadly the lower cost of living by clustering backfires and raises the costs of living in any city.

@ANTSEMUT1

2 жыл бұрын

That's a separate issue from clustering but rather zoning and property speculation.

You said that it was the car that enabled people to spread out, instead of clustering in villages. But really, it was law and order administered impartially, so that the culture was what we would call an 'open,' or 'safe,' culture. In other words, when people are constantly having to defend against attack by either national enemies or some kind of warlord/robber baron, they cluster together for mutual defense. When they feel safe from such attacks, they are much more likely to spread out. The car makes it less inconvenient to be spread out, but it's not really the enabler. If you look at different countries around the world, consider what was going on when those towns and villages were built -- were the people in constant fear of attack? Or did they feel relatively safe, and able to build homes outside of a defended, walled village? It is true that, in some respects, it uses less of some resources to build clustered communities. But I think a case could be made that more of other resources would be used. For instance, if a family is farming, they may have to travel quite a distance from their kitchen door to get to their farm fields, or to their section of forest. There are also the social considerations -- there are benefits, in that it's easier to step next door to visit with your neighbor, or spend an hour at the pub chatting with the guys. There are also increased opportunities for friction, if your near neighbor happens to be a jerk, because it's harder to avoid them. I'm not necessarily against clustered communities, but I don't think the benefits are quite as cut-and-dried as what you said in the video. Seems like people ought to do a lot of thinking and considering and research before making a decision.

@amillison

2 жыл бұрын

Thanks Kathleen and that is good feedback and something to think about. Best regards, Andrew

I’m in the process of building a custom fantasy map of The Shire/Hobbiton, and your images and information have helped me immensely.

@ProfBoggs

Жыл бұрын

Similar motivations for TTRPGs brought me here.

Not even a minute into the video and I'm already a subscriber. I can already tell this will be very interesting

The thing about clustering is that there's evidence that higher social density can cause an increase in mental health problems.

This was very informative and enjoyable! Now I want to watch all of your videos :)

Thanks man, I was really wondering where I should build my village for a while now.

It's not just about building a better house that we Americans need to learn. We need to cluster our houses and apartments and build villages. I'm trying to start an intentional permaculture community here in Maine, and some city folks moved in, but don't understand this. I've been to India and seen what real villages look like, but these people are electing to sprawl and drive with little concern for the environment. I didn't know I would have to explain this. I want to work with people who already understand this.

@martinkendrik7776

2 жыл бұрын

I'm not sure I totally agree. I mean it does make sense to cluster for sure but a lot of people that want to move to that lifestyle want to live sprawled out regardless whether it's the best option. I'm currently in the beginning stages of planning a small permaculture community. I have to choose now if I cluster or sprawl. It's not such a simple choice like you make out.

@TJtheHuman

2 жыл бұрын

@@martinkendrik7776 sprawlers need not apply.

Came for the fluvial geomorphology. Stayed for the based fuck-cars discussion at 8:43