I noted all your ‘Hulks’ were late eighteenth early nineteenth century ships of the line

The orgin of the "Swedish" skip is from Central Russia 1500BC.

What this video calls the Hulk was actually called the Hanseatic Cog. There are a number of inacurracies, in your video

@adrianglanvill9749

4 күн бұрын

For instance the Galley use confined to the Atlantic Ocean? What? They were used (mostly) Close to shore in good to moderate weather close to shore in the Mediterranean, surely

The Hansiatic League used the Cog. The hulk was an unservicable moored or agroind, used as accommodation for sailers or as prisons.

You know, the Medieval period is a catagorization that refers specifically to Europe. Historiographically speaking, pre-Contact North America weren't in a Medieval Age.

0:55 These are not medieval hulks, but retired 18th century warships given the same nickname. 1:22 Is a Humber Keel, not a Balingor 1:42 The oldest surviving ship on the planet is the Khufu ship dating from 2500bc, but there are also dugout canoes dated to 7000bc. 8:43 It's spelt 'carrack' not 'carrick'. Also needs to come after the section on caravels. 12:30 It's spelt 'Kon Tiki' not 'conteki' 22:20 It's spelt 'knarr' not 'canar'. As 'Medieval' refers to a period of *European* history from about 500 to 1500, the dhow, north american canoe, Kon Tiki and junk are all outside this definition. Especially the Kon Tiki, which is a speculative ship from *1947* and does not actually represent a historical vessel.

@earlworley-bd6zy

12 сағат бұрын

Its nice that you want to teach the right way.,But,Spelling police is not welcome.

@dominicbuckley8309

11 сағат бұрын

@@earlworley-bd6zyI would agree with you if it was about normal words, punctuation or grammar. But when it is actual names, then it is important to get them right for people who want to find out more. Try googling 'conteki': all you will get are articles on horse racing; google 'canar' and you will find out about birds and Spanish villages.

@BlackHearthguard

55 минут бұрын

@@earlworley-bd6zy Spelling is important, especially when being precise about a specific thing. The internet has bred this culture of being lazy with spelling and grammar, *_that_* is what is unwelcome.

I love how they say "the calm waters of the Mediterranean", then look up storms on the Mediterranean, it's not so calm,lol.

@BlackHearthguard

Сағат бұрын

And then you compare them to the force 10 and larger storms in the northern Atlantic...

Gonna be honest I would love to see these ships in person.

We have an shallow fjord in Denmark called Holckenhavn (Holk harbor). The Caravel was used as a tre masted warship in Scandinavia (at least two was build in 1510 and 1517 respectively) - a sleeker version of the Galleon.

I note the Eurocentric approach. Nothing about the Pacific and its diverse multi hull voyaging canoes and outriggers. These were skilled navigators and explorers who ventured over the Pacific which covers one third of the earths surface. Large vaka, double hulled canoes were made without iron or steel tools. Coral, shell and stone were all that was available. These vessels were fast, stable and safe, totally constructed from local material. The designs came from the Lapita peoples from Melanesia over 3000 years ago, who settled in Tonga, Samoa and Fiji before moving on to Eastern Polynesia and last of all New Zealand.

@kyleglenn2434

9 күн бұрын

But they didn't come and say Hello to the European

@spraakkanon

8 күн бұрын

The middle ages were the middle ages in Europe.

@BlackHearthguard

58 минут бұрын

@@spraakkanon I think you'll find that when it 1066, it was 1066 _everywhere_

@spraakkanon

50 минут бұрын

@@BlackHearthguard 1066 yes, the middle ages no. So I'm right and you misunderstood.

@BlackHearthguard

41 минут бұрын

@@spraakkanon You know, 1066 is right smack bang in the middle ages... I'll wait while you google that.

I got to live and sail on a caravel. It was a replica of La Niña and it was made all of Brazilian tropical hardwood using traditional techniques and was in some ways better than the originals due to the superior quality of wood. Climbing the rigging without rat lines and hauling the anchor by hand could be a little daunting, but it was a great three months!

