Are you dependent on KZread and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.

اللهم صل على محمد و ال محمد

Great video! ❤❤

Let me guess before watching the video: savagery, lack of iman, and deceitfulness.

@boah2759

8 күн бұрын

true😂

@alexmatt4012

7 күн бұрын

@@boah2759 I just had to look at their Muawiah, Bani umayya and Bani Abbas LA to find a pattern. Those three characteristics exist in almost all of their khulafa.

The conditions for those who lead prayer or lead politics are well laid out, but schools of thought tend to ignore details. Regardless of whether pledges of allegiance are given, the sources are clear that obeying, following, or supporting is limited to adherence to Quran, Sunnat Annabiy, and what is fair.

@alexmatt4012

7 күн бұрын

And the khalifas decide what the sunnat of Nabi is. So fair indeed and so circular.

@JaefarSABNW

7 күн бұрын

@alexmatt4012 Umar didn't. That is why they came up with this so-called good bida stuff to excuse changing punishments and status of Ritual. After Sunni Islam started the next century, they started acting like tradition of companions was as good as prophetic.

@alexmatt4012

7 күн бұрын

@@JaefarSABNW If Umar said there are two gods they would accept two gos to not offend him. Their actual prophet is Umar. You can criticize anyone but his a.Holiness.

@boah2759

7 күн бұрын

@@JaefarSABNW Im not gon lie you are pretty confusing, you claim you are a shia but here you are defending umar 🤷‍♂️

@JaefarSABNW

7 күн бұрын

@boah2759 Muhammad, himself, said that if there were other gods or children of God, he would have worshiped them too. Sunni narratives say Umar and Uthman were not chosen by Islamic tradition and they knew it, but Shia narratives say Ali refused to fight with any, but Muawiyah and Aisha from those who were thought to be Muslim. Quran makes clear those two groups were not at the time.

Who recognizes himself, shia or sunni, is it the right way? No!!!!! Only Muslim. Allahpak said in Quran.

Mhmd killed, stole property, tortured for money, commanded assassinations - and you have him in high regard. Same for ali- he burned people alive and you've got so much respect for a criminal... You guys are not right in the head!

@Hassan-vr6ub

6 күн бұрын

Bro read the Catholic Church history 😭buddy idk where you got that info from

@cxaz10

6 күн бұрын

@@Hassan-vr6ub yes, Catholic church also did some despicable things in the name of religion, including burning people alive for "witchcraft", torturing like mhmd did with Kinana for money (in contrast to Al Takathur logic) etc.

@cxaz10

5 күн бұрын

@@Hassan-vr6ub Yes, catolic church also did quite a few gruesome things in the name of religion. Most of muslim arguments and selection of hadith is cherry picking of the things that sound good, refuting the horrible things the "rightly guided" thugs of mhmd did. "The best of creation ", sure... Trust me bro.

@mxhsvn_b7866

3 күн бұрын

This channel has already covered both their lives and proven everything you said to be false. So maybe watch that before commenting

@cxaz10

3 күн бұрын

@@mxhsvn_b7866 yes, I've listened to approx 5 hours of content from this channel. The main argument for rejecting hadith is "it cannot be that our beloved prophet did this, he's the best human". And all this fight over what some arabian gangsters did 1.4k years ago is also nonsense. They killed each other for wealth and power, otherwise there wouldn't have been any robberies, but those juicy dates of jews and trinkets from caravans were too tempting. In Mecca mhmd got less than 100 followers in ~ 10 years, but when it came to robbing caravans and other forms of stealing- everyone saw how profitable is to be a muslim gangster with mhmd as warlord. Religion of peace 🤣 With all this mess with hadith, both in themselves and in interpretation, one who is whole in the head cannot base "law of God"/sharia on this crap.

First bring your own Quran...because this Quran was organized by Usman..... Who you do not believe and curse always behind the Walls........ Why Qureshi??? Is this is according to teachings of Islam ??? Does iit seems to be justified ??? We do not believe in supremacy of Qureshi in matters of Dunya.... We believe in equality of all man kind.,. anyone can become khalifa....... Not Banu Hashim or Banu Qureshi..... Do not spread false knowledge

@Thaqlain

7 сағат бұрын

1) Compilation of the Quran is already covered in previous episode 2) Condition of Qureshi is covered in a proceeding episode

@bittertruth1823

6 сағат бұрын

@@Thaqlain Compilation was done by Usman....whom you always remember with bad name and curse..... Do you think that after 1500 year Allah has appointed you as a judge to decide who is wrong and who is better ....you are trying to exercise powers of Allah and his Rasool.... If Usman was a wrong person we you read this Quran ..go and make a separate koran...... You are racist mindsets and all the time trying to prove that banu Hashim is a super natural tribe and have right to rule while man kind..... This collide with the basic teachings of Islam

@Thaqlain

Сағат бұрын

As we said, we have covered compilation in the previous video already :) Link here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZoBk0tCLpNa2Y5M.html