@kyleglenn2434

9 күн бұрын

You had a adventure of a lifetime.

Lot of these ships I wouldnt call medieval.

@wmason1961

16 күн бұрын

A lot of these I wouldn't call ships.

I CANT BELIEVE THAT´S SO INCREDIBLE... GIMME SOME CREDIBILITY SO I CAN BELIEVE AT LEAST A PART OF IT!!

I think I would use the Gallie

You meant to say the Galleys were confided mostly to the Mediterranean.

Where is the Philippines acceint boat called balangay ?

Mistr, the largest wooden ship--ever, was built as a warship by the Kingdom of Maccasar (the Indonesian islands), and successuly used against the Portuguese invadors. It was around 300 feet long!

2:47 Not the Atlantic Ocean. Galleys generally stayed within the confines of the Mediterranean Sea.

Kamperkogge

The Scottish boats I thought were referred to as Birling's.

Very interesting n informative im an ol history nut so familiar with most I've forgotten more history tgan most ever knew or will.

Is this AI generated? Because there is so much wrong with this video. For starters, a Hulk is not a category of sailing vessel. That Viking boat is nowhere near the oldest boat found. North American fur traders did NOT use dugout canoes. They used bark canoes. And "medieval" is not a period of North American history.

One could wish that the fact checking was better in this video.

@gloria88246

7 күн бұрын

did you fact check everything he said?

🇺🇸

Love your videos! Thank you!!

Fake. There was never such a ship as depicted in the screenshot above. Fakes turn me off and away, so I won't waste my time watching anything with fake or false information.I would expect false ship depictions inside this video, too, probably even mixing up epochs, ship types with each other...

@ethantori6921

10 күн бұрын

Still commented tho

@okeefenokeetheseventeenth2200

10 күн бұрын

@@ethantori6921 Yes, of course. As a warning to anyone who considers watching this.

@gloria88246

7 күн бұрын

who cares 😂🙄

@okeefenokeetheseventeenth2200

7 күн бұрын

@@gloria88246 I do. Too much fake everywhere, we need to call out liars.

@phil20_20

2 күн бұрын

I guess I won't bring up the ancient airplanes then.

I appreciate contribution of Scandinavian ships But u may also check marathas and cholas war ships and kalinga's trade ships These were huge naval power during medieval india

Amazing,,,

This should be followed right after "Notorious pirates in history" but it's ok. All the ships are beautiful and magnificent.

Chris Kane convinced Captain Bligh that flogging people was never an option.😢

@chriskane1

20 күн бұрын

I instead convinced him that walking the plank was a better option.

@tetedur377

20 күн бұрын

So, basically, Chris Kane was kink shaming Captain Bligh?

@chriskane1

20 күн бұрын

@@tetedur377 Aye aye.

@gloria88246

7 күн бұрын

Chris Kane is my favorite 💯💯

Am I the only one who finds it really irritating that the illustrations don't seem to have any relation to the ships they're discussing for a lot of this? Really poorly researched, for the hulk they just googled the name and ended up showing pictures of prison hulks which were a 19th-century invention... Plenty of good videos about ships on youtube but this ain't one of them

The canoe is not a ship

if they were sun to block intruders and were there for centuries were they effective in being barriers? did people just avoid them ever since?

No Galleons !..shame.

First comment please pin it lots of love from india ❤❤❤❤❤❤

So much missinformation, different style ships shown while talking about a certain type. Miss spelled words, miss labeled vessels, this is a shipwreck.

Hi

Beautiful ships, they should build them again for short routes of commerce.

The image at the beginning is pure fiction. The dates are often at odds with the narration... basically junk!

Bonjour de BRETAGNE ! Hye from BRITTANY ! and the ARMENIAN SHIPS ? in straigt line of HERODOTE , why you don't speak about ? the name is CILICIA ;

Shoddy research and content as usual as pointed out in many comments. An interesting subject but please raise your game.

The last person needs to go away.

More AI rubbish of totally wrong, utter tosh. KZread is being seriously degraded by this type of AI rubbish. KZread should make an accuracy grade for AI videos so people know its rubbish before they start watching.